Abundance of female-biased and paucity of male-biased somatically expressed genes on the mouse X-chromosome

  • Björn Reinius1, 2, 3Email author,

    Affiliated with

    • Martin M Johansson1,

      Affiliated with

      • Katarzyna J Radomska1,

        Affiliated with

        • Edward H Morrow4,

          Affiliated with

          • Gaurav K Pandey5,

            Affiliated with

            • Chandrasekhar Kanduri6,

              Affiliated with

              • Rickard Sandberg2, 3,

                Affiliated with

                • Robert W Williams7 and

                  Affiliated with

                  • Elena Jazin1

                    Affiliated with

                    BMC Genomics201213:607

                    DOI: 10.1186/1471-2164-13-607

                    Received: 23 December 2011

                    Accepted: 8 October 2012

                    Published: 10 November 2012

                    Abstract

                    Background

                    Empirical evaluations of sexually dimorphic expression of genes on the mammalian X-chromosome are needed to understand the evolutionary forces and the gene-regulatory mechanisms controlling this chromosome. We performed a large-scale sex-bias expression analysis of genes on the X-chromosome in six different somatic tissues from mouse.

                    Results

                    Our results show that the mouse X-chromosome is enriched with female-biased genes and depleted of male-biased genes. This suggests that feminisation as well as de-masculinisation of the X-chromosome has occurred in terms of gene expression in non-reproductive tissues. Several mechanisms may be responsible for the control of female-biased expression on chromosome X, and escape from X-inactivation is a main candidate. We confirmed escape in case of Tmem29 using RNA-FISH analysis. In addition, we identified novel female-biased non-coding transcripts located in the same female-biased cluster as the well-known coding X-inactivation escapee Kdm5c, likely transcribed from the transition-region between active and silenced domains. We also found that previously known escapees only partially explained the overrepresentation of female-biased X-genes, particularly for tissue-specific female-biased genes. Therefore, the gene set we have identified contains tissue-specific escapees and/or genes controlled by other sexually skewed regulatory mechanisms. Analysis of gene age showed that evolutionarily old X-genes (>100 myr, preceding the radiation of placental mammals) are more frequently female-biased than younger genes.

                    Conclusion

                    Altogether, our results have implications for understanding both gene regulation and gene evolution of mammalian X-chromosomes, and suggest that the final result in terms of the X-gene composition (masculinisation versus feminisation) is a compromise between different evolutionary forces acting on reproductive and somatic tissues.

                    Keywords

                    X-chromosome Sex chromosome Somatic Gene expression Sexual antagonism Sexual selection Gender Sex-bias Female-bias Male-bias Sexual dimorphism Dosage compensation X-inactivation Escape Feminisation Masculinisation De-masculinisation Microarray Non-coding RNA lncRNA Tmem29 Kdm5c Xist

                    Background

                    Females and males have different routes to maximize fitness and therefore the two sexes have different optimal transcriptomes. The X-chromosome is of particular interest in terms of understanding the evolution of sexual dimorphism [1]. Heterogamety in males (XY) and homogamety in females (XX) makes the X-chromosome a unique environment that can expose sexual genomic conflict. Sex-specific selection pressures can favour phenotypic divergence between the sexes [2]. When an allele has opposite effects on fitness in males and females (intralocus conflict) divergent evolution of associated traits is likely to be constrained, and sexual antagonism in allele selection can persist over long timescales [36]. Unlike autosomes, the mammalian X-chromosomes have spent approximately 2/3 of their evolutionary time in females, as compared to 1/3 in males. Consequently, it might be predicted that the X-chromosome should be enriched with female-beneficial rather than male-beneficial alleles [7, 8], although this is also dependent on the dominance state of the alleles. Rice has argued that heterogamety puts X under direct selection in males, and alleles that confer differential fitness, particularly as recessives, will be strongly selected in males, leading to the gradual masculinisation of X during evolution [9].

                    Sequencing of the mammalian X-chromosomes and genome-wide expression profiling are now providing empirical data, shedding new light on these ideas. Indeed, sex-biased expression is at present commonly used as an indicator of previously resolved sexual antagonism at the genomic level [1]. For example, gene expression studies have revealed feminisation of the X in Drosophila melanogaster[10] and Caenohabditis elegans[11]. However, results from studies of mammalian X-chromosomes have been partly conflicting. For example, the mouse X-chromosome has been suggested to be both feminised and masculinised for genes expressed in tissues related to reproduction [8]. Extensive sex-biased expression also occurs in non-reproductive tissues [12]. Therefore comprehensive analyses of sexually dimorphic gene expression in somatic tissues could provide further insight into the sex-biased properties of the mammalian X-chromosome.

                    The current model of the evolution of the XY system describes a chain of events in which the X and Y evolved from a pair of autosomes [7]. In brief, this process involves the establishment of a testis determining factor (TDF) on the proto Y-chromosome, the repression of X/Y recombination to conserve linkage between the TDF and male-beneficial genes on Y, and the consequential erosion of Y which cause the need for up-regulation of X-linked genes in males to restore the X-chromosome:Autosomal ratio of critical genes [13, 14]. Mammalian females have a double dose of all genes located on the non-recombining region of the X relative to males. To reach an equal expression level of X-genes between the sexes, mechanisms evolved to transcriptionally silence one of the two copies of genes encoded on the Xs in females. This is achieved by a chromosome-wide mechanism termed X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) [15]. In female cells, one X is transcriptionally inactive (Xi) while the other remains active (Xa). The selection of Xi and Xa occurs at random in each cell during early development and the silenced state of one X is maintained during cell division throughout adulthood. XCI makes general theoretical predictions of masculinisation versus feminisation of the gene content on X complex [16]. For example, for circulating gene products females might be effectively heterozygous while for intracellular gene products they might be effectively hemizygous chimeras. Empirical investigations of sex-biased expression of the X-chromosome are therefore essential for understanding the evolution of this chromosome. Furthermore, the silence of Xi is not complete. It has been known since the 1970s that some genes "escape" XCI and are expressed from both X-alleles [17, 18]. Early investigations showed that “escapees” are located in disjoint parts of the X-chromosome, and that escape proceeds by a mechanism that allows for considerable autonomy between different genes and regions on the X-chromosome [19, 20]. Now, forty years later, we know many more genes that escape XCI in humans and mouse, but the molecular mechanisms determining escape remain unclear. It is established that escape from XCI can produce gene expression differences between males and females, and that this is one important mechanism for explaining how female and male phenotypes can be obtained from two similar genomes [1, 21]. Escape from XCI is not the only mechanism that can produce sex-biased expression on X. A careful and comprehensive combined analysis of gene content, escape of inactivation, imprinting as well as other allelic asymmetries and their epigenetic control mechanisms will be required in order to understand the selective forces operating on X. For this, robust identification of sex-biased genes located on the X-chromosome is needed. Several previous studies concerned the distribution and expression of X-genes with functions in reproductive tissues, but equally extensive studies of sex-biased expression in somatic tissues are still lacking. To remedy this, we performed large-scale analyses of microarray hybridisations with male and female RNA from multiple somatic mouse tissues including kidney, liver, lung, eye, and two brain regions: the striatum and hippocampus.

                    Results

                    High-resolution screening for sex-biased X-genes in somatic tissues

                    Our first goal was to build a comprehensive list of genes encoded on the mouse X-chromosome with sex-biased expression in somatic tissues. To provide sufficient statistical power to detect even small expression differences, we analyzed a large collection of oligonucleotide microarrays (narrays=728, Affymetrix Mouse 430v.2) hybridized with RNA samples obtained from six somatic tissues: kidney (narrays=152, with nfemale arrays: nmale arrays equal to 99:53), liver (88, 44:44), lung (67, 33:34), striatum (46, 25:21), eye (176, 88:88) and hippocampus (199, 101:98). To identify differentially expressed genes, we applied Wilcoxon rank-sum test (results from parametric tests are broadly similar, see Methods). The result from this analysis is graphically presented in Figure 1, including data for X, Y and autosomal chromosomes. Table 1 gives an overview of the results obtained at the significance threshold p<0.001. Detailed data for all individual genes and tissues are found in Additional file 1 and Additional file 2.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig1_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 1

                    Overview of the microarray results. The data is separated according to chromosomal mapping: Autosomes (A), X-chromosome (X) and Y-chromosome (Y). On the x-axis: mean female/male log2 fold-changes; negative values represent male-bias and positive values represent female-bias. On the y-axis: -log10 p-values (two-sided Wilcoxon test). Each dot represents a probe and the data points marked with crosses represent probes for Xist. The horizontal dashed lines indicate the significance level at which probe intensities presented a non-overlapping distribution between the sexes; probes lying on this line show higher expression in one sex relative to the other in all possible combinations of individual comparisons. The vertical dashed lines mark the fold-change +/−4 (i.e. 2 on log2 scale), included in the figure for the sake of comparisons.

