A newly discovered Bordetella species carries a transcriptionally active CRISPR-Cas with a small Cas9 endonuclease

Background Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) and CRISPR-associated genes (cas) are widely distributed among bacteria. These systems provide adaptive immunity against mobile genetic elements specified by the spacer sequences stored within the CRISPR. Methods The CRISPR-Cas system has been identified using Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) against other sequenced and annotated genomes and confirmed via CRISPRfinder program. Using Polymerase Chain Reactions (PCR) and Sanger DNA sequencing, we discovered CRISPRs in additional bacterial isolates of the same species of Bordetella. Transcriptional activity and processing of the CRISPR have been assessed via RT-PCR. Results Here we describe a novel Type II-C CRISPR and its associated genes—cas1, cas2, and cas9—in several isolates of a newly discovered Bordetella species. The CRISPR-cas locus, which is absent in all other Bordetella species, has a significantly lower GC-content than the genome-wide average, suggesting acquisition of this locus via horizontal gene transfer from a currently unknown source. The CRISPR array is transcribed and processed into mature CRISPR RNAs (crRNA), some of which have homology to prophages found in closely related species B. hinzii. Conclusions Expression of the CRISPR-Cas system and processing of crRNAs with perfect homology to prophages present in closely related species, but absent in that containing this CRISPR-Cas system, suggest it provides protection against phage predation. The 3,117-bp cas9 endonuclease gene from this novel CRISPR-Cas system is 990 bp smaller than that of Streptococcus pyogenes, the 4,017-bp allele currently used for genome editing, and which may make it a useful tool in various CRISPR-Cas technologies. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-2028-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.


Background
Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-Cas (CRISPR-associated) systems serve as an adaptive immune mechanism in prokaryotes that confer protection against bacteriophages and other mobile elements and vectors [1]. A typical CRISPR-cas locus includes a CRISPR array of containing direct repeats (DR) separated by spacers (Sp) and adjacent cas genes [2]. In response to invading DNA, CRISPRs acquire short fragments of the foreign nucleic acid sequences and insert those as new spacers at the beginning of the CRISPR array, with each spacer flanked on both sides by direct repeat sequences. This acquisition step involves Cas1, Cas2, and Cas9 proteins [3][4][5]. Cas9, the signature of Type II CRISPR systems [6], is a RNA-guided endonuclease. CRISPR arrays are transcribed and subsequently processed into small individual CRISPR RNAs (crRNA). This "maturation" step of the array precursor requires a trans-activating crRNA (tracrRNA), an endogenous ribonuclease RNase III, and Cas9 [7,8]; although RNase-III-independent systems exist for some bacteria with Type II-C CRISPRs [9]. In Streptococcus pyogenes, one of the most well studied Type II CRISPR-Cas systems, both tracrRNA and crRNA guide the Cas9 endonuclease to a complementary target sequence (protospacer) to mediate a double-stranded DNA break during target interference. For additional specificity and to avoid cutting within the array itself (autoimmunity), RNA-guided Cas9 cleavage requires a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM; in S. pyogenes: 5′-NGG-3′) flanking the target site. The specifically targeted endonuclease activity of the S. pyogenes Type II-A CRISPR-Cas system has allowed for important breakthrough applications in RNA-guided control of gene expression, genome engineering, and genome editing of multiple organisms [7,10]. But limitations of this particular system have led to a search for new CRISPR-Cas systems with altered features.
The publicly available CRISPRfinder program [11] identified CRISPR-cas loci in 45 % (1176/2612) of the bacterial genomes analyzed, but CRISPR-Cas systems have not been identified within the genus Bordetella. This genus, which is comprised of nine species, is historically subdivided into "classical" and "non-classical" bordetellae. The extensively studied classical bordetellae consist of the three respiratory pathogens: B. pertussis and B. parapertussis, the causative agents of "whooping cough" in humans, and B. bronchiseptica, which causes a broad variety of respiratory disease in many different mammals. The non-classical bordetellae are both genotypically and phenotypically different from the classical bordetellae [12]. They consist of the six recently described species: B. hinzii, B. holmesii, B. ansorpii, B. trematum, B. petrii, and B. avium, all of which are only partially characterized [13][14][15][16][17]. While the classical bordetellae are usually associated with respiratory disease, several non-classical species have also been isolated from wound and ear infection, septicemia and endocarditis, predominantly from immunocompromised patients. For example, B. hinzii, which is a respiratory pathogen in poultry [18] and rodents [19], has also been isolated from humans with chronic cholangitis [20], bacteremia [21], or fatal septisemia [22].
We set out to define the sequence diversity within the Bordetella genus and recently published the genome sequences of numerous isolates from several species [23][24][25][26]. During these studies, we discovered a novel species that we named Bordetella pseudohinzii (manuscript in preparation). This species is a close relative of B. hinzii and naturally infects laboratory-raised mice. B. hinzii and B. pseudohinzii are distinguishable based on substantial divergence in sequence and gene content, as well as the presence of a CRISPR-Cas system that is unique to the genome of B. pseudohinzii. Here, we describe this novel CRISPR-Cas system, demonstrate that it is transcriptionally active and present evidence that it acts as an adaptive immune system against mobile genetic elements, including bacteriophage sequences present in B. hinzii. These data suggest that both species have recently shared an ecological niche with phages, which are represented by the prophages in B. hinzii genomes and the matching spacers in the genome of B. pseudohinzii, and that acquisition of this CRISPR-Cas system protects against those.

