- Research article
- Open Access
Ethylene induces combinatorial effects of histone H3 acetylation in gene expression in Arabidopsis
BMC Genomics volume 18, Article number: 538 (2017)
Histone acetylation and deacetylation are essential for gene regulation and have been implicated in the regulation of plant hormone responses. Many studies have indicated the role of histone acetylation in ethylene signaling; however, few studies have investigated how ethylene signaling regulates the genomic landscape of chromatin states. Recently, we found that ethylene can specifically elevate histone H3K14 acetylation and the non-canonical histone H3K23 acetylation in etiolated seedlings and the gene activation is positively associated with the elevation of H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac in response to ethylene. To assess the role of H3K9, H3K14, and H3K23 histone modifications in the ethylene response, we examined how ethylene regulates histone acetylation and the transcriptome at global level and in ethylene regulated genes both in wild type (Col-0) and ein2-5 seedlings.
Our results revealed that H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac are preferentially enriched around the transcription start sites and are positively correlated with gene expression levels in Col-0 and ein2-5 seedlings both with and without ethylene treatment. In the absence of ethylene, no combinatorial effect of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac on gene expression was detected. In the presence of ethylene, however, combined enrichment of the three histone acetylation marks was associated with high gene expression levels, and this ethylene-induced change was EIN2 dependent. In addition, we found that ethylene-regulated genes are expressed at medium or high levels, and a group of ethylene regulated genes are marked by either one of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac or H3K23Ac. In this group of genes, the levels of H3K9Ac were altered by ethylene, but in the absence of ethylene the levels of H3K9Ac and peak breadths are distinguished in up- and down- regulated genes. In the presence of ethylene, the changes in the peak breadths and levels of H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac are required for the alteration of gene expressions.
Our study reveals that the plant hormone ethylene induces combinatorial effects of H3K9Ac, K14Ac and K23Ac histone acetylation in gene expression genome widely. Further, for a group of ethylene regulated genes, in the absence of ethylene the levels and the covered breadths of H3K9Ac are the preexist markers for distinguishing up- and down- regulated genes, the change in the peak breadths and levels of H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac are required for the alteration of gene expression in the presence of ethylene.
Epigenomic modifications modulate gene expression in response to environmental biotic and abiotic stimuli and developmental cues [1,2,3]. For example, covalent modifications of histone proteins have been demonstrated to be essential gene expression modulators . Histone modifications can be associated with chromatin-dependent transcriptional activation or repression depending on the specific amino acid substrate. Combined mutations at K5, K8, and K12 residues of histone H4 have significant impact on gene expression, whereas the individual mutations have negligible effects . This combinations of various histone modifications is collectively known as the ‘histone code’ .
Histone acetylation counteracts the tendency of nucleosomal fiber that folds into a highly compact structure [7, 8], acetylated chromatin is more accessible to interacting proteins. The histone acetyltransferases and deacetylases that modify histone proteins provide a critical link between chromatin structure and transcriptional output . Histone acetylation influences DNA replication, DNA repair, gene silencing, genome defense, genome organization, normal growth and development, aging, and numerous diseases [10,11,12]. Recently, histone acetylation has been implicated in responses of plants to hormones [13,14,15]. For example, abscisic acid (ABA) induces the elevation of acetylation at H3K9 and H3K14 in the promoter of phas gene, and the elevation is positively associated with gene expression . MSI1 is a partner of the histone deacetylase HDA19 that fine-tunes ABA signaling by binding to the chromatin of ABA receptor genes to maintain a low level of histone acetylation at H3K9, thereby affecting the expression levels of ABA receptor genes . Furthermore, HDA19 interacts with SNL1 and SNL2 to regulate acetylation of histone H3 at K9/18 and K14 in response to ABA .
