Development and mapping of DArT markers within the Festuca - Lolium complex
BMC Genomics volume 10, Article number: 473 (2009)
Grasses are among the most important and widely cultivated plants on Earth. They provide high quality fodder for livestock, are used for turf and amenity purposes, and play a fundamental role in environment protection. Among cultivated grasses, species within the Festuca-Lolium complex predominate, especially in temperate regions. To facilitate high-throughput genome profiling and genetic mapping within the complex, we have developed a Diversity Arrays Technology (DArT) array for five grass species: F. pratensis, F. arundinacea, F. glaucescens, L. perenne and L. multiflorum.
The DArTFest array contains 7680 probes derived from methyl-filtered genomic representations. In a first marker discovery experiment performed on 40 genotypes from each species (with the exception of F. glaucescens for which only 7 genotypes were used), we identified 3884 polymorphic markers. The number of DArT markers identified in every single genotype varied from 821 to 1852. To test the usefulness of DArTFest array for physical mapping, DArT markers were assigned to each of the seven chromosomes of F. pratensis using single chromosome substitution lines while recombinants of F. pratensis chromosome 3 were used to allocate the markers to seven chromosome bins.
The resources developed in this project will facilitate the development of genetic maps in Festuca and Lolium, the analysis on genetic diversity, and the monitoring of the genomic constitution of the Festuca × Lolium hybrids. They will also enable marker-assisted selection for multiple traits or for specific genome regions.
Grasses are among the most important and widely cultivated plants on Earth, with a total area of grassland estimated to be twice that of cropland. In Europe, fifty percent of the farmed landscape is under grasses which accounts for a large proportion of the annual production of beef and milk with a total value of more than € 70 billion . They are also used extensively for turf and amenity purposes, and play an important role in soil conservation and protection of environmental resources. Among the cultivated grasses, ryegrasses (Lolium spp.) and fescues (Festuca spp.) predominate, especially in temperate climates .
Fescues and ryegrasses are closely related and belong to the Poaceae. Whereas Lolium consists of only eight diploid species, Festuca comprises nearly 500 species with ploidy levels ranging from diploid to dodecaploid. The two agronomically exploited fescues - F. pratensis and F. arundinacea - belong to the Bovinae section, subgenus Schedonorus [3, 4], but the systematics of Lolium and Festuca are still a subject for review. Darbyshire  proposed to merge Festuca subgenus Schedonorus with the Lolium. However, clear differentiation of Lolium and Festuca into two separate taxa is supported based on morphological traits, isozymes , RAPD markers , analysis of ITS and the chloroplast trn region , as well as EST-SSR markers .
Decades of breeding resulted in superior ryegrass and fescue cultivars outperforming their wild progenitors. However, there is a risk that some desirable alleles of the progenitors were lost during the breeding process. The analysis of genetic diversity in cultivars of Dactylis glomerata and Gossypium arboreum revealed lower levels of intraspecific variability as compared to the wild types [10, 11]. Similar trends were observed in F. pratensis  and L. perenne . Investigations of genetic diversity of Nordic F. pratensis cultivars and natural populations have shown that although the molecular genetic variation has not been reduced by breeding , the phenotypic variation in important agronomic traits is lower in cultivars when compared to natural populations . Thus, the existing gene pool of wild accessions represents an invaluable source of alleles, which can be introduced into existing cultivars. The risk of erosion of species' gene pools calls for characterization of the natural genetic variability and its conservation in gene banks. An ideal system to describe genetic diversity should allow for parallel screening of thousands of genomic loci and quickly analyze many accessions at a low cost. Such a method will allow more effective selection of material for breeding purposes.
A high-throughput genotyping system is also required to speed up the development of new cultivars with desirable attributes using marker assisted selection (MAS). For MAS, the development of genetic markers and genetic linkage maps is required. Several genetic maps were constructed for Lolium spp. using isozymes, RFLP, AFLP, RAPD, SSR, and EST-derived CAPS markers [15–21]. Markers associated with traits such as disease resistance [22–24], winter hardiness , quality parameters  and fertility traits  have been identified through the analysis of quantitative trait loci (QTL). Within fescue species, genetic maps were generated for both agronomically important species - F. arundinacea and F. pratensis [28, 29]. The identification of QTLs for resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses as well as the application of genetic markers in cultivar development has been recently summarized by Zhang et al. .
In addition to breeding of fescue and ryegrass cultivars, some breeding programs have released cultivars originating from intergeneric crosses of Festuca with Lolium (called Festuloliums), thereby combining desirable agronomic characteristics of both genera . The ryegrass species - L. multiflorum Lam. and L. perenne L. are highly nutritious, palatable and digestible, and display numerous valuable characteristics for turf culture including deep green color, uniformity, and rapid establishment. Fescues are known for their adaptation to abiotic stresses. In particular, F. arundinacea is well known for its drought tolerance, while F. pratensis carries genes for winter hardiness. Until recently, the genomic constitution of commercial Festulolium cultivars was mostly a matter of speculation and extrapolation from research stocks. Kopecký et al. , using genomic in situ hybridization (GISH), demonstrated that genomic composition of the commercial Festulolium varied significantly, depending on the parents used for hybrid development and the breeding strategy employed. While GISH is a very powerful and simple method for karyotypic studies in the Lolium-Festuca complex, it does have limited resolution. While this resolution limit has not yet been established in grasses, in wheat-rye hybrids it was found to be up to the Mb level . Obviously, this limits the technique to identification of large genomic regions. Low throughput is another bottleneck preventing its broader use in breeding. Thus, a more sensitive and effective system is needed for genotyping in breeding of commercial Festulolium cultivars.
