QTL mapping of root traits in wheat under different phosphorus levels using hydroponic culture

Background Phosphorus (P) is an important in ensuring plant morphogenesis and grain quality, therefore an efficient root system is crucial for P-uptake. Identification of useful loci for root morphological and P uptake related traits at seedling stage is important for wheat breeding. The aims of this study were to evaluate phenotypic diversity of Yangmai 16/Zhongmai 895 derived doubled haploid (DH) population for root system architecture (RSA) and biomass related traits (BRT) in different P treatments at seedling stage using hydroponic culture, and to identify QTL using 660 K SNP array based high-density genetic map. Results All traits showed significant variations among the DH lines with high heritabilities (0.76 to 0.91) and high correlations (r = 0.59 to 0.98) among all traits. Inclusive composite interval mapping (ICIM) identified 34 QTL with 4.64–20.41% of the phenotypic variances individually, and the log of odds (LOD) values ranging from 2.59 to 10.43. Seven QTL clusters (C1 to C7) were mapped on chromosomes 3DL, 4BS, 4DS, 6BL, 7AS, 7AL and 7BL, cluster C5 on chromosome 7AS (AX-109955164 - AX-109445593) with pleiotropic effect played key role in modulating root length (RL), root tips number (RTN) and root surface area (ROSA) under low P condition, with the favorable allele from Zhongmai 895. Conclusions This study carried out an imaging pipeline-based rapid phenotyping of RSA and BRT traits in hydroponic culture. It is an efficient approach for screening of large populations under different nutrient conditions. Four QTL on chromosomes 6BL (2) and 7AL (2) identified in low P treatment showed positive additive effects contributed by Zhongmai 895, indicating that Zhongmai 895 could be used as parent for P-deficient breeding. The most stable QTL QRRS.caas-4DS for ratio of root to shoot dry weight (RRS) harbored the stable genetic region with high phenotypic effect, and QTL clusters on 7A might be used for speedy selection of genotypes for P-uptake. SNPs closely linked to QTLs and clusters could be used to improve nutrient-use efficiency. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12864-021-07425-4.


Background
Phosphorus (P) is an important macro-element for ensuring plant development, productivity, and grain quality [1]. P deficiency causes abnormal physiological and biochemical metabolism during critical plant growth stages and resulted yield losses [2]. P as phosphate is immobile in most of the soil types that make its application on the soil surface less beneficial for plants. While efficient uptake of P from deep soil depends on plant's underground organs [3]. In crops, an efficient root system is crucial for P-uptake. For example, increase in root to shoot ratio in most of the elite cultivars helps to up-take P from deep soil or by growing longer root hairs to exploit the spatial characteristics of soil for maximum nutrient storage in shoots [3,4]. Therefore, optimization of root and biomass related attributes such as root length, root width, root tips number, root diameter, root biomass and shoot biomass at seedling stage could provide a promising avenue to explore early variations correlated with high P uptake. Genetic diversity for root-related traits under different nutrient conditions has been also considered very important for grain yield enhancement [5,6]. Therefore, improvement of nutrient up-take through useful variations in seedling root and biomass traits under varied growth conditions could provide a sustainable solution for developing elite cultivars [2,7,8].
In wheat, QTLs have been detected for root traits under different P treatments across the 21 chromosomes [9,10]. But despite the many genetic interactions which have been determined for the seedling biomass and root system architecture traits, still few loci were reported with major effects [11,12]. Accurate phenotyping of root traits under normal field conditions is difficult, whereas traditional methods such as soil columns and soil cores are time-consuming and laborious for screening of large populations [13,14]. Artificial systems like sand, germination paper and hydroponic based cultures have been used as proxies for characterization of root traits [4,15]. Hydroponic culture with digital imaging has given new opportunities to detect number of root traits with different aspects of root development compared with sand culture and germination paper techniques [11]. Moreover, hydroponic technique can be easily applied for rapid and precise screening of large populations to bridge the phenome to genome knowledge gaps. Several common QTL related to root biomass and root system architecture traits have been reported in both hydroponic and field trials conditions [11,12,16]. But, there is no report regarding cloning of QTL for P-uptake related root traits or P uptake efficiency yet.
Nowadays, construction of high-density genetic maps has accelerated the accuracy of quantitative genomic analysis. Therefore, it could increase the chance for identification of true loci for complex traits [17]. The 660 K SNP array in wheat has greatly improved the density of genetic maps for QTL analysis compared with the earlier 90 K array [18,19]. In this study, we have used hydroponic culture-based image pipeline for root phenotyping and 660 K SNPs array for QTL and joint QTL analysis. This will identify useful loci and can help to understand their pleiotropic effect for multiple root morphological and P-uptake related traits during selection. The aims of this study were (1) to evaluate phenotypic diversity of Yangmai 16/Zhongmai 895 derived doubled haploid (DH) population for seedling root and biomass related traits in different P treatments, (2) to identify QTLs for root traits and biomass at seedling stage under low and high P conditions using 660 K SNP array based high-density genetic map and (3).to detect QTL with pleiotropic effect for multiple traits.

