MicroRNA expression patterns in post-natal mouse skeletal muscle development

Skeletal muscle development (myogenesis) and homeostasis are regulated by a continuum of external and internal cell signals that activate or repress gene expression. These processes are fine-tuned by the joint action of transcription factors [1, 2], DNA methylation [3, 4], histone modification [5] and non-coding RNAs that include micro (miRNAs) and long (lncRNAs) forms [6, 7]. The role of lncRNAs has been scarcely described when compared to miRNAs; the latter playing an essential part in the control of cellular processes via transcriptional regulation [8–12].

Our study is focussed on miRNAs, which are small 20–24 nucleotide non-coding RNA molecules. In miRNA nomenclature, the species is denominated by the first 3 letters of the miRNA; where hsa defines a human miRNA, mmu defines a mouse miRNA and dre defines a zebrafish miRNA. MiRNAs bind to specific sites on the 3’UTR of their target transcripts and repress their translation into a functional protein [13–17]. This repression predominantly occurs by degradation of the target mRNA [15] but also by directly inhibiting protein translation. In some cases, it has been reported that miRNAs also stabilize their target mRNAs [18]. The current estimation is that more than a third of the mRNA pool possesses at least one miRNA target [19]. MiRNAs bind to mRNA 3’UTR regions on the basis of partial or full sequence homology [11, 13] and putative miRNA target sequences can be identified using freely available bioinformatics tools [20–22]. MiRNAs play a major role in the maintenance of skeletal muscle homeostasis in health and disease conditions [23]. Over the last decade, studies in tissue culture and embryogenic models have established that miRNAs are essential regulators of myogenesis. However, the role and regulation of miRNAs during post-natal skeletal muscle development in mammals has not been comprehensively described.

In mice, a rapid 7–8 fold increase in body mass occurs during the first 3 weeks of post-natal life. About half of this increase is due to accretion in skeletal muscle mass [24]. Murine post-natal muscle growth almost exclusively relies on an increase in the size of muscle fibres (hypertrophy) rather than an increase in fibre number, which ceases around birth [25, 26]. Post -natal murine skeletal development consists of 2 main growth phases with a transition around 3 weeks of age, as represented in Fig. 1. In the first 3 weeks, muscle precursor cells (also known as myoblasts or satellite cells) proliferate and fuse with the rapidly elongating myofibres to provide new myonuclei (hyperplasia) (Fig. 1a) [26, 27]. From 3 to 8 weeks of age, rapid hypertrophy results in a 3-fold increase in the myofibre size [26]. This increase in sarcoplasmic volume continues until at least 14 to 28 weeks of age [27]. Early autoradiography studies tracking the in vivo kinetics of myoblast proliferation and fusion in healthy muscles of mice aged 6–8 weeks confirmed that most satellite cells were quiescent at this age [28]. The reason for this striking transition from hyperplasia to hypertrophy during muscle growth is not known and has not been widely investigated in other species (discussed in [29]).

At the molecular level, mammalian myogenesis is a finely regulated process controlled by a series of muscle specific transcription factors known as myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs). The early regulators myogenic differentiation 1 (Myod1) and myogenic factor-5 (Myf5) facilitate the commitment of satellite cells to the myogenic fate, while myogenin (Myog/Myf4) and myogenic factor-6 (Myf6) are essential for muscle cell differentiation and muscle fibre formation [30]. In addition, the paired box transcription factors (Pax3/Pax7) act upstream of Myod1 to regulate the entry of satellite cells into the myogenic programme [31, 32]. MiRNAs play a role in multiple aspects muscle growth [33], including development, metabolism and repair. MRFs are involved in the transcriptional regulation of muscle enriched miRNAs (myomiRs), including miR-1, miR-133 and miR-206, and regulatory feedback loops have been identified between miRNAs and MRFs in muscle cells [26, 34–36]. Recently, our group reported the expression levels of these 3 myomiRs during post-natal muscle growth [12]. Gene expression profiling of post-natal myogenesis recently identified new genes involved in the regulation of satellite cell activation, proliferation and fusion including ephrin-related molecules. These findings suggest that myomiRs and other miRNAs may regulate more targets in skeletal muscle [37].