The need for a high-throughput genotyping system led to the development of various DNA arrays and chips (reviewed in ). Although they are based on different principles, all of them can be used to screen thousands or hundreds of thousands genomic loci in a single pass. However, most of them are based on scoring single nucleotide or single feature polymorphisms (SNP and SFP, respectively) and the development of such markers requires detailed knowledge of the DNA sequence. Therefore, it can only be used with some degree of success in species with at least some minimum level of DNA sequencing completed. In contrast, Diversity Arrays Technology (DArT) is a microarray hybridization based technique that permits simultaneous screening thousands of polymorphic loci without any prior sequence information . DArT is high-throughput, low-cost, quick and reproducible. It has been used for genotyping and genetic mapping of genomes in numerous species, such as Arabidopsis thaliana , Hordeum vulgare [36, 37], Triticum aestivum [38, 39], Cajanus cajan , Sorghum bicolor  and many others. DArT markers were also employed in the construction of a physical map of wheat chromosome 3B .
In this study we report on the development of a DArT array for five agronomically important species within the Festuca-Lolium complex. We demonstrate the utility of the approach for the estimation of intra- and interspecific genetic diversity. Moreover, by combining the DArT array with cytogenetic information in specific stocks of Festulolium, we illustrate successful anchoring of sets of DArT markers to individual chromosomes and chromosome bins.
Development of DArT array
We developed a DArT array containing 7680 probes derived from methyl-filtered (through the use of Pst I restriction enzyme) genomic representations. In the first marker discovery experiment performed with 40 genotypes from each of the species L. perenne, L. multiflorum, F. pratensis and F. arundinacea, and seven genotypes of F. glaucescens, we identified 3884 polymorphic markers with standard DArTsoft settings. This is the highest frequency of polymorphism (50.6%) reported for DArT arrays, consistent with a very high level of DNA sequence variation in the fescue/ryegrass complex. Such a high degree of polymorphism was not unexpected, because the array consists of five different species of two genera. Most of these markers detected reliable polymorphisms across all accessions tested, while a subset of markers worked reliably only in a subset of diversity tested on the array.
In order to estimate the level of redundancy of markers on the array we used 184 festuloliums samples. It is important not to confuse the apparent redundancy (very high level of correlation between pairs of markers) which is due to Linkage Disequilibrium (LD) in the material analysed and probe sequence redundancy due to sampling the same (or highly similar) restriction fragment due to the random cloning process. The festuoliums lines we used for redundancy analysis were derived from various parents through interspecific hybridizations therefore they are expected to have very low level of LD. We applied correlation analysis of all possible pairs of 2352 markers discovered in the analysis (data not presented) and found a low level of redundancy: out of 1983 unique score signatures we found 1713 singletons, 198 bins with 2 markers, 53 bins with 3 markers, 11 bins with 4 markers, 6 bins with 5 markers and single bins with 6 and 7 markers, respectively. The detected level of redundancy (16%) will be verified in the future through sequencing, but taking this preliminary estimate we can conclude that there are approximately 3260 unique markers on the array (0.84 × 3884).
Analysis of genetic diversity using DArT markers
Of the 3884 polymorphic markers identified on the array when polymorphic markers detected in each species were summed up only 2629 markers gave unequivocal scores in the joint fuzzy C-means clustering-based classification of all five species (see Additional file 1). Joint classification of signal on DArT arrays was compromised for the remaining 1255 markers by multiple alleles present in the same locus of the five species. Different alleles present in targets, especially when dealing with different species, often result in different levels of relative signal intensity for a probe on the array, either due to sequence or fragment length difference. These different levels of signal intensity do not conform to bimodal distribution DArTsoft requires for unambiguous 0/1 binarisation (scoring).
