Pathways of aging: comparative analysis of gene signatures in replicative senescence and stress induced premature senescence
BMC Genomics volume 17, Article number: 1030 (2016)
In culturing normal diploid cells, senescence may either happen naturally, in the form of replicative senescence, or it may be a consequence of external challenges such as oxidative stress. Here we present a comparative analysis aimed at reconstruction of molecular cascades specific for replicative (RS) and stressinduced senescence (SIPS) in human fibroblasts.
An involvement of caspase-3/keratin-18 pathway and serine/threonine kinase Aurora A/ MDM2 pathway was shared between RS and SIPS. Moreover, stromelysin/MMP3 and N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase enzyme MGAT1, which initiates the synthesis of hybrid and complex Nglycans, were identified as key orchestrating components in RS and SIPS, respectively. In RS only, Aurora-B driven cell cycle signaling was deregulated in concert with the suppression of anabolic branches of the fatty acids and estrogen metabolism. In SIPS, Aurora-B signaling is deprioritized, and the synthetic branches of cholesterol metabolism are upregulated, rather than downregulated. Moreover, in SIPS, proteasome/ubiquitin ligase pathways of protein degradation dominate the regulatory landscape. This picture indicates that SIPS proceeds in cells that are actively fighting stress which facilitates premature senescence while failing to completely activate the orderly program of RS. The promoters of genes differentially expressed in either RS or SIPS are unusually enriched by the binding sites for homeobox family proteins, with particular emphasis on HMX1, IRX2, HDX and HOXC13. Additionally, we identified Iroquois Homeobox 2 (IRX2) as a master regulator for the secretion of SPP1-encoded osteopontin, a stromal driver for tumor growth that is overexpressed by both RS and SIPS fibroblasts. The latter supports the hypothesis that senescence-specific de-repression of SPP1 aids in SIPS-dependent stromal activation.
Reanalysis of previously published experimental data is cost-effective approach for extraction of additional insignts into the functioning of biological systems.
All biological organisms share a universal feature called aging. In multicellular organisms, the major consequence of aging is a functional deficiency of cells, tissues and organs. Additionally, renewable cells and tissues display deficits in regenerative capacities that are paralleled by an increase in incidence of hyperplasia, a gain-of-functional change that allow cells to proliferate inappropriately . The most serious type of hyperplasia is known as cancer.
In order to understand the aging process, model experiments are of crucial importance. Majority of well-known cellular models were developed at the time of the boom in cell and tissue culturing, providing a trove of important insights into cellular physiology. In particular, one of the pioneers in cell culture, Leonard Hayflick, showed that normal, non-transformed cells in culture can go through a limited number of divisions upon reaching the end of their replicative life span . This finite number of divisions has been termed as the Hayflick limit.
Over the decades, it was discovered that proliferating cells reach the Hayflick limit largely because repeated DNA replication in the absence of telomerase causes telomeres to shorten and eventually affect chromosomal stability and genome functioning . The cells undergoing replicative senescence (RS) became enlarged in size and demonstrate systemic changes in expression level of many genes. The entry into the senescent state is mediated by at least two distinct signaling cascades linked to the activation of two tumor suppressing proteins, the p53/ p21 and p16INK4a/pRB pathways . On the other side, cells exposed to various concentrations of different DNA damaging agents such as bleomycin, tert-butylhydroperoxide, hydrogen peroxide or doses of UV A and UV B also become post-mitotic and display signs of senescence. Latter phenomenon is termed as stress induced premature senescence (SIPS) . The expression levels of many genes are changed during SIPS. It is believed that cellular and molecular mechanisms promoting an entry into senescence also provide protection against tumor formation [6, 7]. Identification and understanding the differences between RS and SIPS senescence is critical for the development of anti-aging strategies that do not induce tumorigenesis.
The main purpose behind this study was to identify the differentially expressed genes DEGs) that distinguish the processes of replicative and stress induced senescence and to reconstruct relevant molecular cascades. To this end, we employed bioinformatics software platform GeneXplain that allowed both upstream and downstream analysis of DEGs validated by three-way comparisons of each type of senescent cells against the young cells (control group) and against each other. In both types of senescence, master regulators genes were identified. We also identified Iroquois Homeobox 2 (IRX2) as the master regulators for an expression of SPP1-encoded osteopontin, a secreted stromal driver for tumor growth that is overexpressed by both RS and SIPS fibroblasts.
Microarray data, differential expression analysis
To investigate both types of senescence, publicly available dataset GSE13330 was downloaded from Gene Expression Omnibus (NCBI, Bethesda, MD, USA). This dataset is comprised of 16 samples profiled using Affymetrix Human Genome U133 Plus 2.0 Array. In this dataset, replicative-senescent human foreskin BJ fibroblasts and young fibroblast controls were assayed in 6 biological replicates each. An induction of cell senescence by stress was performed with 100ug/ml of bleomycin sulfate, and analyzed in four biological replicates .