                    Table 1

                    Summary of the microarray results

                    Tissue

                    Probes

                    All probes

                    Autosomes

                    X-chromosome

                    Y-chromosome

                    Location N/A

                    Tot

                    F

                    M

                    Tot

                    F

                    M

                    Tot

                    F

                    M

                    Tot

                    F

                    M

                    Tot

                    F

                    M

                    Kidney

                    #

                    8153

                    4360

                    3793

                    7825

                    4157

                    3668

                    287

                    196

                    91

                    15

                    0

                    15

                    26

                    7

                    19

                    %

                    18.1

                    9.67

                    8.41

                    18.2

                    9.67

                    8.54

                    20.1

                    13.7

                    6.38

                    45.5

                    0

                    45.5

                    3.87

                    1.04

                    2.83

                    Liver

                    #

                    5193

                    2420

                    2773

                    4961

                    2296

                    2665

                    176

                    111

                    65

                    15

                    0

                    15

                    41

                    13

                    28

                    %

                    11.5

                    5.37

                    6.15

                    11.5

                    5.34

                    6.20

                    12.3

                    7.78

                    4.56

                    45.5

                    0

                    45.5

                    6.11

                    1.94

                    4.17

                    Lung

                    #

                    563

                    304

                    259

                    491

                    259

                    232

                    48

                    42

                    6

                    16

                    0

                    16

                    8

                    3

                    5

                    %

                    1.25

                    0.67

                    0.57

                    1.14

                    0.60

                    0.54

                    3.36

                    2.94

                    0.42

                    48.5

                    0

                    48.5

                    1.19

                    0.45

                    0.75

                    Striatum

                    #

                    747

                    541

                    206

                    690

                    497

                    193

                    38

                    37

                    1

                    12

                    0

                    12

                    7

                    7

                    0

                    %

                    1.66

                    1.20

                    0.46

                    1.61

                    1.16

                    0.45

                    2.66

                    2.59

                    0.07

                    36.4

                    0

                    36.4

                    1.04

                    1.04

                    0

                    Eye

                    #

                    106

                    65

                    41

                    49

                    28

                    21

                    38

                    36

                    2

                    17

                    0

                    17

                    2

                    1

                    1

                    %

                    0.24

                    0.14

                    0.09

                    0.11

                    0.07

                    0.05

                    2.66

                    2.52

                    0.14

                    51.5

                    0

                    51.5

                    0.30

                    0.15

                    0.15

                    Hippocampus

                    #

                    50

                    26

                    24

                    8

                    2

                    6

                    25

                    23

                    2

                    16

                    0

                    16

                    1

                    1

                    0

                    %

                    0.11

                    0.06

                    0.05

                    0.02

                    0.00

                    0.01

                    1.75

                    1.61

                    0.14

                    48.5

                    0

                    48.5

                    0.15

                    0.15

                    0

                    The table presents the number (#) and the percentage (%) of significantly sex-biased assayed probes (p<0.001, two-sided Wilcoxon test) separated by chromosomal location. Abbreviations: Tot Total, F female-biased, M male-biased, N/A chromosomal location not available. Complete data for all individual probes is available in Additional file 1 and Additional file 2.

                    A first observation was that the overall percentage of sex-biased transcripts encoded on the X-chromosome was higher than the percentage of sex-biased transcripts encoded on the autosomes, and this observation was consistent in all tissues (See columns labelled “Autosomes Tot” and “X-chromosome Tot”, Table 1). Therefore, it can be concluded that the X-chromosome is a chromosomal location overrepresented for sex-biased genes, in agreement with previous results [12]. Also in line with previous investigations, we observed substantial tissue differences in the number of sex-biased genes (Table 1). This was the case when considering only the X-chromosome (ranging from 25 to 287 transcripts) as well as when considering autosomes (8–7825 transcripts), while the number of Y-linked genes remained nearly constant between the tissues analysed (12–17 transcripts).

                    Large number of genes with small magnitude sex-biased expression on X

                    We found that while sex-biased genes located on X are numerous, the magnitude of their sex differences was small, and this was valid for all somatic tissues investigated. For example, while 80 autosomal transcripts showed sex differences larger than 4-fold in the kidney, not a single transcript with such a large difference was found on the X-chromosome when Xist (X-inactive specific transcript, “Master regulator” of XCI) was excluded (Additional file 1). In the liver, 53 autosomal transcripts were sex-biased beyond 4-fold, while only a single male-biased X-linked gene (Alas2) showed differences beyond 4-fold (Xist excluded). These small differences are better illustrated in Figure 1, where only three crosses, all of them representing probes for parts of the Xist gene, resulted in female-bias greater than 4-fold. At the same time, the figure shows results for many autosomal transcripts with large sexual expression differences, particularly in the liver and kidney. Genes encoded by the Y-chromosome also resulted in large differences in all tissues as expected, since they are only expressed in males (Figure 1). The spatial distribution of sex-biased genes along the X-chromosome is illustrated in Figure 2A, where it can be observed that their distribution is widespread over the chromosome rather than concentrated on specific chromosomal segments, and does not significantly diverge from the overall gene density on the X.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig2_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 2

                    Localisation of sex-biased genes on the mouse X-chromosome. A: The female/male relative expression levels of all assayed transcripts on the mouse X-chromosome is shown for the six tissues included in the study. The heights of the bars indicate mean log2 female/male fold-change and the x-axis corresponds to spatial location on X (NCBI37/mm9 genome assembly). Orange bars indicate a fold-change beyond the given y-axis limit. Probe coverage (Affymetrix M430v2) and gene density (UCSC Browser, NCBI37/mm9, 10 Mb bins) is shown below. B: The distribution of transcripts with consistent female-bias (red) and male-bias (blue) in more than two tissues is shown. The heights of the bars indicate the number of tissues wherein the transcripts were sex-biased. The corresponding probes are listed in Table 2. The green belt on the D-band marks the X-inactivation center.

                    Abundance of female-biased and paucity of male-biased genes on X

                    To study the relative allocation of male- and female-biased genes, we compared their frequencies on the X-chromosome. We found significantly more transcripts with female-bias than with male-bias in all six somatic tissues examined (Figure 3A, comparison XF vs. XM, p<0.001). Next, we compared the X with autosomes, and found female-biased genes to be more abundant on the X in all tissues (Figure 3A, comparison XF vs. AF, p<0.001). More remarkable, in the most sexually dimorphic somatic tissues analysed: the kidney and liver, we found a significant depletion of male-biased genes on the X relative to the frequencies on autosomes (Figure 3A, comparison XM vs. AM, kidney: 25% relative depletion, p= 0.0032 liver: 27% relative depletion, p= 0.0099). These observations provide the first evidence of de-masculinisation of a mammalian X-chromosome in terms of X-gene expression in somatic tissues. The overall frequencies of male-biased genes in the remaining four tissues were too low to allow similar meaningful comparisons between X and autosomes in those tissues.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig3_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 3

                    Abundance of female-biased and paucity of male-biased genes on X. A: Comparisons of the fraction of female-biased and male-biased transcripts within the X-chromosome and between the X-chromosome and autosomes in six somatic tissues: kidney (Ki), liver (Li), lung (Lu), striatum (St), eye (Ey) and hippocampus (Hi). P-values for differences in frequencies; ns: not significant, *: p<0.01, **: p<0.001, ***: p<0.0001 (two-sided Fisher’s exact test). B: The relative overrepresentation of female-biased as compared to male-biased transcripts on the mouse X-chromosome is illustrated (X). Overrepresentation of female-biased transcripts on X mostly remained after exclusion of all known XCI escapee genes (X’). The data presented in A and B corresponds to probes selected at p<0.001 (two-sided Wilcoxon test).

                    To evaluate whether biallelic expression of genes previously known to escape XCI could explain the excess of female-biased transcripts observed on X, we compared the frequencies of male- and female-biased X-genes (Figure 3B, left panel) with the frequencies of sex-biased genes excluding previously known mouse escapees (Figure 3B, right panel). As expected, the exclusion of escapees reduced the female to male imbalance on the X, however, a substantial excess of female-biased genes remained. This suggests the existence of novel tissue-specific escapees in our gene sets, and/or other sex-skewed mechanisms exist that regulate the expression of the remaining female-biased genes.

                    Small female-biased gene clusters on X

                    We have previously identified small female-biased gene clusters on the mouse X-chromosome, including female-biased long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs) and protein coding genes that escape XCI, raising the possibility that such lncRNAs might be involved in the epigenetic regulation of escape domains [22]. Using the more extensive datasets included in the current study, we searched for additional female-biased clusters or additional genes in previously found clusters. To do this, we performed a second analysis in which the significance cut-off was relaxed from p<0.001 to p<0.01, increasing the sensitivity to detect sex-biased genes. At the same time, we only selected genes with consistent bias in more than one tissue, decreasing the expected number of false positives. The result from this analysis is shown in Table 2, containing 94 genes (and 8 additional non-annotated intronic sequences) with female-bias, and only 33 genes (and 2 intronic sequences) with male-bias. The spatial distribution of these genes on the X-chromosome is shown in Figure 2B. Female-biased genes located in close proximity to each other (defined as less than 50 kb) are marked “a f” on the right side of Table 2. The table then shows 6 clusters, and each of them, with the exception of cluster “e”, containing an lncRNA. One of the female-biased clusters “f” deserves special attention because it includes several novel non-coding genes. In addition to the known escapees Kdm5c (coding) and D930009K15Rik (non-coding), three additional female-biased 3’-located non-coding genes were herein identified in this cluster, including 2810454L23Rik, 1441020_at (intergenic) and 2900056M20Rik.
                    Table 2