Using these 2629 markers, we compiled a dendrogram including all 167 accessions of fescue and ryegrass. This differentiated two major groups, representing the fescue and ryegrass genera (Figures 1 and 2). Both ryegrass species analyzed (L. perenne and L. multiflorum) were closely related, but divergent enough to form separate groups. Fescue species formed two major groups. The first one included F. pratensis and, as the level of DArT polymorphism among F. pratensis accessions was low, they formed a tight group in the dendrogram. The second group included F. arundinacea and F. glaucescens. This group included two subgroups, one representing F. arundinacea accessions and the second F. glaucescens accessions. F. arundinacea accession Fa-35 (Moroccan ecotype 599533) was placed distant from the main F. arundinacea cluster. Similarly, one accession of F. glaucescens Fg-7 (genotype FRA001, obtained from Seed Bank, W. Reg. P. I. Station, Pullman, WA) clustered with the subgroup of F. arundinacea. All plants of this accession tested had chromosome numbers 2n = 42, indicating that this accession was probably a mislabeled F. arundinacea, and not of F. glaucescens origin. Moreover, the number of markers that scored positive ("1") in this accession (1253 markers) was higher than in any other accession of F. glaucescens (1059 - 1101 positive markers per accession) and was similar to those of F. arundinacea (1000 - 1351 markers per accession). Another inconsistent accession, F. pratensis Fp-40 (Norwegian cultivar Norild), was located outside of all other species in the dendrogram probably due to contamination of its DNA. Both accessions (Fg-7 and Fp-40) were excluded from further analyses.
The molecular genetic diversity analyses revealed several attributes characteristic for all species:
(1) Ecotypes from one country were usually more closely related than those from different countries (as in case of Lithuanian ecotypes of F. pratensis 3982 and 3985).
(2) Cultivars released in one country usually displayed little polymorphism (as in case of F. arundinacea cultivars Eldorado and Wrangler released in USA and L. perenne cultivars Jakub and Kelt released in Czech Republic).
(3) Ryegrasses displayed higher levels of polymorphism than fescues.
Polymorphism between the parents of mapping populations
With the prospect of using the array for mapping various agronomically important traits, we evaluated the presence of polymorphisms among (grand-) parents of mapping populations, which were deliberately included in our set of genotypes in the marker discovery stage of the project. It is clear that the level of marker polymorphism among the parents of mapping populations depends primarily on the purpose for which any specific map was developed. Where the purpose was to generate general genetic maps, the parents should be genetically as distant as possible, thus the number of polymorphic markers was expected to be high. This was the case for the L. perenne F2 mapping population VrnA, where 464 DArT markers were polymorphic between the grandparents NGB and VEYO (see Additional file 2). On the other hand, when a mapping population was generated to target a few specific traits, the parents can be genetically similar except for the region(s) harboring the gene(s) of interest. For example, only 289 polymorphic markers were found between LTS-01 and LTS-02. These two parental genotypes are both derived from similar gene pools, but designed to maximize heterozygosity for nitrogen use efficiency and cell wall digestibility, respectively.
Genus- and species-specificity of DArT markers
Reliable discrimination of DNA markers from both grass genera tested here, and possibly also from individual species, would greatly expand the utility of the DArT array. As the DArTFest array contained markers derived from both genera and all five species tested, our subsequent analysis focused on identifying genus- and species-specific markers. Of 3884 polymorphic DArT markers identified, over 1,000 markers detected a positive ("1") allele in each species (Table 1). The highest number of such markers "1" was in F. pratensis (between 1619 and 1821 markers per accession) and in L. multiflorum (between 1507 and 1852 markers per accession). Lower numbers of markers were detected in F. arundinacea (between 1000 and 1351 markers per accession), in F. glaucescens (between 1059 and 1101 markers per accession) and in L. perenne (between 821 and 1127 markers per accession). However, a large proportion of markers present in all five species tested reduced the numbers of species-specific markers. Thus, only nine species-specific markers were detected in F. glaucescens. For the two other fescue species, 34 and 123 species-specific markers were identified in F. arundinacea and F, pratensis, respectively. The number of markers shared between the allopolyploid F. arundinacea and its progenitors - F. pratensis and F. glaucescens - was high. Specifically, F. arundinacea shared 274 markers with only F. glaucescens and 82 markers exclusively with F. pratensis. In ryegrass, 52 markers specific for L. perenne and 82 markers specific for L. multiflorum were identified. Another 381 markers were present in both ryegrass species and absent in fescues. The number of markers, which could be used to identify particular genomes in intra- and interspecific hybrids, is shown in Figure 3.
Based on the proportion of markers shared by pairs of species, genome relationships within this complex are as follow: Fa-Fg >> Lm-Lp >> Fa-Fp >> Fp-Lm > Fp-Fg > Fg-Lm > Fa-Lm > Fa-Lp > Fg-Lp > Fp-Lp. This correlates with the results of the cluster analysis.
Mapping DArT markers to F. pratensis chromosomes and chromosome bins
We used a complete set of Festuca-Lolium single chromosome substitution lines of F. pratensis into tetraploid L. multiflorum to allocate DArT markers showing interspecific polymorphism to individual chromosomes of F. pratensis. In total, 160 DArT markers were anchored this way with six to 34 DArT markers anchored to a specific chromosome (Table 2). This represents 56% of all markers present in F. pratensis but absent in L. multiflorum. The lowest numbers of chromosome-specific markers were found on chromosome 4 (10 markers) and chromosome 7 (6 markers). However, another 18 markers were shared by the two chromosomes. This was surprising, as any other pair of chromosomes shared up to four markers only.
