Sex-dependent genetic effects on immune responses to a parasitic nematode
© Hayes et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2014
Received: 30 January 2014
Accepted: 6 March 2014
Published: 14 March 2014
Skip to main content
© Hayes et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2014
Received: 30 January 2014
Accepted: 6 March 2014
Published: 14 March 2014
Many disease aetiologies have sex specific effects, which have important implications for disease management. It is now becoming increasingly evident that such effects are the result of the differential expression of autosomal genes rather than sex-specific genes. Such sex-specific variation in the response to Trichuris muris, a murine parasitic nematode infection and model for the human parasitic nematode T. trichiura, has been well documented, however, the underlying genetic causes of these differences have been largely neglected. We used the BXD mouse set of recombinant inbred strains to identify sex-specific loci that contribute to immune phenotypes in T. muris infection.
Response phenotypes to T. muris infection were found to be highly variable between different lines of BXD mice. A significant QTL on chromosome 5 (TM5) associated with IFN-γ production was found in male mice but not in female mice. This QTL was in the same location as a suggestive QTL for TNF-α and IL-6 production in male mice suggesting a common control of these pro-inflammatory cytokines. A second QTL was identified on chromosome 4 (TM4) affecting worm burden in both male and female cohorts. We have identified several genes as potential candidates for modifying responses to T. muris infection.
We have used the largest mammalian genetic model system, the BXD mouse population, to identify candidate genes with sex-specific effects in immune responses to T. muris infection. Some of these genes may be differentially expressed in male and female mice leading to the difference in immune response between the sexes reported in previous studies. Our study further highlights the importance of considering sex as an important factor in investigations of immune response at the genome-wide level, in particular the bias that can be introduced when generalizing results obtained from only one sex or a mixed sex population. Rather, analyses of interaction effects between sex and genotype should be part of future studies.
Many human diseases differ in prevalence, course and severity between males and females [1, 2]. This sex bias is most obvious in human autoimmune conditions  that predominantly affect women. Additionally, many other diseases such as cardiovascular disease, osteoporosis and Alzheimer’s also have differing effects in males and females [1–3]. Males and females differ genetically by only a few genes located on sex-specific chromosomes, which are unlikely to account for the vast range of phenotypic differences. It has become increasingly evident that these sex-specific phenotypes are due to differentially expressed genes present in both sexes [4–6]. Such genotype by sex interactions have been observed in a number of organisms, from insects  to mammals . Further, sexually dimorphic gene expression patterns are often tissue specific suggesting that different regulatory interactions might control gene expression in different tissues. This can involve genes exclusively expressed in one sex or genes expressed predominantly in one sex. The latter are often referred to as male or female biased genes, where male biased genes are generally more functionally diverse than female biased genes .
Over three billion people worldwide, mainly in developing countries, are thought to be susceptible to stable transmission of one or more of the four geohelminth species, Ascaris lumbricoides, Trichuris trichiura, Ancylostoma duodenale and Necator americanus. T. trichiura, the human whipworm, is a key parasitic nematode that is known to cause considerable morbidity. This nematode has been the focus of much research (reviewed in ) using T. muris, the mouse whipworm, as a well-established model system. The immune response to this infection in mice is very well characterised and there is a distinct polarisation of immune response in resistant and susceptible strains of mouse [12, 13]. Resistant animals produce high levels of interleukin 13 (IL-13) and associated T helper type 2 (Th2) cytokines in response to infection, which is essential for parasite expulsion. In contrast, a susceptible animal produces high amounts of interferon γ (IFN-γ) and associated Th1 cytokines that leads to chronic infection. Importantly, the term resistance in this model is used when expulsion of the worms occurs before they become sexually mature and in both resistant and susceptible animals, T. muris establishes within the intestine. Resistance to T. muris has been demonstrated to have a strong genetic component with both H2 (major histocompatibility complex) linked genes and background genes influencing immunity [14, 15].
A known sex bias exists in immunity to T. muris infection [16, 17] whereby female mice are known to mount a stronger Th2 response to infection and are thus more resistant. This phenotype is more readily seen in genetically deficient animals such as the IL-4 KO mouse, although a weaker effect is still detectable in wild type mice . Such sex-specific immune responses are also known in other models of helminth infection [19, 20]. Thus, while differences between sexes in immunity have been well documented, few studies have attempted to identify the underlying genetic variants that may cause such sex-specific responses. To date, a genome-wide analysis of genetic variants whose effects on immune response differ between the sexes has not been conducted in experimental populations.
