The venom-gland transcriptome of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus)

Abstract

Background

Snake venoms have significant impacts on human populations through the morbidity and mortality associated with snakebites and as sources of drugs, drug leads, and physiological research tools. Genes expressed by venom-gland tissue, including those encoding toxic proteins, have therefore been sequenced but only with relatively sparse coverage resulting from the low-throughput sequencing approaches available. High-throughput approaches based on 454 pyrosequencing have recently been applied to the study of snake venoms to give the most complete characterizations to date of the genes expressed in active venom glands, but such approaches are costly and still provide a far-from-complete characterization of the genes expressed during venom production.

Results

We describe the de novo assembly and analysis of the venom-gland transcriptome of an eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus) based on 95,643,958 pairs of quality-filtered, 100-base-pair Illumina reads. We identified 123 unique, full-length toxin-coding sequences, which cluster into 78 groups with less than 1% nucleotide divergence, and 2,879 unique, full-length nontoxin coding sequences. The toxin sequences accounted for 35.4% of the total reads, and the nontoxin sequences for an additional 27.5%. The most highly expressed toxin was a small myotoxin related to crotamine, which accounted for 5.9% of the total reads. Snake-venom metalloproteinases accounted for the highest percentage of reads mapping to a toxin class (24.4%), followed by C-type lectins (22.2%) and serine proteinases (20.0%). The most diverse toxin classes were the C-type lectins (21 clusters), the snake-venom metalloproteinases (16 clusters), and the serine proteinases (14 clusters). The high-abundance nontoxin transcripts were predominantly those involved in protein folding and translation, consistent with the protein-secretory function of the tissue.

Conclusions

We have provided the most complete characterization of the genes expressed in an active snake venom gland to date, producing insights into snakebite pathology and guidance for snakebite treatment for the largest rattlesnake species and arguably the most dangerous snake native to the United States of America, C. adamanteus. We have more than doubled the number of sequenced toxins for this species and created extensive genomic resources for snakes based entirely on de novo assembly of Illumina sequence data.

Background

Human envenomation by snakes is a worldwide issue that claims more than 100,000 lives per year and exacts untold costs in the form of pain, disfigurement, and loss of limbs or limb function [1–3]. Despite the significance of snakebites, their treatments have remained largely unchanged for decades. The only treatments currently available are traditional antivenoms derived from antisera of animals, usually horses [4], innoculated with whole venoms [5, 6]; such an approach is the only readily available option for largely uncharacterized, complex mixtures of proteins such as snake venoms. Although often lifesaving and generally effective against systemic effects, these antivenoms have little or no effect on local hemorrhage or necrosis [7–9], which are major aspects of the pathology of viperid bites and can result in lifelong disability [4, 5]. These traditional treatments also sometimes lead to adverse reactions in patients [6]. Advances in treatment approaches will depend on a complete knowledge of the nature of the offending toxins, but current estimates of the numbers of unique toxins present in snake venoms are in excess of 100 [10], a number not approached in even the most extensive venom-characterization efforts to date [11].

The significance of snake venoms extends well beyond the selective pressures they may directly impose upon human populations. Snake venoms have evolutionary consequences for those species that snakes prey upon [12, 13], as well as species that prey upon the snakes [14], and their study can therefore provide insights into predator-prey coevolution. Snake venom components have been leveraged as drugs and drug leads [15–17] and have been used directly as tools for studying physiological processes such as pain reception [18]. In addition to the significance of the toxins, the nature of the extreme specialization of snake venom glands for the rapid but temporary production and export of large quantities of protein could provide insights into basic mechanisms of proteostasis, the breakdown of which is thought to contribute to neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s [19].

The eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus) is a pit viper native to the southeastern United States and is the largest member of the genus Crotalus, reaching lengths of up to 2.44 m [20]. The diet of C. adamanteus consists primarily of small mammals (e.g., squirrels, rabbits, and mouse and rat species) and birds, particularly ground-nesting species such as quail [20]. Because of its extreme size and consequent large venom yield, C. adamanteus is arguably the most dangerous snake species in the United States and is one of the major sources of snakebite mortality throughout its range [21]. Crotalus adamanteus has recently become of interest from a conservation standpoint because of its declining range, which at one time included seven states along the southeastern Coastal Plain [22]. This species has now apparently been extirpated from Louisiana and is listed as endangered in North Carolina [23, 24]. As a consequence of recent work by Rokyta et al. [11] based on 454 pyrosequencing, the venom of C. adamanteus is among the best-characterized snake venoms; 40 toxins have been identified.

Transcriptomic characterizations of venom glands of snakes [25–28] and other animals [29–32] have relied almost exclusively on low-throughput sequencing approaches. Sanger sequencing, with its relatively long, high-quality reads, has been the only method available until recently and has provided invaluable data on the identities of venom genes. Because venomous species are primarily nonmodel organisms, high-throughput sequencing approaches have been slow to pervade the field of venomics (but see Hu et al. [33]), despite becoming commonplace in other transcriptomic-based fields. Rokyta et al. [11] recently used 454 pyrosequencing to characterize venom genes for C. adamanteus. More recently, Durban et al. [34] used 454 sequencing to study the venom-gland transcriptomes of a mix of RNA from eight species of Costa Rican snakes. Whittington et al. [30] used a hybrid approach with both 454 and Illumina sequencing to characterize the platypus venom-gland transcriptome, although they had a reference genome sequence, making de novo assembly unnecessary. Pyrosequencing is expensive and low-throughput relative to Illumina sequencing, and the high error rate, particularly for homopolymer errors [35], significantly increases the difficulty of identifying coding sequences without reference sequences.

