The mitochondrial and plastid genomes of Volvox carteri: bloated molecules rich in repetitive DNA
BMC Genomics volume 10, Article number: 132 (2009)
The magnitude of noncoding DNA in organelle genomes can vary significantly; it is argued that much of this variation is attributable to the dissemination of selfish DNA. The results of a previous study indicate that the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) of the green alga Volvox carteri abounds with palindromic repeats, which appear to be selfish elements. We became interested in the evolution and distribution of these repeats when, during a cursory exploration of the V. carteri nuclear DNA (nucDNA) and plastid DNA (ptDNA) sequences, we found palindromic repeats with similar structural features to those of the mtDNA. Upon this discovery, we decided to investigate the diversity and evolutionary implications of these palindromic elements by sequencing and characterizing large portions of mtDNA and ptDNA and then comparing these data to the V. carteri draft nuclear genome sequence.
We sequenced 30 and 420 kilobases (kb) of the mitochondrial and plastid genomes of V. carteri, respectively – resulting in partial assemblies of these genomes. The mitochondrial genome is the most bloated green-algal mtDNA observed to date: ~61% of the sequence is noncoding, most of which is comprised of short palindromic repeats spread throughout the intergenic and intronic regions. The plastid genome is the largest (>420 kb) and most expanded (>80% noncoding) ptDNA sequence yet discovered, with a myriad of palindromic repeats in the noncoding regions, which have a similar size and secondary structure to those of the mtDNA. We found that 15 kb (~0.01%) of the nuclear genome are homologous to the palindromic elements of the mtDNA, and 50 kb (~0.05%) are homologous to those of the ptDNA.
Selfish elements in the form of short palindromic repeats have propagated in the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA, resulting in the distension of these genomes. Copies of these same repeats are also found in a small fraction of the nucDNA, but appear to be inert in this compartment. We conclude that the palindromic repeats in V. carteri represent a single class of selfish DNA and speculate that the derivation of this element involved the lateral gene transfer of an organelle intron that first appeared in the mitochondrial genome, spreading to the ptDNA through mitochondrion-to-plastid DNA migrations, and eventually arrived in the nucDNA through organelle-to-nucleus DNA transfer events. The overall implications of palindromic repeats on the evolution of chlorophyte organelle genomes are discussed.
The amount of noncoding DNA (i.e., intronic and intergenic DNA) in organelle genomes varies significantly. One evolutionary lineage where the gamut of organelle-genome compactness is particularly pronounced is the Chlorophyta (a phylum containing most known classes of green algae ) for which the noncoding-DNA contents span from 10% (Ostreococcus tauri) to 53% (Pseudendoclonium akinetum) for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and from 5% (Helicosporidium sp. ex Simulium jonesii) to 56% (Chlamydomonas reinhardtii) for plastid DNA (ptDNA). Although the processes influencing genome compactness are poorly understood, it is suggested that they are associated with the proliferation of selfish DNA [2–4], which we will define for the purpose of this study as any noncoding DNA element with the ability to spread its sequence to new genomic locations. Selfish DNA is ubiquitous in eukaryotic nuclear genomes and is also present, though less pervasive, in organelle genomes [5–7], including those of chlorophytes  – and see Hurst and Werren  for a review.
One proposed type of selfish DNA that is often observed in the mitochondrial and plastid genomes of chlorophytes are short palindromic repeats; these repetitive elements are marked by their short length [10–100 nucleotides (nt)] and their ability to be folded into hairpin (i.e., stem-loop) structures. Short palindromic repeats have been identified in the mtDNA and ptDNA from a variety of chlorophyte taxa (for compilations see [6, 10–13]), and there are indications that the organelle genomes of some chlorophyte species are more prone to the dissemination of palindromic repeats than those of other chlorophyte species. For example, the mtDNA of P. akinetum, the largest chlorophyte mitochondrial genome sequenced to date [95 kilobases (kb)], contains a series of short palindromic repeats that have proliferated throughout its intergenic and intronic regions ; moreover, these same palindromic elements are found in the noncoding regions of the P. akinetum ptDNA , indicating that the lateral transfer of repetitive DNA between organelle compartments is taking place – it is speculated that this process involves the hitchhiking of repeats on introns that migrate between the mtDNA and ptDNA . Short palindromic repeats in chlorophyte organelle DNA, as well as adding to the amount of noncoding DNA in a genome, have been credited for: 1) genome rearrangements , including the fragmentation and scrambling of ribosomal-RNA (rRNA) coding modules ; 2) changes in genome conformation and chromosome number [13, 15]; and 3) having regulatory functions [13, 16].
A previous study found that the mitochondrial genome of the multicellular, chlorophyte green alga Volvox carteri, a close relative to C. reinhardtii, is profuse with short palindromic repeats . By sequencing ~8 kb of mtDNA, corresponding to portions of cob, cox1, and their group-I introns, and an intergenic region between nad2 and nad6, these authors showed that at least two group-I introns and one intergenic region of the V. carteri mitochondrial genome contain extensive palindromic sequences. Ten classes of short palindromic repeats, all of which share sequence identity with one another, were discerned. Aono et al.  concluded that these repetitive elements are selfish DNA, that they are expanding the intronic and intergenic regions of the mitochondrial genome, and that they may have played a role in the fragmentation of rRNA-coding modules.
In June 2007, the United States Department of Energy Joint Genome Institute (DOE JGI) released the draft nuclear genome sequence of V. carteri . This genome is ~140 megabases (Mb) in length [18–20], which is the largest chlorophyte nuclear genome sequence currently available (see  for a compilation), and the preliminary annotation of this sequence suggests that it is rich in noncoding DNA, much of which appears to be selfish .
