Skip to main content
  • Correspondence
  • Open access
  • Published:

The reported colour formation mechanism in pitaya fruit through co-accumulation of anthocyanins and betalains is inconsistent and fails to establish the co-accumulation

A Correspondence to this article was published on 09 November 2022

A Research article to this article was published on 22 October 2020


The premise of the paper authored by Zhou et al. [1] published in BMC Genomics is that, in pitayas Hylocereus undatus (red peel-red pulp or RR; green peel-white pulp or GW) and H. megalanthus (yellow peel-white pulp or YW, also called Selenicereus megalanthus,, accessed on 14/11/2020) [2, 3]), anthocyanins and betalains co-accumulate, and hence both contribute to peel and pulp colour formation. Transcriptome sequencing, metabolome analysis, and qPCR were carried out. Despite inconsistencies, incomplete data, and inaccurate interpretation of data in the paper, the authors concluded that anthocyanins and betalains might co-accumulate in the same plant. Recently, a similar claim of co-accumulation of anthocyanins and betalains in Hylocereus spp. was systematically refuted [4]. In nature, anthocyanins and betalains have been found to be mutually exclusive [5, 6]. However, it is possible that some plants may accumulate both the pigments. Herein, I systematically point out the inconsistencies and misinterpretations of data in the paper by Zhou et al. [1], to demonstrate that this study does not disprove the mutual exclusiveness of anthocyanins and betalains.

Main text

Profiling betacyanins and amaranthin do not meet established standards

White pulp of H. undatus fruits have been reported to contain no betacyanins and betaxanthins [7,8,9,10]. Since betalains were detected in white pulp of H. undatus by Zhou et al. [1], the analysis they carried out should be confirmed in accordance with the available standard practices [11]. Nevertheless, they did not report any confirmatory data, except referring to two previous studies among which only one reported data on white and red species of Hylocereus [9], which was contrary to the findings of Zhou et al. [1]. This indicates that the analytical data presented by Zhou et al. [1] was unreliable. What furthers this assumption is that no Hylocereus sp. has been reported to accumulate amaranthin and/or contain more gomphrenin-I than betanin and hylocerenin [12,13,14,15], unlike what Zhou et al. reported [1]. In fact, in none of the references that Zhou et al. [1] depended upon for secondary metabolite identification by declaring “…….metabolites with similar fragment ions were suggested to be the same compounds. (page 15, column 2, lines 5–6)”, there was detection of either amaranthin or gomphrenin-I in pitaya samples. However, Zhou et al. [1] reported the contrary without thorough chemical/spectral characterisation. Such characterisation steps include profiling authentic reference compounds, fragmentation or neutral loss patterns, and matching of tentative structures’ precursor m/z to relevant databases. Accurate mass determination based on isotopic abundance and various charged and adduct ion forms must be performed to rule out multiple candidate structures of a single molecular formula [11, 16]. Moreover, multiple analytical steps/techniques for confirmation would be absolutely required, because the only difference in the structures of gomphrenin-I and betanin is the position of glucose moiety attachment, and hence MS spectra of these two compounds are the same. Therefore, there is need for additional spectroscopic characterisation to confirm the identity of gomphrenin-I. However, quite questionably, on page 11, column 2, it is reasoned with regard to the presence of high gomphrenin-I that “……this is possibly due to the conversion of betanin into gomphrenin-I as the latter was the significantly enriched metabolite mapped on the betalain biosynthesis pathway.” This explanation has no scientific basis because the literature cited to support the explanation is a review paper focussed on betalain evolution in which there is no mention of gomphrenin-I and the (bio)chemistry of its conversion into betanin. With regard to betanin content, on page 11, column 2, the authors mention that “…[betanin] was present in low quantities in RR-peel as compared to GW and YW-peels…the quantity [of betanin] in GW pulp was almost double than RR pulp.” This cannot be reconciled with the betalain biosynthetic pathway, and also not supported by the metabolite profile provided in Table S9 in [1], i.e. RR pulp has more than 800 times total betacyanins than GW pulp, and RR peel has more than 5 times than GW peel. As mentioned above, H. undatus white pulp has been reported to contain no betaxanthins or betacyanins, let alone betanin. Therefore, it is contradictory that green samples and yellow peels had more betanin than red samples that had the highest betacyanin content among all studied samples. Contents of both betacyanins (ca. 1.5 mg/100 g fresh peels) and betaxanthins (ca. 7 mg/100 g fresh peels) in H. megalanthus have already been reported from China [17], whereas Colombian Selenicereus megalanthus (or H. megalanthus) peels were reported to contain ca. 2.5 mg betaxanthins/100 g fresh weight [18]. The quantification of betacyanins, in particular, and metabolites, in general, in Zhou et al. [1] considers the area under the peak, whose relationship with concentration could be established only through a linear regression curve of the respective authentic reference compound. The cascading effect of the absence of authentic reference compounds, and lack of proper identification of metabolites through spectral characteristics, could be seen in the case of metabolite profile of different samples, viz. pulp and peel of RR, GW and YW. For example, green peel and white pulp samples of H. undatus are expected to have the least betacyanin content, as Israeli H. undatus (white pulp) has been reported to contain no betacyanins and betaxanthins [10]. Surprisingly, Zhou et al. [1] reported green peel and white pulp to have total betacyanins content higher than yellow pulp and yellow peel, when the areas under the curve of all the major identified betacyanins in Table S9 [1] are summed up. As for YW pulp, Ecuadorian S. megalanthus (or H. megalanthus) pulp was earlier reported to contain no betacyanins and betaxanthins [10]. In addition, there are 433 metabolites listed in Table S9 [1], but, curiously, some of the commonly reported amino acids or amines, like L-DOPA, dopamine, and also ascorbic acid are not among them, though their presence in H. megalanthus [17, 19] and H. undatus [7,8,9, 19] has been established beyond doubt.