A number of studies have focused on the role of histone acetylation in ethylene signaling [19,20,21,22]; however, how the genomic landscape of chromatin states is altered in response to ethylene and how histone acetylation integrates in the control of gene expression in response to ethylene signaling are not well characterized. Recently, we found that ethylene can specifically elevate histone H3 acetylation at K14 and at the non-canonical site K23 in etiolated seedlings, and the gene activation is positively associated with the elevations in H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac in response to ethylene . In addition, we found that both EIN2 [24,25,26] and EIN3  are involved.
Here, we present an in-depth epigenomic analysis of acetylation of H3K9, H3K14, and H3K23 in both wild-type Arabidopsis and the ein2-5 mutant, which is completely ethylene insensitive. In this study, we compared the global histone H3 acetylation patterns at K9, K14, and K23 in wild-type (Col-0) and ein2-5-mutant etiolated seedlings with or without ethylene gas treatment. We discovered that H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac preferentially mark highly expressed genes at transcription start site (TSS) regions both in Col-0 and ein2-5 mutant seedlings. Neither heights nor breadths of H3K9Ac ChIP peaks were altered by ethylene, but differences in H3K9Ac peak heights and breadths before ethylene treatment distinguish ethylene up- and down- regulated genes, and changes in H3K14Ac or H3K23Ac are observed in genes that responding to ethylene treatment. Overall, our study revealed ethylene induces combinatorial effects of H3K9Ac, K14Ac and K23Ac histone acetylation in gene expression genome widely. Further, for a group of ethylene regulated genes, in the absence of ethylene, the levels and the peak breadths of H3K9Ac are the potential preexist markers for distinguishing up- and down- regulated genes; in the presence of ethylene, the changes in the peak breadths and levels of H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac are required for the alteration of gene expression.
Plant growth conditions
Arabidopsis seeds were surface-sterilized in 50% bleach with 0.01% Triton X-100 for 15 min and washed five times with sterile, doubly distilled H2O before plating on MS medium (4.3 g MS salt, 10 g sucrose, pH 5.7, 8 g phyto agar per liter). After 3-4 days of cold (4 °C) treatment, the plates were wrapped in foil and kept in at 24 °C in an incubator before the phenotypes of seedlings were analyzed. For propagation, seedlings were transferred from plates to soil (Pro-mix-HP) and grown to maturity at 22 °C under 16-h light/8-h dark cycles. Ethylene treatment of Arabidopsis seedlings was performed by growth of seedlings on MS plates in air-tight containers in the dark supplied with either a flow of hydrocarbon-free air (Zero grade air, AirGas) or hydrocarbon-free air with 10 ppm (ppm) ethylene as previously described .
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assays
ChIP was performed according to a published protocol [29, 30]. Briefly, 3-day-old etiolated seedlings treated with air or ethylene were harvested and crosslinked in 1% formaldehyde, and then ground into fine power with liquid nitrogen. Chromatin was isolated and sheared into 200–800 base pair fragments by sonication. Antibody H3K9Ac (Millipore; 07-352, 1:3000 dilution), anti-H3K14Ac (Millipore; 07-353, 1:2000 dilution), anti-H3K23Ac (Millipore; 07-355, 1:3000 dilution), and Magnetic Protein G Beads (Promega, G747A) were added to the sonicated chromatin followed by incubation overnight to precipitate bound DNA fragments. In this work, 2 mg antibody per reaction was used. The precipitated DNA was then recovered and ChIP-qPCR was performed with three technical replicates, and results were calculated as percentage of input DNA. Independent ChIP experiments were performed at least two more times and similar results were obtained. Primer sequences used for ChIP-qPCR were listed in Additional file 2: Table S1.
Ten ng of ChIP DNA immuoprecipitated by antibody was used for ChIP-seq library construction. End repair, adapter ligation and amplification were carried out using NEB ChIP-seq Library Kit (NEB #E6240S/L) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. HiSeq 2000 (Illumina) was used for high-throughput sequencing of the ChIP-seq library in the UW-Madison Biotechnology Center. Independent ChIP-seq experiments, as well as IgG control, were performed two times.