Our interest regarding the evolution of selfish DNA in V. carteri was sparked when we located short palindromic repeats in the V. carteri draft nuclear genome sequence that are similar to those in the mtDNA. To see if palindromic repeats are also present in the V. carteri ptDNA, we PCR amplified and sequenced an intergenic region from the plastid genome; our analysis of this sequence confirmed that the ptDNA contains palindromic repeats that have a similar size and potential secondary structure to those in the mitochondrial compartment. We, therefore, set out to do a detailed investigation of the palindromic repeats in V. carteri by sequencing and characterizing large portions of mtDNA and ptDNA and then comparing these data to the nuclear DNA (nucDNA). Our motives for this study are to gain insights into the role selfish DNA plays in organelle-genome expansion and its ability to move between genetic compartments.
General features of the mitochondrial- and plastid-DNA sequences from V. carteri
Using a long-range PCR approach in conjunction with cloning, we sequenced from V. carteri 29,961 nt of the mitochondrial genome and 420,650 nt of the plastid genome; partial genetic maps of these genomes describing the coding and noncoding regions that were sequenced are respectively shown in Figures 1 and 2. Regions of the V. carteri organelle DNA that were previously characterized (~8 kb of mtDNA and ~5 kb of ptDNA) are highlighted in pink on these maps. Although we attempted to completely sequence the mitochondrial and plastid genomes, presumed secondary structures in the mtDNA and ptDNA templates likely caused many of the sequencing reactions to suddenly stop – even when using protocols designed to alleviate this problem . Furthermore, the repetitive nature of the organelle genomes means that much of the mtDNA and ptDNA sequence data are irresolvable using the currently available genome-assembly software programs: many of the organelle intergenic and intronic DNA sequences collapse into networks of spurious repetitive motifs upon assembly. Moreover, the fact that most of the mtDNA and ptDNA intergenic regions are much longer than a typical sequencing read (some intergenic regions exceed 15 kb) means that these collapsed repeats are irresolvable. At present, the most sophisticated assembly programs use the paired-end sequencing data from whole-genome shotgun reads to resolve complex repeat regions. Because there is a V. carteri nuclear genome sequencing project , we have access to paired-end sequencing reads for the mitochondrial and plastid genomes (see Methods for details); but even with these data, neither the assembly programs nor our own manual, by-eye assembly methods can untangle these repeats. Because of these difficulties, our V. carteri mitochondrial-genome assembly, although contained in a single contig, contains six regions where the mtDNA sequence is either unreadable or unavailable (Figure 1), and the assembly of the ptDNA is divided into 34 contigs (Figure 2). Nevertheless, we did sequence and characterize enough mtDNA and ptDNA to confidently describe the abundance and various types of noncoding DNA in each of these organelle genomes.
The organelle-DNA sequences presented in this study were validated by collecting and assembling mtDNA and ptDNA sequence data that were generated by the DOE JGI V. carteri nuclear genome sequencing project . This was performed by: 1) downloading DNA-sequence trace files corresponding to the V. carteri mitochondrial and plastid genomes; 2) assembling these trace files into contigs; and 3) mapping the trace-file contigs to the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA sequences produced in this study. Ultimately, the mtDNA and ptDNA sequences coming from the DOE JGI covered all of our self-generated V. carteri sequence data with >50-fold redundancy. It is important to note that the DOE JGI data that we used to confirm our mtDNA and ptDNA sequences came from V. carteri strain HK10 (UTEX 1885), whereas the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA sequences that we generated came from strain 72-52 (UTEX 2908), which is a dissociator mutant derived from HK10 [23, 24]. In all instances, the organelle DNA sequence data coming from strain HK10 were identical to those of strain 72-52 (i.e., no ambiguities between the DOE JGI trace-file contigs and our sequences were observed), with the exception of a group-I intron that is present in the mtDNA of HK10 but absent in that of 72-52 (see below for details).
Of the 29,961 nt of V. carteri mtDNA sequence data presented here, 18,355 nt (61%) are noncoding, which include 7,870 nt (26%) of intronic DNA and 10,485 nt (35%) of intergenic DNA; the remaining 11,606 nt (39%) are comprised of 8,166 nt (27%) coding for proteins and 3,440 nt (12%) coding for structural RNAs. The intergenic regions range from 0 to >1,400 nt in length, and, on average, are 455 nt long. The AT content of the 29,961 nt mtDNA sequence is 66%. Our annotation of the V. carteri mtDNA includes 7 protein-coding genes; the full suite of rRNA-coding modules required for the formation of the large-subunit and small-subunit rRNAs; 3 tRNA-coding genes; and 3 introns, 2 of group-I affiliation, located in cox1 and cob, and 1 of group-II affiliation, located in cob (Figure 1). Both group-I introns contain an open reading frame (ORF) encoding a putative LAGLIDADG endonuclease. The sole group-II intron has an ORF for which the deduced amino-acid sequence shows similarity to a reverse transcriptase (Figure 1). The DOE JGI V. carteri mtDNA sequences that we assembled (derived from V. carteri strain HK10) have, as mentioned above, an additional group-I intron in cox1 that is not present in V. carteri strain 72-52 (Figure 1). The coding suite that we acquired for the V. carteri mtDNA is identical to that of the C. reinhardtii mitochondrial genome [16, 25, 26] as is the gene order save for two rearrangements, which are outlined on Figure 1. There are two interesting features of the V. carteri mtDNA relative to its C. reinhardtii counterpart. First, the V. carteri L8 rRNA-coding module harbours a 725 nt insertion composed of short palindromic repeats, whereas that of C. reinhardtii contains no repeats (Figure 3a). When the V. carteri L8 module is folded into a putative secondary-structure model within the context of the LSU rRNA it contains two structural constituents: L8a and L8b (corresponding to the LSU rRNA domains V and VI, respectively), where the 3' end of L8a and the 5' end of L8b border the 725 nt insertion (Figure 3b). At present, we do not know if this insertion is removed from the primary transcript so that separate L8a and L8b mature transcripts are produced or if a single mature L8 transcript is generated with the insertion. The second point of interest is that although a putative reverse transcriptase gene is found in the mtDNA of both of V. carteri (ORF750) and C. reinhardtii (rtl), that of V. carteri appears to be part of a group-II intron located in cob, whereas in C. reinhardtii, rtl is a free standing gene that is lacking an intron but speculated to have originated from one [27, 28] – see Popescu and Lee  for further discussion. The deduced amino-acid sequences of both ORF750 and rtl have a conserved domain that resembles that of a reverse transcriptase with group-II intron affiliation; however, the amino-acid sequence of ORF750 also has a conserved domain with similarity to a type-II intron maturase, while that of rtl does not. This extra domain encoded in ORF750 also explains why this ORF is twice the size of rtl (2,250 nt versus 1,119 nt).