In this study, we focus on sex-specific genetic effects on immune response phenotypes to T. muris in a population of BXD recombinant inbred (RI) mice. This reference panel consists of experimentally tractable mouse lines capturing a large amount of naturally occurring genetic variation and is ideally suited to integrate and analyse massive phenotypic data sets [21, 22] thus providing a valuable tool to identify loci that contribute to immune phenotypes in T. muris infection. To determine the heritable differences in immune phenotypes to T. muris, we profiled parasite burden and infection-induced cytokine responses in peripheral blood in 20 BXD lines and both parental strains, C57Bl/6J and DBA/2J. Our analysis concentrated on cytokines that are reliably measurable in serum as a reflection of inflammatory/immune events occurring in the infected animal. We used interval mapping and gene-mining tools in GeneNetwork (GN) to identify novel candidate loci involved in promoting immunity without bias to any particular subset of genes. We mapped a significant QTL to an interval on chromosome 5 (TM5) and an additional suggestive QTL to an interval on chromosome 4 (TM4). TM5 was male-biased suggesting that expression of a gene or multiple genes within this region are differentially expressed in male and female mice. This has important implications not only for highlighting new genes important in immunity to T. muris and by extension, T. trichiura, but also provides a mechanistic basis for the known sex bias in infection.
Heritability for each phenotype was calculated by ANOVA with line as the independent variable using batch/age corrected values of our phenotypes. In BXD mice, heritabilities of worm burden by rank (no worms, low numbers, medium numbers and high numbers), IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-6 were 42%, 22%, 14% and 18%, respectively.
Both loci were linked to susceptibility. The DBA/2 (D2) allele at TM4 was associated with a 2-fold increase in worm burden when compared with strains having a C57BL/6 (B6) allele (t16 = 2.278, p = 0.04), while a B6 allele at TM5 was associated with a 2-fold increase in IFN-γ production (t19 = 2.421, p = 0.02).
Candidate genes in TM4
CAP, adenylate cyclase-associated protein 1
3′ UTR, exon 2, 8 and 10
c-myc binding protein
Zinc metallopeptidase, ste24 homolog
3′ UTR, exon 1 and 2
Palmitoyl-protein thioesterase 1
3′ UTR and exon 6
Metal response element binding transcription factor 1
3′ UTR, 5′ UTR, exon 11
Microtubule-actin crosslinking factor 1
Exons 1, 9, 10, 19, 20, 35–40, 43–45, 47–48
Zinc finger protein 69
5′ UTR, exons 3, 4 and 6
Stromal membrane-associated GTPase-activating protein 2
Inositol polyphosphate-5-phosphatase B
Exon 1, 2, 3 and 8
Candidate genes in TM5
Phospohatidylinositol 4-kinase type 2 beta
Exons 1, 2 and 7
Leucine aminopeptidase 2
Exons 1 and 5
Transmembrane anterior posterior transformation 1
Sep (O-phosphoserine) tRNA:Sec (selenocysteine tRNA synthase)
3′ UTR, exon 7
Ligand dependent nuclear receptor corepressor-like
3′ UTR, exons 1 and 4
Anaphase promoting complex subunit 4
Exons 1 and 4
Slit homolog 2 (Drosophila)
3′ UTR, 5′ UTR, exons 9, 17, 20, 26 and 32
Superoxide dismutase 3
Candidate genes within the interactions locus TM16
ATP-binding cassette, sub-family C (CFTR/MRP), member1
3′ UTR and multiple exons (13)
Exons 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 15
G1 to S phase transition 1
3′ UTR, exons 1 and 2
Nuclear distribution gene E homolog 1
B-cell leukaemia/lymphoma 6
SUMO/Sentrin specific peptidase 2
Myosin, heavy polypeptide 11, smooth muscle
Multiple exons (11)
Class II transactivator
3′ UTR, exons 9, 10 and 11
Mannan-binding lectin serine peptidase 1
Chloride channel 2
Exons 1 and 2
Sex bias in many diseases has been well documented, particularly with autoimmune diseases, and is attributable in part to the different immune responses that male and females are able to mount. Such sex-dependent effects are potentially caused by differential expression of autosomal genes [8, 9], yet the underlying genetics of this sex-dependence has hitherto been poorly explored. However, if we wish to develop effective interventions we need to understand the genetics of sex-dependent immune responses.
In an effort to address the paucity of data on genetic architecture underlying sex-specific immune response at a genome-wide level we identified loci TM4 and TM5 associated with susceptibility parameters of infection: worm burden and the production of IFN-γ, a Th1 cytokine. Moreover, suggestive QTL can be found in exactly the same position as TM5 when looking at two other susceptibility associated cytokines, IL-6 and TNF-α, suggesting a common control of all these pro-inflammatory cytokines. TM5 was only apparent when analysing male data whereas TM4, associated with worm burden, was apparent in both male and female cohorts. This would suggest that worm burden is controlled similarly in both sexes, whereas the production of the pro-inflammatory cytokines in response to T. muris is differentially controlled in male and female mice, in particular given that this QTL is not located on chromosome X or Y. This phenomenon is also seen in other disease systems, such as coronary heart disease and kidney diseases  highlighting the importance of sex on disease outcome. Another recent QTL study utilising the T. muris system  has been conducted using an intercross approach between AKR and BALB/c mice with different parameters of infection considered (absolute worm burden and antibody response). Thus, our study here has identified different QTL associated with sex-dependent immune responses, rather than QTL associated with colitis as in the intercross study .