Based on the analysis of 14 recombinant lines with different lengths of the introgressed F. pratensis segments of chromosome 3, we were able to anchor 36 DArT markers to seven bins of this chromosome (Figure 4). Each bin contained between one and nine markers; nine markers were also shared with other chromosomes. The co-localization was found with all six remaining chromosomes with similar frequency.
The results of this study represent a major step toward the development of a high-throughput genotyping platform for important grass species from the genera Festuca and Lolium. Both genera contain agronomically important species, and are frequently intercrossed to combine complementary species characteristics. The 3884 DArT markers on the array is by far the highest number of markers ever used in studies of diversity or for genetic mapping of Lolium and Festuca species [7, 16]. Our choice of the DArT array was motivated by the relative ease of its development, a good chance for extensive marker polymorphism, and its low cost per data point for future applications.
The results obtained in a set of 167 accessions representing two genera and five species proved the usefulness of the array to analyze genetic diversity. Intraspecific variability evaluated based on the detection of 2629 DArT markers was found to be higher in both ryegrass species as compared to the fescues. The lowest intraspecific variability was detected among the accessions of F. arundinacea. Using RAPD markers, Kölliker et al.  revealed much lower intraspecific variability in F. pratensis compared to L. perenne. Fjellheim et al.  found that the number of cpDNA haplotypes in F. pratensis was only about 25% of that observed in L. perenne by Balfourier et al. , and suggested that F. pratensis in Europe has been through a recent bottleneck. The higher intraspecific variability in ryegrasses compared with that in fescues was also noted based on screening of EST-SSR markers  and based on the observations of phenotypic traits (Černoch et al., unpublished). Although it was outside of the immediate goal of this study, the bottleneck created by interspecific hybridization in the evolution of tall fescues seems a reasonable assumption.
The set of genotypes used in this study included parents from the B14/16 × HF2/7 mapping population of F. pratensis . The genetic map of this population contains 550 loci from homologous and heterologous RFLP, AFLP, isozyme, and SSR markers, and has a total length of 658.8 cM with an average marker density of 1.4 cM/marker. The number of polymorphic DArT markers between the parents of this mapping was 322. Thus, the number of DArT markers released in this study could significantly increase the density of the genetic linkage map.
Prior to this study, no high-throughput approach was available to study genomic constitutions of interspecific and intergeneric hybrids of Festuca and Lolium, nor in any other combination of frequently mated species/genera, such as wheat and rye. Yet, such systems would enable characterization of unknown accessions as well as hybrid breeding materials and cultivars, and assist greatly in early characterization of all primary recombinants that have to be generated in large numbers whenever high precision of alien introgression is required . Our analyses indicate that the DArT array is very useful for these purposes. For each of the analyzed species, a number of species-specific markers were identified. For two species of high interest in relation to production of Festulolium cultivars, L. multiflorum and F. pratensis, over 400 species-specific markers were identified. Such a high number of markers will facilitate detailed analyses of genomic constitution in wide hybrids. It should also be possible to establish genome profiles specific for individual genotypes (e.g., cultivars), which could be useful in terms of legal protection of commercial cultivars.
In our previous work, we have shown that several hybrid Festulolium cultivars do not contain complete parental chromosome sets . The range of applications of the DArTFest array to characterize genomic constitution in these cultivars would be greatly expanded, if DArT markers were assigned to individual chromosomes. This was partially achieved in this study using Festuca-Lolium chromosome substitution lines and 160 markers were anchored to individual chromosomes of F. pratensis. The observation of 18 markers co-localizing on chromosomes 4 and 7 could be explained by ancestral or more recent duplication(s).
In addition to varying proportions of parental chromosome sets, Festuca × Lolium hybrids often contain recombined chromosomes resulting from meiotic crossing-over between homoeologous chromosomes [31, 46]. To describe genomes of hybrids at the subchromosomal level using DArT markers, these need to be assigned to specific chromosome regions via genetic mapping. However, as genetic linkage between genetic markers does not correspond to physical distances , physical mapping seems a better choice. In this study, we assigned a set of DArT markers to seven bins on chromosome 3 using 14 recombination lines of this chromosome. We developed about 30 such recombinant lines for each chromosome of F. pratensis and thus it will be possible to dissect the entire genome of F. pratensis into ca. 70 chromosomal bins. In a similar study, King et al. [47, 48] utilized a set of introgression lines of diploid L. perenne harboring chromosome segments of F. pratensis. The authors reported the establishment of 18 bins for chromosome 3 of F. pratensis and physical localization of 104 AFLP markers. As DArT markers are much more amenable to multiplexing than AFLP markers (thousands rather than dozens of markers per assay) the throughput and cost advantage of the DArT array is significant (below 1 cent per datapoint). This advantage can be further enhanced through planned array expansion that could easily double the number of markers per assay, thereby further reducing the cost per datapoint with a minimum increase in price per sample. In addition, DArT markers are "sequence-ready", cloned genomic fragments, which offer important advantages over AFLPs for physical and genetic mapping. Sequencing of DArT markers identified in this study will enable in-silico comparisons of physical maps of fescue and ryegrass chromosomes with the sequenced grass genomes.