In regard to the 420,650 nt of V. carteri ptDNA sequence data that were generated, 338,557 nt (80%) are noncoding, of which 16,005 nt are intronic DNA and 322,552 nt are intergenic DNA; 77,335 nt (19%) code for proteins and 4,758 nt (1%) code for structural RNAs. The intergenic regions that were sequenced range from 87 nt to >12,444 nt in length and have an average size of 5,103 nt. The 420 kb of ptDNA are 57% AT. Our annotation of the ptDNA sequences includes 91 genes: 60 coding for standard plastid proteins, 27 coding for structural RNAs (23 tRNAs and 4 rRNAs), and 4 corresponding to ORFs (ORF494, ORF2032, ycf12, ORF2828) that have been previously found in plastid genomes (Figure 2). Three group-I introns were observed, located in chlL, psaA, and atpA; those in the later two genes contain an ORF encoding a putative LAGLIDAD endonuclease. Five group-II introns were discerned, situated in psaA, cemA, psaB, atpA, and atpB; the introns of the latter two genes have an ORF for which the inferred amino-acid sequence resembles that of a reverse transcriptase. The group-II intron of psaA is fragmented into two separate modules, which is also the case for C. reinhardtii (Figure 2). The 91 V. carteri ptDNA genes presented here are all found in the C. reinhardtii plastid genome with the exception of ORF494. The only apparent homolog of ORF494 is the ribosomal operon-associated gene (roaA) found in the Euglena gracilis plastid genome. Note, the C. reinhardtii ptDNA encodes a further 4 tRNA-coding and one rRNA-coding regions that we were unable to amplify from V. carteri.
A graph comparing both the estimated sizes and the fraction of noncoding nucleotides in the mitochondrial and plastid genomes of V. carteri relative to those of the currently available complete organelle-genome sequences from chlorophyte-, streptophyte- and other plastid-harbouring-taxa is shown in Figure 4 [and see Additional file 1]. Values of 30 kb and 420 kb, respectively, were chosen, based on our sequence data, as minimum-estimate genome sizes for the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA.
Short palindromic repeats in the mitochondrial and plastid genomes of V. carteri
Scanning of the V. carteri mitochondrial- and plastid-DNA sequences for repetitive elements lead to the identification of a series of short palindromic repeats in both of the organelle genomes; the consensus sequences, complementary bases, and copy numbers of the mtDNA and ptDNA palindromic elements are outlined in Figures 5 and 6, respectively. Although the short palindromic repeats of the mtDNA share many of the same structural traits as those of the ptDNA (discussed below), they differ by >50% in sequence identity and, therefore, must be considered as distinct repeats relative to those of the plastid genome.
The short palindromic repeats in the V. carteri mtDNA are restricted to intergenic and intronic regions, with the exception of the palindromic elements in the L8 rRNA-coding module. All of the intergenic regions that measure >50 nt in length consist predominantly of palindromic repeats; the few intergenic regions with lengths <50 nt are composed of non-repetitive DNA. Within the intronic regions, the palindromic repeats are confined to the non-ORF portions of the group-I and group-II introns. All four of the identified mitochondrial introns contain short palindromic repeats in their non-ORF regions, including the optional group-I intron of cox1, which was found in the mtDNA of V. carteri strain HK10. Approximately 14,600 nt (~80%) of the 18,355 nt of noncoding mtDNA that were sequenced are composed of short palindromic repeats. A dotplot similarity matrix of the V. carteri mtDNA plotted against itself, shown in Supplementary Figure S1 [see Additional file 2], emphasizes the magnitude of repetitive DNA in this genome and draws attention to the high degree of sequence identity between the different palindromic elements within and among the various intergenic and intronic regions.
The short palindromic repeat elements identified in the V. carteri mtDNA show >50% sequence identity with one another and share similar structural and compositional traits (Figure 5). The individual palindromes range from 11–77 nt in length (the average size is 50 nt) and from 71–84% in their AT content. When the palindromes are folded into hairpin structures, the stem component of the hairpin varies from 4–37 nt in length, and the loop portion is usually 3–5 nt long and frequently has the sequence 5'-TAAA-3' or 5'-TTTA-3' (Figure 5). In many instances, a short palindromic repeat is found inserted within another palindromic repeat, resulting in larger, more elaborate repetitive elements; these larger repeats have a maximum length of 633 nt, and, in a few cases, are found at multiple locations in the mitochondrial genome. For example, a 550 nt repeat sequence composed of complete and incomplete short palindromic units is found in the group-I introns of cob and cox1, in the intergenic regions between cob and nad4, and in the group-II intron of cob. Some of these more complex repeats can also be folded into tRNA-like structures – as shown in Supplementary Figure S2 [see Additional file 3].