Plant materials
The panel of 198 DH lines from the cross of Yangmai 16/Zhongmai 895 were evaluated for root-related traits in hydroponic culture. The female parental Yangmai 16 is a spring wheat cultivar with drought resistance attributes and cover the largest planting area in the middle and lower Yangtze River Region. Zhongmai 895 is a facultative cultivar and widely cultivated in southern parts of the Yellow and Huai Valleys. This has been characterized as high yielding with drought and heat resistance ability, strong roots and early vigor.

Hydroponic culture and experimental design
Hoagland's nutrient solution was used [20], and three P levels were kept at zero (control), low and high P contents (KH 2 PO 4 0, 0.005, 0.25 mmol/L, respectively). Whereas, levels of KCl in solution were at 0.35, 0.345 and 0.10 mmol/L, respectively in the three treatments to maintain a common nutrient concentration across treatments [21] ( Table 1). The experiments were conducted in randomized complete blocks (RCBD), with three replications from March 15 to April 28, 2017, and 30 healthy seeds of each DH line were used for each treatment.
The seeds of each DH line were sterilized for 15-20 min in a 10% H 2 O 2 solution. After rinsing 5-6 times in sterilized water, seeds were placed on moisturized germination paper in glass Petri dishes, crease-side down and left for 36 h in darkness to initiate germination. After the early appearance of germination, seeds were transferred to sand (2 mm diameter) box in a dark environment for seedling growth at 24°C for 72 h. The sand box was kept under a constant environment room (12 h photo-period: 16°C day and 13°C night, light intensity at 400 μmol m − 2 s − 1 PAR and relative humidity at 70%).
Three uniformly sprouted seeds with~5 mm in roots length for each replication were transferred to holes in trays (the seedling was holed with a sponge), and were placed on plastic tanks (660 × 480 × 280 mm) containing 20 L of nutrient solution. The solution was renewed after every 3 days. After 10 days (two-leaf stage) plants were harvested and placed in 30% ethanol prior to imagery for phenotyping.

Trait measurements
Five root system architecture (RSA) traits, viz. root length (RL), root volume (RV), root diameter (RD), root tip number (RTN), root surface area (ROSA) were captured through images using a scanner (Perfection V700/ V750 2.80A; Epson, China). Images were analyzed by using a software RootNav V1.7.5, which was operationally semi-automated [22]. Root biomass-related traits (BRT), including shoot dry weight (SDW) and root dry weight (RDW) were measured after oven-drying for 72 h at 70°C (mg/plant). Total dry weight (TDW) was estimated as the sum of SDW and RDW, and ratio of root to shoot dry weight (RRS) was measured as ratio between RDW and SDW.