We sequenced the venom-gland transcriptome of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake with Illumina technology using a paired-end approach coupled with short insert sizes effectively to produce longer, high-quality reads on the order of approximately 150 nt to facilitate de novo assembly (an approach similar to that of Rodrigue et al. [36] for metagenomics). The difference in read length from that of 454 sequencing was compensated for by the increase of more than two orders of magnitude in the number of reads. We demonstrated de novo assembly and analysis of a venom-gland transcriptome using only Illumina sequences and provided a comprehensive characterization of both the toxin and nontoxin genes expressed in an actively producing snake venom gland.

Results and discussion

Venom-gland transcriptome sequencing and assembly

We generated a total of 95,643,958 pairs of reads that passed the Illumina quality filter for > 19 gigabases (Gb) of sequence from a cDNA library with an average insert size of ∼170 nt. Of these reads, 72,114,709 (75%) were merged (see Methods) on the basis of their 3’ overlap (Figure 1), yielding composite reads of average length 142 nt with average phred qualities > 40 and a total length > 10 Gb. This merging of reads reduced the effective size of the data set without loss of information and provided long reads to facilitate accurate assembly.

Figure 1

Merging overlapping reads. (A) Reads are slid along each other until the number of matches exceeds the significance threshold. In the example shown, the optimal overlap is 74 nucleotides (nt). (B) The quality of reads declines dramatically toward their 3’ ends, where overlap occurs if the fragment length is less than twice the read length, allowing the actual quality to be much higher than the nominal values. The example shown is the average of pairs that overlap by exactly 50 nt.

Our first approach to transcriptome assembly was aimed at identifying toxin genes. We attempted to use as many of the data as possible to ensure the identification of even the lowest-abundance toxins. To this end, we conducted extensive searches of assembly parameter space for both ABySS [37, 38] (Table 1) and Velvet [39] on the basis of the full set of both merged and unmerged reads. We used the assemblies with the best N 50 values for further analysis. For Velvet, the assembly using a k-mer size of 91 was best (N 50=408); this assembly was subsequently analyzed with Oases [40]. For ABySS, the best k-mer value was also 91 (N 50 = 2,007), but because the performance in terms of full-length transcripts appeared to depend strongly on the coverage (c) and erode (e) parameters, we further analyzed the k = 91 assemblies with c = 10 and e = 2, c = 100 and e = 100, and c = 1000 and e = 1000. We identified all full-length toxins by means of blastx searches on the results of all four assemblies.

Table 1 ABySS assembly summaries

As part of our first approach, we also performed four independent de novo transcriptome assemblies with NGen: three with 20 million merged reads each and one with the remaining 12,114,709 merged reads (Table 2). We identified all full-length toxins from all four assemblies. Given that all three assembly methods tended to generate a large number of fragmented toxin sequences, apparently because of retained introns and possibly alternative splicing, we developed and implemented a simple hash-table approach to completing partial transcripts, which we will refer to as Extender (see Methods). We used Extender on partial toxin sequences identified for two of the four NGen assemblies. We also annotated the most abundant full-length nontoxin transcripts for the three assemblies based on 20 million reads. After combining all of the annotated toxin and nontoxin sequences from the ABySS, Velvet, and NGen assemblies and eliminating duplicates, we had 72 unique toxin sequences and 234 unique nontoxin sequences. The paucity of full-length annotated nontoxins reflects our focus on toxin sequences rather than their absence in the assemblies.

Table 2 NGen assembly summaries

Our second approach to transcriptome assembly was designed to annotate as many full-length coding sequences (toxin and nontoxin) as possible and to build a reference database of sequences to facilitate the future analysis of other snake venom-gland transcriptomes. We found that NGen was much more successful at producing transcripts with full-length coding sequences but also that it was quite inefficient when the coverage distribution was extremely uneven (see Figure 2). Feldmeyer et al. [41] also found NGen to have the best assembly performance with Illumina data. We sought therefore first to eliminate the transcripts and corresponding reads for the extremely high-abundance sequences. To do so, we employed Extender as a de novo assembler by starting from 1,000 individual high-quality reads and attempting to complete their transcripts (see Methods). From 1,000 seeds, we identified 318 full-length coding sequences with 213 toxins and 105 nontoxins. After duplicates were eliminated, this procedure resulted in 58 unique toxin and 44 unique nontoxin full-length transcripts. These sequences were used to filter the corresponding reads from the full set of merged reads with NGen. We then performed a de novo transcriptome assembly on 10 million of the filtered reads with NGen, annotated full-length transcripts from contigs comprising ≥ 200 reads with significant blastx hits, and used the resulting unique sequences as a new filter. This process of assembly, annotation, and filtering was iterated two more times. The end result was 91 unique toxin and 2,851 unique nontoxin sequences.

Figure 2

Domination of the C. adamanteus venom-gland transcriptome by toxin transcripts. The 123 unique toxin sequences were clustered into 78 groups with less than 1% nucleotide divergence for estimation of abundances. (A) The vast majority of the extremely highly expressed genes were toxins. The inset shows a magnification of the top 200 transcripts. (B) Expression levels of individual toxin clusters are shown with toxin classes coded by color. The toxin clusters are in the same order as in Table 3.

The results from both assembly approaches were merged to yield the final data set. The first approach produced 72 unique toxin and 234 unique nontoxin sequences, and the second 91 toxin and 2,851 nontoxin sequences. The merged data set consisted of 123 unique toxin sequences and 2,879 nontoxins that together accounted for 62.9% of the sequencing reads (Figure 3).