The results of this study suggest that the newly developed DArTFest array will find numerous applications in grass genetics and breeding. It can be used to characterize genetic diversity as well as to develop genetic maps and identify markers linked with traits of interest. The ability to physically map DArT marker using chromosome substitution and recombinant lines will support the development of integrated genetic and physical maps of fescue and ryegrass. We also envisage a great impact of the array on characterizing genomic constitution of interspecific an intergeneric hybrids at the chromosomal and subchromosomal level. This progress should provide tools to understand the behavior of hybrid genomes as well as to improve the breeding of grass cultivars.
The array data have been deposited on a publically available website http://bioinf.scri.ac.uk/germinate_grasses/. The website will be permanent and will be expanded by genetic and physical mapping data as they become available.
For the development of the DArT array, 40 accessions each of L. perenne L. (2n = 2x = 14), L. multiflorum Lam. (2n = 2x = 14 and 2n = 4x = 28), F. pratensis Huds. (2n = 2x = 14) and F. arundinacea Schreb. (2n = 6x = 42, plus all seven available accessions of F. glaucescens Boiss. (2n = 4x = 28) were chosen to discover the maximum genetic variability within the Lolium-Festuca complex and included ecotypes, cultivars and parents of mapping populations (see Additional file 1).
To map DArT markers to individual chromosomes of F. pratensis, we used single chromosome monosomic and disomic substitutions of Festuca into tetraploid L. multiflorum, as described by Kopecký et al. . Whenever possible, five plants of each substitution line were used. To test whether DArT markers could be anchored to defined chromosome intervals, we selected 14 recombinant lines of F. pratensis chromosome 3 (using the Triticeae chromosome nomenclature system) in tetraploid L. multiflorum, with various lengths of Festuca chromatin present. These recombinants were selected from among backcross progeny of a monosomic substitution of chromosome 3 in tetraploid L. multiflorum (unpublished data).
Development of the DArTFest array
For each of the five species tested, we developed a library of DArT clones using the PstI/TaqI method of complexity reduction. Both methods of complexity reduction and procedures for the library construction were performed as reported by Akbari et al. (2006). Each library consisted of 1536 clones organized into 4 microtiter plates with 384 clones per plate. Inserts from individual clones were amplified in the 384 microtiter plates using M13 primers so that part of the polylinker region of the cloning vector was co-amplified . The amplicons were dried at 37°C, washed with 70% ethanol, and dissolved in a spotting buffer developed specifically for the Erie Scientific poly-L-lysine microarray slides (Wenzl et al., in preparation). The arrays containing inserts from 7680 clones were printed in duplicate using a MicroGridII arrayer (Biorobotics, Cambridge, UK) onto poly-L-lysine-coated slides (Erie Scientific, Portsmouth, NH, USA). Arrays were hybridized with fluorescently labeled targets from all genotypes used for the array development. Targets were prepared using a PstI/TaqI complexity reduction method . For the marker discovery experiment, two replicated targets were analyzed for each genotype so that the technical reproducibility of markers discovered could be easily evaluated by comparing scoring consistency among technical replicates.
After overnight hybridization at 62°C, the slides were washed and scanned using a Tecan LS300 (Grödig, Salzburg, Austria) confocal laser scanner. Three images were generated from each slide: the image produced with a 488 nm laser was used for quality control and image processing was measuring the intensity of hybridisation of the reference (vector's polylinker) labelled with FAM fluorescent dye, and two images representing two independent targets, one produced with the 543 nm laser (Cy3 labelled targets) and one produced with the 633 nm laser (Cy5 labelled targets). The image processing and marker classification were performed using DArTsoft version 7.3 (DArT Pl, unpublished), a dedicated software package developed at DArT P/L (Yarralumla, Australia). Briefly, the relative hybridisation intensity of each clone on each slide was determined by dividing the hybridisation signal in the target channel (genomic representation) by the hybridisation signal in the reference channel (polylinker). Clones with variable relative hybridisation intensities across slides were subjected to fuzzy k-means clustering to convert relative hybridisation intensities into binary scores (presence vs. absence). The clustering was performed on averaged log-transformed relative intensity of two replicates printed for each probe on the array. The markers reported in this paper were selected with a call rate >80% and with technical reproducibility of above 99%.
We processed individual samples in the same way as samples for marker discovery experiments using similar marker quality thresholds in DArTsoft analysis.
Analysis of genetic diversity
The DArTsoft-generated 0-1 scores were used as input for the RESTDIST and NEIGHBOR programs of the PHYLIP 3.6 software package to construct a dendrogram based on the Unweighted Pair Group Method with Algorithmic Mean (UPGMA) and Felsenstein's modification of the Nei/Li restriction fragment distance [49, 50].
