Skip to main content

Table 6 Experimental results for fruit fly ONT data set D3-O

From: A comprehensive evaluation of long read error correction methods

Method

# Reads

# Bases

# Aligned

# Aligned

Maximum

N50

Genome

Alignment

CPU time

Wall time

Memory

  

(Mbp)

reads

bases (Mbp)

length (bp)

(bp)

fraction (%)

identity (%)

(hh:mm:ss)

(hh:mm:ss)

usage (GB)

Original

642255

4609.5

554083

3857.9

446050

11956

98.719

83.5921

-

-

-

Non-hybrid methods

FLAS

423097

3507.6

422206

3402.6

64365

11517

97.588

95.3301

23:04:50

03:12:50

10.8

LoRMA

703097

615.5

682288

592.3

32644

865

30.338

98.1230

666:37:35

25:52:14

92.8

Canu

430082

3415.6

421475

3220.2

254967

12090

97.592

96.3739

88:51:10

04:36:20

20.2

Short-read-assembly-based methods

HG-CoLoR

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

FMLRC

641945

4647.2

578290

3978.2

444605

12088

98.592

97.6010

47:45:17

03:06:05

31.2

HALC

643002

4668.5

611191

3955.7

451284

12115

98.616

97.6634

126:30:01

05:43:37

42.4

Jabba

494546

2878.2

494430

2876.3

72501

9305

83.166

99.9745

175:19:34

06:56:29

136.8

LoRDEC

642882

4655.9

567878

3921.1

447726

12079

98.691

94.0382

152:05:32

05:38:05

5.7

ECTools

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

>72:00:00

-

Short-read-alignment-based methods

Hercules

642287

4612.8

554630

3859.4

449799

11966

98.713

83.9340

398:10:17

17:32:36

247.7

CoLoRMap

649041

4692.1

565881

3963.8

442948

12050

98.715

94.3361

160:00:22

16:07:18

57.3

Nanocorr

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

>72:00:00

-

proovread

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

>72:00:00

-

LSC

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

>72:00:00

-

  1. Note: HG-CoLoR reported an error when correcting this dataset