Like the mitochondrial genome, the noncoding regions of the V. carteri plastid genome abound with short palindromic sequences. These palindromic elements are observed in all of the sequenced intergenic regions that have lengths >100 nt and in the non-ORF portions of the psaA and atpA group-I introns. No palindromic elements are located in the chlL group-I intron or in any of the identified group-II introns. Overall, the short palindromic repeats constitute ~80% (~270 kb) of the 338,557 noncoding nucleotides in the V. carteri ptDNA. A dotplot similarity matrix of the V. carteri plastid genome plotted against itself (Supplementary Figure S3 [see Additional file 4]) shows the high level of sequence identity among the various palindromic repeats.
In the V. carteri ptDNA, most of the short palindromic repeats contain the sequence motif 5'-TCCCCTTTAGGGA-3' (Figure 6). The palindromes have a size range of 14–79 nt, with an average length of 50 nt, and, when folded into hairpin structures, their stems and loops vary in length from 5–29 nt and 3–5 nt, respectively. In most cases, the loops of the hairpin structures contain the sequence 5'-TAAA-3' or 5'-TTTA-3' (Figure 6). The AT content of the ptDNA palindromes varies from 39–55%. As observed for the mtDNA, the ptDNA palindromic elements are often found inserted into one another, the consequence of which is a series of multifarious repetitive sequences.
The short palindromic repeats of the mitochondrial and plastid compartments have similar structural attributes: 1) they have proliferated in intergenic regions and non-ORF segments of introns; 2) they have an average size of 50 nt and a maximum length of ~78 nt; and 3) the loops of their hairpin structures are generally 3–5 nt long with the sequence 5'-TTTA-3' or 5'-TTTA-3'.
The nuclear genome of V. carteri shares sequence identity with organelle DNA
To investigate if the short palindromic repeats in the mtDNA and ptDNA of V. carteri are present in the nucDNA, we analyzed the draft nuclear genome sequence of V. carteri at the DOE JGI . Manual curation of the V. carteri nuclear genome is still underway; therefore, only the first 75 scaffolds of the nuclear-genome assembly were analyzed. Approximately 78% of the V. carteri nucDNA is contained in these 75 scaffolds, their cumulative length is 109.2 Mb, and each scaffold is at least 0.5 Mb long. The amount of nucDNA in these 75 scaffolds that map to mtDNA and ptDNA is described in Table 1; the approximate number of nucDNA-located organelle-like repeats is outlined in Figures 5 and 6.
Thirty-three kilobases of nucDNA (~0.03% of the nuclear genome) share >90% identity with mtDNA; 14.7 kb (44%) of this shared sequence are homologous to the short palindromic repeats in the intergenic and non-ORF intronic regions of the mitochondrial genome; the remaining 10.6 kb (56%) map to the coding and intronic-ORF portions of the mtDNA (Table 1). In the nucDNA, 802 distinct regions show homology to mtDNA; the average mapping length of these regions is 39 nt. Of the 75 nuclear scaffolds that were analyzed, all but two (scaffold 66 and 75) have at least one region that shows homology to mtDNA.
Seventy-three kilobases of the V. carteri nucDNA (~0.07% of the nuclear genome) share >90% identity with ptDNA; 50.6 kb (69%) of this shared sequence are homologous to the short palindromic repeats in the intergenic and non-ORF-intronic portions of the ptDNA, and 22.5 kb (31%) are homologous to the coding regions and intronic ORFs of the plastid genome (Table 1). In the nuclear genome, 1,450 different regions show homology to ptDNA, and the average similarity length is 29 nt. All of the 75 nuclear scaffolds that were examined have at least one region that shows homology to ptDNA.
In total, 65.4 kb (~0.06%) of the V. carteri nuclear-genome-sequence data that were analyzed share sequence identity to the short palindromic repeats of the organelle genomes. The secondary structure and general characteristics of the nuclear-palindromic repeat elements are the same as those described for the organelle palindromes in Figures 5 and 6.
In order to place the V. carteri data described above in a broader context, we analyzed the C. reinhardtii nuclear genome for regions that show sequence identity to its mtDNA and ptDNA – these results are summarized in Supplementary Table S2 [see Additional file 5]. Only 0.007% of the C. reinhardtii nuclear genome maps to organelle DNA (0.0035% to the mtDNA and 0.0035% to the ptDNA), which is 10-times less than what is observed for V. carteri (0.01%).
Expanded architectures and the proliferation of selfish DNA in the organelle genomes of V. carteri
The V. carteri organelle genomes are profuse with noncoding DNA. Our analyses indicate that the mitochondrial genome is >61% noncoding, which is the most expanded chlorophyte-mtDNA sequence currently deposited in Genbank  – other complete mitochondrial genome sequences from chlorophyte are larger only because they contain more genes. The plastid genome is the largest (>420 kb) and most bloated (>81% noncoding) ptDNA sequence from any taxon observed to date (Figure 4). Heretofore, the largest documented plastid genome was 223.9 kb, belonging to the chlorophyte Stigeoclonium helveticum ; and the plastid genome with the highest fraction of noncoding DNA was that of C. reinhardtii (56% noncoding) . At present, due to a lack of available mtDNA and ptDNA sequence data, we do not know if other colonial or multicellular algae in the volvocine line of the Chlorophyceae have bloated organelle genomes as a result of excessive noncoding DNA. Preliminary investigations of the Volvox aureus mitochondrial genome indicate that it harbours palindromic repeats; these repeats do not share sequence similarity with those of the V. carteri mtDNA .