Raw data of stress induced and replicative senescence as well as data on younger control cells were normalized and background corrected using RMA (Robust Multi-Array Average). The Limma (Linear Models for Microarray Data) method [9, 10] was applied to define fold changes of genes and to calculate adjusted p-values using a Benjamini-Hochberg adjusted p-value cutoff (.05). The up regulated genes were filtered using the filter: logFC > 0.5 && adj_P_Val < 0.05. Down regulated genes were filtered using the filter: logFC < −0.5 && adj_P_Val < 0.05.
Functional enrichment analysis
DEGs were analyzed using geneXplain bioinformatics software platform (http://www.genexplain.com). Using the workflows in geneXplain framework, the sets of up and down regulated genes for both SIPS and RS were mapped to various gene ontologies, i.e. biological processes, cellular components, molecular functions, reactome pathways, TRANSPATH®  pathways and transcription factor classification.
The output links each gene to GO identifiers that are, in turn, are hyperlinked to the page http://www.ebi.ac.uk/QuickGO with information about this ontological term. Ontological classification evaluates statistical significance for each term; the resultant p-values were used for further interpretation of the results.
The sets of up- and down-regulated genes identified in each comparison were subjected to the promoter analysis using TRANSFAC  database of position weight matrices (PWMs) characteristic for vertebrate genomes (vertebrate_non_redundant_minSUM database subdivision). Each promoter was defined as the sequence within −1000 to +100 coordinates, where the TSS of the main transcript of each gene was the point 0.
The TFBS search on promoter sequences was done using the MATCH algorithm [13, 14] integrated in the GeneXplain platform and executed within the pre-defined workflows. The promoter sequences and annotations of TSS positions were accordinh to the Ensembl database (version hg19 build 72.37).
Identification of master regulators
Lists of DEGs upregulated in each of cell senescence types were used as inputs in a search for master regulatory key molecules that influence the senescence pathways . The search was performed in the TRANSPATH® database networks with a maximum radius of 10 steps upstream of an input gene set, a default cut-off score at 0.2, and for FDR at 0.05 and Z-score at 1.0.
Pathway studio -guided analysis of ospeopontin regulation
To construct a concise network that bridges senescence regulators highlighted by GeneXPlain–guided analysis of DEGs, we used the Pathway Studio software (Elsevier, Rockville, MD) that is able to dynamically create and draw protein interaction networks and pathways. Each node represents either a molecular entity or a control mechanism of the interaction. In this study, we the shortest path analysis function was utilized predominantly.
Extraction of gene signatures important in replicative and stress-induced cell senescence was performed using public 16-sample dataset GSE13330 previously described in . We divided the study in two parts. First, we analyzed signaling events that are shared in both RS and SIPS. Second, we identified DEGs and respective signaling events uniquely describing each type of senescence.
To dissect the differences between RS and SIPS, 1) six biological replicates of replicative senescent fibroblasts were compared to six biological replicates of young fibroblasts and yielded 1994 downregulated and 2818 upregulated mRNAs; 2) four biological replicates of bleomycin induced senescent fibroblasts were compared to six replicates of young fibroblast cultures (3082 downregulated and 2768 upregulated mRNAs); 3) six biological replicates of replicative senescent fibroblasts were compared to four biological replicates of bleomycin induced senescent fibroblasts (2724 downregulated and 1628 upregulated mRNAs). Each list of DEGs was divided into up- and downregulated sections. A comparison of the three DEG lists that resulted from comparisons described above have identified 524 shared between RS and SIPS (Fig. 1a and b for downregulated (N = 248) and upregulated (N = 242) genes, respectively). All these mRNAs exhibited a change in expression levels of more than two fold in all three types of the profiled cells.
Genes commonly involved in both bleomycin induced and replicative senescence
A total of 1410 genes were upregulated and a total of 1291 genes were downregulated both in RS and SIPS as compared to younger control fibroblasts. Resultant lists of up- and downregulated genes were subjected to functional analysis separately. Each gene was mapped to GO biological processes, GO cellular components, GO molecular functions, Reactome, HumanCyc, TF classification and the latest TRANSPATH®  available in the geneXplain platform.
Caspase-3/keratin-18 and Aurora A kinase/MDM2 pathways were the most upregulated signaling events commonly dominating regulatory landscapes in both bleomycin-induced and replicative type of senescence (adjusted P-values < 0.009 for each of these signaling events). Concerted upregulation of many enzymes participating in glutamate (ABAT, GCLM, GLS), nucleotide (PNP, NT5E, NAMPT, NMNAT2, AMPD3), polyamine (ABT, ODC1) and choline (EPT1, PLCB4) metabolic branches was also noted (adjusted p-value range of <0.016 to < 0.05 for various fragments of these metabolic cascades) (Table 1).
Among the most downregulated signaling events significantly overrepresented in both bleomycin-induced and replicative type of senescence were GluR/AMPA receptor (GRIA1 isoforms), wnt/beta-catenin (TCF7L2/WNT2) and SDF-1 cascades (adjusted p-value range of <0.026 to < 0.05 for various fragments of these signaling pathways).
