Skip to content


BMC Genomics

Open Access

Physical mapping and candidate gene prediction of fertility restorer gene of cytoplasmic male sterility in cotton

  • Cunpeng Zhao1,
  • Guiyuan Zhao1,
  • Zhao Geng1,
  • Zhaoxiao Wang1,
  • Kaihui Wang1,
  • Suen Liu1,
  • Hanshuang Zhang1,
  • Baosheng Guo1Email author and
  • Junyi Geng1Email author
Contributed equally
BMC Genomics201819:6

Received: 20 June 2017

Accepted: 20 December 2017

Published: 2 January 2018



Cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) is a maternally inherited trait failing to produce functional pollen. It plays a pivotal role in the exploitation of crop heterosis. The specific locus amplified fragment sequencing (SLAF-seq) as a high-resolution strategy for the identification of new SNPs on a large-scale is gradually applied for functional gene mining. The current study combined the bulked segregant analysis (BSA) with SLAF-seq to identify the candidate genes associated with fertility restorer gene (Rf) in CMS cotton.


Illumina sequencing systematically investigated the parents. A segregating population comprising of 30 + 30 F2 individuals was developed using 3096A (female parent) as sterile and 866R (male parent) as a restorer. The original data obtained by dual-index sequencing were analyzed to obtain the reads of each sample that were compared to the reference genome in order to identify the SLAF tag with a polymorphism in parent lines and the SNP with read-associated coverage. Based on SLAF tags, SNP-index analysis, Euclidean distance (ED) correlation analysis, and whole genome resequencing, the hot regions were annotated.


A total of 165,007 high-quality SLAF tags, with an average depth of 47.90× in the parents and 50.78× in F2 individuals, were sequenced. In addition, a total of 137,741 SNPs were detected: 113,311 and 98,861 SNPs in the male and female parent, respectively. A correlation analysis by SNP-index and ED initially located the candidate gene on 1.35 Mb of chrD05, and 20 candidate genes were identified. These genes were involved in genetic variations, single base mutations, insertions, and deletions. Moreover, 42 InDel markers of the whole genome resequencing were also detected.


In this study, associated markers identified by super-BSA could accelerate the study of CMS in cotton, and as well as in other crops. Some of the 20 genes’ preliminary characteristics provided useful information for further studies on CMS crops.


CMSHigh-throughput sequencingSLAF-seqSuper-BSACotton


As a maternally inherited characteristic, cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) plays a major role in crop heterosis research and practice. The current studies suggest that CMS is caused by mutations in the correlated genes in the mitochondrial genome and inhibited by fertility restorer genes in the nuclear genome [1]. This phenomenon exists in bean [2, 3], petunia [4], sorghum [5], and rice [6]. Fertility restorer gene (Rf), was often found in these crop, can inhibit the expression of mitochondrial sterility gene. For the cotton, the gene are not consistent in different sterile lines.

The main cotton hybrids, which have the value of utilization were Harknessii cytoplasmic male sterile line, Trilobum cytoplasmic male sterile line, and cytoplasmic sterile line of upland cotton (104-7A, Xiangyuan A, Jin A). The three-line hybrid selection of China was primarily derived from the cytoplasmic male sterile lines of the upland cotton. Since the CMS sources are different, the restorers are also different, which leads to various theories on the CMS recovery mechanism of cotton. The fertility restoring characteristics of CMS in Harknessii cotton were regulated by one dominant gene, Rf1. The sterile nature of the Trilobum cotton could be restored by either Rf2 of the Trilobum restorer gene or Rf1 of the Harknessii restorer gene; however, Rf2 is not able to restore the CMS-D2–2 of Harknessii. Rf1 and Rf2 are closely linked with a distance of 0.93 cM [7]. The Chinese breeding varies from the CMS lines of Harknessii and Trilobum. The fertility restoration of upland cotton CMS line is regulated by two pairs of independent recovery genes: Rf1 completely dominant and Rf2 partially dominant. The recovery effect of Rf1 is higher than that of Rf2 [8]. The identification of the molecular marker and gene mapping of CMS in cotton has also progressed. Liu et al. found 3 SSR and 2 RAPD markers closely linked to the restorer gene [9]. Feng et al. found that 3 STS was co-segregated from the restorer gene [10]. Yin et al. constructed accurate genetic and physical maps of 15 molecular markers closely linked to the restorer gene that was located on chromosome 19 (LGD08 linkage group) with a genetic distance of <1 cM, and the physical location was on 100 kb between the two BAC clone overlapping regions [11]. Wang et al. suggested that the two Rf restorer genes might be located on chromosome 19 in the D chromosome subgroup, i.e. chromosome D5 of the cotton [12, 13]. However, due to differences in the source of sterile cytoplasm and the variation in nuclear genotypes, the effects of nuclear gene and sterile cytoplasm are different. Thus, fine positioning and finding new restorer gene candidates in upland cotton are essential.

Large-scale genotyping plays a major role in genetic association studies. Specific locus amplified fragment sequencing (SLAF-seq) provides a high-resolution strategy for large-scale genotyping and can be applied to various species and populations [14]; for instance, cucumber [15], Glycine max [16], and sesame [17]. It is based on reduced representation library (RRL) and high-throughput sequencing. The technology has several distinguishing characteristics: i) deep sequencing to ensure genotyping accuracy; ii) reduced representation strategy to reduce sequencing costs; iii) pre-designed reduced representation scheme to optimize marker efficiency; and iv) double barcode system for large populations [14].

In this study, we used the female parent CMS line 3096A (using CMS 104-7A of upland cotton as a recurrent parent line that was breeded with the backbone parent line for nucleus replacement) of three-line Ji FRH3018 [18] and the male parent restorer line 866R with strong restoring power and its combination F2 segregating population as the material. Herein, we studied the fine mapping of the restorer gene and its correlated candidate gene using high-throughput sequencing platforms. A total of 137,741 SNPs were detected and we found that 20 candidate genes are identified and 19 genes were found annotated in each database of the candidate genes located on 1.35Mbp of chrD05.