Bacterial strains and culture conditions
Bacterial isolates used in this study are described in Additional file 1: Table S1. Cultures used for preparation of DNA were grown at 37°C on Bordet-Gengou agar containing 10 % sheep's blood. Stainer-Scholte broth cultures inoculated with colonies from Bordet-Gengou agar and incubated at 37°C with shaking were used for RNA purification. Growth in broth culture was monitored periodically by checking optical density values (at 600 nm wave length).

DNA isolation, PCR, and sequencing
DNA used for amplification and sequencing of cas genes and the CRISPR array was purified using a commercially available kit (Promega) and was quantified with a Nanodrop 2000 (Thermo Scientific). Primers for amplification of the complete CRISPR array and of the cas9, cas1, cas2, and 16S rRNA genes from other B. pseudohinzii isolates (Additional file 2: Table S2) were designed based on the genome sequence of isolate 8-296-03 [GenBank:JHEP01000084]. PCR reactions included 200 μM of dNTPs, 0.5 μM of each primer, 1.5 mM of MgCl 2 , 2 U of Taq polymerase (Roche), 5.0 μl of 10× Buffer II, 10 % DMSO and~150 ng of purified DNA template in a final volume of 50 μl. Cycling conditions for the amplification of cas9 were 95°C for 15 min and 35 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 54°C for 30 s and 72°C for 3 min, followed by a final elongation step of 72°C for 4 min. Cycling conditions used with the remaining primer pairs were identical except that the extension time was shortened from 3 min to 1 min. PCR amplicons used for sequencing were purified with ExoSAP-IT (USB Corporation) and sequenced at the National Animal Disease Center Genomics Unit using Applied Biosystems Big Dye Terminator v3.1 on an Applied Biosystems 3130 XL Genetic Analyzer sequencer.

CRISPR-cas locus annotation and protospacer prediction
All Bordetella genome sequences available at GenBank were searched for the presence of CRISPR systems using CRISPRFINDER [11]. Predicted spacer sequences were submitted to BLAST search to query the nucleotide collection (nr/nt) and whole-genome shotgun contigs (wgs) databases at NCBI. Because E-value is inadequate when using short nucleotide sequences as BLAST queries, we introduce a "percent hit quality" score (% HQ) to identify and rank the most significant BLAST hits: where %cov represents the percentage of coverage between the spacer and predicted protospacer sequences and %ID stands for percent nucleotide identity between the two.