SNP genotyping and QTL analysis
The DH lines and parent cultivars were genotyped through Wheat 660 K SNP array synthesized by Affymetrix and commercially available from Capital Bio Corporation (Beijing, China; http://www.capitalbio.com). Dataset is available in an online repository named "Dataset Yang et al. at Dryad data bank (please see data sharing link in availability of data and materials section). Genetic map was contacted by Wang et al. [23] from our lab. Briefly, markers with no polymorphisms between parents, severely distorted segregations, and missing rate greater than 20% were removed in the subsequent linkage analysis. Finally, 10,242 markers each representing a bin site were selected to construct the linkage map of Yangmai 16/Zhongmai 895 population., Map was comprised 25 linkage groups, covering all 21 wheat chromosomes. Among them, chromosomes 1B, 2B, 4A and 7A consisted of two linkage groups, and the remaining chromosomes were with only one linkage group. Inclusive composite-interval mapping was used for QTL analysis in IciMappingV4.1 software [24], and averaged data from the three replicates were used for QTL detection. The SNP genotypes of Yangmai 16 were defined as A, and those of Zhongmai 895 as B. Alleles from Yangmai 16 reduced trait values when the additive effects were negative. Kosambi mapping approach was used to convert recombinant frequencies into distance map [25]. Locations of QTLs for the root traits were detected by inclusive composite interval mapping-additive (ICIM-ADD) by using same software as for the QTL analysis. The threshold for significant QTL of each trait was demarcated by 1000-permutations at P = 0.05 [26], and minimum LOD score at 2.5 with walking speed at 1.0 cM. Joint QTL analysis for closely linked pleiotropic QTL was performed using the general linear model scripted in lm package of R software. Phenotypic variance explained by each QTL was calculated as demonstrated in Li et al. [27].

Identification of putative candidate genes
The genes located in the physical intervals of RSA and BRT-associated genomic regions were screened based on the annotations in the wheat reference genome (CS RefSeq v1.0; IWGSC 2018), and those related to growth, development and nutrient mobilization were considered as candidate genes. Gene annotation was retrieved using EnsemblPlant and EMBL-EBI (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/ interpro) databases. Gene annotation for putative proteins was performed using BLAST2GO (https://www. blast2go.com/).

Statistical analysis
Pearson's correlations analysis among the traits were estimated using averaged data from each replicate. Significance of variances among DH lines, treatments and interactions between genotypes and treatments (G × T) was calculated using following mixed linear model and considered significant at P < 0.05.
where Y is demonstrated as the response from fixed (β) and random (μ) effects with random error (ε), ge is the genotype × environment effect while X and Z illustrate fixed and random effects, respectively. Broad sense heritabilities for all traits were estimated using genotypes as a random effect following [28].
where σ g 2 , σ gt 2 and σ ε 2 represent genotype, genotype (DH line) × P treatment interaction and error variances, respectively, while t is indicated P treatments and r is replicates. The R package was used for all statistical analyses [29].

Phenotypic variation and correlations among traits under P treatments
Data for all nine traits were normally distributed across the three P treatments ( Figure S1). Under low P condition, Zhongmai 895 showed higher RL, RV, ROSA, RDW, TDW and RRS, but lower RD, RTN, and SDW than Yangmai 16. Except for RD and RRS in the high P treatment, Yangmai 16 had higher RL, RV, RTN, ROSA, SDW, RDW and TDW than Zhongmai 895 (Fig. 1).
Phenotypic variances among the DH lines were significant (P < 0.0001). Transgressive segregations across P treatments were observed for most of traits (Figs. 1, 2; Table 2). The average values of the DH lines for RL, RV, RTN, and RRS were higher than parents in the low P treatment, indicating positive effects for root vigor from both parents (Figs. 1 and 2). Broad sense heritabilities of nine traits were high ranged from 0.76 to 0.91 (Table 2).
RSA and BRT traits were correlated significantly (r = 0.59 to 0.98 at all three P levels) with each other. However, RD was negatively correlated with RL, RTN and ROSA (r = − 0.23 to − 0.69) (Fig. 3).

QTL for root biomass-related traits
Fifteen QTL for BRT traits were identified on chromosomes 3AS (3), 3DL, 4BS (5), 4DS (4), 6BL and 6DS (Table 3). Two, 4 and 9 QTL were identified in the zero, low and high P treatments, and explained 34.0, 42.8 and 67.6% of the phenotypic variances, respectively. A stable QTL (QRDW.caas-4BS) was identified under both low and high P conditions, explaining 8.1 to 17.7% of the phenotypic variances for RDW. A pleiotropic QTL on chromosome 4DS in interval AX-109816583 -AX-109478820 (16.64-30.66 Mb) detected in the low P treatment for RDW co-located with 3 QTL in all three P treatments for RRS explained 7.1 to 20.4% of the phenotypic variances (Table 3).

QTL clusters
Fifteen QTL were grouped in seven clusters (C1 to C7) for both RSA and BRT traits in all three P treatments. These clusters were identified in the same or close marker intervals (Fig. 4) (Fig. 4). Joint QTL analysis reveal that, QTLs presented in four clusters. i.e. C3 (RDW and RRS), C4 (RL and RTN), C5 (RL, RTN, ROSA) and C7 (RL and RTN) were identified as pleiotropic QTL under different P levels ( Fig. 4 and Table 4).

Significant variations and correlations observed for RSA and BRT
Hydroponic-based rapid phenotyping approach was used to measure for BRT and RSA related traits in DH population. Previous studies identified strong correlations between such laboratory-based experiments and field data [30,31]. Therefore, use of digital dataset on BRT and RSA can be used to explore phenotypic variations among the DH population under varied nutrient levels. Most of the phenotypes were higher under the high P treatment compared with zero and low P treatments (Fig. 2). High heritabilities and significant genetic variances for root system architecture and biomass traits indicated that these traits could be used as primary selection criteria for enhancement of P uptake and to identify underlying genetics [12,17] (Table 2). The present results corroborated earlier findings for genetic variances of root-related traits under different nutrient treatments [6,32,33]. Abbreviations: C, control; L, low P treatment; H, high P treatment; RL, root length; RV, root volume; RD, root diameter; RTN, root tip number; ROSA, root surface area; SDW, shoot dry weight; RDW, root dry weight; TDW, total dry weight; RRS, ratio of root to shoot dry weight P deprivation restricts the growth of main roots, while increases the lateral roots elongation with high numbers of root hairs [34]. This phenomenon leads higher ratio of root to shoot that significantly changes the root architecture for greater nutrient up-take [10]. In this study, RSA traits i.e. RL, RV, RTN and ROSA, and BRT traits i.e. RDW and RRS showed higher growth and highly positive correlation between each other at the low P level (Figs. 2 and 3). This trend was contributed by Zhongmai 895, which also had longer roots, high root tip number and high RRS in the low P treatment. High accumulation of SDW under high P conditions and greater RRS under low P were observed in Yangmai 16 (Fig. 1). Zhongmai 895 performed higher as compared to Yangmai 16 across the P treatments, as previously reported elite for high root growth at seedling stage and field-based nitrogen use efficiency [35,36]. SDW and RRS were negatively correlated across treatments (Fig. 3), although previous work found that low P led to reduced root biomass and had a significant impact on root system architecture traits [4,17,37]. A significantly negative correlations ranging from − 0.23 to − 0.69 of RD with RL, RTN and ROSA in all three P treatments indicated a negative association of RD with high P uptake among DH lines (Fig. 3). A similar trend also observed for Zhongmai 895 under high P treatment (Fig. 1). These kind of variations among the population for complex root behavior could be important for genetic dissection of useful loci.