Mapping DArT markers to fescue chromosomes and chromosome bins
To anchor markers to individual chromosomes of F. pratensis, DNA isolated from monosomic and disomic substitution lines for individual chromosomes of F. pratensis in tetraploid L. multiflorum were hybridized to the DArT array. A marker present in F. pratensis and absent in L. multiflorum was assigned to a chromosome if it was present in at least one substitution line for a particular chromosome. Several markers were assigned to multiple chromosomes. The same approach was used to anchor markers allocated on bins of F. pratensis chromosome 3 using the recombinant lines described above.
amplified fragment length polymorphism
cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence
Diversity Arrays Technology
DArT array for the Festuca Lolium :complex
expressed sequence tag
genomic in situ hybridization
internal transcribed spacer
marker assisted selection
quantitative trait loci
random amplified polymorphic DNA
restriction fragment length polymorphism
single feature polymorphism
single nucleotide polymorphism
simple sequence repeat.
Jauhar J: Cytogenetics of the Festuca-Lolium complex. Relevance to Breeding. 1993, Berlin: Springer-Verlag
Hackel E: Monographia Festucarum Europearum. 1882, Theodor Fischer, Kassel et al Berlin
Clayton W, Renvoize S: Genera Graminum: Grasses of the World. Kew Bull. 1986, Add Ser 13: 1-389.
Darbyshire SJ: Realignment of Festuca subgen Schedonorus with the genus Lolium (Poaceae). Novon. 1993, 3: 239-343. 10.2307/3391460.
Charmet G, Balfourier F: Isozyme Variation and Species Relationships in the Genus Lolium l (Ryegrasses, Graminaceae). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 1994, 87: 641-649. 10.1007/BF00222888.
Kolliker R, Stadelmann FJ, Reidy B, Nosberger J: Genetic variability of forage grass cultivars: A comparison of Festuca pratensis Huds., Lolium perenne L., and Dactylis glomerata L. Euphytica. 1999, 106: 261-270. 10.1023/A:1003598705582.
Catalan P, Torrecilla P, Rodriguez JAL, Olmstead RG: Phylogeny of the festucoid grasses of subtribe Loliinae and allies (Poeae, Pooideae) inferred from ITS and trnL-F sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. 2004, 31: 517-541. 10.1016/j.ympev.2003.08.025.
Mian MAR, Saha MC, Hopkins AA, Wang ZY: Use of tall fescue EST-SSR markers in phylogenetic analysis of cool-season forage grasses. Genome. 2005, 48: 637-647. 10.1139/g05-029.
Peng Y, Zhang XQ, Deng YL, Ma X: Evaluation of genetic diversity in wild orchardgrass (Dactylis glomerata L.) based on AFLP markers. Hereditas. 2008, 145: 174-181. 10.1111/j.0018-0661.2008.02038.x.
Mehboob uR, Yasmin T, Tabbasam N, Ullah I, Asif M, Zafar Y: Studying the extent of genetic diversity among Gossypium arboreum L. genotypes/cultivars using DNA fingerprinting. Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution. 2008, 55: 331-339. 10.1007/s10722-007-9238-1.
Guthridge KM, Dupal MP, Kolliker R, Jones ES, Smith KF, Forster JW: AFLP analysis of genetic diversity within and between populations of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.). Euphytica. 2001, 122: 191-201. 10.1023/A:1012658315290.
Fjellheim S, Rognli OA: Genetic diversity within and among Nordic meadow fescue (Festuca pratensis Huds.) cultivars determined on the basis of AFLP markers. Crop Science. 2005, 45: 2081-2086. 10.2135/cropsci2005.0091.
Fjellheim S, Blomlie AB, Marum P, Rognli OA: Phenotypic variation in local populations and cultivars of meadow fescue - potential for improving cultivars by utilizing wild germplasm. Plant Breeding. 2007, 126: 279-286. 10.1111/j.1439-0523.2007.01363.x.
Hayward MD, Forster JW, Jones JG, Dolstra O, Evans C, Mcadam NJ, Hossain KG, Stammers M, Will J, Humphreys MO, et al: Genetic analysis of Lolium. I. Identification of linkage groups and the establishment of a genetic map. Plant Breeding. 1998, 117: 451-455. 10.1111/j.1439-0523.1998.tb01972.x.
Bert PF, Charmet G, Sourdille P, Hayward MD, Balfourier F: A high-density molecular map for ryegrass (Lolium perenne) using AFLP markers. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 1999, 99: 445-452. 10.1007/s001220051256.
Jones ES, Dupal MP, Dumsday JL, Hughes LJ, Forster JW: An SSR-based genetic linkage map for perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2002, 105: 577-584. 10.1007/s00122-002-0907-3.
Jones ES, Mahoney NL, Hayward MD, Armstead IP, Jones JG, Humphreys MO, King IP, Kishida T, Yamada T, Balfourier F, et al: An enhanced molecular marker based genetic map of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) reveals comparative relationships with other Poaceae genomes. Genome. 2002, 45: 282-295. 10.1139/g01-144.
Inoue M, Gao ZS, Hirata M, Fujimori M, Cai HW: Construction of a high-density linkage map of Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.) using restriction fragment length polymorphism, amplified fragment length polymorphism, and telomeric repeat associated sequence markers. Genome. 2004, 47: 57-65. 10.1139/g03-097.