                    Genes with sex-bias in multiple tissues

                    A. Female-biased genes

                    ProbeSet ID

                    Start align

                    Stop align

                    Ki

                    Li

                    Lu

                    St

                    Ey

                    Hi

                    Gene symbol

                      

                    1426269_at

                    Rnd 10740

                    Rnd 39163

                    ns

                    1.15

                    1.16

                    ns

                    1.31

                    ns

                    Vamp7

                    1

                     

                    1452007_at

                    Rnd 10740

                    Rnd 39163

                    ns

                    1.21

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.32

                    ns

                    Vamp7

                    1

                     

                    1436778_at

                    9012379

                    9015421

                    ns

                    1.65

                    1.19

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Cybb

                    2

                     

                    1436779_at

                    9012379

                    9015421

                    ns

                    1.25

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Cybb

                    2

                     

                    1448737_at

                    10062241

                    10173728

                    1.66

                    1.29

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tspan7

                    3

                     

                    1433867_at

                    12232009

                    12232793

                    1.08

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.05

                    ns

                    1810030O07Rik*

                    4

                     

                    1416467_at

                    12858147

                    12870179

                    1.21

                    1.18

                    1.22

                    ns

                    1.26

                    1.16

                    Ddx3x*

                    5

                     

                    1423042_at

                    12868948

                    12871177

                    1.35

                    1.21

                    1.19

                    1.35

                    1.24

                    1.18

                    Ddx3x*

                    5

                     

                    1423043_s_at

                    12868948

                    12871177

                    1.37

                    1.32

                    1.14

                    ns

                    1.21

                    1.18

                    Ddx3x*

                    5

                     

                    1428667_at

                    16196827

                    16262870

                    1.47

                    1.36

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Maoa

                    6

                     

                    1442676_at

                    16262773

                    16263384

                    1.05

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Maoa

                    6

                     

                    1424215_at

                    17133689

                    17149423

                    1.14

                    1.17

                    1.10

                    ns

                    1.06

                    ns

                    Fundc1

                    7

                     

                    1427672_a_at

                    17740544

                    17855992

                    1.94

                    1.45

                    1.32

                    ns

                    1.64

                    1.32

                    Kdm6a*

                    8

                     

                    1446278_at

                    17804913

                    17805592

                    1.18

                    1.18

                    1.36

                    ns

                    1.46

                    1.15

                    --- (Kdm6a intron)

                    8i

                     

                    1446234_at

                    17805383

                    17806066

                    1.53

                    1.32

                    1.33

                    ns

                    1.76

                    1.38

                    --- (Kdm6a intron)

                    8i

                     

                    1427235_at

                    17818825

                    17856644

                    2.05

                    1.60

                    1.31

                    1.38

                    1.80

                    1.43

                    Kdm6a*

                    8

                     

                    1445198_at

                    17854669

                    17855386

                    1.09

                    1.25

                    1.26

                    ns

                    1.49

                    1.13

                    Kdm6a*

                    8

                     

                    1434061_at

                    19976041

                    19977980

                    1.19

                    1.19

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rp2h

                    9

                     

                    1454816_at

                    19976041

                    19977980

                    1.11

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rp2h

                    9

                     

                    1448852_at

                    20126913

                    20139212

                    1.82

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rgn

                    10

                     

                    1440764_at

                    ^20430444

                    ^20432638

                    ns

                    1.18

                    ns

                    1.29

                    ns

                    ns

                    Araf

                    11

                     

                    1452279_at

                    20502657

                    20508661

                    ns

                    1.66

                    1.21

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    Cfp

                    12

                    a

                    1447537_at

                    20508977

                    20509301

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.50

                    ns

                    ns

                    1500032P08Rik

                    13

                    a

                    1416242_at

                    22796396

                    22942189

                    1.08

                    1.09

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Klhl13

                    14

                     

                    1448269_a_at

                    22796396

                    22942189

                    1.26

                    1.94

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Klhl13

                    14

                     

                    1429028_at

                    33584857

                    33616555

                    1.11

                    1.18

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Dock11

                    15

                     

                    1457265_at

                    34148177

                    34149112

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    Sfrs17b

                    16

                     

                    1417609_at

                    34413894

                    34424221

                    1.25

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ube2a

                    17

                     

                    1449393_at

                    39855741

                    39875274

                    ns

                    1.05

                    1.24

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Sh2d1a

                    18

                     

                    1438916_x_at

                    47908927

                    47909357

                    1.06

                    1.12

                    ns

                    1.32

                    ns

                    ns

                    6720401G13Rik*

                    19

                     

                    1435744_at

                    47916296

                    47922553

                    1.19

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.34

                    ns

                    ns

                    6720401G13Rik*

                    19

                     

                    1419033_at

                    48194223

                    48246471

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.21

                    ns

                    ns

                    2610018G03Rik

                    20

                     

                    1434678_at

                    48466677

                    48468296

                    1.11

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Mbnl3 &

                    21

                     

                    1426832_at

                    53752788

                    53761020

                    1.34

                    1.13

                    1.05

                    1.41

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ddx26b

                    22

                     

                    1454760_at

                    54307208

                    54320357

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    Htatsf1

                    23

                     

                    1455635_at

                    54630061

                    54630758

                    ns

                    1.09

                    ns

                    1.23

                    ns

                    ns

                    4732460I02Rik

                    24

                    b

                    1426863_at

                    54636524

                    54646143

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.37

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rbmx

                    25

                    b

                    1423369_at

                    65931756

                    65971138

                    1.18

                    1.23

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Fmr1

                    26

                     

                    1451302_at

                    67639051

                    67642592

                    1.18

                    1.34

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1110012L19Rik

                    27

                     

                    1435228_at

                    67712927

                    67713571

                    1.18

                    1.27

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    BC023829

                    28

                     

                    1418397_at

                    70587973

                    70604418

                    1.25

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Zfp275

                    29

                     

                    1448323_a_at

                    70728980

                    70741722

                    1.30

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Bgn*

                    30

                     

                    1437889_x_at

                    70740822

                    70741271

                    1.17

                    1.09

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Bgn*

                    30

                     

                    1426677_at

                    71468799

                    71481154

                    1.24

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    Flna

                    31

                     

                    1448354_at

                    71654824

                    71674529

                    1.08

                    1.09

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    G6pdx

                    32

                     

                    1455724_at

                    75694953

                    75696134

                    1.16

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Prrg1

                    33

                     

                    1420514_at

                    78316031

                    78343314

                    1.13

                    1.21

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tmem47

                    34

                     

                    1417307_at

                    80194208

                    82450389

                    1.20

                    1.24

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Dmd

                    35

                     

                    1448665_at

                    80194208

                    82450389

                    1.20

                    1.39

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Dmd

                    35

                     

                    1423744_x_at

                    91434045

                    91435976

                    1.53

                    1.37

                    1.34

                    1.38

                    1.41

                    1.37

                    Eif2s3x*

                    36

                     

                    1451090_a_at

                    91434045

                    91435976

                    1.55

                    1.45

                    1.32

                    1.43

                    1.39

                    1.39

                    Eif2s3x*

                    36

                     

                    1421895_at

                    91435260

                    91457988

                    1.48

                    1.60

                    1.34

                    ns

                    1.71

                    1.58

                    Eif2s3x*

                    36

                     

                    1435818_at

                    91522460

                    91523059

                    1.08

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Klhl15

                    37

                     

                    1434729_at

                    92834534

                    92835231

                    1.06

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Zc4h2

                    38

                     

                    1437064_at

                    95514880

                    95516618

                    1.22

                    1.56

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ar

                    39

                     

                    1455647_at

                    95517026

                    95518558

                    1.29

                    1.62

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ar

                    39

                     

                    1419108_at

                    95752847

                    96086120

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ophn1

                    40

                     

                    1427072_at

                    96265193

                    96270067

                    1.47

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Stard8

                    41

                     

                    1416918_at

                    97963090

                    98013749

                    1.23

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Dlg3

                    42

                     

                    1455465_at

                    98394381

                    98395191

                    ns

                    1.15

                    ns

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Snx12 intron)

                    i

                     

                    1416295_a_at

                    98459719

                    98463545

                    1.21

                    1.62

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Il2rg &

                    43

                     

                    1460631_at

                    98878217

                    98879690

                    1.19

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ogt

                    44

                     

                    1440522_at

                    100590759

                    100591430

                    ns

                    2.02

                    ns

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    Chic1

                    45

                     

                    1427262_at

                    100655713

                    100678556

                    128

                    114

                    55

                    7.9

                    65

                    33

                    Xist*

                    46

                     

                    1427263_at

                    100655713

                    100678556

                    1.9

                    16.7

                    5.1

                    3.3

                    5.1

                    2.5

                    Xist*

                    47

                     

                    1436936_s_at

                    100677542

                    100678588

                    22

                    67

                    6.5

                    26

                    22

                    11

                    Xist*

                    47

                    c

                    1442137_at

                    ^100689134

                    ^100701764

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.13

                    1.07

                    1.16

                    ns

                    2010000I03Rik (Jpx)*

                    48

                    c

                    1438838_at

                    100764844

                    100765429

                    1.05

                    1.12

                    ns

                    1.70

                    1.40

                    ns

                    B230206F22Rik (Ftx)*

                    49

                    c

                    1439305_at

                    100772965

                    100773674

                    1.32

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.46

                    1.09

                    --- (Ftx intron)