Upstream analysis aimed at identifying potential transcription factor binding sites (TFBSs) overrepresented in the promoters of differentially expressed genes commonly deregulated in both types of senescence was performed after filtration of gene expression levels by log fold change (FC) of 1.5 for up-regulated (N = 130 genes) and down-regulated (N = 177) genes, separately. The algorithm for transcription factor binding site (TFBS) enrichment analysis has been described in Kel et al. .
The outputs shown in Additional files 1 and 2 include the matrices of the hits which are over-represented in the Yes track (study set) versus the No track (background set), with only the overrepresented matrices with Yes-No ratio higher than 1 included, and the highest Yes-No ratios reflecting higher degrees of matches enrichment for the respective matrix in the Yes set. Matrix cut-off value were calculated and associated with the P-value score of enrichment as described before [14, 15].
Four homeobox genes, namely IRX2, HMX1, HDH, HOXC13 were binders for Top sites enriched in genes overexpressed in both bleomycin induced and replicative senescence phenotypes, while HOXB13, MAZ, GKLF, GLI, IK, SP1, PLZF, PBX were among transcription factors that preferentially bind to the sites located in genes downregulated both in RS and in SIPS.
Genes uniquely involved in replicative senescence
A total of 1408 genes were upregulated and a total of 703 genes were downregulated in replicative senescence, but not in bleomycin induced senescence as compared to younger control fibroblasts. Functional analysis was performed for the lists of up- and downregulated genes separately, as described before.
The list of the signaling events significantly overrepresented in replicative senescence, but not in bleomycin induced senescence was represented entirely by various fragments of cyclosome regulatory network (adjusted p-values range of <4.1e-5 to < 0.023), with Top overrepresented being Aurora-B cell cycle regulation. The list of most significantly downregulated fragments centered around fatty acid anabolism, with an emphasis on biosynthesis of n-9 MUFAs and PUFAs, cholesterol metabolism and biosynthesis of estrogens (adjusted p-value range of <5.8e-4 to < 0.028).
Upstream analysis aimed at identifying potential TFBSs overrepresented in the promoters of differentially expressed genes uniquely deregulated in replicative senescence was performed after filtration of gene expression levels by log fold change (FC) of 1.5 for up-regulated (N = 1408 genes) and down-regulated (N = 703) genes, separately.
The outputs are shown in Additional files 3 and 4. Interestingly, lists of putative transcription factor candidates for being positive drivers for replicative senescence was very similar to that driving both types of senescence. In particular, homeobox genes IRX2, HMX1, HOXB13, HOXC13 (p-values range of E-39 to < E-25) were among Top positive regulators of replicative senescence. The only non-homeobox positive regulator identified at similar levels of confidence was promyelocytic leukemia zinc finger PLZF (e-31). Transcription factors HOXB13, IRX2, PLZF, HDX, DUXL, CDX2 and CPXH were among these that significantly preferred to bind promoters of genes downregulated in replicative senescence (p-values range of E-23 to < E-12).
Genes uniquely involved in bleomycin-induced senescence
A total of 1358 genes were upregulated and a total of 1791 genes were downregulated in bleomycin induced, but not in replicative senescence as compared to younger control fibroblasts. Functional analysis was performed for the lists of up- and downregulated genes separately, as described before.
The signaling event significantly overrepresented in bleomycin induced, but not in replicative senescence was HMGCR regulation (adjusted p-value <6.5e−5), followed by two cholesterol biosynthesis network fragments (adjusted p-values <0.006 for each event evaluated separately), and a number of events with the participation of proteasome or ubiquitin ligases (adjusted p-values range of < 0.03 for each separate event).
Upstream analysis aimed at identifying potential TFBSs overrepresented in the promoters of differentially expressed genes uniquely up-regulated (N = 1358 genes) and down-regulated (N = 1791) genes in bleomycin-induced senescence was performed similarly to that for the genes deregulated in replicative senescence.
The outputs are shown in Additional files 5 and 6. List of putative transcription factor candidates for genes with increased expression in bleomycin-induced senescence included homeobox genes IRX2, CPHX and HDX as well as other types of transcriptional factors, namely Helios, RelA and HNF3B (p-values range of E-10 to < E-8). A list of transcription factor bindings sites in overrepresented genes downregulated in bleomycin induced senescence were MAZ (E-13) and GKLF (E-12).
Master regulators orchestrating replicative and bleomycin-induced senescence
An analysis of DEGs upregulated in RS and in SIPS identified stromelysin and MGAT1 as master regulator molecules that influence the replicative senescence and bleomycin–induced senescence expression programs, respectively.
Bridging senescence regulators to ospeopontin secretion
In their previous publication, Pazolli et al.  identified SPP1-encoded osteopontin as a secreted driver for tumor cells growth that is provided by senescent fibroblast. To understand how senescence-wide targets highlighted by microarray analysis of senescent fibroblasts results in an increase in osteopontin secretion, a concise network was constructed using Shortest Path function in Pathway Studio software (Fig. 2). Iroquois Homeobox 2 (IRX2) and POU4F1 were highlighted as most plausible connecting signaling molecules.
