Skip to main content

Table 2 Percent of SNP and INDEL calling sensitivity in NA12878

From: An analytical workflow for accurate variant discovery in highly divergent regions

Mapper

Caller

SNP

INDEL

  

Non-HLA

HLA

HLA-DRB1

Non-HLA

HLA

BWA

FreeBayes

95.8

76.0

49.3

72.9

50.0

BWA

GATK HC

94.9

76.9

58.0

83.3

61.3

BWA

GATK UG

96.0

80.5

78.3

74.4

46.7

BWA

Platypus

94.0

71.9

50.7

86.1

60.0

BWA

SAMtools

95.7

75.3

58.2

51.7

48.4

GSNAP

FreeBayes

95.6

80.3

59.4

75.2

46.7

GSNAP

GATK HC

96.1

90.0

72.5

85.7

77.4

GSNAP

GATK UG

97.0

91.7

100.0

76.3

51.6

GSNAP

Platypus

95.2

77.8

42.6

87.7

70.0

GSNAP

SAMtools

96.3

88.3

87.9

55.6

51.6

NextGenMap

FreeBayes

95.5

79.2

48.5

68.6

46.7

NextGenMap

GATK HC

94.1

79.0

62.3

81.5

67.7

NextGenMap

GATK UG

94.5

83.2

76.5

66.9

41.9

NextGenMap

Platypus

92.8

72.8

38.2

76.5

50.0

NextGenMap

SAMtools

94.8

78.6

60.6

47.1

32.3

Novoalign

FreeBayes

94.9

80.1

59.4

76.1

50.0

Novoalign

GATK HC

95.4

89.3

75.4

84.0

67.7

Novoalign

GATK UG

95.6

89.7

85.5

78.2

54.8

Novoalign

Platypus

93.8

79.3

53.6

88.6

73.3

Novoalign

SAMtools

94.7

87.4

83.8

60.2

54.8

Stampy

FreeBayes

96.0

82.7

65.2

81.4

53.3

Stampy

GATK HC

94.9

87.1

72.5

86.4

83.9

Stampy

GATK UG

95.4

87.4

82.6

63.9

51.6

Stampy

Platypus

93.5

78.8

53.7

91.2

73.3

Stampy

SAMtools

95.1

86.6

79.4

68.5

51.7

  1. HLA 29,500,000–33,500,000 bp on Chr6; non-HLA other capture regions on Chr6; GATK HC GATK HaplotypeCaller; GATK UG GATK UnifiedGenotyper