GC-content
The guanine and cytosine content (GC-content) was calculated within a 120-bp sliding window. The difference in GC-content between the CRISPR-cas locus and the genome average was determined using a two-proportion test implemented in Minitab 17 (www.minitab.com). Briefly, numbers of G + C ("positive events") and A + T ("negative events") were calculated separately for the chromosome [GenBank:JHEP01000084] and for the CRISPR-cas locus. Because the CRISPR array consists of repetitive sequences, its GC-content is skewed and, therefore, the array sequence was not included. The significance of the difference (P-value) was calculated using two-tailed Fisher's exact test.

RNA purification and RT-PCR analysis
Total RNA was isolated from bacterial cultures during logarithmic growth at OD 600 = 0.5 and during the stationary phase after overnight growth using the TRIzol® Plus RNA Purification System (Life Technologies). To eliminate any residual DNA in the samples, a DNase treatment was implemented during RNA extraction, following the manufacturer's protocol. Reverse transcription reactions were carried out using Superscript III reverse transcriptase (Invitrogen), random hexamer primers and 150 ng of total RNA, following the manufacturer's instructions. Primers for the amplification of cas9, cas1, and cas2 gene fragments (Additional file 2: Table S2) were designed to yield PCR amplicons of~100 bp in size (Fig. 1c). The PCR reaction mixture consisted of 2 μl of cDNA template (150 ng/μl), 0.2 μl of 10-mM dNTP mix, 1 μl of 10-mM forward and reverse oligonucleotide primer, 0.2 μl of Taq DNA polymerase (1 unit), 2 μl of 10× ThermoPol reaction buffer, and 14.6 μl of ddH 2 O, in a total volume of 20 μl. Amplification was carried out at 95°C for 10 min, followed by 35 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 55°C for 30 s, and 72°C for 30 s. A final extension step was carried out at 72°C for 8 min. PCR products were electrophoresed in 2 % agarose gels and visualized with ethidium bromide under UV-light. Mature crRNAs were PCR amplified using the Quanti-Mir RT Kit (Systems Biosciences) following the manufacturer's instructions. Briefly, a poly(A)-tail with an attached adaptor sequence was ligated to the mRNA transcripts, and the product was converted to cDNA. crRNAs corresponding to spacers Sp2, Sp3, Sp10, and Sp19 were PCRamplified from the resulting cDNA library with primers (Additional file 2: Table S2) complementary to the attached adaptor and the individual spacer sequences. The PCR only yielded amplicons from mature crRNAs but not from the unprocessed transcript of the CRISPR array. Each PCR product consisted of a spacer sequence, a flanking part of the direct repeat and an attached poly(A)-tail with a universal primer sequence. The expected size of each of the four tested amplicons is~85 bp. PCR products were electrophoresed in 2.8 % agarose gels and visualized with ethidium bromide under UV-light.

