Table 6 Performance comparision on Krogan-core, DIP and combined6 datasets

Krogan-Core

MCODE

78

0.4492 ^3rd

0.2163

0.292

0.4001 ^{1 st}

0.2192

0.2832

MCL

374

0.2507

0.342

0.2893

0.2195

0.3236

0.2616

CFinder

1396 ^3rd

0.2913

0.3437

0.3154

0.2311

0.3263

0.2705

DPClus

497

0.2816

0.4142 ^3rd

0.3352

0.2443

0.3897 ^3rd

0.3003

IPCA

579

0.4744 ^2nd

0.4016

0.435 ^2nd

0.3403

0.3671

0.3532 ^2nd

CMC

2136 ^{1 st}

0.1065

0.1403

0.1211

0.091

0.1346

0.1086

COACH

348

0.4206

0.3971

0.4085

0.325

0.3575

0.3405

HC-PIN

167

0.3543

0.2891

0.3184

0.3152

0.292

0.3032

SPICi

227

0.3453

0.3383

0.3417

0.2991

0.3165

0.3075

ClusterONE

243

0.426

0.3568

0.3884 ^3rd

0.3556 ^3rd

0.3244

0.3393 ^3rd

WPNCA

374

0.3889

0.3646

0.3764

0.2673

0.3239

0.2929

CALM

1411 ^2nd

0.2728

0.4495 ^{1 st}

0.3395

0.2377

0.4299 ^{1 st}

0.3061

ClusterEPs

540

0.3185

0.3034

0.3108

0.2927

0.3034

0.2980

SE-DMTG

371

0.5124 ^{1 st}

0.432 ^2nd

0.4688 ^{1 st}

0.3973 ^2nd

0.4044 ^2nd

0.4008 ^{1 st}

DIP

MCODE

53

0.188

0.1099

0.1387

0.184

0.1098

0.1375

MCL

609

0.142

0.33

0.1986

0.1241

0.3031

0.1761

CFinder

2147 ^2nd

0.1654

0.346

0.2238

0.1544

0.3437

0.2131

DPClus

909

0.1786

0.3991

0.2468

0.1602

0.3695

0.2235

IPCA

1242 ^3rd

0.2283

0.4062 ^3rd

0.2923

0.1986

0.3938

0.2641

CMC

1192

0.2086

0.4344 ^2nd

0.2818

0.1894

0.4081 ^3rd

0.2587

COACH

329

0.2986 ^3rd

0.3878

0.3374

0.2509

0.3659

0.2977

HC-PIN

21

0.0097

0.0075

0.0085

0.0142

0.0077

0.01

SPICi

402

0.2213

0.3303

0.265

0.1944

0.3175

0.2412

ClusterONE

341

0.2752

0.2909

0.2828

0.2556 ^3rd

0.2918

0.2725

WPNCA

654

0.2889

0.4059

0.3376 ^3rd

0.2458

0.3922

0.3022 ^3rd

CALM

2447 ^{1 st}

0.1031

0.3773

0.1619

0.0931

0.3519

0.1473

ClusterEPs

728

0.2992 ^2nd

0.3941

0.3402 ^2nd

0.2963 ^{1 st}

0.4107 ^2nd

0.3442 ^2nd

SE-DMTG

758

0.3266 ^{1 st}

0.4717 ^{1 st}

0.386 ^{1 st}

0.2842 ^2nd

0.4504 ^{1 st}

0.3485 ^{1 st}

combined6

MCODE

63

0.2309

0.1661

0.1932

0.2089

0.1625

0.1828

MCL

508

0.2182

0.3799

0.2772

0.1854

0.3456

0.2414

CFinder

5140 ^{1 st}

0.1829

0.4858

0.2658

0.1621

0.4506 ^3rd

0.2384

DPClus

658

0.2548

0.4742

0.3315

0.2227

0.4261

0.2925

IPCA

2160 ^2nd

0.3850 ^2nd

0.5025 ^3rd

0.4360 ^2nd

0.3136 ^2nd

0.4556 ^2nd

0.3715 ^2nd

CMC

892

0.2573

0.5006

0.3399

0.2188

0.4442

0.2932

COACH

682

0.2872

0.5082 ^2nd

0.3670 ^3rd

0.221

0.4458

0.2955

HC-PIN

176

0.2606

0.2481

0.2542

0.2225

0.2139

0.2181

SPICi

348

0.3033 ^3rd

0.4307

0.3560

0.2614 ^3rd

0.382

0.3104 ^3rd

ClusterONE

648

0.2292

0.4387

0.3011

0.1944

0.3971

0.261

WPNCA

898

0.2252

0.4339

0.2965

0.181

0.3943

0.2482

CALM

2064 ^3rd

0.2229

0.476

0.3036

0.1894

0.4255

0.2621

ClusterEPs

907

0.2542

0.3206

0.2836

0.2533

0.3381

0.2896

SE-DMTG

490

0.4679 ^{1 st}

0.5208 ^{1 st}

0.493 ^{1 st}

0.3520 ^{1 st}

0.471 ^{1 st}

0.4029 ^{1 st}