ChIP-seq data analysis
Raw ChIP-seq data from a previous study  were downloaded from NCBI GEO under GSE77396. H3K9Ac ChIP data for ein2-5 seedlings under air and ethylene treatment were collected for this study. Initial quality-control analysis was performed using FastQC . Single-end 51-bp reads were mapped to the Arabidopsis genome (TAIR10)  and uniquely mapped sequencing reads were generated using bowtie software (version 1.1.2) [33, 34]. For each histone modification in each condition, mapped reads were pooled across ChIP-seq replicates as described [23, 35]. Peaks significantly enriched in ChIP-seq tags were identified by Model-based Analysis for ChIP-Seq (MACS2, version 184.108.40.20650603; parameters: --nomodel,-p 0.01) as previously described . Differential peaks were identified using the MAnorm method . For this method, the normalized M value (M = log2 (Read density in C2H4 treated sample/Read density in air treated sample)) represents log2-transformed fold changes of enrichment intensities at each peak region [37,38,39]. Thus, an absolute threshold value of M ≥ 0.4 and P ≤ 0.05 were used to select differentially enriched peaks as done previously . The nearest gene was assigned if there was more than one gene within 5 kilobases (kb) of the peak region . Biological functions of associated genes were assessed by agriGO . To show ChIP binding signal surrounding TSSs or in gene bodies, read coverage was first calculated using the bamCompare tool (RPKM, Log2(ChIP/IgG) in deepTools version 1.5.11 . Heat maps of ChIP-seq enrichment across gene body regions were calculated using deepTools version 1.5.11 . Generation of dot plots, heat maps (in Fig. 2b, Fig. 6 c-e), venn diagrams and statistical analyses were performed using R (version 3.2.2).
RNA-seq data analysis
RNA-seq raw data were downloaded from NCBI GEO under GSE77396 [23, 25]. Initial quality-control analysis was performed using FastQC . Raw reads were aligned to TAIR10 genome release using TopHat version 2.0.9  with default parameters. Differential expressed genes were identified using Cufflinks version 2.2.1 following the workflow with default parameters . Gene expression levels (RPKM, Reads Per Kilobase per Million mapped reads) in air and ethylene condition were generated from the output files of cuffdiff . Differentially expressed genes were those for which relative fold change values (RPKM) of larger than 1.5 and RPKM value larger than 1 were observed .
Total RNA was extracted using a Qiagen Plant Total RNA Kit (Sigma) from 3-day-etiolated seedlings treated with air or 4 h ethylene gas. First-strand cDNA was synthesized using Invitrogen Superscript III First-Strand cDNA Synthesis Kit. PCR reactions were performed in a total volume of 20 mL, containing 2 mL each 5-mM primer and 10-mL SYBR Green PCR Supermix in triplicate on a Roche 96 Thermal cycler according to the manufacturer’s instruction. The cycling program comprised an initial denaturation step at 95 °C for 10 min, followed by 50 cycles of 95 °C for 10 s, 60 °C for 10 s, and 72 °C for 20 s. All qRT-PCR values were normalized using the cycle threshold value corresponding to the reference gene. The relative expression levels of the target gene were calculated using 2(−Delta Delta C(T)) method . The sequences of all primers are listed in Additional file 2: Table S1.
Genome-wide mapping of H3K9, H3K14, and H3K23 in wild-type etiolated seedlings
Our previous study showed that H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac but not H3K9Ac are specifically elevated by ethylene . To fully understand the function of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac, we re-analyzed the ChIP-seq data from our previously published data obtained from 3-day-old etiolated Col-0 seedlings (Additional file 1: Figure S1 a,b) . ChIP-seq profiles revealed that all three histone acetylation marks are enriched in promoters and intragenic regions (Fig. 1a and b). Furthermore, the three acetylation marks were depleted in transposable elements (Fig. 1c). To further examine the correlation between gene expression and three histone acetylation marks, we divided the approximately 30,000 genes in the Arabidopsis genome into five groups based on expression levels in wild type plants (Additional file 1: Figure S1c). We found that highly expressed genes show significantly higher levels of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac both near TSS regions and in gene bodies than the genes expressed at low levels (Fig. 1a, d-f).