Annotation of the CRISPR-Cas elements and expression in vitro
The genome of Bordetella pseudohinzii strain 8-296-03 contains three consecutive, apparently co-transcribed, genes ( Fig. 1a) that are homologous to cas9, cas1, and cas2 of Alicycliphilus denitrificans (Additional file 3: Figure S1, Additional file 4: Table S3). Upstream of those genes, a putative tracrRNA is encoded divergently, flanked by a putative promoter and a rho-independent stem-loop terminator. Downstream of the cas genes, the CRISPR array contains 22 direct repeats (DR) and 21 spacer sequences (Sp). Of these, 19 direct repeats are identical, one repeat (DR-4) has a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP), and the terminal direct repeat (DR-1) has 3 SNPs (Fig. 1b). While each direct repeat is exactly 36 nucleotides in length, the spacer sequences vary: 19 spacers are 30 nucleotides and two are 29 nucleotides long. The sequence of each spacer is unique. Based on the presence and organization of cas9, cas1, and cas2 genes within the operon, we typed this CRISPR-Cas system as Type II-C, according to the classification of the CRISPR-Cas systems established by Makarova et al. [6].
(See figure on previous page.) Fig. 1 Organization and expression of the Type II-C CRISPR-cas locus of B. pseudohinzii. a Graphical representation of the CRISPR-cas locus. The red block upstream of the cas9 gene is a putative tracrRNA flanked by the predicted promoter (arrow) and stem-loop terminator (up-side-down sigma symbol). The CRISPR array is enlarged relative to the cas genes for visual clarity. b Nucleotide sequence of the CRISPR array. SP# is the spacer sequence number; DR# is the direct repeat number. Nucleotides deviating from the DR consensus in DR-1 and DR-4 are highlighted in red. c Confirmation of cas9 (C9), cas1 (C1), and cas2 (C2) expression during logarithmic (Log) and stationary phases of growth. Each PCR amplicon was designed to have a similar size. M: 100-bp DNA ladder. d The CRISPR array is processed into individual, mature crRNAs. Positive and negative strands are relative to the orientation shown in Fig. 1a. M: 50-bp DNA ladder A functional CRISPR-Cas system requires expression of the cas genes and the CRISPR array, followed by maturation of individual crRNAs. Therefore, we performed an RT-PCR to test whether the cas genes are transcribed during growth in vitro. Amplicons of cas9, cas1, and cas2 were observed from RNA obtained during both logarithmic and stationary phases of growth (Fig. 1c). Processing of the precursor CRISPR array transcript into mature crRNAs was also confirmed by RT-PCR (Fig. 1d).
To predict putative protospacer targets we submitted each spacer sequence to BLAST search. Table 1 summarizes hits with >80 % hit quality (HQ). Two spacers, Sp8 and Sp9, are identical to prophage elements found in B. hinzii. Sp16, Sp10, and Sp20 show high HQ (97 %, 86 %, and 83 %, respectively) with different prophages found in B. hinzii and B. bronchiseptica and with a capsid gene of a Microviridae-family phage (subfamily Gokushovirinae), respectively. Spacer Sp13 matches a transposase of the IS3/IS911 family with (90 % HQ). Importantly, several prophages identified as likely sources of spacer elements are not found in the genome of B. pseudohinzii 8-296-03 but are present in closely related B. hinzii, which appear to lack a CRISPR-Cas system. Collectively, these observations suggest that acquisition of the CRISPR-Cas system by B. pseudohinzii conferred CRISPR-mediated protection against these bacteriophages and other mobile genetic elements.
The S. pyogenes Cas9 protein (SpyCas9) contains RuvC-like and HNH motifs that were shown to be essential for its function [7]. We searched for both these motifs in the corresponding Cas9 from B. pseudohinzii (BpsuCas9) (Additional file 5: Figure S2). The RuvC-like endonuclease motif showed 80 % amino acid (aa) similarity (47 % aa identity) and the HNH motif had 66 % aa similarity (33 % aa identity). In each of the motifs, amino acid residues that are conserved among different type-II Cas9 proteins and that were shown to be essential for Cas9 function are identical in BpsuCas9.
Targeted cleavage by Cas9 requires a protopspacer adjacent motif (PAM), a short sequence, which is 5′-NGG-3′ in S. pyogenes [7]. We attempted to determine in silico a possible PAM sequence that is recognized by BpsuCas9, but the few available protospacer sequences with a high HQ score (Table 1) limited the number of potential sequence candidates. Although eight predicted protospacers and their flanking sequences are not sufficient to conclusively determine the exact PAM sequence, we propose 5′-WGR-3′ as a potential motif used by BpsuCas9 (Additional file 6: Figure S3).