                    49i

                    c

                    1435822_at

                    101705781

                    101707391

                    1.19

                    1.28

                    ns

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    D830012I24Rik

                    50

                     

                    1438893_at

                    102237486

                    102238144

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.22

                    ns

                    1.28

                    1.06

                    5530601H04Rik*

                    51

                     

                    1436347_a_at

                    102238820

                    102265435

                    1.06

                    1.24

                    1.41

                    1.18

                    1.63

                    1.24

                    5530601H04Rik*

                    51

                     

                    1452750_at

                    ^102232689

                    ^102265463

                    1.20

                    1.33

                    1.33

                    1.34

                    1.58

                    1.27

                    5530601H04Rik*

                    51

                    d

                    1417921_at

                    102275115

                    102278930

                    1.27

                    1.40

                    1.30

                    1.16

                    1.48

                    1.15

                    2610029G23Rik*

                    52

                    d

                    1433537_at

                    102992735

                    102993644

                    1.30

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.23

                    ns

                    ns

                    Atrx

                    53

                     

                    1453734_at

                    102993154

                    102995719

                    1.14

                    1.13

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Atrx

                    53

                     

                    1418774_a_at

                    103222614

                    103320808

                    1.19

                    1.09

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Atp7a

                    54

                     

                    1436921_at

                    103321257

                    103323499

                    1.21

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Atp7a

                    54

                     

                    1457753_at

                    103354989

                    103355829

                    ns

                    1.11

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tlr13

                    55

                     

                    1435584_at

                    104368242

                    104369000

                    1.03

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    A630033H20Rik

                    56

                     

                    1453078_at

                    104978092

                    104980504

                    1.11

                    1.26

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    2610002M06Rik

                    57

                     

                    1421871_at

                    106290703

                    106357275

                    1.43

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Sh3bgrl

                    58

                     

                    1459571_at

                    106306845

                    106307385

                    1.06

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Sh3bgrl intron)

                    58i

                     

                    1428107_at

                    106356680

                    106357810

                    1.64

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Sh3bgrl

                    58

                     

                    1442003_at

                    126999308

                    127000367

                    ns

                    1.18

                    ns

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    Diap2

                    59

                     

                    1416807_at

                    131120240

                    131122656

                    1.23

                    ns

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rpl36a

                    60

                     

                    1425914_a_at

                    131252558

                    131256449

                    1.08

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Armcx1

                    61

                     

                    1456739_x_at

                    131338685

                    131338978

                    1.64

                    1.41

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Armcx2

                    62

                     

                    1435829_at

                    131505913

                    131506643

                    1.16

                    1.35

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Zmat1

                    63

                     

                    1428512_at

                    132424218

                    132425617

                    1.69

                    1.21

                    ns

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    Bhlhb9

                    64

                     

                    1428209_at

                    132673583

                    132674982

                    1.84

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Bex4

                    65

                    e

                    1418171_at

                    132704620

                    132706881

                    1.37

                    2.04

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tceal8

                    66

                    e

                    1451230_a_at

                    132779633

                    132781675

                    1.59

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Wbp5

                    67

                     

                    1439413_x_at

                    133267489

                    133267797

                    1.14

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Morf4l2

                    68

                     

                    1418318_at

                    136145158

                    136207908

                    1.08

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rnf128

                    69

                     

                    1449036_at

                    136145158

                    136207908

                    1.10

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rnf128

                    69

                     

                    1456027_at

                    136476076

                    136477767

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    1.05

                    ns

                    Rbm41

                    70

                     

                    1416052_at

                    136991147

                    137010679

                    1.11

                    1.30

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Prps1

                    71

                     

                    1425476_at

                    137909933

                    138123778

                    1.19

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Col4a5

                    72

                     

                    1460016_at

                    139118850

                    139119428

                    1.08

                    1.09

                    ns

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tmem164

                    73

                     

                    1441195_at

                    139127416

                    139128111

                    1.05

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.22

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Tmem164 intron)

                    73i

                     

                    1454741_s_at

                    139269949

                    139272918

                    1.25

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tmem164

                    73

                     

                    1428930_at

                    146843122

                    146893683

                    1.10

                    ns

                    1.14

                    ns

                    1.29

                    ns

                    Tmem29

                    74

                     

                    1426306_a_at

                    147240996

                    147247504

                    ns

                    1.12

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Maged2

                    75

                     

                    1426497_at

                    148667784

                    148708632

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.26

                    ns

                    1.25

                    1.13

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1426498_at

                    148667784

                    148708632

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.18

                    ns

                    1.23

                    1.07

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1441449_at

                    148679626

                    148681294

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.08

                    1.11

                    1.15

                    ns

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1441450_s_at

                    148679626

                    148681294

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.18

                    1.12

                    1.19

                    ns

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1457930_at

                    148691371

                    148692025

                    1.14

                    1.18

                    1.24

                    ns

                    1.47

                    1.21

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1440123_at

                    148699256

                    148700276

                    1.10

                    1.24

                    1.29

                    ns

                    1.51

                    1.09

                    --- (Kdm5c intron)

                    76i

                     

                    1444157_a_at

                    148708371

                    148709078

                    1.09

                    1.26

                    1.28

                    1.26

                    1.46

                    1.18

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                     

                    1444158_at

                    148708371

                    148709078

                    1.28

                    1.31

                    1.24

                    1.19

                    1.44

                    1.18

                    Kdm5c*

                    76

                    f

                    1435348_at

                    148712014

                    148713640

                    1.24

                    1.32

                    1.33

                    1.38

                    1.53

                    1.28

                    D930009K15Rik

                    77

                    f

                    1428499_at

                    148729448

                    148730847

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    2810454L23Rik

                    78

                    f

                    1441020_at

                    148742556

                    148743349

                    1.07

                    1.14

                    ns

                    1.29

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Intergenic)

                    79

                    f

                    1441816_at

                    148749758

                    148750124

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.12

                    1.32

                    ns

                    ns

                    2900056M20Rik

                    80

                    f

                    1433992_at

                    149044532

                    149046561

                    1.15

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Shroom2

                    81

                     

                    1422498_at

                    149470708

                    149472081

                    1.13

                    1.29

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Mageh1

                    82

                     

                    1430538_at

                    150158096

                    150175958

                    1.29

                    1.36

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    2210013O21Rik

                    83

                     

                    1416167_at

                    151758460

                    151773001

                    1.50

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Prdx4

                    84

                     

                    1441360_at

                    155711288

                    155712253

                    ns

                    1.09

                    ns

                    1.43

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Rps6ka3 intron)

                    85i

                     

                    1455206_at

                    155803349

                    155806175

                    ns

                    1.32

                    ns

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rps6ka3

                    85

                     

                    1452358_at

                    158154967

                    158217429

                    1.10

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Rai2

                    86

                     

                    1448111_at

                    159340115

                    159469264

                    1.18

                    1.32

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ctps2

                    87

                     

                    1452657_at

                    160346948

                    160371598

                    1.12

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ap1s2

                    88

                     

                    1438953_at

                    160838594

                    160838901

                    1.18

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    Figf

                    89

                     

                    1438954_x_at

                    160838594

                    160838901

                    1.20

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    Figf

                    89

                     

                    1424124_at

                    161374107

                    161418260

                    1.20

                    1.26

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Mospd2

                    90

                     

                    1423091_a_at

                    162676903

                    162826964

                    1.21

                    1.12

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Gpm6b

                    91

                     

                    1415906_at

                    163645025

                    163645984

                    1.35

                    1.33

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tmsb4x

                    92

                     

                    1454843_at

                    163784253

                    163785400

                    1.46

                    1.13

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Prps2

                    93

                     

                    1417704_a_at

                    165233904

                    165742756

                    1.09

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Arhgap6

                    94

                     

                    1451867_x_at

                    165233904

                    165742367

                    1.14

                    1.32

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Arhgap6

                    94

                     

                    B. Male-biased genes

                    ProbeSet ID

                    Start align

                    Stop align

                    Ki

                    Li

                    Lu

                    St

                    Ey

                    Hi

                    Gene symbol

                      

                    1422827_x_at

                    7461369

                    7471588

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    Slc35a2

                    1

                     

                    1432533_a_at

                    7462961

                    7471586

                    1.10

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Slc35a2

                    1

                     

                    1436664_a_at

                    7470132

                    7471590

                    1.10

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Slc35a2

                    1

                     

                    1425490_a_at

                    7700426

                    7709678

                    1.04

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Wdr13

                    2

                     

                    1422660_at

                    7719484

                    7722860

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.08

                    1.18

                    Rbm3

                    3

                     

                    1457519_at

                    7729990

                    7730655

                    1.08

                    1.09

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Tbc1d25

                    4

                     

                    1438753_at

                    7779325

                    7780137

                    1.07

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Porcn intron)

                    i

                     

                    1451939_a_at

                    9616032

                    9694713

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.11

                    ns

                    1.15

                    ns

                    Srpx

                    5

                     

                    1450039_at

                    12648662

                    12749154

                    1.22

                    1.18

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Usp9x

                    6

                     

                    1431955_at

                    20783706

                    20798793

                    1.05

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    4930453H23Rik

                    7

                     