To date, the expression levels of a large range of miRNAs in post-natal skeletal muscle development in vivo has not been investigated. This study is the first to examine the expression pattern of 768 miRNAs and their putative gene targets and function during post-natal development of the mouse quadriceps muscle, specifically at 2 days as well as 2, 4 and 12 weeks of age.

In this study, we describe for the first time the collective and individual expression patterns of a subset of 768 miRNAs in mouse quadriceps muscle tissue during the first 12 weeks of post-natal life. We report unprecedented changes in the miRNA expression levels over time, supporting the hypothesis that miRNAs play an essential role in the regulation of cellular processes underlying skeletal muscle formation and maturation. Stringent statistical and bioinformatics analysis confirmed the putative role of these miRNAs in the regulation of the proliferation, differentiation and development pathways, mainly via the regulation of gene targets that were not specifically linked to skeletal muscle, but to the development of a variety of tissues. The additional genetic regulation exerted by lncRNAs [12] falls outside the scope of this study.

Over the last 2 decades, miRNAs have emerged as important regulators of molecular processes in cells in general [8–11] and in skeletal muscle in particular [12, 23, 33]. MiRNA detection is commonly achieved using real-time quantitative PCR, with commercially available PCR-based miRNA arrays allowing the simultaneous quantification of hundreds of miRNAs [42, 43]. While a lack of consensus exists around the most suitable normalization strategy for single miRNA PCR analysis [44], the use of PCR-based miRNA arrays allows for the normalization of the individual cycle threshold (Ct) values to the geometric mean of the whole miRNA pool, a process referred to as global normalization [45]. Global normalization rules out the occurrence of false-positive results due to a lack of stability of a single normalization miRNA over different times and conditions. This advantage is particularly relevant in a growth model as extreme as the one used in this study.

MiRNAs can be specifically enriched in certain tissues [46] and myomiR is the term referring to the miRNA species that are highly expressed in skeletal and cardiac muscle [41, 47]. These miRNAs are involved in the regulation of all fundamental biological processes in the muscle, including growth, development, metabolism and repair [33]. MiR-1, miR-133a and miR-206 were amongst the 3 first identified myomiRs, with miR-1 and miR-133a being part of a bicistronic cluster on the same chromosome [36]. Their role in myogenesis has been well described in vitro using gain— and loss-of-function studies. MiR-1, miR-133a and miR-206 are highly conserved between species. Our study respectively reported a 4-fold and 3-fold increase in mmu-miR-1a-3p and mmu-miR-133a-3p expression levels over the first 12 weeks of age. MiR-133a and miR-1 respectively promote myoblast proliferation and differentiation via the repression of Srf and Hdac4 [36]. In contrast, the expression of hsa-miR-206, an indirect activator of Myod1 [48], decreased by 40-fold between birth and 12 weeks of age. Similar to miR-1, miR-206 promotes satellite cell differentiation and suppresses cell proliferation by directly targeting the Pax7 3’UTR [48], suggesting a reduced need to engage stem cells into the myogenic fate during the later stages of muscle growth. This is in line with the in vivo pattern of cessation of satellite cell proliferation and fusion by 3 weeks of age in mice [26].