Test material

The female parent CMS line 3096 from three-line CMS hybrid Ji FRH3018 of upland cotton and the male parent restorer line 866 with strong restoring power and its combination F2 segregation population (30 + 30 mixed pools with extreme characteristics) were used as research materials.

Test method

Genomes resequencing of CMS line 3096A and fertility restorer line 866R

Sample collection and SLAF library preparation

Fresh leaves were obtained from the parent lines and F2, frozen with liquid nitrogen, extracted by the CTAB method, and assessed for the quality of DNA by 1% agarose gel electrophoresis. The purity of DNA was examined using the NanoPhotometer® spectrophotometer (Implen, CA, USA). The DNA concentration was estimated using Qubit® DNA Assay Kit in Qubit® 2.0 Fluorometer (Life Technologies, CA, USA).

We used 1.5 μg DNA/sample as input material for the preparations of the sample. We have chosen to use RsaIas restriction enzyme in the electronic enzyme-digestion projections to the reference genome sequences of cotton. Sequencing libraries were generated using RsaIof restriction enzyme according to the manufacturer’s recommendations, and index codes were added to ascribe the sequences to each sample. Briefly, the DNA sample was fragmented by sonication to a size of 350 bp. Then, the DNA fragments were end-polished, A-tailed, and ligated with the full-length adapter for Illumina sequencing by PCR amplification. Consequently, the PCR products were purified (Agencount® AMPure® XP, USA), and libraries were analyzed for size distribution by Agilent2100 Bioanalyzer and quantified by real-time PCR.

Illumina sequencing

The libraries constructed above were sequenced by Illumina HiSeq ™2500 (Illumina, Inc., San Diego, USA) platform at Biomarker Technologies Corporation in Beijing ( and 125 bp paired-end reads were generated with an insert size approximately 350 bp.

Data analysis, data filtering, and alignment

The recently released genome of Gossypium hirsutum was downloaded from Cotton Research Institute (CRI) of Nanjing Agricultural University in China. (, v1.1) and used as a reference genome [19]. Fastx-toolkit (v 0.0.14–1) was used to filter out the low-quality reads based on the following criteria: (i) reads with ≥10% unidentified nucleotides (N); (ii) reads >50% read length with a Phred quality value ≤10; (iii) reads with the adapter. The remaining clean reads were aligned to the reference cabbage genome using BWA-MEM (0.7.10-r789) [20] and default parameters. Sequence Alignment/Map tools (SAMtools) (v1.1) [21] was applied to sort and index the resulting binary alignment map (BAM) format files. The duplicates were excluded using Picard tools (v1.102) (, and the final sorted bam files were utilized in the downstream analysis. Variant calling and filtering were performed in order to reduce the inaccuracy of the alignment. The local realignment around insertions and deletions, the base quality recalibration of the reads and variant calling was conducted using GATK Tools version 3.6. GATK Haplotype Caller (HC) was used for variant calling [22, 23]. The variants that fulfilled the following criteria were retained (1) mapping quality filter equivalent to PASS; (2) quality depth (QD) >2; (3) mapping quality (MQ) >40; (5) QUAL >30. Moreover, the variants were filtered further if the coverage was <10, the cluster SNPs were >2 in a 5 bp window, if the SNP around the Indel was within 5 bp. SV detection and annotation BreakDancer was used to predict the five types of structural variants (SVs): insertions (INSs), deletions (DELs), inversions (INVs), intra-chromosomal translocations (ITXs), and inter-chromosomal translocations (CTXs) from next-generation paired-end sequencing reads utilizing the read pairs mapped with excessive separation distances or orientation. The SVs with read depth < 2 were filtered. Bedtools was employed to annotate the detected DELs, INSs, and INVs. The detection and annotation of CNVs (copy number variations) refers to a normal variation in the number of copies of ≥1 sections of some genomic fragments. We used CNVnator (parameters: -call 100) for the identification of CNVs and bedtools for annotations.

SLAF library construction and high-throughput sequencing

The target fragment was selected by PCR amplification, purification, sample mixing, and excising from the gel. Illumina HiSeq™2500 was utilized for sequencing after inspection of the quality of the library.

SLAF tag development and SNP detection

The original data reads were obtained by dual-index sequencing for each sample. After filtering the sequencing joints of the reads, the sequencing quality, and the volume of data were assessed. The efficiency of Rsa I through the control data was used to determine the accuracy and efficiency of the test procedure. The data reads were compared to that of the reference genome and the SLAF tag was developed in parent lines and mixed pools in order to identify the SLAF tag with a polymorphism in parent lines and SNP with reads coverage [21]. A correlation analysis was conducted to identify the SNPs on the loci closely related to the characteristics and determine the candidate regions according to the correlation thresholds. Finally, a functional annotation and biological pathway enrichment analysis were conducted to identify the genes in the candidate regions.

Correlation analysis

SNP-index analysis

The SNP-index of the two mixed pools was calculated using the SNP data of the parent lines and assessing the loci that might be associated with the segregation of characteristics through the ΔSNP-index [24, 25]. The SNP-index is calculated as follows:
$$ {\displaystyle \begin{array}{l}\mathrm{SNP}\hbox{-} \mathrm{index}\ \left(\mathrm{Mut}\right)=\uprho \mathrm{x}/\left(\uprho \mathrm{X}+\uprho \mathrm{x}\right)\\ {}\mathrm{SNP}\hbox{-} \mathrm{index}\ \left(\mathrm{WT}\right)=\uprho \mathrm{x}/\left(\uprho \mathrm{X}+\uprho \mathrm{x}\right)\\ {}\Delta \mathrm{SNP}\hbox{-} \mathrm{index}=\mathrm{SNP}\hbox{-} \mathrm{index}\ \left(\mathrm{Mut}\right)\hbox{-} \mathrm{SNP}\hbox{-} \mathrm{index}\ \left(\mathrm{WT}\right)\end{array}} $$

Mut and WT are the mutation and wild-type pool of the filial generation, respectively. ρX and ρx indicate the number of reads of the alleles of the wild and the mutation parent lines appearing in their pools, respectively. The difference in each locus between the mutation and pools can be observed through the ΔSNP-index [26]. In order to eliminate the false positive locus, the SNP-indexes marked on the same chromosome can be fit by the position of the marker on the genome. The region above the threshold is correlated to the parameters. With respect to the qualitative character, the correlation threshold is the theoretical ΔSNP-index value of the corresponding population. For example, the correlation threshold of the F2 population is 0.67. In the case of quantitative character the correlation threshold is obtained by a computer simulation sampling experiment, and the probability of each marker associated with the target characteristic is calculated.