H3K9Ac, not the combined enrichment of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac, is critical for gene expression in the absence of ethylene treatment
We found that about 92% of H3K14Ac-marked genes were overlapped with genes marked with H3K23Ac. In addition, 85% of H3K23Ac-marked genes were also marked with H3K9Ac, and about 93% of H3K14Ac-marked genes overlapped with H3K9Ac-marked genes (Fig. 2a, Additional file 1: Figure S2a and Additional file 2 Table S2). Thus, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac preferentially co-exist with H3K9Ac. In pairwise association analyses we found that H3K9Ac is positively correlated with both H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac (Fig. 2b). Interestingly, the correlation between H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac is more significant than the others pairs (Fig. 2b, Pearson’s correlation coefficient = 0.93, P < 2.2 × 10−16).
To further explore how these three histone marks coordinate to regulate gene expression, we divided genes marked by H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, or H3K23Ac into seven clusters based on the distributions of three histone marks (Fig. 2a, Additional file 1: Figure S2a and Additional file 2 Table S2). Approximately 2400 genes were marked by all three histone modifications, 202 genes were marked with both H3K9Ac and H3K14Ac but not H3K23Ac, 1529 genes contained both H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac but not H3K14Ac, and 172 genes were marked with H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac but not H3K9Ac. Only 25 genes were uniquely marked with H3K14Ac, and 513 genes were uniquely marked with the H3K23Ac mark, indicating that H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac preferentially co-exist with each other or with H3K9Ac (Fig. 2a, Additional file 1: Figure S2a and Additional file 2 Table S2).
By comparing transcript abundance within different clusters of genes, we found that the genes without histone marks were expressed at the lowest levels (Fig. 2c), which is consistent with previous studies . Interestingly, the expression levels of the genes containing all three histone marks were not significant higher than that of the genes containing H3K9ac/H3K14ac, H3K9ac/H3K23Ac, or containing only H3K14Ac, or H3K9Ac (K9/K14/K23 vs. K14/K23, P = 5.49 × 10−11; K9/K14/K23 vs. K14/K9, P = 0.154; K9/K14/K23 vs. K9/K23, P = 0.171). In addition, expression levels of the genes containing only with H3K23Ac were lower than that of the genes in any other clusters. Notably, genes in any all clusters containing H3K9Ac showed similar gene expression levels (Fig. 2c). In order to confirm the observation, we did a similar analysis using the top 20% enriched peaks associated genes, and similar results were obtained (Additional file 1: Figure S2b, c), indicating that H3K9Ac is involved in the determination of genome-wide gene expression levels in etiolated seedlings.
We next compared the peak breadths for each of the three histone marks to mRNA transcript levels. We found peak breadths in the ChIP data for histone H3K9Ac were positively correlated with gene expression in the genes at the highest three levels of transcript abundance, whereas there were no correlations between the peak breadths of H3K14Ac or H3K23Ac with gene expression in the absence of ethylene (Fig. 2d-f). These results revealed a positive correlation between transcript abundance and levels of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac.
Ethylene induces combinatorial effects of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac in gene expression
To study whether and how ethylene leads to the H3K14Ac, H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac changes genome wide, we examined the ChIP-seq profiles of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac in seedlings treated with ethylene. The ChIP-seq profiles of H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac were not significantly changed by ethylene (Additional file 1: Figure S3a). In the presence of ethylene, the three histone marks were more highly correlated (based on Pearson coefficient) than in the absence of ethylene with the largest increased in the association between H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac (Additional file 1: Figure S3b). To further explore how the three histone marks coordinate in regulation of gene expression in response to ethylene, we compared correlations within seven clusters of the genes divided based on transcript abundance (Fig. 3a and Additional file 2 Table S3). The abundances of the genes marked only with H3K14Ac or only with H3K23Ac were the lowest in all clusters, and no “biological process” GO terms were significantly associated with these genes. The genes marked by both H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac had higher expression levels than those marked with H3K14Ac only or H3K23Ac only (Fig. 3b) (the expression of genes marked by K14/23Ac vs. the expression of genes marked by K14Ac, P = 1.52 × 10−7; the expression of genes marked by K14/23Ac vs. the expression of genes marked by K23Ac, P = 6.04 × 10−6).