Over past decade, transcriptome profiling efforts that employ either microarray or RNAseq have already generated enormous amounts of data, with respective data analysis often only scratching the surface [16, 17]. In many cases, high-quality datasets are generated to investigate specific hypothesis, and consequently, these datasets get analyzed in a particular way. At least in theory, the study design of these narrow-set, but technically sound experiments should allow extraction of additional information that could remain unrecovered at the moment that the main manuscript gets sent to the publishers .
In their 2009 paper, Pazolli et al. started to investigate the mechanisms of the manner in which senescent BJ fibroblasts stimulate the growth of preneoplastic cells in vitro and in vivo . In their experiments, replicative senescent (RS) and stress-induced premature senescent (SIPS) fibroblasts were equally proficient at inducing the growth of HaCaT cells. Their study of fibroblasts/HaCaT xenografts in vivo arrived essentially at same results . The authors subsequently hypothesized that growth-promoting activities of both types of senescent cells are maintained by a common core of genes. Based on that hypothesis, they embarked on microarray-driven dissection of secreted factors commonly produced by RS and SIPS fibroblasts. After a set of validation experiments in qRT-PCR and in-cell cultures, soluble protein osteopontin was highlighted as the protein of functional importance, and its gene, SPP1, was identified as a master regulator of a cancer niche environment . An objective of the study achieved; however, the microarray dataset never got analyzed in larger context, i.e. for the purpose of direct comparison between RS and SIPS drivers.
In this study, we used the dataset of Pazolli et al., 2009 to extract the differentially expressed genes (DEGs) that differentiate the processes of RS and SIPS, to reconstruct relevant molecular cascades and to gain additional insights into popular cellular model of bleomycin induced senescence. Analysis of signaling events indicated that an involvement of caspase-3/keratin-18 pathway that is indicative of apoptotic rather than necrotic cell death  and an evolutionarily conserved serine/threonine kinase Aurora A/ MDM2 pathway essential for mitotic progression  was shared between both types of senescence. Observed upregulation of Aurora A is consistent with previously demonstrated increase in a number of aneuploid cells observed in ageing fibroblast cultures . Our analysis also highlighted concerted alteration of glutamate, polyamine and choline metabolisms as well as wnt/β-catenin and SDF-1/CXCL12 cascades. All these findings are generally consistent with previous studies of various ageing fibroblasts both in culture and in human cohorts [22–24]. This consistency prompts us to stress on the high quality of the dataset of Pazolli et al., 2009 being analyzed.
An analysis aimed at identifying master regulator molecules that influence the replicative senescence and bleomycin–induced senescence expression programs, pointed at stromelysin/MMP3 and N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase enzyme MGAT1 that initiates the synthesis of hybrid and complex N-glycans as key orchestrating components in replicative senescence and in bleomycin-induced senescence, respectively (Fig. 2 and Additional file 7). Traditionally, MMP3 is seen as end-point biomarker or effector molecule associated with ageing in fibroblasts. However, in Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome, there is a progressive loss of MMP3 mRNA and protein expression . Another study linked carrier status for MMP3 6A (rs3025058) allele to skin and lung aging . Moreover, an exposure to MMP3 stimulates expression of Rac1b, a tumor-associated protein with cell-transforming properties that aids in bypassing replicative senescence  while driving motility and protumorigenic responses of the stroma . Hence, there is an accumulation of evidence that stresses on an importance of MMP3 as a molecule of importance in replicative senescence that deserves additional investigations. An identification of MGAT1 that controls the synthesis the complex N-glycan sugars in the Golgi as the key regulator of SIPS is even more intriguing as there is strong associations between human plasma N-glycans and age [29, 30].
Specific question that we aimed to dissect was on the differences of the senescence programs executed in SIPS and RS. Indeed, our analysis showed that in RS fibroblasts, the list Top deregulated events is populated by fragments of Aurora-B driven cell cycle signaling that are accompanied by the suppression of anabolic branches of the fatty acids and estrogen metabolism. This may be interpreted as an execution of ordered senescence program that proceeds along with shutting down the metabolism on a way to the halt of mitotic progression and apoptosis that is being upregulated in both RS and SIPS. On the other end, in bleomycin exposed fibroblasts, Aurora-B signaling is deprioritized and the synthetic branches of cholesterol metabolism are upregulated, rather than downregulated, while proteasome/ ubiquitin ligase pathways of protein degradation are dominating the regulatory landscape. This picture is indicative that the cells are going down actively fighting overwhelming amounts of stress that is facilitating premature senescence of cells, but fail to completely activate orderly program of replicative senescence. Latter observation is consistent with activation of 26S proteasome and enhanced protein polyubiquitination previously observed in both idiopathic and bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis . Generalized mechanistic depiction of cellular processes common and differentiating RA and SIPS is presented at Fig. 2.