                    1422241_a_at

                    34727595

                    34731158

                    1.08

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ndufa1

                    8

                     

                    1416344_at

                    35758238

                    35809556

                    1.24

                    ns

                    1.03

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    Lamp2

                    9

                     

                    1439298_at

                    39437302

                    39438087

                    1.09

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    --- (Xiap intron)

                    i

                     

                    1449825_at

                    43682183

                    43683528

                    1.05

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Actrt1

                    10

                     

                    1433652_at

                    47135712

                    47137009

                    ns

                    1.09

                    ns

                    1.55

                    ns

                    ns

                    Igsf1

                    11

                     

                    1442549_at

                    48470442

                    48471160

                    ns

                    1.10

                    1.19

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Mbnl3 &

                    12

                     

                    1453453_at

                    49321871

                    49325949

                    1.03

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1700080O16Rik

                    13

                     

                    1443620_at

                    49403554

                    49404019

                    1.21

                    ns

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Gpc4

                    14

                     

                    1448736_a_at

                    50341268

                    50374837

                    1.17

                    1.32

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Hprt

                    15

                     

                    1435815_at

                    58963393

                    58964128

                    ns

                    1.16

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    Ldoc1

                    16

                     

                    1434739_at

                    66015028

                    66057768

                    1.07

                    1.21

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Fmr1nb

                    17

                     

                    1458014_at

                    67115572

                    67116574

                    ns

                    1.06

                    ns

                    1.05

                    ns

                    ns

                    Aff2

                    18

                     

                    1421536_at

                    70070608

                    70083883

                    1.03

                    1.05

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Gabrq

                    19

                     

                    1417412_at

                    70473356

                    70475147

                    1.06

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    F8a

                    20

                     

                    1422711_a_at

                    70901332

                    70905177

                    ns

                    1.14

                    ns

                    1.19

                    ns

                    ns

                    Pnck

                    21

                     

                    1451049_at

                    70931516

                    70961761

                    1.13

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.13

                    ns

                    ns

                    Bcap31

                    22

                     

                    1438120_x_at

                    71260144

                    71260313

                    1.19

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Irak1

                    23

                     

                    1450161_at

                    71669950

                    71694950

                    1.07

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Ikbkg

                    24

                     

                    1437553_at

                    72698339

                    72699357

                    1.06

                    1.07

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Brcc3

                    25

                     

                    1429793_at

                    82514833

                    82515627

                    1.06

                    1.09

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1600014K23Rik

                    26

                     

                    1458481_at

                    98456711

                    98459331

                    1.04

                    1.10

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Il2rg &

                    27

                     

                    1447725_at

                    100211276

                    100211547

                    1.06

                    1.11

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    C030034E14Rik

                    28

                     

                    1437355_at

                    104032421

                    104033595

                    1.04

                    1.08

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Zcchc5

                    29

                     

                    1422164_at

                    108009755

                    108012520

                    1.06

                    1.17

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Pou3f4

                    30

                     

                    1444668_at

                    120324027

                    120326909

                    1.13

                    1.25

                    1.15

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Astx

                    31

                     

                    1417979_at

                    130385542

                    130400116

                    1.03

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    1.17

                    ns

                    Tnmd

                    32

                     

                    1425954_a_at

                    147018680

                    147022624

                    1.05

                    1.14

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    ns

                    Apex2

                    33

                     

                    The female-biased (A) and male-biased (B) genes with the same direction of sex-bias in more than one tissue are listed. The mean fold-changes for significant differences are given for each tissue. Fold-changes in Italic font denote the significance level p<0.01, and fold-changes in bold font denote the significance level p<0.001. The letters “a-f”, to the right in the table, indicate female-biased gene clusters as described in the main text. The additional notation used in the table is as follows. i: intronic transcript. ^: the exact probe mapping coordinates was not specified in the array annotation file, and gene start/stop locations are therefore given according to the NCBI37/mm9 genome assembly. &: these genes showed opposing sex-bias for different probes. *: known XCI escapee gene.

                    Candidate genes for tissue-specific escape from X-inactivation

                    We sought to investigate whether any of the newly identified female-biased genes might escape XCI. Candidates for this analysis were selected from Table 2, since these genes exhibit bias in at least two tissues, and therefore the evidence for possible escape from inactivation is stronger than for genes biased only in one tissue. Indeed, every gene in Table 2 that were female-biased consistently in all tissue analysed, have been previously recognised as escapees [2225]. New selected candidates might escape XCI in a tissue-specific manner. As a first step, to identify novel escapee genes, we here investigated possible biallelic expression of five candidate genes in primary female mouse embryonic fibroblasts derived from skin. We performed RNA-FISH using a probe for Xist RNA in parallel with a probe for either one of the five candidate genes (4732460I02Rik/Rbmx 24/25 , Rbm4 70*, Tmem164 73 , Tmem29 74 and Ctps2 87 ; superscripted numbers corresponding to Table 2) and a positive control for escape: Kdm5c 76 . Kdm5c showed biallelic signals in 25% of the cells (13 of 52 counted, Figure 4). One of the candidates, Tmem29, was confirmed to partially escape XCI, showing biallelic signals in 12% of the cells (10 of 82 counted, Figure 4). None of the other candidates indicated biallelic expression in any of the examined cells, suggesting that they are X-inactivated in mouse embryonic skin fibroblasts. The possibility remains that they might escape inactivation in other cell types.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig4_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 4

                    Confirmation of a candidate XCI escapee gene. The figure displays results from RNA-FISH experiments on female embryonic fibroblasts. The upper panel shows a cell with biallelic RNA signals for the candidate gene Tmem29, which escaped in 12% of the cells (82 cells counted). The lower panel shows a cell with biallelic RNA signals for a positive control for escape, Kdm5c, which escaped in 25% of the cells (52 cells counted).

                    Gene ontology analysis

                    To investigate whether sex-biased X-linked genes are associated with a specific functionality that is overrepresented, we performed a Gene Ontology classification [26, 27]. To do this, we contrasted the proportion of sex-biased genes in each functional category with the proportion of the same functional category among all genes in the genome (Additional file 3 A) or with all genes on the X-chromosome (Additional file 3 B). These analyses revealed three groups with significant over-representation (p<0.05 after Bonferroni correction) in the genome-wide comparison, namely IPR006911: Protein of unknown function DUF634 (p=3E-06; overrepresented among female-biased genes in kidney), GO:0031090 Organelle membrane (p=0.009; overrepresented among male-biased genes in kidney), and perhaps most interesting because of possible sex differences in synaptic plasticity: mmu04720: Long term potentiation (p=0.04; among female-biased genes in striatum).

                    Female-biased X-genes pre-date mammalian radiation

                    It was earlier shown that genes on the X-chromosome with female-biased function (defined by high expression in female reproductive tissues) are mainly evolutionarily old genes, while genes with male-biased function (defined by high expression in male reproductive tissues) are enriched among more recently formed genes (<50 myr) [28]. To investigate whether similar conclusions hold for X-genes with sex-biased expression in non-reproductive tissues, we determined the age of the X-linked genes included in our dataset. To do this, we used gene age data obtained recently by comparative genomic analysis for the presence or absence of orthologs in a vertebrate phylogeny [28], and we calculated the proportion of female- and male-biased genes among the genes assigned to each branch in the phylogeny. We found that the proportion of genes with female-biased expression in kidney and liver was higher among evolutionarily old genes, preceding the radiation of placental mammals, than among younger genes (Figure 5). The difference in proportion of female-biased genes older than 100 myr (branch 0–5) versus younger genes (<100 myr, branch 6–11) was significant both in kidney (p=1.6E-6, two-sided Fischer’s exact test) and liver (p=1.9E-4). A modestly significant age-related decrease in male-biased genes was observed in kidney (p=0.032), while no significant difference was found in liver (p=0.64). Similar analyses of the other somatic tissues included in our study were not possible due to the low number of sex-biased genes detected in those tissues.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig5_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 5

                    Age of sexually dimorphic genes on the X. The upper panel shows a phylogeny and gene branch assignment according to Zhang et al. [28]. The lower panels show the proportion of genes with female-bias (red) and male-bias (blue) among genes assigned to each branch, for the kidney and liver datasets. Branches marked with parenthesis (4, 8 and 9) are not included due to low number of probes corresponding to these branches (see Methods).