In addition, in the presence of ethylene, the genes with all three histone marks had significantly higher transcript abundances than other genes with one or two of the marks (Fig. 3b; K9/K14/K23 vs. K9/K14, P = 1.31 × 10−26; K9/K14/K23 vs. K9/K23, P = 3.29 × 10−28; K9/K14/K23 vs. K14/K23, P = 1.6 × 10−176; K9/K14/K23 vs. K9, P = 9.6 × 10−138; K9/K14/K23 vs. K14, P = 0; K9/K14/K23 vs. K23, P = 3.2 × 10−270). In the presence of ethylene, the breadths of ChIP peaks for all three histone marks showed a significant positive correlation with transcript abundance (Fig. 3c). These results reveal that H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac have combinatorial effects in gene expression.
To further compare the histone marks between with and without ethylene treatments, we checked histone enrichment in different sets of peak associated genes. We found that highly expressed genes had significantly higher levels of the H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac both with and without ethylene treatments (Fig. 3d-f). The levels of both H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac, were elevated by ethylene, whereas no difference was detected in H3K9Ac levels (Fig. 3d-f), which is consistent with a previous report . We then compared differential peaks induced by ethylene for all three histone marks. Significant differences in H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac were observed in the presence of ethylene relative to in the absence of ethylene, and fewer differential H3K9Ac peaks were identified (Fig. 3g-i). Thus, the combined histone enrichment is positively associated with high gene expression levels.
To further explore the regulation of histone acetylation in response to ethylene, we did ChIP-seq of H3K9Ac in the ein2-5 mutant, which is completely ethylene insensitive . As in Col-0 seedlings, highly expressed genes in 3-day-old ein2-5 seedlings had significantly higher levels of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac than all groups of genes both near the TSSs and in the gene bodies. Genes expressed at low levels had lower levels of these three histone marks across the entire gene body (Fig. 4a and Additional file 1: Figure S4a-c). Different from Col-0, in the ein2-5 mutant, the levels of H3K9Ac were not altered by ethylene; however, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac enrichment was reduced in genes in the three abundance groups, but not the two highest groups, in seedlings grown in ethylene compared to those grown in air (Fig. 4b-d). When Col-0 plants treated with ethylene, the ChIP peak breadths for all three histone marks showed significant positive correlations with gene expression genome wide (Fig. 3c). In ein2-5 mutant seedlings, the ChIP signals showed significantly positive correlations with gene expression in both the presence and absence of ethylene (Additional file 1: Figure S4d and e); however, no ethylene-induced enhancements were detected, revealing that the ethylene-induced increase in acetylation of histone H3 is EIN2 dependent (Additional file 1: Figure S4d and e).
The combined effects of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac on the expression of ethylene-regulated genes
To further study how histone acetylation integrates into the regulation of gene expression, we re-analyzed the published RNAseq data from 3-day-etiolated seedlings treated with air or 4 h ethylene gas [23, 25], and further isolated the ethylene-regulated genes that are marked by any one of the three histone marks. In total 1039 genes were identified (Fig. 5a and Additional file 2 Table S4). In this group of genes, in the absence of ethylene, the enrichments of H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac were observed more often in intragenic than in promoter regions in the absence of ethylene (Additional file 1: Figure S5a-g). The opposite was the case in our genome-wide analysis (Fig. 1b). In the presence ethylene, there was no change in H3K9Ac in ethylene regulated genes (Additional file 1: Figure S5g); however, enrichment in the promoter regions and intragenic regions for H3K23Ac and H3K14ac were increased (Additional file 1: Figure S5d-g). The ethylene-regulated genes (total 2674) were mainly (97.8%) expressed at high or medium levels (Fig. 5b, Additional file 1: Figure S5a-f), indicating that certain levels of histone modification and gene expression above a certain threshold characterize a group of genes responding to ethylene. We then examined whether the combination of these three histone acetylation marks is associated with changes in gene expression in the presence of ethylene (Additional file 1: Figure S5 h-j and Additional file 2 Table S5). The genes were divided into seven clusters based on the combination of acetylation of H3. No significant correlations were detected between the differences in gene expression in the presence and absence of ethylene with any combined enrichments of the three histone acetylation marks (Additional file 1: Figure S5i-j).