The list of the transcription factors capable of binding within the promoter regions of the genes that change their expression in either RS or SIPS was unusually enriched by the members of homeobox family, with particular emphasis on HMX1, IRX2, HDX and HOXC13. The possibility of an involvement of homeobox genes in ageing has been proposed earlier , with many homeobox containing TFs included in manually curated GenAge reference database . Our findings indicate that the senescent program may be orchestrated by transcription factors (TFs) of Homeobox family at least in case of replicative senescence in vitro. On the other hand, promoters of genes that change their expression in bleomycin-induced senescence but not in replicatively senescent fibroblasts were enriched by binding sites for transcription factors Ikaros, RelA, HNF3B, GKLF and MAZ. Both RelA and GKLF are known stress-induced transcription regulators. RelA is the central player in the classical (or canonical) pathway of induction of NF-κB subunits that promotes senescence when activated in human lung fibroblasts exposed to ROS . GKLF-deficient fibroblasts exposed to excessive levels of reactive oxygen species are more prone to become prematurely senescent than normal fibroblasts . Moreover, yet another transcription factor, HNF3B/FOXA2 is epigenetically silenced in peroxide-stressed fibroblasts , therefore, an enrichment for binding sites for this factor in transcripts downregulated in bleomycin induced senescence is not surprising.
SPP1-encoded osteopontin, a secreted stromal driver for tumor growth, is overexpressed by both RS and SIPS fibroblasts . Concise network constructed using Shortest Path function in Pathway Studio software (Fig. 3) highlighted Iroquois Homeobox 2 (IRX2) and POU4F1 were highlighted as most likely signaling events to connect the DEGs identified by GeneXPlain-guided microarray analysis and osteopontin. In this network, suppression of Aurora kinases that normally monitor the mitotic checkpoint, centrosome separation and cytokinesis, cause catastrophic consequences and result in increase in apoptosis, thus, being in in agreement with recently published observations of senescent fibroblasts . Apoptosis activated caspase-3 directly or indirectly eliminates POU4F1/Brn-3a, the prediction that is consistent with previous observation of enhanced apoptosis in the neurons derived from Brn-3a knockout mice . Moreover, POU4F1 gene is expressed in fibroblasts where it is required for proliferation, and cooperates with activated RAS/RAF signalling by reducing oncogene-induced senescence, consistent with its caspase-driven downregulation in both RS and SIPS . In our network, POU4F1/Brn-3a suppresses transcription factor IRX2 that repeatedly showed up in lists of TF that recognize bindings sites differentially enriched in promoters of genes associated with fibroblast senescence. Caspase-3-driven removal of POU4F1 allows higher levels of IRX2 biosynthesis that is known for its ability to upregulate VEGF, metalloproteinases and other secreted molecules [40, 41].
An involvement of IRX2 in the transcription of osteopontin-encoding SPP1 gene was never evaluated in wet lab experiments; however, the knowledge-based algorithm identified IRX2 as positive regulator of SPP1 expression by three independent molecular interaction events involving AKT1, VEGFA and INS. Moreover, marker co-expression pattern of IRX2 and SPP1 was observed during hair-cell development in the chick’s cochlea . Two independent studies demonstrated that an expression of IRX2 is commonly suppressed by DNA methylation of its promoter [43, 44], including its differential methylation noted in osteoarthritis and osteoporosis , two age-related diseases of the cartilage and the bone charactrized by changes in the levels of osteopontin secretion [46, 47]. As IRX2 is strongly expression in human primary osteoblasts of the skeleton , its putative roles in SPP1 regulation in osteoarthritis and osteoporosis are worthy of investigation.
Importanttly, Pazolli and co-authors followed up on their own study that identified osteopontin as driver of tumor cell proliferation supplied by senescent stromal fibroblasts  and showed that the treatment with histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors that reverse CpG methylation is sufficient to induce expression of osteopontin . Moreover, an examination of PWM matches in the promoter of SPP1 showed that it contains 25 sites for IRX2 binding within 1100 nucleotides located between positions −1000 to +100 relative to major transcription start site (TSS) for SPP1 gene (Additional file 8).
All this evidence adds up in favor of the hypothesis that SPP1/osteopontin expression may be controlled by IRX2, and that its derepression in senescent fibroblast aids in SIPS-dependent stromal activation that, in turn, stimulate the growth of tumor cells.
Here we present a detailed comparison of stress/bleomycin induced and replicative senescence. We predicted the master regulatory molecules and transcription factors which play a key role in these two types of cell senescence, RS and SIPS. We showed that SIPS proceeds in cells that are actively fighting stress which facilitates premature senescence while failing to completely activate the orderly program of RS. Stromelysin/MMP3 and MGAT1 were identified as master regulators of RS and SIPS, respectively. We also demonstrated that promoters of genes differentially expressed in either RS or SIPS are unusually enriched by the binding sites for homeobox family proteins. Moreover, Iroquois Homeobox 2 (IRX2) was highlighted as a master regulator for the secretion of SPP1-encoded osteopontin, a stromal driver for tumor growth that is overexpressed by both RS and SIPS fibroblasts. The latter supports the hypothesis that senescence-specific de-repression of SPP1 aids in SIPS-dependent stromal activation.