                    Discussion

                    Skewed allocation of male- and female-biased X-genes in somatic tissues

                    We have used a large sample set of oligonucleotide microarrays to identify with high-resolution transcripts encoded on the X-chromosome that are expressed in a sex-biased manner in somatic tissues. We observed a skewed allocation of sex-biased somatic transcripts encoded on the X-chromosome: namely an abundance of female-biased transcripts and a paucity of male-biased transcripts. A previous large genome-wide analysis in mice, including four somatic tissues (liver, adipose, muscle and brain) also found over-representation of female-biased genes on the X [12]. However, under-representation of male-biased genes was not reported, possibly due to the lower probe content of their arrays. Our study might thus provide the first empirical evidence of de-masculinisation of a mammalian X-chromosome in terms of X-gene expression in somatic tissues. Our investigation of somatic tissues complements earlier analyses of sex-biased gene expression on the X-chromosome that investigated expression in reproduction-related tissues such as testis, ovary and placenta [29]. Khil et al. demonstrated that genes enriched in mouse testis are under-represented on the X-chromosome, likely as a consequence of meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI), and at the same time, genes with high expression in ovary and placenta were shown to be enriched [29]. We here demonstrated a similarly skewed allocation of male- and female-biased X-genes in somatic tissues. However, a crucial difference is that the observed paucity of male-biased genes in somatic tissues is unlikely to be explained by MSCI, since this process does not occur in these tissues. The results are relevant in terms of interpreting the Rice hypothesis [9]. This hypothesis states that any recessive allele on the X that gives males a reproductive advantage is immediately available for positive selection since males carry a single X-chromosome. Accordingly, an excess of male-beneficial genes should accumulate on the X. This may be the case for genes specifically expressed in spermatogonia [30], but seemingly not for genes enriched in whole testis [29] or for genes expressed in somatic tissues, as indicated in our current study. Therefore, it is most plausible that different selection pressures operate on X-genes active in different tissues, and that the final result in terms of the evolution of gene composition in the X (masculinisation versus feminisation) is a compromise between different evolutionary forces acting on reproductive and somatic tissues, as has been hypothesised both for rodents [8] and similarly for Drosophila[31]. Our data gives support to this hypothesis.

                    The importance of our results can also be discussed in relationship to studies of gene composition of the sex chromosomes of other species. Indeed, the paucity of male-biased genes in both reproductive and somatic tissues of the mouse is similar to that reported in Drosophila melanogaster[10] and Caenohabditis elegans[11]. Interestingly, while the overall pattern is the same in many species, the particular genes are not. Moreover, the collections of genes biased in reproductive tissues are different from those found in somatic tissues from the same species [32, 33]. Nonetheless, the similarity in our results from the mouse X-chromosome and in the evolutionarily unrelated X-chromosomes in distant species such as Drosophila and Caenohabditis elegans, indicate the generality of at least some selective forces acting on X-chromosomes.

                    Genes female-biased in multiple tissues reveal genes that escape X-inactivation

                    The analysis of genes with sex-bias in more than one tissue revealed clues to the potential mechanisms controlling sex-bias of X-encoded genes as well as to whether such mechanisms operate in a ubiquitous versus tissue-specific fashion. Interestingly, while several of the genes listed in Table 2were female-biased in all six tissues, none of the male-biased X-linked transcripts were consistently biased in four or more tissues. Indeed, only two transcripts, Lamp2 and Astx, were male-biased in more than two tissues. This was in stark contrast to the widespread expression differences of several female-biased transcripts, with 25 unique genes female-biased in more than two tissues (Table 2). These observations are in agreement with the conclusion that the mechanisms controlling female-bias versus male-bias are different. It is worth noting that all transcripts that were female-biased in all tissues were encoded by genes known to escape XCI [2225], namely Ddx3x, Kdm6a, Eif2s3x, Xist, 5530601H04Rik, 2610029G23Rik, Kdm5c, and D930009K15Rik. Our microarray analysis of somatic tissues, together with previous global analysis of escape from XCI performed on fibroblasts in vitro[23], indicate that most of the ubiquitously expressed coding escapee genes in mouse have now been identified. On the other hand, the fact that most of the genes included in Table 2were female-biased in a tissue-specific manner, might suggest that escape from XCI is conveyed by tissue-specific mechanisms, at least for some genes.

                    Our RNA-FISH experiments confirmed that Tmem29 escapes XCI, adding yet another gene to the 15 or so escapees previously known in mouse [34]. Tmem29 escaped inactivation in 12% of the fibroblasts counted, while Kdm5c presented biallelic expression in 25% of the cells. This deviation suggests dissimilarity in control mechanisms for biallelism for these two genes, but we cannot fully rule out that differences in probe composition contributed to the divergence observed.

                    Genes escaping X-inactivation [35] and even the Xi heterochromatin itself [36] may underlie significant phenotypic differences between the sexes. It should however be pointed out that female mice that are monosomic for X are fertile and show a mild phenotype compared to women with Turner Syndrome [37].

                    Small female-biased gene clusters on X

                    Our current investigation extended our previous discovery of female-biased gene clusters on the mouse X-chromosome [22]. Here we investigate in more detail the cluster including Kdm5c, because it contains the largest number of female-biased non-coding genes. X-inactive repressive histone marks, such as histone variant macroH2A1 (macroH2A1) and tri-methylation at lysine 27 of histone 3 (H3K27me3), are known to be depleted in escape domains [23, 24]. It was previously shown by us and others that Kdm5c and D930009K15Rik are located in a chromosomal region virtually depleted of these repressive marks, and that both escape XCI [2225]. Novel in the current study is the identification of three additional female-biased non-coding genes in this cluster, located downstream of Kdm5c and D930009K15Rik, apparently in the transition region of macroH2A1 and H3K27me3 enrichment (Figure 6A). This pattern is consistent with a model for the Kdm5c escape domain, in which Kdm5c and D930009K15Rik are located in a transcriptionally active chromosomal domain while the subsequent non-coding genes are located in the transition region between active and silenced domains (Figure 6B). We note that one of these non-coding genes, 2900056M20Rik, was in a previous study classified as X inactivated [38], perhaps indicating tissue variability in escape among genes in the transition region. The coding genes located upstream (Iqsec2) and downstream (Tspyl2) of the female-biased Kdm5c cluster have previously been shown to be X-inactivated [39], and therefore the limits of the Kdm5c escape domain are established. Whether the non-coding RNAs encoded in this escaping domain serve any function in the regulation of escape, the preservation of the boundary between active/inactive domains, or the silencing of neighbouring inactive genes, remains to be explored.
                    http://static-content.springer.com/image/art%3A10.1186%2F1471-2164-13-607/MediaObjects/12864_2011_4535_Fig6_HTML.jpg
                    Figure 6

                    A Model of the Kdm5c escape domain. A: Depletion of the repressive histone marks macroH2A1 and H3K27me3 in the Kdm5c domain (liver ChIP data: GSM469459 and GSM517918). Genes: 1: Iqseq2, 2: Kdm5c, 3: D930009K15Rik, 4: 2810454L23Rik, 5: 1441020_at (Intergenic), 6: 2900056M20Rik, 7: Tspyl2, 8: Gpr173. B: The schematic figure places Kdm5c (red) and the nearby-located female-biased non-coding genes (green) in a loop-out escape model, based on a general model of escape domains [40]. The light grey area symbolises a transcriptionally silenced X-inactive territory. The chromosomal region containing the known escapee genes Kdm5c (2) and D930009K15Rik (3) is depleted of repressive marks and loops out from the silenced territory. 2810454L23Rik (4), 1441020_at (5) and 2900056M20Rik (6) are situated in the transition region between active and inactive chromosomal domains, producing variable and less robust female-bias. The coding genes located upstream (Iqsec2) and downstream (Tspyl2) of the Kdm5c escape domain have previously been shown to be inactivated (black) [39].

                    Other mechanisms that may explain sex-biased expression of X-encoded genes

                    Escape from XCI is not the only mechanism that leads to female-biased expression of X-linked genes. For example, some of the female-biased genes may be controlled by regulators acting in trans, such as hormonally regulated factors. If this is so, the abundance of female-biased genes on X may correlate with an overrepresentation of the corresponding transcription factor binding sites in X-gene promoters. Conversely, it is conceivable that X-gene transcriptional down-regulating factors are enriched in males, and binding motifs for these factors are then similarly expected to be enriched on the X. Sex-bias of some of the identified genes may also reflect sex differences in cell composition within the tissues. Another possible mechanism for sex-biased gene expression is genomic imprinting of X-chromosome genes [41, 42]. Indeed, widespread sex-specific parent-of-origin-dependent allelic expression was reported recently in the brain of rodents in several studies [4346]. This may also mediate or resolve sexually antagonistic effects [47]. If any of the mechanisms described above would affect one sex but not the other, the dosage compensation achieved by random X-inactivation would be altered, resulting in sex-biased expression in the particular tissue in which the mechanism operates.

                    Female-biased X-genes are evolutionarily old

                    Multiple studies have demonstrated that different evolutionary processes and patterns are observed on X-chromosome and autosomal chromosomes [48]. For example, a recent study showed that two bursts of gene gain on the X-chromosome occurred during the evolution of mammals [28]. Moreover, it was suggested that the X-chromosome recently acquired a burst of young male-biased genes (operating in testis), which is consistent with a fixation of recessive male-beneficial alleles by sexual antagonism [28]. Our results provide a different story in terms of the evolution of sex-biased genes acting in somatic tissues. While both studies indicate that female-biased genes are old, the results for male-biased genes differ between our study of somatic tissues and the study of gonadal expression. We found a moderately significant abundance of evolutionarily old genes also among male-biased genes, at least in the kidney. These combined results demonstrate that considerations on the potential effect of sexual antagonism during the evolution of X-chromosome will require a concerted analysis of the selective forces operating both in gonads and in somatic tissues.