Euclidean distance (ED) algorithm

The ED algorithm evaluates the significant difference between mixed pools using the sequencing data. It also evaluates the area associated with the specific parameter [27]. Theoretically, in addition to the difference in the target character-related loci between the two mixed pools established by BSA, the others tend to be consistent, and hence, the ED value of the non-target related loci is equivalent to 0. The formula for ED is as follows:
$$ ED=\sqrt{{\left( Amut- Awt\right)}^2+{\left( Cmut- Cwt\right)}^2+{\left( Gmut- Gwt\right)}^2+{\left( Tmut- Twt\right)}^2} $$

The larger the ED value, the greater the difference between the two mixed pools. Amut is the frequency of the A base in the mutation pool, and Awt is the frequency of the A base in the wild pool; Cmut is the frequency of the C base in the mutation pool, Cwt is the frequency of the C base in the wild pool; Gmut is the frequency of the G base in the mutation pool, Gwt is the frequency of the G base in the wild pool; Tmut is the frequency of the T base in the mutation pool, Twt is the frequency of the T base in the wild pool.

In the analysis, the SNP loci with differences in the genotypes between the two mixed pools are used for calculating the depth of each base in the different pools and the ED value of each locus. The original ED value is processed such as to exclude the background interference. In order to eliminate the false positives, the position of the marker on the genome can be utilized to fit the labeled ED on the same chromosome and select the region above the threshold as the region related to the fertility restoring gene according to the association threshold. In order to eliminate the false positive locus, the ED values marked on the same chromosome can be fit according to the position of the marker on the genome. The region above the threshold is selected as the region related to the fertility restoring gene according to the correlation threshold.

Identification of potential candidate genes

The reference genome sequence of the AD genome of tetraploid G. hirsutum was downloaded. The region related to the target characteristics was identified in both genome sequences and scanned for annotated genes using the Multiple Sequence Comparison by Log-Expectation software.

The Method of InDel (insertion-deletion Length Polymorphism) Markers Development on the Correlated Region.

Eprimer3 in the EMBOSS (v6.4.0) [28] software package was used on both ends of these loci sequences to design primers. The PCR reaction system constituted of 25 μL, containing 2 mmol/L MgCl2, 100 μmol/L dNTP, 0.2 μmol/L primers, 2 U Taq polymerase, 50 μL template DNA, and overlying 20 μL mineral oil. The PCR reaction was carried out in type PE480 DNA amplification equipment at 94 °C degeneration 3 min, 94 °C modified 30s, 40s, 58 °C annealing stretching up to 72 s, and 72 °C for 40 cycles, followed by a final extension at 72 °C for 10 min. The PCR products were resolved on 6% polyacrylamide electrophoresis.

Results and analysis

SLAF-seq data analysis and evaluation

The two parent lines and F2 segregation population were sequenced by SLAF-seq. Rsa I is selected to construct the SLAF library, and the SLAF fragment should be between 364 and 414 bp; 38.94 M reads were obtained. The reads from samples were aligned to the reference genome using the BWA software, with >80% efficiency, which is normal. For sequencing results, the average Q30 was 92.01%, and the average GC content was 37.63%. The male parent lines (R restorer lines) retrieved 9,673,045 reads, Q30 was 90.07%, and the average GC content was 37.40%. On the other hand, the female parent lines (A sterile lines) obtained 9,901,640 reads, Q30 90.65%, and the average GC content was 37.41%. The filial generation F2 (aa and ab) retrieved 10,687,924 and 8,679,918 reads, respectively, Q30 was 93.73% and 90.04%, respectively, and the average GC content was 37.96% and 37.73%, respectively (Table 1).
Table 1

Mining results of the high-throughput sequencing data

Sample ID

Total map (%)

Properly mapped (%)

Total Reads

Q30 percentage (%)

GC percentage (%)

























Development of SLAF tag and SNP

A total of 165,007 SLAF tags have been developed. The average sequencing depth of the parent lines was 47.90× and that of the mixed pools was 50.78×. Of these, the male parent lines obtained 16,173 SLAF tags with an average sequencing depth of 46.01×. The female parent lines obtained 161,854 SLAF tags, and the average sequencing depth was 49.78×; whereas, the filial generation F2 retrieved 163,688 and 163,189 SLAF tags, respectively, and the average sequencing depth was 55.96× + 45.59× (Table 2).
Table 2

Sequencing data of the developed SLAF markers

Sample ID

SLAF number

Total depth

Average depth

















SNPs were primarily detected by GATK software. According to the positioning results of the sequencing reads to the reference genome, GATK performs the local realignment, GATK mutation detection, samtools mutation detection, and identifying the overlapped mutation loci of GATK and samtools in order to ensure the accuracy of SNP, and obtain the final SNP loci set. A total of 137,741 SNPs were detected, of which, the male parent SNPs were 113,311, and the heterozygosity of SNPs in the sample was 4.19%. The female parent SNPs were 98, 861, and the heterozygosity was 5.37%. The filial generation F2 demonstrated 82,874 and 75,961 SNPs, respectively, and the heterozygosity was 20.55 and 19.28%, respectively (Table 3). The distribution of SLAF tags and SNP markers on different chromosomes was enumerated (Additional file 1), chrA01 had the maximum number of SLAF tags, while chrA08 exhibited the maximum number of SNP markers. According to the distribution of SLAF and SNP on the chromosome, the chromosome distribution map of SLAF tag and SNP is plotted. The specific distribution is shown in Fig. 1.
Table 3

The statistic results of each sample SNP

Sample ID

Total SNP

SNP number

Heterozygous locus numbers ratio (%)

