Santos Franco S, Raveh-Amit H, Kobolák J, Alqahtani MH, Mobasheri A, Dinnyes A. The crossroads between cancer stem cells and aging. BMC Cancer. 2015;15 Suppl 1:S1.
Hayflick L. The limited in vitro lifetime of human diploid cell strains. Exp Cell Res. 1965;37:614–36.
Shay JW, Wright WE. Hayflick, his limit, and cellular ageing. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2000;1(1):72–6.
Salama R, Sadaie M, Hoare M, Narita M. Cellular senescence and its effector programs. Genes Dev. 2014;28(2):99–114.
Toussaint O, Royer V, Salmon M, Remacle J. Stress-induced premature senescence and tissue ageing. Biochem Pharmacol. 2002;64(5–6):1007–9.
Campisi J. Cellular senescence as tumor-suppressor mechanism. Trends Cell Biol. 2001;11:27–31.
Campisi J. Senescent cells, tumor suppression and organismal aging. Good citizens, bad neighbors. Cell. 2005;120:513–22.
Pazolli E, Luo X, Brehm S, Carbery K, et al. Senescent stromal-derived osteopontin promotes preneoplastic cell growth. Cancer Res. 2009;69(3):1230–9.
Wettenhall JM, Smyth GK. limmaGUI: a graphical user interface for linear modeling of microarray data. Bioinformatics. 2004;20(18):3705–6.
Gentleman R, Carey V, Dudoit S, Irizarry R, Huber W, editors. Computational Biology Solutions using R and Bioconductor. New York: Springer; 2005.
Krull M, Pistor S, Voss N, Kel A, Reuter I, Kronenberg D, Michael H, Schwarzer K, Potapov A, Choi C, Kel-Margoulis O, Wingender E. TRANSPATH: an information resource for storing and visualizing signaling pathways and their pathological aberrations. Nucleic Acids Res. 2006;34 (Database issue):D546–51.
Matys V, Kel-Margoulis OV, Fricke E, Liebich I, Land S, Barre-Dirrie A, Reuter I, Chekmenev D, Krull M, Hornischer K, Voss N, Stegmaier P, Lewicki-Potapov B, Saxel H, Kel AE, Wingender E. TRANSFAC and its module TRANSCompel: transcriptional gene regulation in eukaryotes. Nucleic Acids Res. 2006;34(Database issue):D108–10.
Kel A, Voss N, Jauregui R, Kel-Margoulis O, Wingender E. Beyond microarrays: find key transcription factors controlling signal transduction pathways. BMC Bioinformatics. 2006;7 Suppl 2:S13.
Kel AE, Gössling E, Reuter I, Cheremushkin E, Kel-Margoulis OV, Wingender E. MATCH: a tool for searching transcription factor binding sites in DNA sequences. Nucleic Acids Res. 2003;31(13):3576–9.
Stepanova M, Tiazhelova T, Skoblov M, Baranova A. A comparative analysis of relative occurrence of transcription factor binding sites in vertebrate genomes and gene promoter areas. Bioinformatics. 2005;21(9):1789–96.
Cahan P, Rovegno F, Mooney D, Newman JC, St Laurent 3rd G, McCaffrey TA. Meta-analysis of microarray results: challenges, opportunities, and recommendations for standardization. Gene. 2007;401(1–2):12–8.
Yang IS, Kim S. Analysis of whole transcriptome sequencing data: workflow and software. Genomics Inform. 2015;13(4):119–25.
Piwowar HA, Day RS, Fridsma DB. Sharing detailed research data is associated with increased citation rate. PLoS One. 2007;2(3):e308.
Yilmaz Y. Systematic review: caspase-cleaved fragments of cytokeratin 18 – the promises and challenges of a biomarker for chronic liver disease. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2009;30(11–12):1103–9.
Shagisultanova E, Dunbrack Jr RL, Golemis EA. Issues in interpreting the in vivo activity of Aurora-A. Expert Opin Ther Targets. 2015;19(2):187–200.
Geigl JB, Langer S, Barwisch S, Pfleghaar K, Lederer G, Speicher MR. Analysis of gene expression patterns and chromosomal changes associated with aging. Cancer Res. 2004;64(23):8550–7.
Dekker P, Gunn D, McBryan T, Dirks RW, van Heemst D, Lim FL, Jochemsen AG, Verlaan-de Vries M, Nagel J, Adams PD, Tanke HJ, Westendorp RG, Maier AB. Microarray-based identification of age-dependent differences in gene expression of human dermal fibroblasts. Mech Ageing Dev. 2012;133(7):498–507.
Begley L, Monteleon C, Shah RB, Macdonald JW, Macoska JA. CXCL12 overexpression and secretion by aging fibroblasts enhance human prostate epithelial proliferation in vitro. Aging Cell. 2005;4(6):291–8.
Hoffmeyer K, Raggioli A, Rudloff S, Anton R, Hierholzer A, Del Valle I, Hein K, Vogt R, Kemler R. Wnt/β-catenin signaling regulates telomerase in stem cells and cancer cells. Science. 2012;336(6088):1549–54.