The fact that short palindromic repeats respectively constitute ~80% and ~75% of the mtDNA and ptDNA noncoding regions suggests that these elements precipitated the expansion of the organelle genomes. We must, therefore, ask: how did the palindromic repeats disseminate their sequence throughout the noncoding regions of the organelle DNA? The processes by which this could have occurred include transposition, retrotransposition via an RNA intermediate, and recombination-based mechanisms, such as gene conversion (for a review on the mobility of selfish DNA see Austin and Trivers ); at present, we are not partial to any one of these mechanisms. It is worth noting, however, that both the mitochondrial and plastid genomes of V. carteri encode a putative reverse transcriptase and a putative endonuclease; the mutual association of these enzymes has been invoked for mediating the retrotransposition of selfish DNA. Koll et al.  propose that the mobility of an ultra-short invasive element in the mtDNA of the filamentous fungus Podospora anserina is instigated by a group-II-intron-encoded reverse transcriptase; they also suggest that an intron-encoded endonuclease generates the 3'-hydroxyl required for reverse transcription. Of all the intronic ORFs deposited in Genbank, the deduced amino-acid sequence of ORF261 in the Volvox mtDNA shows the greatest identity (46%; expectation values = 6 × 10-48) to that of the cox1-intronic ORF of P. anserina. Another intriguing observation is that the short palindromic repeats in the V. carteri organelle and nuclear genomes are found in both orientations on the same strand, i.e., the same sequence can occur in the 3' to 5' and 5' to 3' directions – this is suggestive of a transposition-mediated mechanism of mobility rather than one based on recombination.
Short palindromic repeats in the three genetic compartments of V. carteri
Short palindromic repeats are found in the three genetic compartments of V. carteri. The palindromic elements of the mtDNA are structurally similar but different in nucleotide sequence to those of the ptDNA, whereas the nucDNA palindromes are of two types: those that map to the mtDNA and those that map to ptDNA. These observations evoke several questions, such as are the palindromic repeats in the mtDNA and ptDNA related? And if so, in what genetic compartment did they first appear? Moreover, how did the nucDNA acquire palindromes that share sequence identity to those of the mitochondrial and plastid genomes, and why are they not as abundant as those of the organelle DNA? And finally, are the palindromic elements indigenous to V. carteri or are they the products of lateral gene transfer?
Although the mtDNA palindromic repeats differ in nucleotide sequence to the palindromes of the ptDNA, these two groups of repeats share enough structural features to suggest that they have descended from a common repetitive element and, thus, represent a single class of selfish DNA. For instance, in both the mitochondrial and plastid compartments the palindromic repeats reside in identical genomic landscapes (intergenic regions and non-ORF portions of introns) and they also inhabit these noncoding regions in similar abundances, representing ~80% of the noncoding nucleotides in both the mitochondrial and plastid genomes. Moreover, the mtDNA and ptDNA palindromes fold into hairpin structures where the loop portion is consistently 5'-TAAA-3' or 5'-ATTT-3'.
The same palindromic elements that have propagated in the V. carteri organelle DNA are also found in a small fraction (~0.06%) of the nucDNA. Although these nuclear-palindromic repeats can share up to 100% sequence identity with those of the mtDNA or ptDNA, many are degenerate with mismatches in the stem component of their hairpin structures. This observation, coupled with the relatively low abundance of these repeats in the nuclear genome, leads us to suggest that the nucDNA palindromes are inert, accumulating in the nucDNA through both mitochondrial-to-nucleus and plastid-to-nucleus DNA-transfer events – the movement of organelle DNA to nuclear genomes is well documented [34–37]. Further evidence to support this hypothesis is the fact that the proposed organelle-derived palindromes are present within the nuclear genome in the same proportions as other genetic regions from the mitochondrial and plastid genomes, such as coding regions (Table 1).
Two observations regarding the derivation of the short palindromic repeats in V. carteri are worth noting. First, the palindromic elements appear to have a strong affinity for the non-ORF regions of organelle introns, especially those in the mitochondrial genome. Because organelle introns are, themselves, a type of selfish element, which can migrate between organelle compartments, both within a species and between unrelated species ([38, 39], and see  for a discussion on volvocalean ptDNA group-I introns), it is not unreasonable to surmise that the origin of the short palindromic repeats in V. carteri is linked to lateral intron transfer. The second observation is that the short palindromic repeats have propagated in only two of the nine introns in the V. carteri plastid genome: the group-I introns of psaA and atpA. Why have the other seven plastid introns (one group-I and six group-II introns) remained inviolate from palindromic elements? The two group-I plastid introns that contain short palindromic repeats belong to subgroup IB. Considering that the other group-I intron in the ptDNA (that of chlL), which is devoid of palindromes, is also of subgroup IB, it seems unlikely that the palindromic elements are favouring a certain class of intron. It is noteworthy that the chlL group-I intron lacks a LAGLIDADG homing endonuclease, whereas the group-I introns of psaA and atpA, as well as those of the mtDNA, harbour LAGLIDADG ORFs – perhaps, as suggested above, the mobility of the palindromic elements is dependent on intronic endonuclease proteins. Another possibility is that the plastid genome was seeded with short palindromic repeats after the inception of palindromic elements in the mtDNA and, therefore, the plastid palindromic repeats have not had sufficient time to spread to all of the intronic regions in the ptDNA; moreover, some of ptDNA introns may have arrived more recently in evolutionary time than those of psaA and atpA, and, thus, have not yet been seeded with repeats.