Hirata M, Cai HW, Inoue M, Yuyama N, Miura Y, Komatsu T, Takamizo T, Fujimori M: Development of simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers and construction of an SSR-based linkage map in Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2006, 113: 270-279. 10.1007/s00122-006-0292-4.
Miura Y, Hirata M, Fujimori M: Mapping of EST-derived CAPS markers in Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.). Plant Breeding. 2007, 126: 353-360. 10.1111/j.1439-0523.2007.01386.x.
Studer B, Boller B, Bauer E, Posselt UK, Widmer F, Kolliker R: Consistent detection of QTLs for crown rust resistance in Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.) across environments and phenotyping methods. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2007, 115: 9-17. 10.1007/s00122-007-0535-z.
Studer B, Boller B, Herrmann D, Bauer E, Posselt UK, Widmer F, Koelliker R: Genetic mapping reveals a single major QTL for bacterial wilt resistance in Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2006, 113: 661-671. 10.1007/s00122-006-0330-2.
Muylle H, Baert J, Van Bockstaele E, Pertijs J, Roldan-Ruiz I: Four QTLs determine crown rust (Puccinia coronata f. sp lolii) resistance in a perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) population. Heredity. 2005, 95: 348-357. 10.1038/sj.hdy.6800729.
Yamada T, Jones ES, Cogan NOI, Vecchies AC, Nomura T, Hisano H, Shimamoto Y, Smith KF, Hayward MD, Forster JW: QTL analysis of morphological, developmental, and winter hardiness-associated traits in perennial ryegrass. Crop Science. 2004, 44: 925-935.
Turner LB, Cairns AJ, Armstead IP, Ashton J, Skot K, Whittaker D, Humphreys MO: Dissecting the regulation of fructan metabolism in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) with quantitative trait locus mapping. New Phytologist. 2006, 169: 45-57. 10.1111/j.1469-8137.2005.01575.x.
Studer B, Jensen LB, Hentrup S, Brazauskas G, Kolliker R, Lubberstedt T: Genetic characterisation of seed yield and fertility traits in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2008, 117: 781-791. 10.1007/s00122-008-0819-y.
Alm V, Fang C, Busso CS, Devos KM, Vollan K, Grieg Z, Rognli OA: A linkage map of meadow fescue (Festuca pratensis Huds.) and comparative mapping with other Poaceae species. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2003, 108: 25-40. 10.1007/s00122-003-1399-5.
Saha MC, Mian R, Zwonitzer JC, Chekhovskiy K, Hopkins AA: An SSR- and AFLP-based genetic linkage map of tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb.). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2005, 110: 323-336. 10.1007/s00122-004-1843-1.
Zhang Y, Mian MAR, Bouton JH: Recent molecular and genomic studies on stress tolerance of forage and turf grasses. Crop Science. 2006, 46: 497-511. 10.2135/cropsci2004.0572.
Kopecky D, Loureiro J, Zwierzykowski Z, Ghesquiere M, Dolezel J: Genome constitution and evolution in Lolium × Festuca hybrid cultivars (Festulolium). Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2006, 113: 731-742. 10.1007/s00122-006-0341-z.
Lukaszewski AJ, Lapinski B, Rybka K: Limitations of in situ hybridization with total genomic DNA in routine screening for alien introgressions in wheat. Cytogenetic and Genome Research. 2005, 109: 373-377. 10.1159/000082422.
Gupta PK, Rustgi S, Mir RR: Array-based high-throughput DNA markers for crop improvement. Heredity. 2008, 101: 5-18. 10.1038/hdy.2008.35.
Jaccoud D, Peng K, Feinstein D, Kilian A: Diversity Arrays: a solid state technology for sequence information independent genotyping. Nucleic Acids Research. 2001, 29: e25-10.1093/nar/29.4.e25.
Wittenberg AHJ, Lee van der T, Cayla C, Kilian A, Visser RGF, Schouten HJ: Validation of the high-throughput marker technology DArT using the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Molecular Genetics and Genomics. 2005, 274: 30-39. 10.1007/s00438-005-1145-6.
Wenzl P, Carling J, Kudrna D, Jaccoud D, Huttner E, Kleinhofs A, Kilian A: Diversity Arrays Technology (DArT) for whole-genome profiling of barley. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2004, 101: 9915-9920. 10.1073/pnas.0401076101.
Wenzl P, Li HB, Carling J, Zhou MX, Raman H, Paul E, Hearnden P, Maier C, Xia L, Caig V, et al: A high-density consensus map of barley linking DArT markers to SSR, RFLP and STS loci and agricultural traits. Bmc Genomics. 2006, 7: 206-10.1186/1471-2164-7-206.
Akbari M, Wenzl P, Caig V, Carling J, Xia L, Yang SY, Uszynski G, Mohler V, Lehmensiek A, Kuchel H, et al: Diversity arrays technology (DArT) for high-throughput profiling of the hexaploid wheat genome. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2006, 113: 1409-1420. 10.1007/s00122-006-0365-4.