We next divided ethylene-regulated genes marked by H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and/or H3K23Ac into two groups: ethylene-up regulated genes (n = 405) and ethylene-down regulated genes (n = 634) (Additional file 2: Table S4). In the absence of ethylene, the ChIP peak breadths for H3K9Ac were larger in ethylene up-regulated genes than in down-regulated genes, but no differences were detected for H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac (Fig. 5c). In the presence of ethylene, the peak breadths for each of the three histone marks increased in both up- and down-regulated genes. For both H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac, the peak breadths became larger in up-regulated genes than in down-regulated genes (Fig. 5c). Even though the H3K9Ac signal was not altered in ethylene (Fig. 3d) as reported previously , the levels enriched for H3K9Ac were higher in ethylene up-regulated genes than in ethylene down-regulated genes before ethylene treatment, and no significant difference was detected after ethylene treatment. Unlike H3K9Ac, the levels for H3K23Ac showed a positive association with gene expression after ethylene treatment, although not before ethylene treatment (Fig. 5d; Additional file 1: Figure S5 k,l). These results suggest that in the absence of ethylene, the H3K9Ac mark distinguishes ethylene up-regulated from ethylene down-regulated genes and that the changes in H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac are potentially required for the alteration of gene expression in response to ethylene.
Finally, we examined the histone acetylation of ethylene-regulated genes in the ein2-5 mutant. Intriguingly, in ein2-5 mutant, three histone marks showed a positive correlation with gene expression both with and without the presence of ethylene (Additional file 1: Figure S6a-f), which was similar to that of the Col-0 seedlings treated with ethylene, but the ethylene induced alterations in Col-0 were not detected in ein2-5 mutant (Fig. 6a, b). Furthermore, in ein2-5 mutant seedlings, the peak breadths in ethylene down-regulated genes were larger than those in ethylene up-regulated genes, and the signals of the three histone acetylation marks were also higher in ethylene down-regulated genes than in ethylene up-regulated genes both with and without ethylene (Fig. 6a, b). In addition, most transcripts from genes that were differentially marked by histone H3 acetylation in the presence versus the absence of ethylene were not detectable in ein2-5 mutant (Fig. 6c-e). Collectively, the results show that EIN2 is required for the ethylene induced combinatorial effects of histone acetylation in a group of ethylene-regulated genes.
The correlation between histone acetylation and gene expression has been well studied [9, 47]. Here, we confirmed that H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac are positively associated with gene expression levels genome-wide in Arabidopsis both with and without ethylene treatments (Fig. 1). A number of studies have shown that histone acetylation is involved in responses to plant hormones including ABA [17, 21, 48], jasmonic acid [19, 49], auxin [50, 51], and ethylene [19,20,21,22]. Little is known, however, about how histone acetylation alters in response to plant hormones genome-wide. Our study represents an important initial step toward a description of the genomic landscape of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac in response to ethylene. Many acetylated residues act coordinately and the combined effect ultimately dictates the functional outcome . For example, acetylation at K5, K8, and K12 of H4 have redundant influences on nucleosome assembly and transcription . Effects can also be combinatorial; for example, the combined accumulation of H3K23Ac and H4K16Ac is positively associated with gene expression in green plants . Interestingly, we found that in the absence of ethylene, no combinatorial effect of histone acetylation on genome-wide gene expression was detected in 3-day-old etiolated Col-0 seedlings (Fig. 2c). However, in the presence of ethylene, a significant positive correlation between the combined labels of histone acetylation and high levels of gene expression was detected (Fig. 3b). In addition, when seedlings treated with ethylene, there was a positive correlation between H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac signals with the levels of gene expression. Acetylation of histones H3 and H4 leads to partial decondensation of chromosomal domains, although this opening is not necessarily tightly correlated with active transcription . Our observation of an ethylene-induced positive association between H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac and gene expression is likely due to the combined effects of both an increase in the number of bases of the gene covered by H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac and an elevation in acetylation.