T. muris is a parasite that lives in close association with its host, embedding into the caecal epithelium and therefore causing damage to the integrity of the gut. It is further known that the intestinal epithelium plays a key role in expulsion , as resistant animals have a faster rate of epithelial turnover than susceptible animals. Furthermore, increasing the turnover rate in susceptible animals enables expulsion. This process will require a fine balance between apoptosis and proliferation within the gut. Our study has identified several genes from three different chromosomes that play a role in epithelial barrier integrity and host responses to damage.
MacF1 is a member of the Wnt signalling pathway , a highly conserved signal transduction cascade that is known to play a role in gut epithelium homeostasis . Although Rspo1 does not score highly in the system used to identify candidate genes, it is biologically relevant in the context of T. muris infection as it is involved in the proliferative control of intestinal crypt cells, which will be in close association with the parasite, and enhances Wnt/β-catenin signalling in the intestine [30, 31]. Additionally, QTLminer analysis does not include intronic SNPs that may have regulatory functions, which can be found within the Rspo1 gene. Thus these two genes may be important in T. muris infection by regulating the speed of epithelial turnover in the intestine. Rspo1 has also been shown to ameliorate colitis in mice by improving the mucosal integrity of the gut . Clcn2 is known to be important in regulating intestinal mucosa barrier function  and like Rspo1, is important in the recovery of the epithelial barrier in the intestine after damage , which will be important in T. muris infection. Not only has mucus been shown to be extremely important in protecting against T. muris infection  but also that T. muris worms secrete specific proteins to break down the mucus barrier . As turnover is finely balanced with apoptosis  in the gut, and apoptosis has been shown to be important during T. muris infection , the candidate gene Ppt1 is of particular interest because it is known to modulate TNF-α induced apoptosis . Accelerated turnover is thought to dislodge T. muris from its niche, pushing it into the lumen of the gut where 'weep and sweep’ mechanisms will then facilitate expulsion. Myh11 is a contractile protein of smooth muscle and so may be important in the expulsion of T. muris worms by peristalsis or by maintaining the integrity of the smooth muscle in the intestine .
Another aspect of T. muris chronic infection is the damage caused by the parasite burrowing through the epithelium. A number of studies on intestinal inflammation have shown a close association of this inflammation with tissue hypoxia. T. muris has been shown to share many phenotypic characteristics of Inflammatory Bowel Diseases (IBD)  and as damage is sustained during infection, then it is likely that genes in the hypoxia pathway are likely to be important in protecting the host. SOD3 is an antioxidant enzyme that is known to protect tissues against hypoxic stress [41, 42] and is a primary scavenger of superoxide. It is known that the induction of HIF-1α is regulated closely by oxidant/antioxidant equilibrium involving SOD3. Interestingly, HIF-1α has been shown to be upregulated during chronic T. muris infection (data not shown). Another hypoxia gene highlighted in this study is Mtf1, which induces metallotheionein transactivation . Metallothioneins are a family of small proteins that may have a potential role in IBD  and as such may indeed play a role in T. muris infection.
T. muris infection is controlled largely by the production of Th2 cytokines. Several genes involved in T cell signalling have been identified in this study. MacF1, as well as being important in the homeostasis of the gut epithelium, may also be important as down stream events of MacF1 signalling, such as beta-catenin degradation, are implicated in T cell receptor signalling [46, 47]. Pi4k2b is associated with components of the T cell receptor [48, 49] and so may also play an important role in T. muris infection. CIIta is essential for controlling MHCII expression  and so is important in Th2 cell recognition of parasite antigens and subsequent activation. A mutation in this protein is known to upregulate IL-33 dependent differentiation of Th2 cells , a process that has been shown to be critical in immunity to T. muris. Senp2 is another member of the Wnt signalling pathway, like MacF1. Additionally, it can conjugate with PPARγ, a nuclear receptor, affecting the transcription of PPARγ response genes . PPARγ is known to have multiple functions in the immune system [55, 56], including protection against IBD.