Beyond the highly expressed myomiRs, we report that 46% of all measured miRNAs were expressed in mouse quadriceps muscle over the first 12 weeks of life. The expression levels of a majority of miRNAs decreased with age, as the incidence and amplitude of many regulative processes become less important. Statistical analysis followed by miRNA clustering allowed the isolation of 2 subsets of miRNAs displaying common expression patterns that were selected for bioinformatics analysis. The predicted expression levels of the members of cluster A were below or close to the 32 Ct limit of detection between 4 and 12 weeks of age. These miRNAs may therefore be involved in the regulation of very early cell processes, and conceivably play an even more important role in pre-natal (foetal and embryonic) muscle formation and growth. Accordingly, cellular development, growth and proliferation were the highest ranked molecular functions returned for cluster A. In contrast, the members of cluster B were consistently expressed from week 4 to week 12 and were strongly linked to organismal development. This suggests that, in addition to the development of the muscle fibre itself, these miRNAs may regulate the development of other cell components in the growing muscle tissue (see Fig. 1). Indeed, it is important to acknowledge that other cell types outside the myofibre contribute to the dynamics of muscle growth. These are associated with neuromuscular function (nerves and Schwann cells), vascularization (endothelium, smooth muscle and bone-marrow derived cells) and formation of the extracellular matrix (ECM), whose components are largely produced by fibroblasts [49]. While skeletal muscle fibres represent about 95% of the volume of muscle tissue, much of this consists of sarcoplasm containing large contractile proteins with relatively sparse myonuclei (see Fig. 1b). Furthermore, the number of nuclei associated with adult myofibres only represent about half of all nuclei present in muscle tissue [50, 51]. The other 50% of nuclei outside the myofibre are within different types of mononucleated cells associated with the nervous and the vascular systems (see Fig. 1b), as well as the interstitial connective tissue containing various cells, including fibroblasts. Although in adult muscle tissue, myofibres are patently the most transcriptionally active cell type [52], the transcriptome activity of muscle tissue includes the combined expression of the myogenic nuclei, plus the various non-myogenic nuclei, in a ratio that may vary with development. Thus, these aspects must be considered when interpreting patterns of gene expression, especially related to miRNAs. Finally, other miRNAs from cluster B have also been significantly associated with muscular disorders in adults, indicating that these miRNAs are presumably more active at the level of the post-natal than the pre-natal developing muscle.

Sparse literature exists around the top-ranked miRNAs identified in this study and their role in the cell proliferation and differentiation processes. Although not selected for bioinformatics analysis in this study, the top-3 miRNAs displaying an increase in expression with age were members of the miR-29 family of miRNAs (mmu-miR-29a, rno-miR-29c# and mmu-miR-29c), supporting the important role played by this miRNA cluster in the myogenesis process. MiR-29a inhibition downregulates MyoD and upregulates cyclin-dependent kinase 6 (Cdk6) expression in C₂C₁₂ myoblasts, therefore delaying cell differentiation [53]. In contrast, miR-29 is upregulated in the muscle of aged when compared to young rodents. Corroborating our findings, miR-29 electroporation into the muscle of young mice suppressed cell proliferation and accelerated aging [54]. Several additional gene targets have been identified for the miR-29 family of miRNAs, including Akt3 [55] and Ring1 and YY1 binding protein (Rybp) [55], a negative regulator of myogenesis. Amongst the top-ranked miRNAs of cluster A, mmu-miR-199a– 5p (homologous to hsa-miR-199a–5p and dre-miR-199a–5p) regulates myogenic differentiation acting downstream of Srf; the latter targets multiple differentiation and proliferation factors within the Wnt signalling pathway. Hsa-miR-199a-5p expression is increased in human dystrophic muscle and overexpressing dre-miR-199a-5p in zebrafish muscle leads to major and lethal disruption of the myofibers [56]. In line with our observations, hsa-miR-31-5p (homologous to mmu-miR-31-5p) expression is increased in regenerating [57] and dystrophic muscle [57, 58] and positively regulates the proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells [59]. Hsa-miR-31-5p directly targets the 3’UTR of human Hdac4 and Nrf1 [60], as well an evolutionary conserved sequence of dystrophin 3’UTR [61]. Therefore, it likely plays a multifaceted role in the regulation of skeletal muscle development. The other members of miRNA cluster A have received little attention, especially in skeletal muscle. Hsa-miR-18a-5p (homologous to mmu-miR-18a-5p) enhances cell apoptosis in human keratinocytes in vitro [62] and stimulates the protein expression of the vascular smooth muscle cell differentiation markers Acta2 and Tagln [63] and mmu-miR-224-5p negatively regulates mouse adipocyte differentiation [64]. This suggests that mmu-miR-18a-5p and mmu-miR-224-5p may play roles in the early stages of the skeletal muscle tissue development, including vascular and adipocyte differentiation.