Note: Total SNP: Total number of SNP is detected, SNP num: The number of SNPs in the corresponding samples detected, Heterozygous locus numbers ratio (%):The heterozygous locus numbers account for the proportion of all locus of SNPs in the sample

Fig. 1

SLAF distribution and SNP markers on chromosome. Note: The abscissa is the length of the chromosome. Each yellow band represents a chromosome. The genome is divided by every 1Mbp. The more the number of SLAF tags in each window, the deeper the color and lesser the number of SLAF tags, the lighter the color. The darker area in the figure is the area where the SLAF tags are centrally distributed. The left panel shows the distribution of the SLAF tag, and the right panel is the distribution of SNP

Correlation analysis by SNP-index and ED

Before the correlation analysis by SNP-index, 137,741 SNPs are filtered. A total of 16 SNP loci with multiple mutations are also filtered out. 102,105 loci with reads support <4 in the mixed pools are filtered out, and 27,289 loci that do not exist in the parent lines are filtered out. Finally, 8331 SNPs were obtained for the follow-up analysis. Using the SNP-index method, the correlation threshold was 0.67 according to the theoretical separation ratio of the experimental population. 20 association regions (Fig. 2) containing the genes were obtained, located at chr D05.
Fig. 2

The distribution of SNP-index-associated values on chromosome. Note: The abscissa is the chromosome name. The color point represents the calculated SNP-index (or ΔSNP-index) value, and the black line is the fitted SNP-index (or ΔSNP-index) value. The top graph illustrates the distribution of the SNP-index values in h mixed pool; the middle graph is the distribution of the SNP-index values in L mixed pool; the bottom graph is the distribution of the ΔSNP-index values, where the magenta line represents the theoretical threshold line

Similarly, before correlation analysis by ED, 137,741 SNPs should also be filtered out. 102,114 loci with read support <4 in any mixed pool are first filtered out, resulting in 35,627 high-quality and reliability loci. Therefore, a total of 14,226 different loci were identified between the two mixed pools. The correlation value was calculated by ED, and the median + 3SD of all the loci fitted values was considered as the correlation threshold of the analysis: 0.4969. A total of 351 correlated genes (Fig. 3) were obtained according to the correlation threshold.
Fig. 3

The distribution of ED-associated values on chromosome. Note: The abscissa is the chromosome name. The color point represents the ED value of each SNP locus. The black line is the fitted ED value, and the red dotted line represents the significantly associated threshold. The higher the ED value, the better the correlation effect

Finally, the intersection of the associated genes obtained from the above two methods was found to be located on the candidate gene on 1.35 Mb of chrD05, and about 20 candidate genes were identified (Table 4). A correlation analysis of the genetic information to the associated region is summarized in the Additional file 2.
Table 4

The information of the association region

Assocition region

Chromosome ID



Size (Mb)

Gene number
























Gene functional annotations in related area correlation region

The 20 genes in the correlated region are compared to the databases of NR, SwissProt [29], GO [30], COG, and KEGG [31] using BLAST software. Finally, the annotations of 19 genes were obtained (Additional file 3). A total of 19/20 genes were found annotated in each database. Of these, annotations of 8 genes in KEGG, participating in 10 signaling pathways were found, including plant hormone signal transduction, protein output, DNA replication, homologous recombination, mismatch repair, nucleotide excision repair, ribosome, nitrogen metabolism, purine, and pyrimidine metabolism. In the DNA replication pathway, the enrichment factor 29.37 was a significant difference (p = 0.00186).

Differences in sterile and restorer line on the correlated region

The genomes of the CMS line 3096A and fertility restorer line 866R were sequenced at 19× and 20× read depth, respectively, by Illumina sequencing of the paired-end libraries. Using the cotton AD-genome sequence as a reference, genetic variations, single base mutations, insertions, and deletions as compared to the reference genome were identified. The comparison of the structure of the genomes of the sterile and restorer lines on the correlated region revealed that the restorer line was located on the SV of the correlated region; however, the sterile line was not found on the SV as compared to the reference genome. We found that 7 SVs, 4 SVs are deletion and 3 SVs are interchromosomal translocation, are on the restorer line (Table 5). A total of 1607 indels were found in the correlated region, including 1246 intergenic indels, 3 exonic indels, involving 3 genes: Gh_D05G3001, Gh_D05G3028, and Gh_D05G3039; we found 242 intronic indels, 51 upstream indels and 65 downstream indels. A total of 13,175 SNP loci exhibited differences in the correlated region of the sterile and restorer lines, including 10,711 intergenic SNPs, 1858 intronic SNPs, 254 upstream SNPs, 227 downstream SNPs, 124 exonic SNPs and 2 splicing SNPs in reference to the genes, Gh_D05G3005 and Gh_D05G3038. Nonsynonymous SNPs were found in 16 exonic regions, 1 stop-gain SNP was identified in Gh_D05G3042, and a stop-loss SNP was discovered in Gh_D05G3031.
Table 5

The SV on the correlated region in restorer lines













14 + 0-



0 + 16-







15 + 0-



1 + 17-







17 + 0-



0 + 15-







13 + 10-



0 + 12-







7 + 15-



0 + 14-







0 + 15-



15 + 0-







14 + 0-



12 + 14-





InDel (insertion-deletion length polymorphism) markers development on the correlated region

The analysis of the comparison of the correlated regions on the sterile and restorer lines’ genome sequence found 1607 InDel sites. While analyzing the sterile and maintainer line amplification of the genomic DNA and design 165 primers, we found 42 primers (Attached Additional file 4) that distinctly detected the polymorphism, and hence, could be used as InDel markers. The 42 InDel markup tags, 24 as codominant markers, and 18 as dominant markers were developed Fig. 4. These will be laid as the underlying foundations for the fine mapping of the restorer genes.
Fig. 4

The polymorphic graph of primers. Note: 1–24 Codominant markers 25–42 Dominant markers A: sterile lines R: restorer line


The molecular marker discovery and fine mapping of fertility restoring gene of CMS in cotton