                    Conclusions

                    We performed a high-resolution study of sex-biased RNA expression of genes located on the mouse X-chromosome in somatic tissues. We found that the mouse X-chromosome is significantly depleted of male-biased genes and enriched with female-biased genes. Our results in mice correlate with previous analyses of evolutionarily unrelated X-chromosomes in distant species such as Drosophila melanogaster and Caenohabditis elegans, indicating the generality of at least some of the selective forces acting on X-chromosomes. The expression of previously known genes that escape X-chromosome inactivation could explain only a minor part of the observed overrepresentation of female-biased genes in our data set, indicating either the existence of many tissue-specific escapees or the existence of additional sex-skewed gene regulatory mechanisms operating on the X-chromosome. Among the newly identified female-biased genes, using RNA-FISH, the gene Tmem29 was shown to escape X-inactivation in a small proportion of female fibroblasts interrogated. An analysis of gene age showed that evolutionarily old genes, pre-dating the radiation of placental mammals, are more frequently female-biased than younger genes. A similar pattern was observed among male-biased genes in kidney, contrasting with previously shown recent gain on the X-chromosome of male-biased genes expressed in testis.

                    Methods

                    Data analysis

                    We used array data (Affymetrix Mouse 430v.2) from GeneNetwork (University of Tennessee), available at: http://​www.​genenetwork.​org. Datasets: Kidney: “Mouse kidney M340v2 Male (Aug06) RMA” (GN240), “Mouse kidney M340v2 Female (Aug06) RMA” (GN239); Liver: “GenEx BXD Sal Liver Affy M430 2.0 (Feb11) RMA Males” (GN311), "GenEx BXD Sal Liver Affy M430 2.0 (Feb11) RMA Females" (GN312); Lung: “HZI LungM430v2 (Apr08) RMA” (GN160); Striatum: “HBP Rosen Striatum M340V2 (Apr05) RMA” (GN69); Eye: “Hamilton Eye Institute Mouse Eye M430v2 Data Set (Sept08) RMA” (GN207); Hippocampus: “Hippocampus Consortium M340v2 (Jun06) RMA” (GN110). The number of biological specimens was 2–6 individuals per array, as specified for each dataset in the GeneNetwork database. The arrays were normalised with Robust Multichip Average (RMA), and intensities were log-transformed and standardised to a mean of 8 and a standard deviation of 2.

                    Differentially expressed (DE) genes were identified in each tissue using the Wilcoxon Mann-Whitney test (R v2.6.2 Environment for Statistical Computing http://​www.​r-project.​org, wilcox.test(); standard approximation of p-values) at p<0.001 or p<0.01 (not adjusted for multiple testing), as described in the results section. Non-parametric (Wilcoxon) and parametric (t-test) tests showed similar results in number of DE probes. Significant DE X-linked probes using Wilcoxon (or t-test) were as follows for each tissue. Kidney: 287 (290), Liver: 176 (142), Lung: 48 (45), Striatum: 38 (28), Eye: 38 (35), Hippocampus: 25 (25). The Wilcoxon test was chosen to avoid violations of the assumption of normal distribution of probe intensities in each gene. The results for all probes (using both statistics) are available in Additional file 1 and Additional file 2. Since body weight and hormonal state were not controlled, the regulatory origin of any differential expression may be the compound effects of chromosomal constitution, hormonal differences and metabolic states between the sexes. The selection criterion for probes in Table 2was a consistent (defined as a significant deviation in the same direction) female-bias or male-bias (p<0.01) in more than one tissue. SignalMap v1.9.0.03 (NimbleGen) was used to visualise the distribution of sex-biased genes shown in Figure 2. The statistical significance of the observed over-/under-representation of chromosomal location for sex-biased genes was determined with a two-sided Fisher’s exact test and the significance criterion p<0.01. For the analysis shown in Figure 3B (X’), we excluded the following known escapees: Xist, Shroom4, Mid1, Kdm6a, Kdm5c, Jpx, Ftx, Eif2s3x, Ddx3x, Car5b, Bgn, BC022960, D930009K15Rik, 6720401G13Rik, 5530601H04Rik, 2610029G23Rik, and 1810030O07Rik[2225, 49, 50]. The female mouse liver H3K27me3 [23] and macroH2A1 [24] data used in Figure 6 were downloaded from the Gene Expression Omnibus ( http://​www.​ncbi.​nlm.​nih.​gov/​geo, Accession: GSE20617: GSM517918, GSE18963: GSM469459), and SignalMap v1.9.0.03 (NimbleGen) was used to visualize enrichment. For the gene age analysis, branch assignment of sex-biased genes was set according to Zhang et al. (Additional file 2) [28], matched by Ensembl ID, and the phylogeny in the upper section of Figure 5 was depicted accordingly (Zhang et al. 2010, page 2). The lower part of Figure 5 shows only those branches that were represented by at least 10 probes on the Mouse 430v.2 array. An apparent decrease in the proportion of sex-biased genes was observed around the split between branch 5 and 6. A two-sided Fisher’s exact test was applied to determine the statistical significance of the differences in the proportion of sex-biased genes assigned to branches before or after this split. GO analysis was performed in DAVID Bioinformatics Resources 6.7, NIAID/NIH [26, 27], using two reference sets: all X-chromosome genes in the Mouse 430v.2 array, or all genes included in the array, independent of chromosomal location, as specified in Additional file 3 A-E.

                    RNA-FISH

                    Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) derived from skin were cultured in Minimum Essential Medium Eagle (Sigma) supplemented with 2% L-glutamine, 10% fetal bovine serum and 1.5% penicillin/streptomycin (Invitrogen). Upon reaching confluence, MEFs were subcultured 1:4 in Culturewell MultiWell cell culture system (Molecular Probes) and grown until reaching 80% confluence. Cultures were maintained at 37°C and 5% CO2. Cells were fixed by 3% paraformaldehyde for 15 min at room temperature, followed by permeabilization in 0.5% TritonX-100 in PBS with 10 mM Ribonucleoside Vanadyl Complex (New England Biolabs) for 5 min. Fixed cells were stored in 70% ethanol at −20°C until usage. Probes (Xist: RP23-84A16, Tmem29: RP23-84G23, Tmem164: RP23-239E14, Kdm5c: RP23-202H16, Ctps2: RP23-106K4, Rbm41: RP23-381C12, 4732460I02Rik/Rbmx: RP23-44G23) were labeled with ChromaTide Alexa Fluor 488-5-dUTP (Molecular Probes) or Cy3-dCTP (Amersham) PA53021, using the BioPrime Array CGH Genomic Labeling system (Invitrogen). Hybridisation with labelled DNA (40 ng/μl) and mouse Cot1 DNA (100 ng/μl) (Invitrogen) was performed overnight at 38°C in 2×SSC, 50% formamide and 12% dextran sulfate, with 10 mM Ribonucleoside Vanadyl Complex. Cells were washed with 2×SSC and 50% formamide (3x5 min; 40°C) and 2×SSC (3x5 min; 40°C). Slides were mounted with Vectashield (Vector Labs). Cell imaging was carried out using a confocal microscope (Zeiss LSM 510 META, Göttingen, Germany). The images presented in Figure 4 were uniformly processed and merged in Adobe Photoshop CS3 (Adobe).

                    Public data

                    Gene Expression Omnibus ( http://​www.​ncbi.​nlm.​nih.​gov/​geo, Accession: GSM469459, GSM517918).

                    GeneNetwork ( http://​www.​genenetwork.​org, Accession: GN69, GN110, GN160, GN207, GN239, GN240, GN311, GN312).

                    Declarations

                    Acknowledgements

                    We would like to express our gratitude towards Robert J. Rooney for the early access to the mouse liver data sets, and we are grateful to Susana Chuva De Sousa Lopes for her insightful comments on the manuscript. We acknowledge NIH NIAAA INIA Consortium for support of GeneNetwork. This project was funded by a grant from the Marcus Borgström Foundation to BR and EJ.

                    Authors’ Affiliations

                    (1)
                    Department of Organismal Biology, Evolutionary Biology Centre, Uppsala University
                    (2)
                    Ludwig Institute for Cancer Research
                    (3)
                    Department of Cell and Molecular Biology, Karolinska Institutet
                    (4)
                    School of Life Sciences, University of Sussex
                    (5)
                    Department of Genetics and Pathology, Rudbeck Laboratory, Uppsala University
                    (6)
                    Department of Medical and Clinical Genetics, Department of Biomedicine, The Sahlgrenska Academy, Gothenburg University
                    (7)
                    Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, University of Tennessee