Figure 3

Expression levels of major classes of toxins and nontoxins. More than 60% of the total reads have been accounted for with full-length annotated transcripts. (A) The major toxin classes were the CTLs, SVSPs, MYO, and SVMPs (types II and III). (B) As expected for a protein-secreting tissue, the venom gland expresses an abundance of proteins involved in proteostasis.

Toxin transcripts

We identified 123 individual, unique toxin transcripts with full-length coding sequences. To estimate the abundances of these transcripts in the C. adamanteus venom-gland transcriptome, we clustered them into 78 groups with less than 1% nt divergence (Table 3). Clusters could include alleles, recent duplicates, or even sequencing errors, which are characteristic of high-throughput sequencing [42]. For longer genes, clusters might also include different combinations of variable sites that are widely separated in the sequence. We chose 1% as a practical, but arbitrary, cut-off for defining clusters. Mapping reads back to more similar sequences to estimate abundances would be problematic because reads could not be uniquely assigned to a particular sequence. The true number of toxin genes for C. adamanteus probably lies somewhere between 78 and 123. This range is at the lower end of the number of unique toxins typically identified for viperids by means of proteomic techniques [10], which may indicate that the venom of C. adamanteus is less complex than that of other species. Alternatively, posttranscriptional processes such as alternative splicing or posttranslational modifications could significantly increase the diversity of toxins present in the venom. Our identified toxins accounted for 35.4% of the total reads (Figure 3), and the vast majority of the extremely high-abundance transcripts were those encoding toxin proteins (Figure 2A). We named toxins with a combination of a toxin-class abbreviation, a cluster number, and, if the cluster had more than a single member, a lower-case letter to indicate the member of the cluster (e.g., CTL-3b).

Table 3 Expression levels of full-length toxin clusters

We used the number or percentage of reads mapping to a particular transcript as a measure of its abundance. Although average coverage might be a more appropriate proxy for the number of copies of a given transcript present, because it accounts for differences in transcript lengths, we prefer read counts as a measure of the expression expenditure on a given transcript because they better reflect the energetic cost associated with producing the encoded protein and are consistent with previous work using low-throughput sequencing (see, e.g., Pahari et al. [25]). In addition, this measurement should more closely match proteomic-based measurements of the contents of venom components (see, e.g., Gibbs et al. [43]) which come in the form of the percentages of total peptide bonds in the sample.

Snake venom metalloproteinases

We identified 39 unique sequences and 16 clusters of snake-venom metalloproteinases (SVMPs) that accounted for 24.4% of the reads mapping to toxin sequences and 8.6% of the total reads (Figure 3A and Table 3). In terms of total reads, the SVMPs were the most abundant class of toxins in the C. adamanteus venom-gland transcriptome. SVMPs are the primary sources of the local and systemic hemorrhage associated with envenomation by viperids and are divided into a number of subclasses based on their domain structure [44, 45]. All SVMPs have a metalloproteinase domain characterized by a zinc-binding motif. All of the SVMPs identified for C. adamanteus belong to either the type II or the type III subclass. Type II SVMPs (SVMPIIs) have a disintegrin domain in addition to the metalloproteinase domain, which may be proteolytically cleaved posttranslationally to produce a free disintegrin. Type III SVMPs (SVMPIIIs) have a disintegrin-like and a cysteine-rich domain in addition to the metalloproteinase domain. We found 8 clusters of each of these two subclasses with 23 unique SVMPII sequences and 16 unique SVMPIII sequences. SVMPII and SVMPIII clusters comprise 16.4% and 8.0% of the reads mapping to toxins respectively (Figure 3). The sequences in both subclasses are diverse. The maximum pairwise nt divergence for the SVMPIIs was 10.0%, corresponding to a maximum amino-acid divergence of 18.1%. For the SVMPIIIs, the maximum pairwise nt divergence was 20.4% with a maximum amino-acid divergence of 42.3%. Although SVMPs were the dominant toxins as a class, the individual SVMP cluster with the highest abundance was SVMPII-5, which was only the eighth most abundant toxin cluster (Figure 2B and Table 3).

Mackessy [46] categorized rattlesnake venoms as type I or type II on the basis of their toxicities and metalloproteinase activities. These two measurements tend to be inversely related in rattlesnakes: species (or populations) with low LD₅₀ values tend also to have low or undetectable hemorrhagic activities. SVMPs are the major hemorrhagic components of snake venoms, and high toxicity appears to be caused mostly by neurotoxic venom components. Low-toxicity venoms with high metalloproteinase activity are classified as type I, and high-toxicity venoms with low metalloproteinase activity are classified as type II. On the basis of the abundance of SVMPs in the venom-gland transcriptome, C. adamanteus clearly has type I venom, although the relatively low toxicity of its venom [46] is at least partially compensated for by its large size and venom yield.

C-type lectins

The most diverse and the second most abundant toxin class in the C. adamanteus venom-gland transcriptome was the C-type lectin (CTL) class. We identified 37 unique sequences and 21 clusters of CTLs that accounted for 22.2% of the reads mapping to toxins and 7.8% of the total reads (Figure 3A and Table 3). CTLs generally either inhibit or activate components of plasma or blood-cell types, thereby interfering with hemostasis [47]. Most known snake-venom CTLs function as heterodimers or even more complex arrangements [48], probably accounting in part for their diversity. The divergence among members of this class within the C. adamanteus genome was extreme, although all members preserved a CTL-like domain. Some pairs shared virtually no conserved amino-acid positions. Three of the CTL clusters provide evidence for the relevance of alternative splicing in the generation of toxin proteins. CTL-3f, CTL-4e, and CTL9b all have 48-nt insertions in the same region but are otherwise similar or identical to other members of their clusters.