The molecular marker discovery and fine mapping of fertility restorer gene of CMS in cotton are under intensive research. Yin et al. established the location of Rf1 on 100 kb between two BAC clone overlapping regions and selected 5 SSR in proximity to Rf1 by constructing a BAC library of Gossypium harknessii cytoplasmic male sterile restorer lines coupled with the genetic and physical maps recovering gene linkage [11]. Yang et al. screened out 6 EST-SSR markers (NAU2650, NAU2924, NAU3205, NAU3652, NAU3938, and NAU4040) with 0.327 cM from the fertility restorer Rf1 of CMS in Harknessii cotton [32]. Wu et al. found that the fertility of CMS-D2 was regulated by a pair of dominant single gene Rf1, and 13 molecular markers closely linked to the fertility were screened out. The marker closest to Rf1 was BNL3535 with a genetic distance of 0.049 cM; on the other side NAU3652 was the nearest marker with a genetic distance of 0.078 cM. [33]. Wang et al. demonstrated that CIR179–250 was closely linked to both Rf1 and Rf2, which was located on LGD08 linkage group (D5 chromosome, 19th chromosome) of D genome set with CMS-D2 and CMS-D8 restorer, respectively, of upland cotton used as research material [13]. Li et al. located Jin-A cytoplasmic male sterile restorer gene Rf on the 19th chromosome (LGD08) with a distance of 5.4 and 10.3 cM from markers CM042 and CIR179, respectively [34]. You et al. studied three cotton cytoplasmic male sterile lines and their corresponding restorers from China, Israel, and the USA, respectively. The results indicated that 2 restoring genes in the restorers were from the USA. The Rf1 was positioned between BNL3535 and CIR179 at a distance of 5.3 cM, while Rf2 was between STS659 and BNL1045 at a distance of 4.8 cM. Only 1 restoring gene was identified in the restorers from China, and Rf was between CIR222 and BNL632 at a distance of 6.7 cM. Only 1 restoring gene was found in the restorers from Israel, and Rf was between STS147 and CIR179 at a distance of 4.3 cM [35]. According to the SSR primers, we found the recovery of SSR markers in the gene location map (Table 6). Furthermore, we established that although the sterile line source type was different, the tags on the reference genome was found on chrD05 between 35,690,656–59,566,733. The present study on the fertility restoration gene identified the location for chr D05 base sequence as 37,535,705–37,755,211 (0.22Mbp), 39,558,551–40,416,294 (0.86Mbp), and 40,531,406–40,804,095 (0.27Mbp) interval; the sterility-related gene mapping was reported between NAU2924 and NAU4040 SSR markers. As the same markers appear in the position of cotton CMS fertility restoring gene from different sources, it is speculated that the chromosomal segments of the restoring gene derived from various types of restorer lines should be consistent. These markers, which are closely linked to the restorer gene, act as insertion or deletion of the restorer gene fragment in the process of genetic improvement, resulting in the altered genetic distance. The present study developed 42 InDel markers in the correlated region; subsequently, it should be the laid a foundation for positioning of the cotton fertility restoring genes. The present results also showed that SLAF-seq technology is an efficient and high-resolution QTL fine-positioning technique characterized by high success rate, specificity, stability, and cost-efficiency. The combination of SLAF-seq technology, SNP_index, and BSA provides an efficient method for identifying the genomic regions associated with the characteristics described above.
Table 6

The summary of restorer gene marker in the genome location


Chromosome ID

Genome location


Restorer gene





Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]




Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]

Wu [33]




Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]




Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]




Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]




Gossypium harknessii


Yang [32]






Wu [33];

You [35]







You [35]




Jin A


Li [34]







You [35]

Cloning of fertility restorer gene

The cloning of fertility restorer gene in cotton CMS is yet under investigation. Yang et al. identified the gene containing Rf1 and conducted the whole length sequencing. The Rf1 locus is found to contain 5 PPR genes and 2 genes highly homologous to the PPR gene in a region of approximately 130 kb. Based on gene prediction, characterization analysis, and the difference in the phylogenetic sequence analysis, ORF3 is speculated as the Rf1 gene that encodes the PPR gene and contains the mitochondrial localization signal. ORF3 necessitates functional complementation by transgenesis [36]. Zhang et al. concluded that the starch synthase and the phosphate -ribose o-aminobenzoic acid transferase (PAT) gene might be associated with the Rf2 gene in the Trilobum cytoplasm by differential display technique analysis [37]. Wu and Hou cloned the genes, GH182Rorf392 and GhPG2, related to cotton fertility restoration from the upland cotton restorer Y18R line. GH182Rorf392 encodes 392 amino acids. The 3′ end of the gene contains a 26 s rRNA sequence, and the 5′ end is a novel sequence [38, 39]. The gene might interact with ribosomes in organelles such as mitochondria or chloroplasts. GhPG2 codes for polygalacturonase, which is related to the flower organ development. In recent years, the Rf genes of crops such as corn [40], rice [41], onion [42], and sorghum [43] have been cloned successively. Except for corn Rf2 and Rf4 and rice Rf2 and Rf17, the other known Rf genes belong to the PPR (pentatricopeptide repeats) gene family. The coding protein of the PPR gene family is considered to be a single-stranded RNA-binding protein and plays a vital role in the processing of organelles’ RNA [44]. The Rf gene encoding protein plays a major role in organelle RNA processing. The N ends of the Rf gene encoding protein contains the mitochondrial localization sequences that are transported to mitochondria after maturing in the cytoplasm, participating in mitochondrial gene transcription, post-transcriptional processing, and translation for regulating the plant fertility [45]. These studies provided further references for exploring the cotton CMS fertility restorer genes.