                    References

                    1. Mank JE: Sex chromosomes and the evolution of sexual dimorphism: lessons from the genome. Am Nat 2009,173(2):141–150.PubMedView Article
                    2. Lande R: Sexual Dimorphism, Seexual Selection, and Adaptation in Polygenic Characters. Evolution 1980,34(2):292–305.View Article
                    3. Albert AY, Otto SP: Sexual selection can resolve sex-linked sexual antagonism. Science 2005,310(5745):119–121.PubMedView Article
                    4. Gurbich TA, Bachtrog D: Gene content evolution on the X chromosome. Curr Opin Genet Dev 2008,18(6):493–498.PubMedView Article
                    5. Innocenti P, Morrow EH: The sexually antagonistic genes of Drosophila melanogaster. PLoS Biol 2010,8(3):e1000335.PubMedView Article
                    6. Connallon T, Clark AG: The resolution of sexual antagonism by gene duplication. Genetics 2011,187(3):919–937.PubMedView Article
                    7. Bachtrog D: A dynamic view of sex chromosome evolution. Curr Opin Genet Dev 2006,16(6):578–585.PubMedView Article
                    8. Reinke V: Sex and the genome. Nat Genet 2004,36(6):548–549.PubMedView Article
                    9. Rice WR: Sex chromosomes and the evolution of sexual dimorphism. Evolution 1984, 38:735–742.View Article
                    10. Parisi M, Nuttall R, Naiman D, Bouffard G, Malley J, Andrews J, Eastman S, Oliver B: Paucity of genes on the Drosophila X chromosome showing male-biased expression. Science 2003,299(5607):697–700.PubMedView Article
                    11. Reinke V, Smith HE, Nance J, Wang J, Van Doren C, Begley R, Jones SJ, Davis EB, Scherer S, Ward S, et al.: A global profile of germline gene expression in C. elegans. Mol Cell 2000,6(3):605–616.PubMedView Article
                    12. Yang X, Schadt EE, Wang S, Wang H, Arnold AP, Ingram-Drake L, Drake TA, Lusis AJ: Tissue-specific expression and regulation of sexually dimorphic genes in mice. Genome Res 2006,16(8):995–1004.PubMedView Article
                    13. Lin H, Gupta V, Vermilyea MD, Falciani F, Lee JT, O'Neill LP, Turner BM: Dosage compensation in the mouse balances up-regulation and silencing of X-linked genes. PLoS Biol 2007,5(12):e326.PubMedView Article
                    14. Nguyen DK, Disteche CM: Dosage compensation of the active X chromosome in mammals. Nat Genet 2006,38(1):47–53.PubMedView Article
                    15. Lyon MF: Gene action in the X-chromosome of the mouse (Mus musculus L.). Nature 1961, 190:372–373.PubMedView Article
                    16. Fry JD: The genomic location of sexually antagonistic variation: some cautionary comments. Evolution 2010,64(5):1510–1516.PubMed
                    17. Shapiro LJ, Mohandas T, Weiss R, Romeo G: Non-inactivation of an x-chromosome locus in man. Science 1979,204(4398):1224–1226.PubMedView Article
                    18. Migeon BR: Some insights into X chromosome inactivation from studies of human cells. Ann Endocrinol (Paris) 1980,41(4):275–280.
                    19. Goldman MA, Stokes KR, Idzerda RL, McKnight GS, Hammer RE, Brinster RL, Gartler SM: A chicken transferrin gene in transgenic mice escapes X-chromosome inactivation. Science 1987,236(4801):593–595.PubMedView Article
                    20. Brown CJ, Willard HF: Localization of a gene that escapes inactivation to the X chromosome proximal short arm: implications for X inactivation. Am J Hum Genet 1990,46(2):273–279.PubMed
                    21. Mank JE: The W, X, Y and Z of sex-chromosome dosage compensation. Trends Genet 2009,25(5):226–233.PubMedView Article
                    22. Reinius B, Shi C, Hengshuo L, Sandhu KS, Radomska KJ, Rosen GD, Lu L, Kullander K, Williams RW, Jazin E: Female-biased expression of long non-coding RNAs in domains that escape X-inactivation in mouse. BMC Genomics 2010, 11:614.PubMedView Article
                    23. Yang F, Babak T, Shendure J, Disteche CM: Global survey of escape from X inactivation by RNA-sequencing in mouse. Genome Res 2010,20(5):614–622.PubMedView Article
                    24. Changolkar LN, Singh G, Cui K, Berletch JB, Zhao K, Disteche CM, Pehrson JR: Genome-wide distribution of macroH2A1 histone variants in mouse liver chromatin. Mol Cell Biol 2010,30(23):5473–5483.PubMedView Article
                    25. Lopes AM, Arnold-Croop SE, Amorim A, Carrel L: Clustered transcripts that escape X inactivation at mouse XqD. Mamm Genome 2011,  .
                    26. da Huang W, Sherman BT, Lempicki RA: Systematic and integrative analysis of large gene lists using DAVID bioinformatics resources. Nat Protoc 2009,4(1):44–57.PubMedView Article
                    27. da Huang W, Sherman BT, Lempicki RA: Bioinformatics enrichment tools: paths toward the comprehensive functional analysis of large gene lists. Nucleic Acids Res 2009,37(1):1–13.PubMedView Article
                    28. Zhang YE, Vibranovski MD, Landback P, Marais GA, Long M: Chromosomal redistribution of male-biased genes in mammalian evolution with two bursts of gene gain on the X chromosome. PLoS Biol 2010,8(10):e1000494.PubMedView Article
                    29. Khil PP, Smirnova NA, Romanienko PJ, Camerini-Otero RD: The mouse X chromosome is enriched for sex-biased genes not subject to selection by meiotic sex chromosome inactivation. Nat Genet 2004,36(6):642–646.PubMedView Article
                    30. Wang PJ, McCarrey JR, Yang F, Page DC: An abundance of X-linked genes expressed in spermatogonia. Nat Genet 2001,27(4):422–426.PubMedView Article
                    31. Parsch J: X chromosome: expression and escape. PLoS Genet 2009,5(11):e1000724.PubMedView Article
                    32. Jiang M, Ryu J, Kiraly M, Duke K, Reinke V, Kim SK: Genome-wide analysis of developmental and sex-regulated gene expression profiles in Caenorhabditis elegans. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2001,98(1):218–223.PubMedView Article
                    33. Thoemke K, Yi W, Ross JM, Kim S, Reinke V, Zarkower D: Genome-wide analysis of sex-enriched gene expression during C. elegans larval development. Dev Biol 2005,284(2):500–508.PubMedView Article
                    34. Yang C, Chapman AG, Kelsey AD, Minks J, Cotton AM, Brown CJ: X-chromosome inactivation: molecular mechanisms from the human perspective. Hum Genet 2011, 130:175–85.PubMedView Article
                    35. Disteche CM: Escape from X inactivation in human and mouse. Trends Genet 1995,11(1):17–22.PubMedView Article
                    36. Wijchers PJ, Yandim C, Panousopoulou E, Ahmad M, Harker N, Saveliev A, Burgoyne PS, Festenstein R: Sexual dimorphism in mammalian autosomal gene regulation is determined not only by Sry but by sex chromosome complement as well. Dev Cell 2010,19(3):477–484.PubMedView Article
                    37. Burgoyne PS, Baker TG: Oocyte depletion in XO mice and their XX sibs from 12 to 200 days post partum. J Reprod Fertil 1981,61(1):207–212.PubMedView Article
                    38. Tsuchiya KD, Greally JM, Yi Y, Noel KP, Truong JP, Disteche CM: Comparative sequence and x-inactivation analyses of a domain of escape in human xp11.2 and the conserved segment in mouse. Genome Res 2004,14(7):1275–1284.PubMedView Article
                    39. Li N, Carrel L: Escape from X chromosome inactivation is an intrinsic property of the Jarid1c locus. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2008,105(44):17055–17060.PubMedView Article
                    40. Berletch JB, Yang F, Xu J, Carrel L, Disteche CM: Genes that escape from X inactivation. Hum Genet 2011,130(2):237–245.PubMedView Article
                    41. Skuse DH, James RS, Bishop DV, Coppin B, Dalton P, Aamodt-Leeper G, Bacarese-Hamilton M, Creswell C, McGurk R, Jacobs PA: Evidence from Turner's syndrome of an imprinted X-linked locus affecting cognitive function. Nature 1997,387(6634):705–708.PubMedView Article
                    42. Skuse DH: Genomic imprinting of the X chromosome: a novel mechanism for the evolution of sexual dimorphism. J Lab Clin Med 1999,133(1):23–32.PubMedView Article
                    43. Wang X, Sun Q, McGrath SD, Mardis ER, Soloway PD, Clark AG: Transcriptome-wide identification of novel imprinted genes in neonatal mouse brain. PLoS One 2008,3(12):e3839.PubMedView Article
                    44. Gregg C, Zhang J, Weissbourd B, Luo S, Schroth GP, Haig D, Dulac C: High-resolution analysis of parent-of-origin allelic expression in the mouse brain. Science 2010,329(5992):643–648.PubMedView Article
                    45. Wang X, Soloway PD, Clark AG: Paternally biased X inactivation in mouse neonatal brain. Genome Biol 2010,11(7):R79.PubMedView Article
                    46. Gregg C, Zhang J, Butler JE, Haig D, Dulac C: Sex-specific parent-of-origin allelic expression in the mouse brain. Science 2010,329(5992):682–685.PubMedView Article
                    47. Bonduriansky R, Chenoweth SF: Intralocus sexual conflict. Trends Ecol Evol 2009,24(5):280–288.PubMedView Article
                    48. Vicoso B, Charlesworth B: Evolution on the X chromosome: unusual patterns and processes. Nat Rev Genet 2006,7(8):645–653.PubMedView Article
                    49. Tian D, Sun S, Lee JT: The long noncoding RNA, Jpx, is a molecular switch for X chromosome inactivation. Cell 2010,143(3):390–403.PubMedView Article
                    50. Chureau C, Chantalat S, Romito A, Galvani A, Duret L, Avner P, Rougeulle C: Ftx is a non-coding RNA which affects Xist expression and chromatin structure within the X-inactivation center region. Hum Mol Genet 2011,20(4):705–718.PubMedView Article

                    Copyright

                    © Reinius et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012

                    This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License ( http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​2.​0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

                    Advertisement