In contrast, the top-ranked miRNAs of cluster B have been relatively well described in skeletal muscle. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) technology revealed that mmu-miR-136-5p is decreased in gastrocnemius muscle from mice aged 6 and 24 months [65] and targets Rybp. This corroborates our results where mmu-miR-136-5p expression levels decrease by close to 80-fold between the age of 2 days and 12 weeks in mouse quadriceps muscle. In porcine skeletal muscle, the homologous ssc-miR-214-3p is highly expressed in the foetal stages (embryonic day 90) when compared with post-natal levels (post-partum day 120) [66]. This is in line with our findings in mouse muscle, where expression levels at 12 weeks of age were 14-fold greater than at 2 days. Mmu-miR-214-3p inhibits proliferation and promotes differentiation of the immortalized C2C12 mouse myogenic cell line in vitro [67]. Supressing mmu-miR-214-3p expression maintains C2C12 myoblasts in an active cell cycle and inhibits myogenic differentiation [68]. Our data also show that mmu-miR-214-3p is highly predicted to target Pax7 and we propose that it may act as a negative regulator of myoblast proliferation in vivo by directly regulating the Pax7/Myod1 pathway. Of interest, all 4 top-ranked miRNAs in cluster B were predicted to target one of the Pax gene family members with a high degree of certainty, potentially indicating a similar role for mmu-miR-134-5p, mmu-miR-136-5p and mmu-miR-296-5p. Mmu-miR-296-5p overexpression almost totally suppresses the utrophin-A protein in C2C12 myoblasts [69]. Utrophin is a cytoskeletal protein with similarities to dystrophin. Utrophin is initially expressed by all myonuclei and is located around the entire sarcolemma during foetal and early post-natal myofibre growth. However, by 3 weeks of age, utrophin protein expression is restricted to beneath the NMJ [70]. The expression pattern observed for mmu-miR-296-5p (down regulated by 25-fold between 2 days and 12 weeks of age) supports a potential role as an utrophin suppressor during myofibre maturation. Finally, mmu-miR-134-5p (down regulated by close to 100-fold between 2 days and 12 weeks of age) has not been described in skeletal muscle. It enhances differentiation in mouse embryonic stem cells [71] and also promotes cell proliferation while preventing the induction of differentiation and apoptosis in neuronal progenitor cells [72]. Whether mmu-miR-134–5p has a similar role in the muscle remains to be elucidated.

This study is the first to assess the expression levels of a large pool of miRNAs in an in vivo model of muscle development. A similar array has been previously conducted in a mouse model of muscle regeneration [73] and several miRNAs, including mmu-miR-18a-5p, mmu-miR-136-5p, mmu-miR-31-5p and mmu-miR-199a-5p, were similarly regulated as observed in our study. Muscle regeneration may display similarities with post-natal muscle development, although adult skeletal muscle tissue possesses quiescent stem cells that differ from developing tissues in aetiology and properties [74].

In conclusion, collective miRNA expression is subjected to substantial levels of regulation in mouse skeletal muscle tissue over the first 12 weeks of age. This study identified a suite of highly conserved miRNAs that are predicted to control muscle cell proliferation and differentiation pathways with a high degree of certainty. The specific role of these miRNAs in skeletal muscle development, maturation, function and disturbed homeostasis now requires expansion to a range of muscles in a range of species and experimental validation in vivo.