Short palindromic repeats and the evolution of fragmented ribosomal-RNA-coding modules
When Aono et al.  first identified short palindromic repeats in the V. carteri mitochondrial genome they predicted that these repeats would be associated with the fragmentation of rRNA-transcripts. The mtDNA data presented here may support these predications. Our annotation of the V. carteri mitochondrial genome contains eight modules encoding the LSU rRNA, and their arrangement within the mtDNA is identical to that of C. reinhardtii, with the exception that the L8 module of V. carteri contains a large block of palindromic repeats, whereas that of C. reinhardtii harbours no repetitive mtDNA. At the present time we do not know if this insertion represents a fragmentation point within the L8 coding module that is removed from the primary transcript or if it is maintained as a variable region within an intact L8 transcript. We favour the former possibility because in the latter scenario the insertion is three-fold larger than any previously reported variable region identified in ribosomal RNA – based on the Comparative RNA Website .
The goal of this study was to investigate the genomic breadth and the evolutionary implications of short palindromic repeats in the organelle and nuclear genomes of V. carteri. Our findings indicate that selfish DNA, in the form of palindromic elements, have proliferated in the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA; and although copies of this element exist in the nuclear compartment, we suggest that they are inert and arrived in the nuclear genome via rare organelle-to-nucleus DNA transfer events. We speculate that the palindromic repeats in V. carteri descended from a single invasive element, perhaps first seeded in V. carteri through the lateral gene transfer of a mitochondrial intron, eventually spreading to the ptDNA through mitochondrial-to-plastid DNA migration. Overall, the palindromic repeats appear to be involved with the expansion of the V. carteri organelle DNA and have potentially precipitated a gene fragmentation event in the mitochondrial genome.
Strain and DNA extractions
The sequence data generated in this study were obtained from the 72-52 dissociator mutant of V. carteri (UTEX 2908), which is derived from V. carteri strain HK10 (UTEX 885) [23, 24]. Total genomic DNA was extracted using the DNeasy Plant Mini Kit (Qiagen, Germantown, MD, USA) following manufacturer's protocol.
Amplification, cloning, and sequencing of DNA fragments
The organelle loci examined in this study were amplified using a PCR-based approach. PCR reactions were performed with the LongRange PCR Kit (Qiagen) using total genomic DNA as the template. PCR products were cloned using the TOPO TA Cloning Kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA). Purified PCR products and isolated plasmids were sequenced on both strands at the Macrogen Sequencing Facility, Rockville, MD.
Assembly of the mitochondrial and plastid DNA sequences
Sequences were edited and assembled using CodonCode Aligner Version 2.0.6 (CodonCode Corporation, Dedham, MA, USA), which employs the Phred, Cross-match, and Phrap algorithms for base calling, sequence comparison, and sequence assembly, respectively. Assemblies were performed with a minimum-percent-identity score of 98, a minimum-overlap length of 500 nt, a match score of 1, a mismatch penalty of -2, a gap penalty of -2, and an additional first gap penalty of -3.
The mtDNA and ptDNA data presented in this study were validated by collecting and assembling mitochondrial- and plastid-genome sequences that were generated by the V. carteri nuclear genome sequencing project . These sequences were obtained by blasting our mtDNA and ptDNA data against the V. carteri f. nagariensis Whole Genome Shotgun Reads Trace Archive Database at the National Center for Biotechnological Information (NCBI) . Blast hits showing >99% similarity to our V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA sequences were downloaded and assembled (using the assembly program and parameters described above); the downloaded mitochondrial and plastid sequences were subsequently blasted against the V. carteri draft nuclear genome sequence (v1.0 Repeatmasked)  to verify that no nuclear-genome-located mtDNA-like or ptDNA-like sequences were collected.
Analyses of repeats, introns, and intergenic regions
An initial scan for repetitive elements in the V. carteri mtDNA and ptDNA sequence data was performed with REPuter [43, 44] using the Hamming distance option and a minimal-repeat-size setting of 12 nt – note, forward, reverse, complement, and reverse complement repeats were all considered under REPuter. Further analyses of the V. carteri organelle DNA repeats were performed in Geneious (Biomatters LtD, Auckland, NZ) by building a Blast databank of the mtDNA and ptDNA sequences and then blasting these databanks with specific regions from the mitochondrial and plastid genomes. Mfold  was employed for secondary-structure analyses. The mtDNA and ptDNA introns were detected, classified, and folded into secondary structures using RNAweasel [46, 47]. The noncoding-DNA estimates presented for the V. carteri organelle genomes were inferred from the average-intergenic-spacer sizes and intron-densities of the mtDNA and ptDNA data that were collected. Dotplot similarity matrices were plotted with JDotter . The LSU rRNA secondary-structure model depicted in Figure 3 is based on that of Boer and Gray . The C. reinhardtii mtDNA-introns shown in Figure 1 are described elsewhere .