In this study, 20 genes were screened out from the correlation region of the fertility restorer genome, including 1 gene with unknown function. Although the functional annotation and analysis of these candidate genes did not identify the PPR gene family, the gene of Gh_D05G3001 encoding the trihelix transcription factor GT-1-like protein with myb-like protein domain was found, such that the myb-like protein play a major role in normal anther and pollen development [46]. In addition, Gh_D05G3003 coding FAD-binding Berberine family protein was identified, and both Gh_D05G3037 encoding the protein and 23 kDa jasmonate-induced protein-like protein in Corchorus olitorius are homologous. The Gh_D05G3039 encoding the protein belongs to B-box and Zinc finger family protein; the above four genes are associated with tapetal development. The tapetum plays a crucial role in anther development by providing the essential enzymes and nutrients for pollen development. The tapetum, which is the innermost of the four sporophytic layers in the anther wall, comes in direct contact with the developing male gametophyte regulating the development and maturation of microspores [47, 48]. Wang et al. discovered that the abortion of 104-7A and Xiangyuan 4-A at the stage of meiosis, the abortive tapetum, sporogenous cells, and microspore mother cells were considered as chromosomal aberrations [49]. The research region of the annotation to the four tapetum development-related genes, especially with myb-like protein domain of Gh_D05G3001 serves as a focal point for the next phase of research. Its function was similar to AtMYB103 and required for tapetal development and microsporogenesis, found in Arabidopsis thaliana [50].

In addition, the gene Gh_D05G3036 encoding carbonic anhydrase 2-like may also play a pivotal role in the process of anther development [51]. The gene of Gh_D05G3030 encoding the xyloglucan endotransglucosylase might be involved in the growth of stamen filaments [52]. The present study also found that both Gh_D05G3042 and Gh_D05G3043 are a series of homologous gene loci, that encode lipid phosphate phosphatase 2, which is a part of ABA signaling. The gene of Gh_D05G3043 also harbors the mitochondrial sequence. Only a few studies have yet reported the role of these genes in the anther development. Thus, we aspire to substantiate their functional role in future studies.

Standard criteria for restorer genes

Analyzing the characteristic controlled by a single gene or polygene according to the Mendelian classical genetics and molecular genetics might be challenging. When a series of genes that control a characteristic is clustered in a specific segment of the chromosome, the classical genetics might presume that the segment is one gene; however, the molecular genetics would divide the segment into several genes according to ORF, which increases the cloning difficulty of genes modulating these characteristics. In this study, we found that several genes in the associated region are related to the development of cotton anthers, and the restorer genes are difficult to be identified. The following questions are yet to be addressed in order to determine the restorer genes: (1) Why the restoring gene of the restorer lines can restore the infertility of sterile lines? (2) Why does the homologous gene of the restorer gene from maintainer line cannot restore the infertility of sterile lines? (3) The difference in the characteristics is caused by functional gene expression arises from the variability in the sequence of the upstream regulatory region; how is it determined as a restorer gene? Therefore, the study of restorer genes necessitates further analysis to understand the mechanism underlying the sterility of nuclear and cytoplasm interaction.

CMS is a common feature encountered in plant species, which is the result of a genomic conflict between the mitochondrial and nuclear genomes. CMS is caused by mitochondrial-encoded factors that can be counteracted by nuclear-encoded factors restoring male fertility [53]. Despite extensive research, the molecular mechanisms underlying male sterility are yet unknown, especially in the cotton. Li et al. discovered the molecule, orf160, unique at the downstream of atp4 in the cytoplasm of the male sterile cotton lines (Gossypium harknessii L.). The full length of the gene was 480 bp, and the sequence at the N-terminal was partially homologous to the atp6 sequence and that at the C-terminal was homologous to the nuclear sequence [54]. Suzuki et al. compared the RNA editing events of 8 genes (atp1, atp4, atp6, atp8, atp9, cox1, cox2, cox3) in the mitochondria from sterile lines, maintainer lines, and restorer lines and found that the relationship between sterility and fertility restoration cannot be explained by RNA editing analysis of these genes [55]. With the completion of the sequencing of the whole genome of the upland cotton [19, 56] and the cotton mitochondrial genome [57], the studies on cotton CMS and the fertility restoration mechanism can provide the information on the crosstalk between gene functions and genes of upland cotton at the global level.

Whether CMS fertility restoration is caused by gene mutation or gene regulation is yet to be substantiated.


In this study, associated markers identified by super-BSA could accelerate the study of CMS in cotton, as well as in the other crops. Some of the 20 genes’ preliminary characteristics provided useful information for further studies on CMS crops.



Bulked segregantion analysis


Cytoplasmic male sterility


Euclidean distance


Pentatricopeptide repeats


Specific length amplified fragment sequencing


Single nucleotide polymorphism



This work was funded through Genetically Modified Organisms Breeding Major Projects of The Ministry of Science and Technology of China (no.2016ZX08005-005-009) and Science and Technology Plan Projects of Hebei Province of China (no.16226321D).


This work was funded through Genetically Modified Organisms Breeding Major Projects of The Ministry of Science and Technology of China (no.2016ZX08005–005-009) and Science and Technology Plan Projects of Hebei Province of China (no.16226321D).

Availability of data and materials

All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this article and its supplementary information files.

Authors’ contributions

BG, JG conceived the experiment. CZ, GZ designed and conducted the experiments. CZ, ZG conducted data analysis and drafted the manuscript, GZ, ZW revised the manuscript. KW, SL and HZ contributed to the experiments and data analysis. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver ( applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.

Authors’ Affiliations

Institute of Cotton, Hebei Academy of Agriculture and Forestry Sciences, Key Laboratory of Biology and Genetic Improvement of Cotton in Huanghuaihai Semiarid Area, The Ministry of Agriculture, Shijiazhuang, China