Harten IA, Zahr RS, Lemire JM, Machan JT, Moses MA, Doiron RJ, Curatolo AS, Rothman FG, Wight TN, Toole BP, Gordon LB. Age-dependent loss of MMP-3 in Hutchinson-Gilford progeria syndrome. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2011;66(11):1201–7.
Vierkötter A, Schikowski T, Sugiri D, Matsui MS, Krämer U, Krutmann J. MMP-1 and −3 promoter variants are indicative of a common susceptibility for skin and lung aging: results from a cohort of elderly women (SALIA). J Invest Dermatol. 2015;135(5):1268–74.
Stallings-Mann ML, Waldmann J, Zhang Y, Miller E, Gauthier ML, Visscher DW, Downey GP, Radisky ES, Fields AP, Radisky DC. Matrix metalloproteinase induction of Rac1b, a key effector of lung cancer progression. Sci Transl Med. 2012;4(142):142ra95.
Mehner C, Miller E, Khauv D, Nassar A, Oberg AL, Bamlet WR, Zhang L, Waldmann J, Radisky ES, Crawford HC, Radisky DC. Tumor cell-derived MMP3 orchestrates Rac1b and tissue alterations that promote pancreatic adenocarcinoma. Mol Cancer Res. 2014;12(10):1430–9.
Ding N, Nie H, Sun X, Sun W, Qu Y, Liu X, Yao Y, Liang X, Chen CC, Li Y. Human serum N-glycan profiles are age and sex dependent. Age Ageing. 2011;40(5):568–75.
Vanhooren V, Dewaele S, Libert C, Engelborghs S, De Deyn PP, Toussaint O, Debacq-Chainiaux F, Poulain M, Glupczynski Y, Franceschi C, Jaspers K, van der Pluijm I, Hoeijmakers J, Chen CC. Serum N-glycan profile shift during human ageing. Exp Gerontol. 2010;45(10):738–43.
Semren N, Welk V, Korfei M, Keller IE, Fernandez IE, Adler H, Günther A, Eickelberg O, Meiners S. Regulation of 26S Proteasome activity in pulmonary fibrosis. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2015;192(9):1089–101.
Venkataraman K, Futerman AH. Do longevity assurance genes containing Hox domains regulate cell development via ceramide synthesis? FEBS Lett. 2002;528(1–3):3–4.
Tacutu R, Craig T, Budovsky A, Wuttke D, Lehmann G, Taranukha D, Costa J, Fraifeld VE, de Magalhães JP. Human ageing genomic resources: integrated databases and tools for the biology and genetics of ageing. Nucleic Acids Res. 2013;41(Database issue):D1027–33.
Sfikas A, Batsi C, Tselikou E, Vartholomatos G, Monokrousos N, Pappas P, Christoforidis S, Tzavaras T, Kanavaros P, Gorgoulis VG, Marcu KB, Kolettas E. The canonical NF-κB pathway differentially protects normal and human tumor cells from ROS-induced DNA damage. Cell Signal. 2012;24(11):2007–23.
Liu C, La Rosa S, Hagos EG. Oxidative DNA damage causes premature senescence in mouse embryonic fibroblasts deficient for Krüppel-like factor 4. Mol Carcinog. 2015;54(9):889–99.
Zhang W, Ji W, Yang L, Yao L, Wang G, Xuan A, Zhuang Z. The involvement of epigenetic silencing of Foxa2 in cellular replicative and premature senescence induced by hydrogen peroxide. Free Radic Res. 2013;47(4):325–32.
Sadaie M, Dillon C, Narita M, Young AR, Cairney CJ, Godwin LS, Torrance CJ, Bennett DC, Keith WN, Narita M. Cell-based screen for altered nuclear phenotypes reveals senescence progression in polyploid cells after Aurora kinase B inhibition. Mol Biol Cell. 2015;26(17):2971–85.
McEvilly RJ, Erkman L, Luo L, Sawchenko PE, Ryan AF, Rosenfeld MG. Requirement for Brn-3.0 in differentiation and survival of sensory and motor neurons. Nature. 1996;384(6609):574–7.
Hohenauer T, Berking C, Schmidt A, Haferkamp S, Senft D, Kammerbauer C, Fraschka S, Graf SA, Irmler M, Beckers J, Flaig M, Aigner A, Höbel S, Hoffmann F, Hermeking H, Rothenfusser S, Endres S, Ruzicka T, Besch R. The neural crest transcription factor Brn3a is expressed in melanoma and required for cell cycle progression and survival. EMBO Mol Med. 2013;5(6):919–34.
Liu T, Zhou W, Cai B, Chu J, Shi G, Teng H, Xu J, Xiao J, Wang Y. IRX2-mediated upregulation of MMP-9 and VEGF in a PI3K/AKT-dependent manner. Mol Med Rep. 2015;12(3):4346–51.
Liu T, Zhou W, Zhang F, Shi G, Teng H, Xiao J, Wang Y. Knockdown of IRX2 inhibits osteosarcoma cell proliferation and invasion by the AKT/MMP9 signaling pathway. Mol Med Rep. 2014;10(1):169–74.