Inspection of V. carteri nuclear DNA for organelle-like sequences
The V. carteri nucDNA was scanned for regions of identity to organelle DNA by blasting  the mtDNA and ptDNA sequences produced in this study against the V. carteri draft nuclear genome sequence (v1.0 Repeatmasked)  using an expectation value of 1 × 10-5 and a word size of 11. Organelle-DNA sequences that mapped to the nuclear genome with >90% identity and at least 25 nt of aligned length were counted as hits. The same protocol employed for V. carteri was used to scan the C. reinhardtii nucDNA for regions that show identity to organelle sequences. The C. reinhardtii nucDNA scaffolds (version 3.1) were downloaded from the DOE JGI .
The mtDNA and ptDNA sequences generated in this study are found in Genbank under the accession numbers EU760701 and EU755264–EU755299, respectively.
Lewis LA, McCourt RM: Green algae and the origin of land plants. Am J Bot. 2004, 91: 1535-1556.
Doolittle WF, Sapienza C: Selfish genes, the phenotype paradigm and genome evolution. Nature. 1980, 284: 601-603.
Orgel LE, Crick FH: Selfish DNA: the ultimate parasite. Nature. 1980, 284: 604-607.
Lynch M: The Origins of Genome Architecture. 2007, Sunderland: Sinauer Associates, Inc
Paquin B, Laforest MJ, Lang BF: Double-hairpin elements in the mitochondrial DNA of Allomyces: evidence for mobility. Mol Biol Evol. 2000, 17: 1760-1768.
Maul JE, Lilly JW, Cui L, dePamphilis CW, Miller W, Harris EH, Stern DB: The Chlamydomonas reinhardtii plastid chromosome: islands of genes in a sea of repeats. Plant Cell. 2002, 14: 2659-2679.
Smith DR, Snyder M: Complete mitochondrial DNA sequence of the scallop Placopecten magellanicus: evidence of transposition leadng to an uncharacteristically large mitochondrial genome. J Mol Evol. 2007, 65: 380-391.
Fan WH, Woelfe MA, Mosig G: Two copies of a DNA element 'Wendy', in the chloroplast chromosome of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii between rearranged gene clusters. Plant Mol Biol. 1995, 29: 63-80.
Hurst GDD, Werren JH: The role of selfish genetic elements in eukaryotic evolution. Nat Rev Genet. 2001, 2: 597-606.
Nedelcu AM, Lee RW: Short repetitive sequences in green algal mitochondrial genomes: potential roles in mitochondrial genome evolution. Mol Biol Evol. 1998, 15: 690-701.
Pombert JF, Beauchamp P, Otis C, Lemieux C, Turmel M: The complete mitochondrial DNA sequence of the green alga Pseudendoclonium akinetum (Ulvophyceae) highlights distinctive evolutionary trends in the Chlorophyta and suggests a sister-group relationship between the Ulvophyceae and Chlorophyceae. Mol Biol Evol. 2004, 21: 922-935.
Pombert JF, Otis C, Lemieux C, Turmel M: The chloroplast genome sequence of the green alga Pseudendoclonium akinetum (Ulvophyceae) reveals unusual structural features and new insights into the branching order of chlorophyte lineages. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 1903-1918.
Smith DR, Lee RW: Mitochondrial genome of the colorless green alga Polytomella capuana: a linear molecule with an unprecedented GC content. Mol Biol Evol. 2008, 25: 487-496.
Nedelcu AM: Fragmented and scrambled mitochondrial ribosomal RNA coding regions among green algae: a model for their origin and evolution. Mol Biol Evol. 1997, 14: 506-517.
Nedelcu AM: Contrasting mitochondrial genome organizations and sequence affiliations among green algae: potential factors, mechanisms, and evolutionary scenarios. J Phycol. 1998, 34: 16-28.
Gray MW, Boer PH: Organization and expression of algal (Chlamydomonas reinhardtii) mitochondrial DNA. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 1988, 319: 135-147.
Aono N, Shimizu T, Inoue T, Shiraishi H: Palindromic repetitive elements in the mitochondrial genome of Volvox. FEBS Lett. 2002, 521: 95-99.
United States Department of Energy Joint Genome Institute (JGI) Volvox carteri nuclear genome assembly v1.0. [http://genome.jgi-psf.org/Volca1/Volca1.home.html]
Kirk DL, Harper JF: Genetic, biochemical and molecular approaches to Volvox development and evolution. Int Rev Cytol. 1986, 99: 217-93.
Kirk DL: Volvox: Molecular-genetic Origins of Multicellularity and Cellular Differentiation. 1998, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Merchant SS, Prochnik SE, Vallon O, 117 co-authors, et al: The Chlamydomonas genome reveals the evolution of key animal and plant functions. Science. 2007, 318: 245-250.
Macrogen Sequencing Facility: sequencing of difficult templates. [http://www.macrogen.com/eng/sequencing/dna.jsp]
Sessoms AH, Huskey RJ: Genetic control of development in Volvox: isolation and characterization of morphogenetic mutants. P Natl Acad Sci USA. 1973, 70: 1335-1338.
Dauwalder M, Whaley WG, Starr RC: Differentiation and secretion in Volvox. J Ultrastruct Res. 1980, 70: 318-335.
Michaelis G, Vahrenholz C, Pratje E: Mitochondrial DNA of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: the gene for apocytochrome b and the complete functional map of the 15.8 kb DNA. Mol Gen Genet. 1990, 223: 211-216.
Vahrenholz C, Riemen G, Pratje E, Dujon B, Michaelis G: Mitochondrial DNA of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: the structure of the ends of the linear 15.8-kb genome suggests mechanisms for DNA replication. Curr Genet. 1993, 24: 241-247.
Boer PH, Gray MW: Genes encoding a subunit of respiratory NADH dehydrogenase (ND1) and a reverse transcriptase-like protein (RTL) are linked to ribosomal RNA gene pieces in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mitochondrial DNA. EMBO J. 1988, 7: 3501-3508.