Reported betalain biosynthetic gene expression and betalain- especially amaranthin- accumulation cannot be reconciled

The expression patterns of unigenes of betalain biosynthetic pathway presented in Fig. 6 [1] do not corroborate with betacyanin content presented in Table S9 [1]. Of the four genes, viz. CYP76AD1-like (Cluster-864.132907), Portulaca grandiflora DOD (Cluster-864.102567), Beta vulgaris DOD (Cluster-864.111172) and Bougainvillea spectabilis cD5GT (Cluster-864.24834), in RR peel and pulp, only the expression of CYP76AD1-like seems to correlate with their metabolite contents. That is, RR pulp has higher betacyanin content and CYP76AD1-like expression than RR peel. All the remaining genes were either less expressed or not significantly different in RR pulp than RR peel. Similarly, RR pulp had comparable or lower betalain biosynthetic gene expression than GW pulp, but total betacyanins content was much higher in RR pulp. Therefore, of all the four reported betalain biosynthetic genes, only the expression of CYP76AD1-like can be reconciled with the metabolite profile. However, based on Fig. 3 [1], CYP76AD1-like expression should lead to L-DOPA formation, but L-DOPA was not detected in any of the studied samples (Table S9 [1]). Further, based on Fig. 3 in [1], CYP76AD1-like gene was not expressed in GW pulp and peel, and hence betalain biosynthesis should not occur therein. Contrastingly, Table S9 [1] shows that GW samples have higher betalain content than corresponding YW samples. In addition, all the 21 genes whose expressions are listed in Fig. 3 [1] have lower or similar expressions in YW pulp and GW pulp compared to YW peel and GW peel. So, contrary to what Fig. 3 [1] suggests, i.e. betalain formation does not occur in the absence of CYP76ADs, thereby resulting in white pulp and green peel, all the above-mentioned observations do not support GW samples having higher betacyanin content than YW samples.

In Fig. 6 [1], none of the betalain biosynthetic genes presented has higher expression in RR peel or pulp as compared to GW pulp or peel. In fact, cluster-864.102567 (PgDOD-like) and cluster-864.111172 (uncharacterised protein or BvDOD-like) are less expressed in both RR peel and RR pulp, while the other genes remained not significantly different from that of corresponding GW samples. Therefore, the gene expression pattern does not support the metabolite profile, and it cannot be explained by focussing only on betanin content in the samples, as done on page 11, column 2, lines 8–13.