White J, Law JR, MacKay I, Chalmers KJ, Smith JSC, Kilian A, Powell W: The genetic diversity of UK, US and Australian cultivars of Triticum aestivum measured by DArT markers and considered by genome. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2008, 116: 439-453. 10.1007/s00122-007-0681-3.
Yang SY, Pang W, Ash G, Harper J, Carling J, Wenzl P, Huttner E, Zong XX, Kilian A: Low level of genetic diversity in cultivated pigeonpea compared to its wild relatives is revealed by diversity arrays technology. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2006, 113: 585-595. 10.1007/s00122-006-0317-z.
Mace ES, Xia L, Jordan DR, Halloran K, Parh DK, Huttner E, Wenzl P, Kilian A: DArT markers: diversity analyses and mapping in Sorghum bicolor. Bmc Genomics. 2008, 9: 26-10.1186/1471-2164-9-26.
Paux E, Sourdille P, Salse J, Saintenac C, Choulet F, Leroy P, Korol A, Michalak M, Kianian S, Spielmeyer W, et al: A physical map of the 1-gigabase bread wheat chromosome 3B. Science. 2008, 322: 101-104. 10.1126/science.1161847.
Fjellheim S, Rognli OA, Fosnes K, Brochmann C: Recent bottlenecking in the widespread meadow fescue (Festuca pratensis Huds.) inferred from chloroplast DNA sequences. Journal of Biogeography. 2005, 33: 1470-1478. 10.1111/j.1365-2699.2006.01521.x.
Balfourier F, Imbert C, Charmet G: Evidence for phylogeographic structure in Lolium species related to the spread of agriculture in Europe. A cpDNA study. Theoretical and Applied Genetics. 2000, 101: 131-138. 10.1007/s001220051461.
Lukaszewski AJ: Manipulation of the 1RS.1BL translocation in wheat by induced homoeologous recombination. Crop Science. 2000, 40: 216-225.
Kopecky D, Lukaszewski AJ, Dolezel J: Meiotic behaviour of individual chromosomes of Festuca pratensis in tetraploid Lolium multiflorum. Chromosome Research. 2008, 16: 987-998. 10.1007/s10577-008-1256-0.
King J, Armstead IP, Donnison IS, Thomas HM, Jones RN, Kearsey MJ, Roberts LA, Thomas A, Morgan WG, King IP: Physical and genetic mapping in the grasses Lolium perenne and Festuca pratensis. Genetics. 2002, 161: 315-324.
King J, Armstead IP, Donnison IS, Harper JA, Roberts LA, Thomas H, Ougham H, Thomas A, Huang L, King IP: Introgression mapping in the grasses. Chromosome Research. 2007, 15: 105-113. 10.1007/s10577-006-1103-0.
Felsenstein J: PHYLIP-phylogeny inference package (Version 3.2). Cladistics. 1989, 164-166.
Felsenstein J: PHYLIP (Phylogeny Inference Package). (3.6). 2004, University of Washington, Seattle
We thank the following colleagues for contributing DNA samples: Beat Boller (Agroscope Reckenholz-Tänikon Research Station ART, Zurich, Switzerland), Marc Ghesquiere (INRA, Lusignan, France), Stephan Hentrup (Aarhus University, Slagelse, Denmark), Niels Roulund (DLF-Trifolium, Store Heddinge, Denmark), Carole Boucoiran and Oene Dolstra (Wageningen UR Plant Breeding, The Netherlands), Ian P. King and Leif Skot (IBERS, Aberystwyth University, Wales), Isabel Roldan-Ruiz and Hilde Muylle (ILVO, Merelbeke, Belgium) and Susanne Barth (TEAGASC, Oak Park, Carlow, Ireland).
We are greatful to Radka Tušková, Helena Tvardíková and Dr. Jan Šafář for excellent technical assistance, and to the team at Diversity Arrays Technology Pty for providing assistance in array development and DArT genotyping. This work was supported by the Ministry of Agriculture of the Czech Republic (grant award NAZV QH71267) and by the Czech Science Foundation (grant award 521/07/P479).
AK (Director), HB and VC are affiliated with Diversity Arrays Technology Pty Ltd who provide DArT array commercial genotyping services for a range of crops.
DK, JB, AJL, JHB, VC, RK, OAR and BS participated in the collection of plant material. AJL and DK developed the substitution and recombinant lines and characterized them cytologically. DK and JB extracted DNAs and checked the quality. The array was developed by HB, VC and AK. The data analysis was performed by DK, JB and AK. PS created a public website for data deposition. TL and JD made an intellectual contribution to the concept of the experiment. DK drafted the manuscript. AK, JD and AJL revised manuscript critically for important intellectual content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: Hybridization scores. The data provided represent scores obtained after hybridization of Festuca and Lolium genomic DNAs on the DArTFest chip. (XLS 6 MB)
Additional file 2: List of accessions. The list provides the description of all accessions used for the development of the DArTFest chip. (XLS 38 KB)
About this article
Cite this article
Kopecký, D., Bartoš, J., Lukaszewski, A.J. et al. Development and mapping of DArT markers within the Festuca - Lolium complex. BMC Genomics 10, 473 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2164-10-473