Snake venom serine proteinases

The third most abundant toxin class for C. adamanteus was the snake-venom serine proteinases (SVSPs). We identified 18 unique sequences and 14 clusters in this toxin class, accounting for 20.0% of the toxin reads and 7.1% of the total reads (Figure 3A and Table 3). Three of the 10 most highly expressed individual toxins were SVSPs (Figure 2). SVSPs interfere with a wide array of reactions involving blood coagulation and hemostasis and belong to the trypsin family of serine proteases [49, 50]. Mackessy [46] detected significant thrombin-like and kallikrein-like activity in the venom of C. adamanteus, which are attributable to the action of SVSPs. The diversity of SVSPs within the C. adamanteus genome is high; maximum pairwise nt divergence is 20.6% and amino-acid divergence is 47.4%.

The members of two SVSP clusters differ in a way that should be noted. The lengths of SVSPs are generally well conserved throughout the class. SVSP-7a has a 27-nt insertion relative to the two other members of its cluster but is otherwise identical to SVSP-7b. This difference could reflect the presence of alternative splicing for this gene. SVSP-3a is unique among the C. adamanteus SVSPs or those known from other snake species in apparently having a 65-amino-acid extension of its C-terminal region. The other member of its cluster, SVSP-3b, has a single deletion of a C nt in a poly-C tract that terminates its coding sequence consistently with other known SVSPs. The reads generating the SVSP-3a form vastly outnumber those for the SVSP-3b form; more than 95% of the reads support the extended version of the protein. The effect, if any, of this C-terminal extension remains to be determined.

Phospholipase A₂’s

Previous work with C. adamanteus identified only a single phospholipase A₂ (PLA2) sequence [11], but we identifed seven unique sequences in six clusters (Figure 2 and Table 3), accounting for 7.8% of the toxin reads and 2.8% of the total reads (Figure 3). PLA2s are among the most functionally diverse classes of snake-venom toxins and have pharmocological effects ranging from neurotoxicity (presynaptic or postsynaptic) to myotoxicity and cardiotoxicity. Anticoagulant and hemolytic effects due to PLA2s are also known [51, 52]. Compared to other toxin classes of C. adamanteus, the diversity of PLA2s is low. Five of the six clusters are all within 5% nt divergence of one another. PLA2-3 is the lone, high-divergence outlier, differing by more than 31% at the nt level from the other clusters. PLA2-3 is also expressed at the lowest level of any of the PLA2s (Table 3).

Other high-abundance toxins

The SVMPs, CTLs, SVSPs, and PLA2s account for 74% of the reads mapping to toxin sequences (Figure 3), 73% of the toxin clusters, and 82% of the unique toxin sequences. The remaining toxins belong to 16 different classes. Many of these are low-abundance transcripts (Figure 2 and Table 3) and may not actually function as significant toxins, whereas several others have high to moderate abundances and represent significant components of the venom.

The most abundant toxin transcript and the most abundant transcript overall (Figure 2) was a small basic myotoxin related to crotamine [53, 54]. The precursor protein is just 70 amino acids in length with a predicted 22-amino-acid signal peptide. This transcript was detected by Rokyta et al. [11], but the coding sequence was prematurely truncated in their sequence because of a single nt deletion. This toxin accounts for 16.8% of the toxin reads (Figure 3A) and 5.9% of the total reads. Crotamine, originally isolated from the venom of C. durissus, causes spastic paralysis in mice and is found in the venoms of many species of Crotalus[54]. Muscle spasms, twitching, and paralysis of the legs have been reported for human envenomations by C. adamanteus[20]. Interestingly, Straight et al. [55] noted that individuals of C. adamanteus from populations in southern and central Florida lack this toxin in their venoms. Given that this myotoxin is the most abundant transcript in the venom of our specimen, its absence in southern populations points to a dramatic difference in venoms within this species and the potential for significantly different pathological effects associated with bites from different C. adamanteus populations.

A single L-amino-acid oxidase (LAAO) transcript was the second most abundant toxin transcript (Figure 2B), consistent with the previously detected LAAO activity in the C. adamanteus venom [46]. This single transcript accounted for 5.3% of the reads mapping to toxins and 1.9% of the total reads. LAAOs are flavoproteins, giving the venom its yellow color; can be edema- or apoptosis-inducing; and can induce or inhibit platelet aggregation [56]. These effects are probably mediated by H₂O₂released during the oxidation reaction catalyzed by the enzyme. The 29th most abundant toxin transcript was a cysteine-rich secretory protein (CRISP) (Figure 2B and Table 3), accounting for 1.3% of the toxin reads (Figure 3A). Although CRISPs are widely found in snake venoms, their precise effects are not well established [57], but they appear to interfere with smooth-muscle contraction [58, 59]. A single transcript for a bradykinin-potentiating and C-type natriuretic peptide transcript (BPP) was found to account for 0.7% of the toxin reads (Figure 3A). The encoded protein is similar to a protein identified in Sistrurus catenatus (GenBank accession: DQ464265) that was hypothesized to reduce blood pressure in envenomated prey [25]. A loss of blood pressure has been reported in human envenomations by C. adamanteus[20].

Other low-abundance toxins

The remaining 17 clusters are classified as “others” in Figure 3A. Because each has a relatively low expression level (Table 3), many of these should be considered putative toxins until their presence in the C. adamanteus venom is confirmed proteomically and pharmacological effects are associated with them.