Gomphrenin-I is synthesised by a 6-O-GT in plants, particularly betacyanin-accumulating ones (as reviewed in [5]). Therefore, if there were no 6-O-GTs expressed and only 5-O-GTs were differentially expressed as shown in Figs. 3 and 6 [1], then gomphrenin-I cannot be the most abundant betacyanin. However, gomphrenin-I has been claimed to be the most abundant betacyanin (Table S9) [1]. The following reasons make the claim unfeasible: 1) at least, in the case of H. megalanthus, there was no 6-O-GT expression observed by Xie et al. [17], 2) betanidin-5-O-glucosyltransferase (B5GT) and betanidin-6-O-glucosyltransferase (B6GT) share only 19% amino acid sequence identity suggesting that these enzymes are paraphyletic evolutionarily even if they are present in the same plant [20], and 3) betanin (betanidin-5-O-glucoside) has not been shown so far to convert into gomphrenin-I (betanidin-6-O-glucoside) via any enzymatic or non-enzymatic step. Further, the presence of amaranthin in pitaya has not been established so far through extensive spectroscopic characterisation and quantification [12,13,14,15] though Zhou et al. [1] claimed to have detected it. Amaranthin biosynthesis is completed only after glucuronylation at 2′-OH of betanin. Since Zhou et al. [1] did not report data on UDP-glucuronyltransferase and Xie et al. [17] also could not find any upregulated glucuronyltransferase gene, except for a down-regulated one in H. megalanthus peel, it is very unlikely that amaranthin was detected by Zhou et al. [1] in RR and GW samples, especially when other researchers had not detected it before in Hylocereus cacti [9, 12, 13].

Anthocyanins and ANS profiling fall short of established standards

Betalains are tyrosine-derived metabolites, whereas anthocyanins are phenylalanine-derived. In plants, anthocyanidin synthase (ANS) converts colourless leucoanthocyanidins into anthocyanidin pigments [21]. Only after this step does glucosylation and formation of downstream compounds take place [21]. Consequently, it is generally believed that ANS is the most crucial point of separation between anthocyanin and betalain biosynthesis in plants, the other two crucial points being the convergence of one of the transcription factors involved in betalain biosynthesis, and deregulation of arogenate dehydrogenase to favour more tyrosine synthesis at the cost of phenylalanine [6]. Therefore, anthocyanins and betalains are widely accepted to be mutually exclusive, even though ANS is expressed in betalain-accumulating plants. In Mirabilis jalapa, a 69 amino acid truncated and catalytically inactive ANS is expressed, with the truncation involving a part of the active site [22]. Also, ANS is present intact but not expressed in betalain-accumulating Spinacia oleracea and Phytolacca americana [23]. Therefore, any finding contrary to the long-held and well-supported concept of mutual exclusivity of anthocyanins and betalains should be based on unquestionable evidence. Zhou et al. [1] did not include any ANS in Fig. 5 [1], but the expression of one ANS (cluster-864.105069) was presented in Fig. 6 [1]. However, the main concern here is that the lone ANS whose differential expression data is given in Fig. 6 [1] is not a functionally validated protein. Furthermore, its expression is not commensurate with anthocyanin content presented in Table S9 [1]. For example, RR peel has about ten times more total anthocyanins (all the differentially expressed anthocyanins taken together) than RR pulp (Table S9 in [1]), however, the ANS expression in both of them was not significantly different (Fig. 6 in [1]). Similarly, RR peel has about eight times more anthocyanins than GW peel (Table S9 in [1]), but the ANS expression was the same in both the samples (Fig. 6 in [1]). It may not be even required to look for downstream metabolite formation or corresponding gene expression, if ANS expression itself is implausible, because ANS acts as a catalyst that transforms colourless compounds/precursors into corresponding coloured products that exhibit characteristic spectra which are different from that of its precursors or flavonoids derived from the partially overlapping biosynthetic pathway [21, 24, 25]. Therefore, it is questionable as to how this lone ANS candidate whose expression does not correspond to the anthocyanin content can support the premise of anthocyanin accumulation in pitayas, let alone the co-occurrence of anthocyanins and betalains.

