Skip to main content

Table 1 Basecalling comparison: run-times, read accuracy and overall assembly accuracy

From: MicroPIPE: validating an end-to-end workflow for high-quality complete bacterial genome construction

 

Guppy3.4.3_hac

Guppy3.4.3_fast

Guppy3.4.3_hac_modbases

Guppy3.6.1_hac

Guppy3.6.1_hac_ modbases

Basecalling comparison:

 Run time (ms)

49,707,952

176,906,144

57,479,661

57,977,178

46,296,565

 Run time (h)

13.81

49.14

15.96

16.10

12.86

 GPU/CPU

GPU

CPU

GPU

GPU

GPU

 Num callers

4

16

8

8

8

 Average read percent identity

91.0

88.9

90.6

93.7

91.0

 Mean read quality

11.4

10.4

11.3

13.3

11.4

 Number of binned reads (qcat)

240,766

233,802

238,847

244,830

240,156

Final assembly comparison:

 Assembly nucleotide identity (%)

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

99.99

 Number of SNP (DNAdiff)

23

35

3

4

5

 Number of indels (DNAdiff)

45

39

31

25

27

 Assembly quality score (Pomoxis)

48.10

48.08

50.99

52.27

51.83

 Mismatches per 100 kb (QUAST)

0.44

0.67

0.06

0.08

0.10

 Indels per 100 kb (QUAST)

0.88

0.76

0.63

0.50

0.53