Additional B. pseudohinzii isolates possess the CRISPR-cas locus
Eleven other isolates identified as B. pseudohinzii on the basis of their 16S rRNA genes were tested for the presence of a CRISPR-cas locus. PCR using genespecific primers confirmed the presence of cas9, cas1, and cas2 in all isolates (Fig. 2a-c). A CRISPR array was also found in all isolates but some variation in size was observed (Fig. 2d). Sequencing of the CRISPR array PCR amplicons revealed that their lengths are affected by the loss of Sp14 in isolate#2, of Sp8 to Sp11 in isolate#6, and of Sp9 in isolate#10, consistent with the difference in size observed among amplicons ( Fig. 2d and e). Each missing spacer is accompanied by the loss of adjacent direct repeat, so that the overall architecture of the array, (−DR-Sp-) n , remains intact. The array sequences from all isolates are otherwise identical to one another (Fig. 2e). The insertion site of the CRISPR-Cas system is a recombination hotspot in Bordetella Since we found no evidence for a CRISPR-Cas system in any Bordetella species, suggesting it was acquired solely by the B. pseudohinzii lineage, we assessed the local gene organization near the insertion site of the CRISPRcas locus in other Bordetella genomes (Fig. 3). Only B. pseudohinzii and B. hinzii exhibit synteny of both the upstream dapB-murB-tRNA-Gly gene cluster and the downstream cluster consisting of a reductase (redoxin) and a disulfide-isomerase (S 2 isom). In other species, synteny is conserved only upstream of the point at which the CRISPR-Cas locus is located in B. pseudohinzii. Genes downstream vary both in identity and orientation, even among isolates of the same species (B. bronchiseptica), suggesting this region is a hotspot for recombination. Since absence of the CRISPR-Cas system in the other Bordetella species suggests that it was acquired via horizontal gene transfer (HGT), we examined the GC-content of the region including upstream dapB-murB-tRNA-Gly genes, the CRISPR-cas locus, and the downstream redoxin-S 2 isom genes. The GCprofile of the upstream and downstream genes is consistent with the genome average of 66.5 % (Fig. 4, grey horizontal line). In contrast, the CRISPR-cas locus has a GC-content of 56 %, which is significantly lower (twotailed Fisher's exact test, P < 0.01). These data strongly suggest that the CRISPR-cas locus of B. pseudohinzii has been horizontally acquired from an unknown source, likely one with a lower GC-content.

Evolutionary relationship and horizontal gene transfer
The Cas9 protein is a signature feature of all type-II CRISPR-Cas systems. To identify a possible source of the B. pseudohinzii CRISPR-Cas system, we performed BLAST searches for Cas9 protein sequences (Fig. 5). The , cas2 (c) and the CRISPR array (d) from 12 B. pseudohinzii isolates. Lane 1: isolate 8-296-03; lanes 2-12: sequentially obtained isolates #2 to #12, respectively (Additional file 1: Table S1); Lane 13: negative control PCR. e Schematic representation of the CRISPR array in each of the isolates. Squares represent spacer sequences. Diamonds represent direct repeats. Arrows in panel D denote isolates that are missing spacer sequences Sp14 (isolate #2), Sp8 to Sp11 (#6) and Sp9 (#10) in panel e two highest-scoring hits, both from Alicycliphilus denitrificans, have 74 % aa identity (Additional file 4: Table S3), suggesting that the proposed recent acquisition of this CRISPR-Cas system into the genome of B. pseudohinzii was probably from an unknown vector. The Cas9-based phylogeny depicted in Fig. 5 includes the highest-scoring hits together with a subset of selected Cas9 sequences previously published elsewhere [27]. Notably, the 5 closest hits are from related genera, all of which belong to the order Burkholderiales in the class Betaproteobacteria. Immediately outside of this clade is the Cas9 from other Betaproteobacteria and from gamma proteobacterium HdN1. The six-member clade of the Burkholderiales, including B. pseudohinzii, is not the only occurrence of Cas9 in the Burkholderiales; Ralstonia syzygii and Oligella urethralis also belong to this order but possess divergent Cas9 sequences more closely related to those from a variety of Alphaproteobacteria (Fig. 5). The presence of closely related bacteria within several clades of the tree suggests multiple, independent HGT events associated with the acquisition of CRISPR systems.
To further explore horizontal acquisition of CRISPR-Cas systems, we calculated the GC-contents for both the cas9 gene and the genome for all taxa on the tree. The cas9 sequences ranged from 73.5 % to 29 % GC-content. Likewise, the genomes varied in a similar range from 70.7 % to 30.5 % GC-content. However, in several cases a discrepancy is apparent between the GC-contents of cas9 and the corresponding genome (Fig. 5b, column Δ). The largest difference was found in S. pyogenes M1 whose cas9 has a GC-content 24.9 % higher than the average for the genome. Discrepancy between the 16S-rRNA-gene tree relating bacterial species and the tree relating their cas9 gene products suggests horizontal acquisition of the CRISPR-Cas. Similarly, GC-content differences between the CRISPR-cas locus and the rest of the genome further support this HGT.