Yellow colour formation appears to be not supported by the provided data

Zhou et al. [1] wrote on page 2, column 1, second paragraph that “….the color of the peel and pulp [of pitayas] which is contributed mainly by the pigment betalains and other secondary metabolites such as anthocyanins and carotenoids.” To support this statement, a reference was cited, although it does not report the characterisation of the pigment contents of vine cacti, but reports phenotypic and genomic characterisation. In the studied pitaya samples by Zhou et al. [1], YW peels were supposed to accumulate betaxanthins to ascribe their colour to, as contribution of anthocyanins (page 14, column 1, second paragraph, lines 11–13) and carotenoids (page 14, column 1, third paragraph, lines 7–9) in yellow colour formation was ruled out. However, there was no betaxanthin detected in the metabolite analysis data presented in Table S9 [1]. The presence of dopamine has been explained by Zhou et al. [1] as an indication of betaxanthin formation, however, the corresponding betaxanthin, miraxanthin V, which is yellow in colour, is not reported in Table 9 [1]. All the dopamine that has been reduced in yellow samples compared to green and red samples may not be completely attributed to betaxanthin formation, as was hypothesised by Zhou et al. [1]. On the other hand, betalamic acid is also greenish yellow in colour. However, it is also not listed in Table 9 [1] though others have reported its presence in Hylocereus spp. [9]. Any other amino acid, such as phenylalanine, can form a yellow betaxanthin (i.e. Phe-betaxanthin). However, such a yellow betaxanthin was also not identified in Table 9 [1]. Additionally, YW peels and pulps had betacyanins to be detected unlike betaxanthins which were simply assumed to be present but not detected by the same method of analysis that could detect betacyanins. In a separate study, Xie at al. [17], and Cejudo-Bastante et al. [18] reported 5–7 mg, and ca. 2.5 mg betaxanthins/100 g fresh peels, respectively, of H. megalanthus (or Selenicereus megalanthus) after colour breaking stage. So, taking into account all these inconsistencies, it is clear that the metabolite analysis method used by Zhou et al. [1] was not reliable enough to explain the colour formation in the studied samples.

Availability of data and materials

Not applicable.







Anthocyanidin synthase






Beta vulgaris DOPA-4,5-dioxygeanse




A cytochrome P450 protein with monooxygenase activity towards tyrosine and diphenol oxidase activity towards L-DOPA




Green peel-white pulp


High performance liquid chromatography




Mass to charge ratio


Mass spectrometry


Portulaca grandiflora DOPA-4,5-dioxygenase


Red peel-red pulp


Uridyl diphosphate


Yellow peel-white pulp


  1. Zhou Z, Gao H, Ming J, Ding Z, Lin X, Zhan R. Combined transcriptome and metabolome analysis of pitaya fruit unveiled the mechanisms underlying peel and pulp color formation. BMC Genom. 2020;21:734.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  2. Bauer R. A synopsis of the tribe Hylocereeae F.Buxb. Cactaceae Syst Init. 2003;17:3–63.

    Google Scholar 

  3. Korotkova N, Borsch T, Arias S. A phylogenetic framework for the Hylocereeae (Cactaceae) and implications for the circumscription of the genera. Phytotaxa. 2017;327:1–46.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  4. Pucker B, Singh HB, Kumari M, Khan MI, Brockington SF. The report of anthocyanins in the betalain-pigmented genus Hylocereus is not well evidenced and is not a strong basis to refute the mutual exclusion paradigm. BMC Plant Biol. 2021;21:297.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  5. Khan MI, Giridhar P. Plant betalains: Chemistry and biochemistry. Phytochemistry. 2015;117:267–95.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  6. Timoneda A, Feng T, Sheehan H, Walker-Hale N, Pucker B, Lopez-Nieves S, et al. The evolution of betalain biosynthesis in Caryophyllales. New Phytol. 2019;224:71–85.

    Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  7. Lee K-H, Wu T-Y, Siow L-F. Spray drying of red (Hylocereus polyrhizus) and white (Hylocereus undatus) dragon fruit juices: physicochemical and antioxidant properties of the powder. Int J Food Sci Technol. 2013;48:2391–9.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  8. Liaotrakoon W, De Clercq N, Van Hoed V, Van de Walle D, Lewille B, Dewettinck K. Impact of thermal treatment on physicochemical, antioxidative and rheological properties of white-flesh and red-flesh dragon fruit (Hylocereus spp.) purees. Food Bioproc Technol. 2013;6:416–30.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  9. Suh DH, Lee S, Heo DY, Kim Y-S, Cho SK, Lee S, et al. Metabolite profiling of red and white pitayas (Hylocereus polyrhizus and Hylocereus undatus) for comparing betalain biosynthesis and antioxidant activity. J Agric Food Chem. 2014;62:8764–71.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  10. Kugler F, Stintzing FC, Carle R. Evaluation of the antioxidant capacity of betalainic fruits and vegetables. J Appl Bot Food Qual. 2007;81:69–76.