Rokyta et al. [11] detected the presence of a transcript encoding a protein homologous to ohanin from Ophiophagus hannah[60, 61] and to a homologous protein from Lachesis muta[62]; we found a transcript identical to that of Rokyta et al. [11]. Pung et al. [60, 61] found the O. hannah version of this protein to increase pain sensitivity (hyperalgesia) and to induce temporary hypolocomotion in mice and proposed naming the class vespryns (VESP). Exceptionally intense pain has been reported after envenomation of humans by C. adamanteus[20], although whether such pain is due to a specific toxin is not clear.

We detected three different nucleotidases (NUCs) and five different phosphodiesterases (PDEs) in the venom-gland transcriptome of C. adamanteus. Only one of the NUCs and three of the PDEs had signal peptides, and we therefore only considered these as potential toxins: NUC, PDE, PDE-4, and PDE-6 (Table 3). The roles of these enzymes in venoms are uncertain, but their primary function may be to liberate toxic nucleosides [63–65]. Significant PDE activity has been detected previously in the venom of C. adamanteus[46].

The C. adamanteus venom-gland transcriptome contained three Kunitz-type protease inhibitors (KUNs). Two of these shared more than 75% animo-acid identity with a KUN from Austrelaps labialis (GenBank accession: B2BS84), an Australian elapid. All three KUNs have domains that place them in the superfamily of bovine pancreatic trypsin-like inhibitors, and snake toxins from this family are known to inhibit plasma serine proteinases. Although KUNs are commonly observed in snake venoms, their role in envenomation (if any) is not well defined [66]. The three KUNs detected for C. adamanteus are all at relatively low abundances, suggesting that they are not major components of the venom.

We identified two transcripts, HYAL-1 and HYAL-2, encoding hyaluronidase-like proteins. Hyaluronidases are generally regarded as venom components that promote the dissemination of other venom components by degrading the extracellular matrix at the site of injection [67], although they may have more direct toxic effects [68]. The coding sequences of our two transcripts differ only in the presence of a 765-nt deletion in HYAL-2 relative to HYAL-1. Truncated hyaluronidases such as HYAL-2 have been detected in the venoms of other viperid species [67] and may represent an example of alternative splicing. We also identified a transcript encoding a glutaminyl-peptide cyclotransferase (glutaminyl cyclase; GC). Many snake venom components have N termini blocked by pyroglutamate, and GCs catalyze the formation of this block. This component is related more to maturation and protection of other toxins and probably contributes only indirectly to toxicity [69].

We identified six growth-factor-related sequences in the venom-gland transcriptome of C. adamanteus: a nerve growth factor (NGF), a neurotrophic factor (NF), two vascular endothelial growth factors (VEGF) in a single cluster, and a cysteine-rich with EGF-like domain protein (CREGF). The NGF transcript encodes a 241 amino-acid precursor protein and shares 99% amino-acid identity with a NGF from C. durissus (GenBank accession: AAG30924). The NF transcript encodes a 180-amino-acid precursor that shares homology with mesencephalic astrocyte-derived neurotrophic factors. We found no close venom-related sequences for this NF in the available databases. The VEGF sequences appear to be alternatively spliced versions of one another. VEGF-1a encodes a 192-amino-acid precursor, and VEGF-1b encodes a 148-amino-acid precursor. Aside from the 132-nt deletion in VEGF-1b relative to VEGF-1a, their coding sequences are identical. Both forms have database matches of the same length with 99% amino-acid identity from Trimeresurus flavoviridis (GenBank accessions: AB154418 and AB154419). Finally, we detected the same cysteine-rich with EGF-like domain protein as described by Rokyta et al. [11].

The final two putative toxin transcripts are of questionable significance because of their low expression levels. A single sequence with 77% amino-acid identity to a waprin (WAP) sequence from Philodryas olfersii (GenBank accession: EU029742), a rear-fanged colubrid, was detected. Related sequences have been detected in a variety of other rear-fanged snake species, but such proteins are only known to exhibit antimicrobial activity [70]. We detected a venom factor (VF) transcript that shares 87% animo-acid identity with a VF from Austrelaps superbus (GenBank accession: AY903291) [71]. The C. adamanteus VF transcript encodes a 1,652-amino-acid precursor with a 22-amino-acid signal peptide. The best-studied member of this toxin family is cobra venom factor, which is known to activate the complement system [72]. The extremely low expression levels of these transcripts may indicate that they represent the orthologous genes to the ancestors of the known toxic forms and may therefore have no toxic functions.

Comparison to previous work

Rokyta et al. [11] previously described toxin transcripts in the venom-gland transcriptome of C. adamanteus on the basis of 454 pyrosequencing. Their work used RNA from the venom gland of the same individual used in the present work. They found 40 unique toxin transcripts, 10 of which contained only partial coding sequences. Table 4 lists the closest matches from our current sequences to those of Rokyta et al. [11]. The vast majority of the 454-based sequences had either identical matches in our current set of toxins or matches with less than 1% nt divergence (Table 4). Only a single 454 toxin, SVSP-9, did not have a close match. This sequence contains only a partial coding sequence and therefore may not represent a true, functional toxin.

Table 4 Correspondence with the results of Rokyta et al.[11]]

Nontoxin transcripts

We characterized the nontoxin genes expressed in the C. adamanteus venom gland by two means. First, we took all of the contigs from one of our four de novo NGen assemblies based on 20 million merged reads and conducted a full Blast2Go [73] analysis on the contigs comprising ≥ 100 reads. Of the 12,746 contigs (assembly 2 in Table 2), we were able to provide gene ontology (GO) annotations for 9,040 of them (Figure 4A). The major functional classes (level 2) represented in these results were binding and catalysis, followed by transcription regulation (Figure 4B). The major biological process GO terms (level 2) were cellular processes and metabolic processes (Figure 4C). Interestingly, viral reproductive function was detected and probably represents the activity of transposable elements or retroviruses like those previously noted in snake venom-gland transcriptomes [34]. The major cellular component GO terms (level 2) were cell and organelle (Figure 4D). For these results, we made no attempt to exclude toxin sequences, because they are necessarily a small minority of the total sequences, and did not require that contigs contain full-length coding sequences.