Kowalik L, Hudspeth AJ. A search for factors specifying tonotopy implicates DNER in hair-cell development in the chick’s cochlea. Dev Biol. 2011;354(2):221–31.
Faryna M, Konermann C, Aulmann S, Bermejo JL, Brugger M, Diederichs S, Rom J, Weichenhan D, Claus R, Rehli M, Schirmacher P, Sinn HP, Plass C, Gerhauser C. Genome-wide methylation screen in low-grade breast cancer identifies novel epigenetically altered genes as potential biomarkers for tumor diagnosis. FASEB J. 2012;26(12):4937–50.
Kitchen MO, Bryan RT, Emes RD, Glossop JR, Luscombe C, Cheng KK, Zeegers MP, James ND, Devall AJ, Mein CA, Gommersall L, Fryer AA, Farrell WE. Quantitative genome-wide methylation analysis of high-grade non-muscle invasive bladder cancer. Epigenetics. 2016;11(3):237–46.
Delgado-Calle J, Fernández AF, Sainz J, Zarrabeitia MT, Sañudo C, García-Renedo R, Pérez-Núñez MI, García-Ibarbia C, Fraga MF, Riancho JA. Genome-wide profiling of bone reveals differentially methylated regions in osteoporosis and osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 2013;65(1):197–205.
Gravallese EM. Osteopontin: a bridge between bone and the immune system. J Clin Invest. 2003;112(2):147–9.
Jiang SS, Chen CH, Tseng KY, Tsai FY, Wang MJ, Chang IS, Lin JL, Lin S. Gene expression profiling suggests a pathological role of human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells in aging-related skeletal diseases. Aging (Albany NY). 2011;3(7):672–84.
Hsu YH, Zillikens MC, Wilson SG, Farber CR, Demissie S, Soranzo N, Bianchi EN, Grundberg E, Liang L, Richards JB, Estrada K, Zhou Y, van Nas A, Moffatt MF, Zhai G, Hofman A, van Meurs JB, Pols HA, Price RI, Nilsson O, Pastinen T, Cupples LA, Lusis AJ, Schadt EE, Ferrari S, Uitterlinden AG, Rivadeneira F, Spector TD, Karasik D, Kiel DP. An integration of genome-wide association study and gene expression profiling to prioritize the discovery of novel susceptibility loci for osteoporosis-related traits. PLoS Genet. 2010;6(6):e1000977.
Pazolli E, Alspach E, Milczarek A, Prior J, Piwnica-Worms D, Stewart SA. Chromatin remodeling underlies the senescence-associated secretory phenotype of tumor stromal fibroblasts that supports cancer progression. Cancer Res. 2012;72(9):2251–61.
The authors wish to gratefully acknowledge unwavering support of graduate research programs at CoS, GMU and the proofreading by Jerome Glasser.
This article has been published as part of BMC Genetics Vol 17 Suppl 14, 2016: Selected articles from BGRS\SB-2016: genomics. The full contents of the supplement are available online at http://bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/supplements/volume-17-supplement-14.
This study was supported by Ministry of Science and Education, Russia (Project no. RFMEFI60714X0098). The publication of this manuscript was covered by College of Science, George Mason University and Open Access Publishing Fund.
Availability of data and material
Study concept and design: AB. Data analysis: KK, NT, MS, OKM, AB. Drafting manuscript: KK, AB. Revising article critically for important intellectual content: KK, NT, MS, OKM, AB. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Transcription Factor Binding Sites within upstream regions of genes up-regulated in both types of senescence with log Fold Change > 2.0. (DOCX 23 kb)
Transcription Factor Binding Sites within upstream regions of genes down-regulated in both types of senescence with log Fold Change > 2.0. (DOCX 19 kb)
Transcription Factor Binding Sites within upstream regions of genes up-regulated in replicative senescence with log Fold Change > 1.5. (DOCX 27 kb)
Transcription Factor Binding Sites within upstream regions of genes down-regulated in replicative senescence with log Fold Change > 1.5. (DOCX 22 kb)
Transcription Factor Binding Sites within upstream regions of genes up-regulated in bleomycin induced senescence with log Fold Change > 1.5. (DOCX 24 kb)
Transcription Factor Binding Sites of Down-regulated genes with log Fold Change < − 1.5 threshold for bleomycin induced cell senescence. (DOCX 21 kb)
Hierarchically compiled output of an analysis for master regulators orchestrating gene expression program executed in SIPS. MGAT1, the master regulator of this network, is highlighted in red, intermediate controllers that are added by GeneXPlain algorithm, a subset of input molecules is highlighted in blue. The intensity of the pink/red bars on a side of the molecule box represents the degree of overexpression for respective genes. (PNG 669 kb)
IRX2 binding sites in the promoter of SPP1. (DOCX 180 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Kural, K.C., Tandon, N., Skoblov, M. et al. Pathways of aging: comparative analysis of gene signatures in replicative senescence and stress induced premature senescence. BMC Genomics 17 (Suppl 14), 1030 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-016-3352-4