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  11. Sumner LW, Amberg A, Barrett D, Beale MH, Berger R, Daykin CA, et al. Proposed minimum reporting standards for chemical analysis. Metabolomics. 2007;3:211–21.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  12. Wybraniec S, Mizrahi Y. Fruit flesh betacyanin pigments in Hylocereus cacti. J Agric Food Chem. 2002;50:6086–9.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  13. Esquivel P, Stintzing FC, Carle R. Pigment pattern and expression of colour in fruits from different Hylocereus sp. genotypes. Innov Food Sci Emerg Technol. 2007;8:451–7.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  14. Wybraniec S, Stalica P, Spórna A, Mizrahi Y. Profiles of betacyanins in epidermal layers of grafted and light-stressed cacti studied by LC-DAD-ESI-MS/MS. J Agric Food Chem. 2010;58:5347–54.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  15. Ibrahim SRM, Mohamed GA, Khedr AIM, Zayed MF, El-Kholy AA-ES. Genus Hylocereus: Beneficial phytochemicals, nutritional importance, and biological relevance—A review. J Food Biochem. 2018;42:e12491.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  16. Schrimpe-Rutledge AC, Codreanu SG, Sherrod SD, McLean JA. Untargeted metabolomics strategies- Challenges and emerging directions. J Am Soc Mass Spectrom. 2016;27:1897–905.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  17. Xie F, Hua Q, Chen C, Zhang L, Zhang Z, Chen J, et al. Transcriptomics-based identification and characterization of glucosyltransferases involved in betalain biosynthesis in Hylocereus megalanthus. Plant Physiol Biochem. 2020;152:112–24.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  18. Cejudo-Bastante MJ, Hurtado N, Delgado A, Heredia FJ. Impact of pH and temperature on the colour and betalain content of Colombian yellow pitaya peel (Selenicereus megalanthus). J Food Sci Technol. 2016;53:2405–13.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

  19. Kugler F, Graneis S, Schreiter PPY, Stintzing FC, Carle R. Determination of free amino compounds in betalainic fruits and vegetables by gas chromatography with flame ionization and mass spectrometric detection. J Agric Food Chem. 2006;54:4311–8.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  20. Vogt T. Substrate specificity and sequence analysis define a polyphyletic origin of betanidin 5-and 6-O-glucosyltransferase from Dorotheanthus bellidiformis. Planta. 2002;214:492–5.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  21. Belwal T, Singh G, Jeandet P, Pandey A, Giri L, Ramola S, et al. Anthocyanins, multi-functional natural products of industrial relevance: Recent biotechnological advances. Biotechnol Adv. 2020;43:107600.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  22. Polturak G, Heinig U, Grossman N, Battat M, Leshkowitz D, Malitsky S, et al. Transcriptome and metabolic profiling provides insights into betalain biosynthesis and evolution in Mirabilis jalapa. Mol Plant. 2018;11:189–204.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  23. Shimada S, Inoue YT, Sakuta M. Anthocyanidin synthase in non-anthocyanin-producing Caryophyllales species. Plant J. 2005;44:950–9.

    Article  CAS  PubMed  Google Scholar 

  24. Velioglu YS, Mazza G. Characterization of flavonoids in petals of Rosa damascena by HPLC and spectral analysis. J Agric Food Chem. 1991;39:463–7.

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  25. Gurdon C, Poulev A, Armas I, Satorov S, Tsai M, Raskin I. Genetic and phytochemical characterization of lettuce flavonoid biosynthesis mutants. Sci Rep. 2019;9:3305.

    Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 

Download references


MIK is grateful to the Department of Biotechnology (BT/PR16902/NER/95/422/2015) and Science and Engineering Research Board (ECR/2016/000952) of the Government of India for financial support to the Biochemistry and Molecular Biology lab.


Not applicable.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations



Not applicable. The author(s) read and approved the final manuscript.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Mohammad Imtiyaj Khan.

Ethics declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

Not applicable.

Additional information

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver ( applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Khan, M.I. The reported colour formation mechanism in pitaya fruit through co-accumulation of anthocyanins and betalains is inconsistent and fails to establish the co-accumulation. BMC Genomics 23, 740 (2022).

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI: