Skip to main content

Table 3 Predicted transmitting ability (PTA) values (mean ± standard deviation) for three groups of Holstein cattle representing three stages of artificial selection since 1964

From: Effect of sample stratification on dairy GWAS results

Trait

Group I (n = 301) Unselected since 1964

Group II (n = 215) Born 1975-1985

Group III (n = 1,654) Contemporary cows Born 1990-2008

Direction of change (II–I, III–II)

MY

−1118.6±552.3

−403.5±246.8

301.3±239.3

↑↑

FY

−39.2±19.4

−12.2±8.2

11.2±10.3

↑↑

PY

−31.7±15.7

−13.6±6.4

10.3±7.5

↑↑

FPC

0.015±0.035

0.023±0.066

0.002±0.065

↑↓

PPC

0.016±0.018

−0.014±0.037

0.011±0.032

↓↑

PL

−3.093±1.785

−0.327±1.403

1.227±1.982

↓↑

SCS

2.854±0.075

2.948±0.103

2.974±0.165

↑↑

DPR

2.909±1.170

0.558±0.943

−0.151±1.322

↓↓

SCE

8.654±0.329

8.149±0.999

7.508±1.185

↓↓

DCE

7.884±0.175

9.015±0.918

7.664±1.052

↑↓

SSB

7.860±0.192

7.369±0.488

7.657±0.648

↓↑

DSB

8.483±0.694

9.987±0.708

7.661±1.098

↑↓

NM

−549.045±257.56

−211.581±107.18

223.822±178.13

↑↑

STA

−1.840±1.357

−1.146±0.775

0.413±0.990

↑↑

STR

−0.875±0.871

−0.629±0.853

0.198±0.872

↑↑

BD

−1.508±1.225

−0.855±0.866

0.271±0.876

↑↑

RW

−1.705±1.220

−0.918±0.837

0.276±0.903

↑↑

DF

−3.232±2.482

−1.638±0.957

0.703±0.906

↑↑

RA

0.474±0.622

0.143±0.688

0.069±0.792

↓↓

FUA

−1.754±1.278

−1.479±0.825

0.641±1.110

↑↑

RUH

−2.749±2.013

−1.704±0.954

0.942±1.171

↑↑

UD

−0.782±0.730

−0.857±0.738

0.316±0.962

↓↑

UC

−2.114±1.538

−1.607±0.887

0.470±1.013

↑↑

FTP

−1.665±1.307

−1.447±0.906

0.564±0.916

↑↑

RTP

−1.797±1.461

−1.607±0.908

0.477±0.929

↑↑

TL

0.063±0.555

0.251±0.783

−0.076±0.758

↑↓

FA

−0.893±0.866

−0.867±0.964

0.622±1.052

↑↑

RLS

−0.447±0.616

−0.249±0.811

−0.163±0.769

↑↑

RLR

−1.241±1.134

−0.980±0.911

0.611±0.974

↑↑

FL

−1.176±1.033

−1.045±0.916

0.677±0.919

↑↑

FS

−2.173±1.607

−1.378±0.766

0.695±0.910

↑↑

  1. MY, milk yield in units of kilograms; FY, fat yield in units of kilograms; PY, protein yield in units of kilograms; FPC, fat percentage; PPC, protein percentage; PL, productive life; SCS, somatic cell score; DPR, daughter pregnancy rate; SCE, service-sire calving ease; DCE, daughter calving ease; SSB, service-sire stillbirth; DSB, daughter stillbirth; NM, net merit; STA, stature; STR, strength; BD, body depth; DF, dairy form; RA, rump angle; RW, rump width; FUA, fore udder attachment; RUH, rear udder height; UD, udder depth; UC, udder cleft; FTP, front teat placement; RTP, rear teat placement; TL, teat length; FA, foot angle; RLS, rear legs (side view); RLR, rear legs (rear view); FL, feet/legs score; FS, final score.