The loci we identified in this study are susceptibility loci. Susceptible animals mount a strong Th1 response to infection that then facilitates the survival of this parasite. It is not clearly understood why susceptible animals do not mount a Th2 response to infection. Interestingly, two genes identified in this study are known to be negative regulators of immune responses. Slit2 inhibits dendritic cell and neutrophil migration [57–59] whereas Bcl6 is known to negatively regulate Th2 immunity [60, 61]. Thus, it may be that susceptible animals mount strong Th1 responses, at least partly via down-regulation of Th2 immunity through such genes.
Finally, the two response phenotypes, IFN-γ and worm burden, measured in this experiment were also found to positively correlate with each other and further correlations between expression levels in TM4 and TM5 were identified. This has therefore allowed us to construct hypothetical models of interactions between genes on three different chromosomes based on correlation and expression.
Sex-dependence is known to play an important role in the prevalence or severity of diseases and it is becoming increasingly apparent that it is variation within the autosomal genome that cause these wide ranging effects. This study further highlights the importance of sex in parasitic infections and identifies several genes that may be differentially regulated and/or expressed in male and female animals. This not only has implications for research, often dominated by single sex studies, but may also lead to the identification of genes important in T. muris infection that are not considered solely due to a known role in immune responses, a bias that will discount a myriad of genes that may well be critical.
C57BL/6JOlaHsd and DBA/2J parent mice were obtained from Harlan and BXD recombinant inbred mice were obtained from the University of Tennessee Health Science Centre, Memphis, TN, USA. All mice were subsequently bred and maintained under specific pathogen-free conditions at the University of Manchester. 353 mice were used in this study (174 males and 179 females) and analysed as groups within lines. Mice in all lines ranged in age from 12–40 weeks and at least 6 males and 6 females from each line were used. All procedures conformed to the requirements of the UK Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986, were subject to local ethical review by the University of Manchester Ethical Review Panel and followed ARRIVE guidelines.
BXD is the largest and best phenotyped genetic model system in mammals, and is derived from two divergent mouse strains (C57Bl/6 J and DBA/2 J, hence BXD), in which different recombination patterns have been inbred (hence recombinant inbred) in over 100 highly diverse lines, each with a fixed recombination pattern of exactly two possible alleles [21, 22]. These strains incorporate 4–5 million segregating single nucleotide polymorphisms, 500,000 insertions and deletions, and 55,000 copy number variants (1 kb to 100 kb). This is sufficient complexity to model the genetics of human populations used in linkage and genome-wide association studies (GWAS).
Stock infections of T. muris were maintained in susceptible mouse strains and adult worms harvested at day 42 p.i. Adult worms were cultured in RPMI 1640 supplemented with 10% FCS, 2 mM L-glutamine, 100 U/mL penicillin and 100 μg/mL streptomycin (all Invitrogen, UK) and Excretory/Secretory (E/S) antigen and eggs were collected after four hours incubation. T. muris E/S was prepared as follows. The E/S was pelleted to remove eggs, concentrated using a Centriprep YM-10 (Amicon, Gloucester, UK) and then dialysed against PBS. Protein concentration was determined by Nanodrop. Eggs were allowed to embryonate for at least six weeks in dH2O and infectivity established by worm burden in a susceptible mouse strain. Mice were infected with 150–200 embryonated eggs and worm burdens established at day 35 p.i. Seven separate batches of eggs were used for infections, all from the same passage. Parasite specific IgG1 ELISAs as described in  were carried out to confirm infection in all animals.
Adult worm burdens were assessed at day 35 p.i. via longitudinal dissection of caeca and proximal colons. Serum was taken from infected animals at day 35 p.i. Cytokines IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-6 were measured as they can be detected in sera and provide an indication of the ongoing immune response to T. muris. Commercial Cytometric Bead Array Flex Sets (BD, UK) were used to determine the levels (pg/ml) of IFN-γ, TNF-α and IL-6 in sera according to manufacturer’s instructions. Fluorescence was analysed using a flow cytometer (FACSArray, BD) and cytokine levels were determined using BD CBA software. Linear regression models (GLMs) in SPSS were used to adjust for age, batch and maternal genotype in both worm burden and cytokine levels.
QTL analysis was performed using interval mapping  as implemented in the WebQTL module of GN . To identify potential candidate genes we used both information from the UCSC genome browser and GO annotation, and QTL miner in GN . Further, we analysed covariation networks and correlated worm burden and IFN-γ phenotypes with BXD genotype databases (leucocyte mRNA and T cell (helper) mRNA) in GN that contain an extensive collection of previously published and unpublished data from BXD .
We used ANOVA and univariate General Linear Models as implemented in SPSS (v20).
All supporting data available as additional files.
This work was funded by a Wellcome Trust Program Grant (083620Z). The authors would like to thank the staff of the University of Manchester BSF Unit for all technical help. Thanks also go to Dr Joanne Pennock for help with the manuscript.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.