Discussion
Several lines of evidence suggest that the novel CRISPR-Cas system described here is functional. We observed active transcription of cas genes and array sequence, as well as maturation of the array transcript. Further, the array contains multiple spacer sequences with homology to prophages in genomes of the most closely related species, B. hinzii. Yet, those prophages are absent from B. The CRISPR array is shown schematically with black diamonds for direct repeats and colored rectangles for spacer sequences; the total number of spacers is 21 Fig. 4 The GC-content of the B. pseudohinzii 8-296-03 CRISPR-cas locus is significantly lower than that of the genome. The grey horizontal line indicates the average GC-content of 66.5 % for the genome. White rectangles represent genes. The CRISPR array is represented by diamonds (♦, direct repeats) and squares (■, spacer sequences). On the x-axis, 0 corresponds to nucleotide coordinate 24,537 bp of the contig [GenBank:JHEP02000007] pseudohinzii, suggesting that the CRISPR-Cas may have provided protection against them as an adaptive immune system.
Interestingly, B. hinzii contains prophages and B. pseudohinzii contains CRISPR-associated spacer sequences that perfectly match those prophages. These observations indicate that both species have been predated by the same phage and have survived that predation in these two different ways. Acquisition of the prophage or the CRISPR-Cas system, either of which would prevent further phage predation, could have also accelerated the divergent evolution of B. hinzii and B. pseudohinzii by differently affecting uptake or loss of various other genes, contributing to the observed differences in gene content of these closely related species.
It is often observed that horizontally acquired DNA has a lower GC-content than the genome that receives it [28]; and the GC-content of the CRISPR-Cas system in B. pseudohinzii follows this trend. However, our comparison of multiple genomes revealed several cases in which the GC-content of the acquired CRISPR-Cas system is higher than the genome average (Fig. 5). The most striking example is S. pyogenes whose cas9 gene is functional and is successfully used in genome manipulations. This gene has a 25 % higher GC-content than the genome that contains it, suggesting that S. pyogenes acquired its CRISPR-Cas system by HGT and that substantial differences in GC-content do not prevent the function of the Cas9 protein.
Recent advances in genome editing, genome engineering, and transcriptional control of genes in multiple organisms take advantage of the endonuclease SpyCas9. However, an important limitation of SpyCas9 is its size. The S. pyogenes cas9 allele measures 4,107 base pairs, a size that stretches the carrying capacities of some commonly employed vectors. To address this problem, a recent paper described the use of a 3,159-bp gene encoding Cas9 from Staphylococcus aureus (SaCas9), which recognizes a different PAM sequence (5′-NNGRR-3′) [29]. We introduce BpsuCas9, which is of a similarly small size (3,117 bp) and employs a PAM consensus sequence that putatively consists of 5′-WGR-3′ (Additional file 6: Figure S3) and may provide further flexibility with regards to designing guide RNAs. Future experiments will determine the specific features of the B. pseudohinzii CRISPR-Cas system and its potential utility as an additional or alternative tool for genome editing and other applications.