Nedelcu AM, Lee RW: A degenerate group II intron in the intronless mitochondrial genome of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: evolutionary implications. Mol Biol Evol. 1988, 7: 918-922.
Popescu CE, Lee RW: Mitochondrial genome sequence evolution in Chlamydomonas. Genetics. 2007, 175: 819-826.
National center for biotechnology information entrez organelle-genome database. [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genomes/genlist.cgi?taxid=2759&type=4&name=Eukaryotae%20Organelles]
Bélanger AS, Brouard JS, Charlebois P, Otis C, Lemieux C, Turmel M: Distinctive architecture of the chloroplast genome in the chlorophycean green alga Stigeoclonium helveticum. Mol Genet Genomics. 2006, 276: 464-477.
Austin B, Trivers R: Genes in Conflict: the Biology of Selfish Genetic Elements. 2006, Cambridge: Harvard University Press
Koll F, Boulay J, Belcour L, d'Aubenton-Carafa Y: Contribution of ultra-short invasive elements to the evolution of the mitochondrial genome in the genus Podospora. Nucleic Acids Res. 1996, 24: 1734-1741.
Adams KL, Palmer JD: Evolution of mitochondrial gene content: gene loss and transfer to the nucleus. Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2003, 29: 380-395.
Timmis JN, Ayliffe MA, Huang CY, Martin W: Endosymbiotic gene transfer: organelle genomes forge eukaryotic chromosomes. Nat Rev Genet. 2004, 5: 123-135.
Richly E, Leister D: NUMTs in sequenced eukaryotic genomes. Mol Biol Evol. 2004, 21: 1081-1084.
Richly E, Leister D: NUPTs in sequenced eukaryotes and their genomic organization in relation to NUMTs. Mol Biol Evol. 2004, 21: 1972-1980.
Turmel M, Côté V, Otis C, Mercier JP, Gray MW, Lonergan KM, Lemieux C: Evolutionary transfer of ORF-containing group I introns between different subcellular compartments (chloroplast and mitochondrion). Mol Biol Evol. 1995, 12: 533-545.
Turmel M, Lemieux C, Burger G, Lang BF, Otis C, Plante I, Gray MW: The complete mitochondrial DNA sequences of Nephroselmis olivacea and Pedinomonas minor. Two radically different evolutionary patterns within green algae. Plant Cell. 1999, 11: 1717-1729.
Nozaki H, Takahara M, Nakazawa A, Kita Y, Yamada T, Takano H, Kawano S, Kato M: Evolution of rbcL group IA introns and intron open reading frames within the colonial Volvocales (Chlorophyceae). Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2002, 23: 326-338.
Comparative RNA web site and project. [http://www.rna.ccbb.utexas.edu/]
Trace archive database mega BLAST search. [http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast/mmtrace.shtml]
Kurtz S, Schleiermacher C: REPuter: fast computation of maximal repeats in complete genomes. Bioinformatics. 1999, 15: 426-427.
Zuker M: Mfold web server for nucleic acid folding and hybridization prediction. Nucleic Acids Res. 2003, 31: 3406-3415.
Lang BF, Laforest MJ, Burger G: Mitochondrial introns: a critical view. Trends Genet. 2007, 23: 119-125.
Brodie R, Roper RL, Upton C: JDotter: a Java interface to multiple dotplots generated by dotter. Bioinformatics. 2004, 20: 279-281.
Boer PH, Gray MW: Scrambled ribosomal RNA gene pieces in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii mitochondrial DNA. Cell. 1988, 55: 399-411.
Smith DR, Lee RW: Nucleotide diversity in the mitochondrial and nuclear compartments of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: investigating the origins of genome architecture. BMC Evol Biol. 2008, 8: 156-
Altschul SF, Gish W, Miller W, Myers EW, Lipman DJ: Basic local alignment search tool. J Mol Biol. 1990, 215: 403-410.
United States Department of Energy Joint Genome Institute (JGI) Chlamydomonas reinhardtii nuclear genome assembly v3.0. [http://genome.jgi-psf.org/Chlre3/Chlre3.home.html]
This work was supported by a grant to R.W.L. from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) of Canada. D.R.S. is an Izaak Walton Killam Memorial Scholar and holds a Canada Graduate Scholarship from NSERC.
DRS carried out the molecular studies, data analyses, and wrote the manuscript. RWL helped in interpreting the data and revising the manuscript. Both DRS and RWL have read and approved the final version of this manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional File 1: Supplementary Table S1. The fraction of noncoding DNA in completely-sequenced mitochondrial and plastid genomes from streptophytes, chlorophytes, and other plastid-harbouring taxa. (PDF 123 KB)
Additional File 2: Supplementary Figure S1. Dotplot similarity matrix of the Volvox carteri mitochondrial DNA plotted against itself. (PDF 435 KB)
Additional File 3: Supplementary Figure S2. Putative secondary-structure diagrams of the tRNA pseudogenes identified in the mitochondrial genome of Volvox carteri. (PDF 178 KB)
Additional File 4: Supplementary Figure S3. Dotplot similarity matrix of the Volvox carteri plastid DNA plotted against itself. (PDF 651 KB)
Additional File 5: Supplementary Table S2. Amount of nuclear DNA in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii that maps to its mitochondrial and plastid genomes. (PDF 90 KB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Smith, D.R., Lee, R.W. The mitochondrial and plastid genomes of Volvox carteri: bloated molecules rich in repetitive DNA. BMC Genomics 10, 132 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2164-10-132