Figure 4

Comparison of gene ontology (GO) results for our annotated full-length nontoxin sequences with those of the contigs from a de novo assembly with NGen. Only level 2 GO terms are shown. The distributions of GO terms are similar across data sets, suggesting that the annotated transcripts provided a comprehensive characterization of the genes expressed in the venom gland. (A) The distributions of sequences reaching various stages of identification and annotation are shown. The level 2 GO terms are shown for molecular function (B), biological process (C), and cellular component (D).

For our second approach, we used only the 2,879 transcripts with full-length coding sequences for nontoxin proteins. We analyzed these sequences with Blast2GO. The distributions of level 2 GO terms for these data were almost identical to those of the full NGen assembly described above (Figure 4), suggesting that our 2,879 annotated nontoxin sequences provide a representative sample of the full venom-gland transcriptome. The full distributions of GO terms for these sequences across all levels are shown in Figures 5, 6, and 7. As expected for a secretory tissue, processes related to protein production and secretion were well represented (e.g., protein transport and protein modification; Figure 5), as were protein-binding functions (Figure 6) and proteins localized to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and the Golgi apparatus (Figure 7).

Figure 5

The biological-process GO terms identified for the 2,879 annotated full-length nontoxin sequences. Terms specific for the production, processing, and export of proteins are highlighted in black. The inset shows the low-abundance portion of the full distribution.

Figure 6

The molecular-function GO terms identified for the 2,879 annotated full-length nontoxin sequences. Terms specific for the production, processing, and export of proteins are highlighted in black. The inset shows the low-abundance portion of the full distribution.

Figure 7

The cellular-components GO terms identified for the 2,879 annotated full-length nontoxin sequences. Terms specific for the production, processing, and export of proteins are highlighted in black. The inset shows the low-abundance portion of the full distribution.

Four of the top 20 most highly expressed nontoxin genes (Table 5), including the most highly expressed, were protein disulfide isomerases (PDIs). In particular, they were members of the PDI family that is retained in the ER and are characterized by having two or more PDI domains, which are similar to thioredoxin. PDIs catalyze the formation or breaking of disulfide bonds and are therefore involved in protein folding. Molecular chaperones were well represented in the top 20 nontoxins by four genes: endoplasmin (a member of the HSP90 family), calreticulin, 78-kDA glucose-regulated protein (GRP78), and heat shock protein 5. The latter gene appears to be a splice variant of GRP78, differing within the coding region by two point mutations and two short deletions. All of these chaperones are ER specific. Six of the top 20 nontoxins were mitochondrial genes involved in oxidative cellular respiration, consistent with the high energetic demands of venom production [74]: cytochrome C oxidase subunits I and III, cytochrome B, and NADH dehydrogenase subunits 1, 4, and 5. The cells of venom glands are particularly rich in mitochondria [75]. Four genes were involved in various aspects of translation: two translation elongation factors, 18S rRNA, and vigilin. Vigilins are hypothesized to be involved in regulating mRNA stability and translation and might be involved in RNA-mediated gene silencing [76, 77]. The final top 20 nontoxin gene was actin, a component of the cytoskeleton.

Table 5 The 20 most highly expressed nontoxin transcripts

The abundances of several major classes of nontoxins are provided in Figure 3B. We identified 57 sequences with functions related to protein folding [19, 78–80], including various classes of heat-shock proteins, protein-disulfide isomerases, peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerases, dnaJ-complex components, and T-complex components. These sequences together accounted for 28.4% of the total reads mapping to nontoxins. Ribosomal-protein transcripts (cytoplasmic and mitochondrial) accounted for 9.5% of the nontoxin reads, and mitochondrial genes accounted for another 9.0%. Finally, we identified 110 sequences transcripts encoding proteins involved in protein degradation [81, 82], including proteins involved in the ubiquitin-proteasome system and the ER-associated protein-degradation system [83], which accounted for 2.6% of the nontoxin reads. Protein-quality control should be essential in a high-throughput protein-producing tissue such as a snake venom gland.

Our collection of nontoxins included several notable potential inhibitors of the toxins or other proteases (Table 6). Such inhibitors may play a role in preventing autolysis [84] or may serve to protect venom components once inside a victim [85]. We detected three cystatin-like transcripts in the venom gland. Cystatins are cysteine-protease inhibitors and have been detected in numerous elapid venom glands and venoms [85]. We detected three unique metalloproteinase inhibitors and two serine proteinase inhibitors (serpins). Finally, we found four unique PLA2 inhibitors.

Table 6 Toxin and protease inhibitors detected in the venom-gland transcripts

Sequence accession numbers

The original, unmerged sequencing reads were submitted to the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) Sequence Read Archive under accession number SRA050594. The annotated toxin and nontoxin sequences were submitted to the GenBank Transcriptome Shotgun Assembly (TSA) database under accession numbers JU173621–JU173743 (toxins) and JU173744–JU176622 (nontoxins).

Conclusions

We have described the most comprehensive venom-gland transcriptomic characterization of a snake species to date and provided full-length coding sequences for 123 unique toxin proteins and 2,879 unique nontoxin proteins. We have demonstrated the use of Illumina sequencing technology for the sequencing and de novo assembly of a tissue-specific transcriptome for a nonmodel species, C. adamanteus, for which genome-scale resources were previously unavailable. Because the nontoxin sequences in particular should be conserved across snake species, our results should greatly facilitate similar work with other venomous species, serving as an assembly template and reducing the number of reads for which de novo assembly will be necessary.