  1. Linke B, Borner T. Mitochondrial effects on flower and pollen development. Mitochondrion. 2005;5:389–402.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. Janska H, Mackenzie SA. Unusual mitochondrial genome organization in cytoplasmic male sterile common bean and the nature of cytoplasmic reversion to fertility. Genetics. 1993;135:869–79.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  3. Chase CD. Expression of CMS-unique and flanking mitochondrial DNA sequences in Phaseolus Vulgaris L. Curr Genet. 1994;25:245–51.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Hanson MR, Wilson RK, Bentolila S, Kohler RH, Chen HC. Mitochondrial gene organization and expression in petunia male fertile and sterile plants. J Hered. 1999;90:362–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Tang HV, Pring DR, Shaw LC, Salazar RA, Muza FR, Yan B, et al. Transcript processing internal to a mitochondrial open reading frame is correlated with fertility restoration in male-sterile sorghum. Plant J. 1996;10:123–33.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Akagi H, Sakamoto M, Shinjyo C, Shimada H, Fujimura T. A unique sequence located downstream from the rice mitochondrial atp6 may cause male sterility. Curr Genet. 1994;25:52–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Yao Y, Zhu Y, Ren G. Antioxidant and immunoregulatory activity of alkali-extractable polysaccharides from mung bean. Int J Biol Macromol. 2016;84:289–94.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Wang X, Zhang T, Pan J. Genetic basis of fertility restoration to Cytoplasmic male sterile lines available in upland cotton I. Restorer Genes Effects Scientia Agricultura Sinica. 1996;29:32–40.Google Scholar
  9. Liu L, Guo W, Zhu X, Zhang T. Inheritance and fine mapping of fertility restoration for cytoplasmic male sterility in Gossypium Hirsutum L. Theor Appl Genet. 2003;106:461–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Feng CD, Stewart JM, Zhang JF. STS markers linked to the Rf1 fertility restorer gene of cotton. Theor Appl Genet. 2005;110:237–43.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Yin J, Guo W, Yang L, Liu L, Zhang T. Physical mapping of the Rf1 fertility-restoring gene to a 100 kb region in cotton. Theor Appl Genet. 2006;112:1318–25.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Wang F, Stewart JM, Zhang J. Molecular markers linked to the Rf2 fertility restorer gene in cotton. Genome. 2007;50:818–24.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Wang F, Yue B, Hu J, Stewart J, Zhang J. A target region amplified polymorphism marker for fertility restorer gene Rf1 and chromosomal localization of Rf1 and Rf2 in cotton. Crop Scence. 2009;49:1602–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  14. Sun X, Liu D, Zhang X, Li W, Liu H, et al. SLAF-seq: an efficient method of large-scale de novo SNP discovery and genotyping using high-throughput sequencing. PLoS One. 2013;8(3):e58700.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  15. Wei Q, Wang Y, Qin X, Zhang Y, Zhang Z, Wang J, et al. An SNP-based saturated genetic map and QTL analysis of fruit-related traits in cucumber using specific-length amplified fragment (SLAF) sequencing. BMC Genomics. 2014;15:1158.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  16. Li B, Tian L, Zhang J, Huang L, Han F, Yan S, et al. Construction of a high-density genetic map based on large-scale markers developed by specific length amplified fragment sequencing (SLAF-seq) and its application to QTL analysis for isoflavone content in Glycine max. BMC Genomics. 2014;15:1086.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  17. Zhang Y, Wang L, Xin H, Li D, Ma C, Ding X, et al. Construction of a high-density genetic map for sesame based on large scale marker development by specific length amplified fragment (SLAF) sequencing. BMC Plant Biol. 2013;13:141.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  18. Zhu X, Ainijiang ZY, Guo W, Zhang TZ. Relationships between differential gene expression and heterosis in cotton hybrids developed from the foundation parent CRI-12 and its pedigree-derived lines. Plant Sci. 2011;180:221–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  19. Zhang T, Hu Y, Jiang W, Fang L, Guan X, Chen J, et al. Sequencing of allotetraploid cotton (Gossypium Hirsutum L. acc. TM-1) provides a resource for fiber improvement. Nat Biotechnol. 2015;33:531–7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Li H, Durbin R. Fast and accurate short read alignment with burrows–wheeler transform. Bioinformatics. 2009;25(14):1754–60.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  21. Li H, Handsaker B, Wysoker A, Fennell T, Ruan J, Homer N, et al. The sequence alignment-map format and SAMtools. Bioinformatics. 2009;25(16):2078–9.Google Scholar
  22. McKenna A, Hanna M, Banks E, Sivachenko A, Cibulskis K, Kernytsky A, et al. The genome analysis toolkit: a MapReduce framework for analyzing next-generation DNA sequencing data. Genome Res. 2010;20:1297–303.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  23. Reumers J, De Rijk P, Zhao H, Liekens A, Smeets D, Cleary J, et al. Optimized filtering reduces the error rate in detecting genomic variants by short-read sequencing. Nat Biotechnol. 2011;30:61–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Abe A, Kosugi S, Yoshida K, Natsume S, Takagi H, Kanzaki H, et al. Genome sequencing reveals agronomically important loci in rice using MutMap. Nat Biotechnol. 2012;30:174–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Takagi H, Abe A, Yoshida K, Kosugi S, Natsume S, Mitsuoka C, et al. QTL-seq: rapid mapping of quantitative trait loci in rice by whole genome resequencing of DNA from two bulked populations. Plant J. 2013;74:174–83.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Fekih R, Takagi H, Tamiru M, Abe A, Natsume S, Yaegashi H, et al. MutMap+: genetic mapping and mutant identification without crossing in rice. PLoS One. 2013;8:e68529.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  27. Hill JT, Demarest BL, Bisgrove BW, Gorsi B, Su YC, Yost HJ. MMAPPR: mutation mapping analysis pipeline for pooled RNA-seq. Genome Res. 2013;23:687–97.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  28. Olson SA. Emboss opens up sequence analysis. Brief Bioinform. 2012;3(1):87–91.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  29. Yip YL, Famiglietti M, Gos A, Duek PD, David FPA, Gateau A, Bairoch A. Annotating single amino acid polymorphisms in the UniProt/Swiss-Prot knowledgebase. Hum Mutat. 2008;29(3):361–6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  30. Sherlock G. Gene ontology: tool for the unification of biology[J]. Canadian Ins J Food Scie Tech. 2009;22(4):415.Google Scholar