Genetic and biochemical studies suggest that histone acetyltransferases have rather specific roles in gene activation [55, 56], whereas genome-wide experiments suggest that several acetyltransferases are often recruited simultaneously and together acetylate multiple lysine residues at a given loci. Thus, the biological function of histone acetylation may be additive than highly specific. We found that in seedlings grown in the presence or absence of ethylene, H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac coexist and the Pearson correlation between H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac is higher in ethylene-treated plants than those grown in air (Fig. 2b and Additional file 1: Figure S3b). One possibility is that ethylene treatment induces changes in the behaviors of histone acetyltransferases or histone deacetylates, leading to a tighter association of H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac. Alternatively, ethylene may cause changes in other histone modifications or effectors of chromatin configuration that lead to a tighter association between H3K9Ac and H3K23Ac.
The ethylene-induced changes in histone acetylation depended on EIN2. In our genome-wide analysis, the distributions of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac, and H3K23Ac in the ein2-5 mutant and in the Col-0 seedlings were very similar, all of these marks are preferentially enriched at moderately to highly expressed genes in Arabidopsis, consistent with the fact that acetylation marks are generally associated with open chromatin and actively transcribed regions [46, 57]. In wild-type plants, there are clear differences in the histone marks genome-wide between air and ethylene treatments (Fig. 2d-f, Fig. 3c), but in the ein2-5 mutant, this shift was not detected (Additional file 1: Figure S4d and e). Most interestingly, the pattern in wild-type plants treated with ethylene was similar to that of the pattern in the ein2-5 mutant, which indicates that EIN2 is important for maintenance of chromatin signatures and also important for the changes in histone acetylation in response to ethylene. In the presence of ethylene, EIN2 is up-regulated in wild-type plants, whereas EIN2 is absent in ein2-5 mutant, why histone acetylation was similar between wild-type plants and ein2-5 mutant is unclear. One possibility is that the levels of EIN2 fine tune the chromatin state. It will be important to determine at the molecular level how EIN2 regulates histone acetylation in the ethylene response.
The majority of ethylene-regulated genes are expressed at medium to high levels (Fig. 5b). That very few ethylene-regulated transcripts are low abundance, suggests that histone acetylation and a threshold of the expression level are potentially required for the genes to respond to ethylene treatment. Most interestingly, even though H3K9Ac is not regulated by ethylene, the enrichment of H3K9Ac in the ethylene up-regulated genes is higher than in the ethylene down-regulated genes (Fig. 5c). This difference was not observed for H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac signals (Fig. 5c). This suggests that in the absence of ethylene, the levels of H3K9Ac are important to determine the condensation of chromatin in activation regions or repression regions for ethylene response. In the presence of ethylene, the H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac are regulated by ethylene and positively correlated to gene expression in its presence.
How H3K9Ac enrichment is established is unknown. H3K9Ac and H3K4me3 are observed in highly expressed genes , and the locations and distributions of H3K9Ac and H3K4me3 influence transcriptional activity and expression in response to developmental and environmental changes. Chromatin regions with H3K4me3 are targeted for histone acetylation by histone acetyltransferases . Therefore, one possible reason for the difference of H3K9Ac in the genes differentially regulated by ethylene is the preexistence of other histone marks, such as H3K4me3 or H3K27me3, that influence H3K9Ac levels. Alternatively, DNA sequences or the promoter structures may be different in ethylene up-regulated genes than in ethylene down-regulated genes, which leads to different levels of H3K9Ac.