The expressed toxin genes in the venom gland of C. adamanteus provide a detailed portrait of a type I rattlesnake venom [46]. The most abundant transcript expressed in the C. adamanteus venom gland encoded a myotoxin homologous to crotamine. Crotamine is known to induce spastic paralysis [54], a symptom that has been observed in human envenomations by C. adamanteus[20]. Like those of most viperids, the bites of C. adamanteus result in significant tissue damage and necrosis, and we found that SVMPs, the major class of hemorrhagic toxins, dominated venom-gland gene expression. The second most abundant toxin transcript overall was an LAAO, which are also noted for causing local tissue damage [46]. Coagulopathy is a common occurrence with pit-viper bites [5]. The CTLs and SVSPs were also both diverse and abundant in the venom-gland transcriptome of C. adamanteus, and both classes primarily attack the hemostatic system. In terms of gene sequences of venom components, the venom of C. adamanteus is now the best-characterized snake venom, although a thorough proteomic analysis of the venom is still needed. The sequences we have generated will greatly facilitate such a proteomic characterization by serving as a database against which to query mass-spectrum results.

The expression patterns of the nontoxin genes in the venom gland of C. adamanteus reflect the protein-secretory function of the tissue and the high energetic demands of rapid venom production [75]. The most highly expressed nontoxin genes were those involved in the production and processing of proteins and energy production to support these activities. Molecular chaperones and PDIs were particularly abundant. Though the expression patterns for nontoxins were not surprising, future comparisons with other snake species, especially those from other snake families, may be able to elucidate the origin and early stages of the evolution of the venom gland.

Methods

Venom-gland transcriptome sequencing

We sequenced the venom-gland transcriptome of a single animal from Florida (Wakulla County): an adult female weighing 393 g with a snout-to-vent length of 792 mm and a total length of 844 mm. To stimulate transcription in the venom glands, we anesthetized the snake by propofol injection (10 mg/kg) and extracted venom by electrostimulation under anesthesia [86]. After venom extraction, the animal was allowed to recover for four days while transcription levels reached their maxima [87]. The snake was euthanized by injection of sodium pentobarbitol (100 mg/kg), and its venom glands were subsequently removed. The above techniques were approved by the Florida State University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) under protocol #0924.

Sequencing and nonnormalized cDNA library preparation were performed by the HudsonAlpha Institute for Biotechnology Genomic Services Laboratory (http://www.hudsonalpha.org/gsl/). Transcriptome sequencing was performed essentially as described by Mortazavi et al. [88] in a modification of the standard Illumina methods described in detail in Bentley et al. [89]. Total RNA was reduced to poly-A+ RNA with oligo-dT beads. Two rounds of poly-A+ selection were performed. The purified mRNA was then subjected to a mild heat fragmentation followed by random priming for first-strand synthesis. Standard second-strand synthesis was followed by standard library preparation with the double-stranded cDNA as input material. This approach is similar to that of Illumina’s TruSeq RNA-seq library preparation kit. Sequencing was performed in one lane on the Illumina HiSeq 2000 with 100-base-pair paired-end reads.

Transcriptome assembly and analysis

The average insert length of our cDNA library was ∼170 nt, excluding the Illumina adaptors. With 100-base-pair paired-end sequencing, the majority of paired-end reads overlapped at their 3’ ends. Because read quality declines toward the 3’ ends of reads, we developed a method similar to that of Rodrigue et al. [36] for merging the overlapping pairs into single, long, high-quality reads. The members of each pair of reads were slid along each other, and, for each overlap of length n, we calculated the probability of getting the observed number of matches k by chance using a binomial probability given by

P\left(k\right|n)=\left(\begin{array}{c}n\\ k\end{array}\right){\left(\frac{1}{4}\right)}^k{\left(\frac{3}{4}\right)}^{n-k}

(1)

assuming any of the four nucleotides is equally likely to be at any position. To be conservative, we only merged reads if the minimum probability was less than 10⁻¹⁰and the second smallest probability was at least 1000 times larger (Figure 1A). The latter condition was meant to help avoid merging reads that span highly repetitive regions. For cases in which the insert size was less than the read length, sequence data outside the overlap were assumed to represent adaptors and were deleted. We updated quality scores for the overlapping positions following the approach of Rodrigue et al. [36]. For merged reads, quality scores for nonoverlapping bases were left unchanged (Figure 1B). The unmerged reads were typically those pairs from the longer end of the insert-size distribution.

Because of the inherent difficulty in de novo transcriptome assembly, we used a diverse array of assembly approaches and combined the results for a final data set. We performed assemblies using ABySS version 1.2.6 [37, 38] under a wide array of parameter values using both the merged and unmerged reads. In particular, we used k-mer values of 51, 61, 71, 81, and 91 and varied the coverage (c) and erode (e) parameters from 2 to 1,000. We set E = 0, m = 20, and s = 200 for all assemblies. Trans-ABySS [90] provided little or no improvement of our assemblies, primarily because assembly quality appeared to be more dependent on the coverage and erode parameters than on the k-mer length. We also conducted assemblies using both the merged and unmerged reads with Velvet version 1.1.02 [39] and k-mer values of 71, 81, and 91. We selected the best of these assemblies on the basis of the N 50 values for further assembly into transcripts with Oases version 0.1.20 (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/∼zerbino/oases/) [40]. For Oases, we set the minimum transcript length to 300 nt and the coverage cutoff to 10. We also followed the approach of Rokyta et al. [11] and used the NGen2.2 assembler from DNAStar (http://www.dnastar.com/). Because this assembler is limited to 20–30 million reads, we used only the merged reads. We performed four independent assemblies: three with 20 million merged reads each and one with the remaining 12,114,709 merged reads. Each assembly was performed with the default settings for high-stringency, de novo transcriptome assembly for long Illumina reads, including default quality trimming. The high-stringency setting corresponded to setting the minimum match percentage to 90%. We retained contigs comprising at least 100 reads.