  31. Kanehisa M, Sato Y, Kawashima M, Furumichi M, Tanabe M. KEGG as a reference resource for gene and protein annotation. Nucleic Acids Res. 2016;44:457–62.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  32. Yang L. Map-based cloning of fertility restoring gene of CMS and analysis of PPR gene family in cotton. PhD dissertation, Nanjing agricultural university in China. 2009.Google Scholar
  33. Wu J, Cao X, Guo L, Qi T, Wang H, Tang H, et al. Development of a candidate gene marker for Rf1 based on a PPR gene in cytoplasmic male sterile CMS-D2 upland cotton. Molecular Breeding. 2014;34:231–40.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  34. Li P, Cao M, Yang L, Xu A, Liu H. Mapping of fertility restorer gene for cotton cytoplasmic male sterile line Jin a. Acta Botan Boreali-Occiden Sin. 2007;27:1937–42.Google Scholar
  35. You C, Nie X, Lei J, Feng G, Lv J, Hua J. Study on three sets of cytoplasmic male sterility cotton from different countries: locate the molecular markers of restoring genes. Xinjiang Agric Sci. 2013;50:1003–7.Google Scholar
  36. Yang L, Zhu H, Guo W, Zhang T. Molecular cloning and characterization of five genes encoding pentatricopeptide repeat proteins from upland cotton (Gossypium Hirsutum L.). Mol Biol Rep. 2010;37:801–8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  37. Zhang J, Turley RB, Stewart JM. Comparative analysis of gene expression between CMS-D8 restored plants and normal non-restoring fertile plants in cotton by differential display. Plant Cell Rep. 2008;27:553–61.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  38. Wu Q, Song Y, Zhang R, Wang Y, Guo S. Cloning of the gene GH18Rorf392 containing 26S rRNA sequence from cotton restorer line. Cotton Science. 2008;20:323–9.Google Scholar
  39. Hou S, Zhang R, Guo S. Cloning and expression profile analysis of GhPG2 gene associated with fertility in cotton (Gossypium Hirsutum L.). Acta Agron Sin. 2009;35:2008–14.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  40. Feng Y, Zheng Q, Song H, Wang Y, Wang H, Jiang L, et al. Multiple loci not only Rf3 involved in the restoration ability of pollen fertility, anther exsertion and pollen shedding to S type cytoplasmic male sterile in maize. Theor Appl Genet. 2015;128:2341–50.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  41. Huang W, Yu C, Hu J, Wang L, Dan Z, Zhou W, et al. Pentatricopeptide-repeat family protein RF6 functions with hexokinase 6 to rescue rice cytoplasmic male sterility. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2015;112:14984–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  42. Kim S, Kim CW, Park M, Choi D. Identification of candidate genes associated with fertility restoration of cytoplasmic male-sterility in onion (Allium Cepa L.) using a combination of bulked segregant analysis and RNA-seq. Theor Appl Genet. 2015;128:2289–99.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  43. Praveen M, Anurag Uttam G, Suneetha N, Umakanth A, Patil JV, Madhusudhana R. Inheritance and molecular mapping of Rf6 locus with pollen fertility restoration ability on A1 and A2 cytoplasms in sorghum. Plant Sci. 2015;238:73–80.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  44. Han Z, Qin Y, Kong F, Deng Y, Wang Z, Shen G, et al. Cloning and expression analysis of eight upland cotton Pentatricopeptide repeat family genes. Appl Biochem Biotechnol. 2016;180:1243–55.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Fujii S, Small I. The evolution of RNA editing and pentatricopeptide repeat genes. New Phytol. 2011;191:37–47.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  46. Li Y, Jiang J, Du ML, Li L, Wang XL, Li XB. A cotton gene encoding MYB-like transcription factor is specifically expressed in pollen and is involved in regulation of late anther/pollen development. Plant Cell Physiol. 2013;54:893–906.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  47. Suzuki H, Rodriguez-Uribe L, Xu J, Zhang J. Transcriptome analysis of cytoplasmic male sterility and restoration in CMS-D8 cotton. Plant Cell Rep. 2013;32:1531–42.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  48. Ma Y, Kang J, Wu J, Zhu Y, Wang X. Identification of tapetum-specific genes by comparing global gene expression of four different male sterile lines in Brassica Oleracea. Plant Mol Biol. 2015;87:541–54.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  49. Wang X, Zhang T, Pan J. Cytological observation of microsporogenesis and RAPD analysis of mitochondrial DNAs for cytoplasmic male-sterile cotton lines. Sci Agric Sin. 1998;31:70–5.Google Scholar
  50. Higginson T, Li SF, Parish RW. AtMYB103 regulates tapetum and trichome development in Arabidopsis Thaliana. Plant J. 2003;35:177–92.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  51. Villarreal F, Martin V, Colaneri A, Gonzalez-Schain N, Perales M, Martin M, et al. Ectopic expression of mitochondrial gamma carbonic anhydrase 2 causes male sterility by anther indehiscence. Plant Mol Biol. 2009;70:471–85.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  52. Kurasawa K, Matsui A, Yokoyama R, Kuriyama T, Yoshizumi T, Matsui M, et al. The AtXTH28 gene, a xyloglucan endotransglucosylase/hydrolase, is involved in automatic self-pollination in Arabidopsis Thaliana. Plant Cell Physiol. 2009;50:413–22.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  53. Touzet P, Meyer EH. Cytoplasmic male sterility and mitochondrial metabolism in plants. Mitochondrion. 2014;19 Pt B:166–71.Google Scholar
  54. Li S, Liu G, Chen Z, Wang Y, Hua J. A unique orf160 cloning and genetic transformation of Gossypium Harknessii cytoplasmic male sterile line in upland cotton. Acta Agron Sin. 2013;39:1538–47.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  55. Suzuki H, Yu J, Ness SA, O'Connell MA, Zhang J. RNA editing events in mitochondrial genes by ultra-deep sequencing methods: a comparison of cytoplasmic male sterile, fertile and restored genotypes in cotton. Mol Gen Genomics. 2013;288:445–57.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  56. Li F, Fan G, Lu C, Xiao G, Zou C, Kohel RJ, et al. Genome sequence of cultivated upland cotton (Gossypium Hirsutum TM-1) provides insights into genome evolution. Nat Biotechnol. 2015;33:524–30.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  57. Tang M, Chen Z, Grover CE, Wang Y, Li S, Liu G, et al. Rapid evolutionary divergence of Gossypium Barbadense and G. Hirsutum mitochondrial genomes. BMC Genomics. 2015;16:770.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar


© The Author(s). 2018