QTL identified under phosphorus treatments
Significant variances among genotypes allowed to explore genomic regions associated with the observed traits [4]. Several QTL were identified previously using hydroponic culture, which showed a vital role in nutrient uptake and a positive correlation with yield-related morphological traits. Here we identified 34 QTL on 1B, 2B, 2D, 3A, 3D, 4B, 4D, 6A, 6B, 6D, 7A and 7B chromosomes across the P treatments (Table 3). Some QTL were already reported for root system architecture and root biomass-related traits [12,38] The genetic diversity for root vigor under low P conditions could potentially improve P acquisition efficiency and described some QTL for BRT under low P conditions [11]. We also detected QTL on 2BL, 4BS, 4DS, 6BL, 7AL and 7BL showing high phenotypic variances for RSA traits i.e. RTN, RRS and RL under low P. (Table 2). Previously, Su et al. [9,37] evaluated two DH populations in pot and field experiments and reported a common QTL on chromosome 4B associated with shoot biomass and tiller number, was potentially important for P efficiency. Here, QTL in same genomic region of the 4B chromosome were detected for RDW and RRS (Table 3). This QTL was nearly co-located with Rht genes for plant height. The Rht-1 locus on 4B, which was a major factor against lodging as part of the green revolution. Interactions between root-related growth traits and Rht genes were reported as important in early vigor and nutrient uptake [11,[39][40][41]. These reports had demonstrated contrasting impact of Rht genes on seedling traits under different nutrient conditions as compare to our findings. In our results, both QTL mapped on 4B (16.64-30.66 Mb) and 4D  in low P corresponding to Rht-B1b (30.9 Mb) and Rht-D1b (18.9 Mb), respectively, had negative impact on RRS among DH lines in contrast with a previous report [40].
QTL on 2DL and 6BL for RTN, RL and SDW under low P condition were likely to be those which were demonstrated for root related traits under P sufficiency in pot trials [37] and hydroponic culture [4]. Therefore, identification of those QTL influencing root traits for high nutrient uptake under varied conditions could be important for genotypic selection. RL, RTN and ROSA are important traits for nutrient uptake and early seedling vigor. Five QTL on chromosome 7A explained higher phenotypic variances of 4.6 to 11.9% for RL, RTN and ROSA. Four of these QTL detected under high P conditions and negatively influenced the root elongation, RTN and ROSA. Whereas, the QTL on 7AL controlling RTN had a positive role by increasing RTN in low P condition (Table 3). This QTL could play a vital for future crop breeding to improve the P-uptake. Closely linked QTL QRL.caas-7BL and QRTN.caas-7BL near AX-109289805 (705.84 Mb) could also be important for early vigor under P deficient conditions, whereas their strong relationship with kernel number per spike was earlier demonstrated by Zhang et al. [42]. SNPs linked with QTL for these traits on 7A and 7B stably detected in different nutrient conditions might be of great value for wheat breeding.

Putative candidate genes
Putative candidate genes for new QTL identified on 3AS for SDW, RDW and TDW was linked with E3-Ubiquitin ligase gene (TraesCS3A01G030100 14Kb) ( Table 5). It had been reported that E3 ubiquitin ligases are involved in lateral root development in monocots and dicots through regulating plant phytohormone biosynthesis, transport and signaling pathways or cell cycle progression. Whereas, Ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis also has a pivotal role in root development, flowering time control and hypocotyl elongation [43]. Based on putative analysis, flanking sequence of SNP linked with  [44]. Furthermore, a gene for transmembrane domain containing protein family was associated with QTL on 7BL for RL and RTN. These genes have been reported for nutrient import through cell membrane, stress tolerance and vegetative growth in Arabidopsis [45]. These QTL could play an important role for high uptake of P through alteration in root traits under varied P conditions.

QTL clusters
Previously high-density physical mapping results demonstrated about 85% of gene expression and also has many cluster distributions in wheat genome that covered 5 to 10% of chromosome regions [46]. In wheat, many QTL clusters were reported in several studies [47][48][49][50][51]. In the present study, seven clusters were identified in three different P treatments (Fig. 4) [4,17], but it is not confirmed that QTL in our results are new or colocalization with previously identified loci. (Fig. 4). These results also indicated that QTL identified at seedling stage could be reliable for the selection of yield-related traits measured at maturity [12]. The SNPs tightly linked to QTLs or QTL clusters identified in the present study can be converted to KASP assays and effectively used for MAS to improve nutrient-use efficiency in wheat breeding.

Conclusions
Thirty-four QTL with significant phenotypic variations for root system architecture and biomassrelated traits were identified using high-density genetic map constructed from 660 k SNP array and cost-effective hydroponic-based phenotyping pipeline. Four QTLs on chromosomes 6BL (2) and 7AL (2) identified in low P treatment with positive additive effects from Zhongmai 895, indicating that it could be used as parent for P-deficient breeding. A stable QTL QRRS.caas-4DS (16.64-30.66 Mb) was also detected across the three P levels, accounted for 8.4 to 20.4% of the phenotypic variances, which could be used for speedy selection of genotypes for P-uptake. Among the seven QTLs clusters, C5 identified on chromosome 7AS (AX-