In addition to the all-at-once assembly approaches above, we developed an iterative approach that was both more effective at generating full-length transcripts and more computationally efficient. The first step consisted of applying our Extender program (see below) as a de novo assembler starting from 1,000 reads. Full-length transcripts were identified with blastx searches (see below), then used as templates in a reference-based assembly in NGen3.1 with a 98% minimum match percentage to filter reads corresponding to identified transcripts. Ten million of the unassembled sequences were then used in a de novo transcriptome assembly in NGen3.1 with the same settings as described above for de novo assembly except that the minimum match percentage was increased to 93% and contigs comprising less than 200 sequences were discarded. The resulting sequences were identified, where possible, by means of blastx searches, and the identified full-length transcripts were used in another templated assembly to generate a further-reduced set of reads. This iterative process was repeated two additional times.

To provide transcriptional profiles of the venom gland, we performed GO annotation with Blast2GO [73]. We ran full analyses on one of NGen assemblies of 20 million merged reads, including blastx searches, GO mapping, and annotation. We used the default Blast2GO parameters throughout. We converted the GO annotation to generic GO-slim terms. We ran the same analysis on the combined set of annotated nontoxin sequences.

For gene identification and annotation, we conducted blastx searches using mpiblast version 1.6.0 (http://www.mpiblast.org/) of the consensus sequences of contigs of our assemblies against the NCBI nonredundant protein database (nr; downloaded March 2011 and updated through November 2011). We used an E-value cut-off of 10⁻⁴, and only the top 10 matches were considered. For toxin identification, hit descriptions were searched for a set of keywords based on known snake-venom toxins and protein classes. Any sequence matching these keywords was checked for a full-length coding sequence. We generally only retained transcripts with full-length coding sequences (but see below). For the iterative assembly approach, the remaining, presumably nontoxin-encoding, contigs were screened for those whose match lengths were at least 90% of the length of at least one of their database matches. This step was intended to minimize the number of fragmented or partial sequences that were considered for annotation. In addition, we sorted the contigs of the three 20-million-sequence NGen assemblies from the all-at-once approach on the basis of the number of reads and attempted to annotate the top 500 contigs from one assembly and the top 100 from the other two.

We estimated transcript abundances using high-stringency reference-based assemblies in NGen3.1 with a minimum match percentage of 95. Ten million of the merged reads were mapped onto the full-length, annotated transcripts, and the percentage of reads mapping to each transcript was used as a proxy for abundance.

The extender

The purpose of Extender is to estimate quickly one or more full-length transcript sequences from a large number of high-quality sequence reads. The procedure begins with one or more seed sequences provided by the user. The seeds can be known sequences (e.g., partial transcripts from a previous assembly) or simply sequences of one or more of the reads. The Extender procedure begins by hashing the k-mers observed at the two ends of the seeds. If k is set to 50, for example, then the 50-base sequence present at the 5’ end of each seed is used as a key in a hash table, and the hash value is a pointer to the seed in the list of seeds. A second hash table is likewise used for k-mers from the 3’ ends of the seeds. Note that this method requires that all initial k-mers be unique (that no two sequence ends be identical). Once the seeds are hashed, the seeds are extended with the set of reads provided by the user as follows. The two k-mers from the ends of each read are looked up in each hash table. If the key is present in the hash table, the seed is extended by concatenation of the nonoverlapping bases from the read onto the appropriate end of the seed. If the key is absent, the reverse complement of the read is used to extend the seed if the end k-mers are found. After each extension, the k-mer key facilitating the extension is removed from the hash table and the new k-mer key is added (the reference to the seed remains the same). The procedure is repeated until the reads have been cycled through N times, where N is chosen by the user. Cycling is beneficial because the Extender does not reset to the beginning of the read list when an extension is made.

Extension of a seed typically terminates when the end of the full-length transcript is reached or when a sequencing error is encountered in the end of an incorporated read. The presence of low-frequency biological artifacts (e.g., unspliced introns) may also result in termination of the extension. In order to improve the accuracy of the consensus sequence prediction, Extender can create replicate seeds for a particular seed by sequentially trimming one base at a time from both ends. Using replicate seeds allows several independent sequences that represent the same target consensus sequence to be generated simultaneously, and these replicates are entirely independent because they begin with different keys. The user can obtain the final estimate of the sequence corresponding to each original seed by taking the consensus across replicates or by simply choosing the replicate producing the longest sequence. We took the former approach for all of our assembly efforts. Overall, Extender is highly inefficient with its use of data and requires many long, high-quality reads, but it is extremely computationally efficient, having short run times and low memory requirements.

We used Extender in two different ways: to complete partial toxin transcripts and as a de novo assembler. For the former, we used partial toxin transcripts from NGen assemblies that were found to have fragments of coding sequence homologous with known toxins. The partial transcripts were trimmed to just the partial coding sequence and used as seeds. To use Extender as a de novo assembler, we seeded it with 1,000 random reads. For both applications, we used a k-mer size of 100, 20 replicates, 10 cycles through the complete set of merged reads excluding all reads with any bases with quality scores less than 30.