The bromodomain, a evolutionarily conserved protein interacting module, has been reported to be responsible for acetylated lysine residues recognition . The Arabidopsis proteome encodes 29 bromodomain-containing proteins . GCN5/HAG1, a bromodomain-containing histone acetyltransferase that is required for the binding of GCN5 to a subset of its target chromatin loci , has been studied to be involved into many plant development processes, as well as environmental stimuli responses . Rice OsHAG702, which shows high similarities with AtHAG1, was significantly elevated in response to exogenous ABA application to seedlings, indicating that it may be involved in the ABA signaling pathway for response to environmental stresses . Some bromodomain proteins exhibit an extra terminal (ET) domain besides the N-terminal bromodomain(s), and they are named as BET proteins . The BET domain functions as a protein-protein interaction domain to recruit other proteins to acetylated histones . Twelve BET-encoding genes have been identified in the Arabidopsis genome, and some of are known to involve in plant development, mitotic cell cycle regulation and ABA response [64,65,66,67]. Considering the histone acetylation changes in response to ethylene , further studies are needed to confirm whether these bromodomain-containing proteins are involved in the ethylene response.
Histone acetylation and deacetylation are essential for gene regulation and have been implicated in the regulation of plant hormone responses. Many studies have indicated the role of histone acetylation in ethylene signaling; however, few studies have investigated how ethylene signaling regulates the genomic landscape of chromatin states. This study reveals that the plant hormone ethylene induces combinatorial effects of H3K9Ac, K14Ac and K23Ac histone acetylation in gene expression both genome widely and a group of ethylene regulated genes, providing an insight knowledge of plant hormone induced combinatorial effect in gene expression.
Chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing
ethylene-insensitive protein 2
EIN2 nuclear associated protein 1
H3 lysine 14 (H3K14) acetylation
H3 lysine 23 (H3K23) acetylation
H3 lysine 9 (H3K9) acetylation
Murashige & Skoog
Reads per kilo base per million mapped reads
Yuan L, Liu X, Luo M, Yang S, Wu K. Involvement of histone modifications in plant abiotic stress responses. J Integr Plant Biol. 2013;55(10):892–901.
Yamamuro C, Zhu JK, Yang Z. Epigenetic modifications and plant hormone action. Mol Plant. 2016;9(1):57–70.
Trollope AF, Gutierrez-Mecinas M, Mifsud KR, Collins A, Saunderson EA, Reul JM. Stress, epigenetic control of gene expression and memory formation. Exp Neurol. 2012;233(1):3–11.
Strahl BD, Allis CD. The language of covalent histone modifications. Nature. 2000;403(6765):41–5.
Dion MF, Altschuler SJ, Wu LF, Rando OJ. Genomic characterization reveals a simple histone H4 acetylation code. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005;102(15):5501–6.
Jenuwein T, Allis CD. Translating the histone code. Science. 2001;293(5532):1074–80.
Tse C, Sera T, Wolffe AP, Hansen JC. Disruption of higher-order folding by core histone acetylation dramatically enhances transcription of nucleosomal arrays by RNA polymerase III. Mol Cell Biol. 1998;18(8):4629–38.
Garcia-Ramirez M, Rocchini C, Ausio J. Modulation of chromatin folding by histone acetylation. J Biol Chem. 1995;270(30):17923–8.
Grunstein M. Histone acetylation in chromatin structure and transcription. Nature. 1997;389(6649):349–52.
Unnikrishnan A, Gafken PR, Tsukiyama T. Dynamic changes in histone acetylation regulate origins of DNA replication. Nat Struct Mol Biol. 2010;17(4):430–7.
Gong F, Miller KM. Mammalian DNA repair: HATs and HDACs make their mark through histone acetylation. Mutat Res. 2013;750(1-2):23–30.
Timmermann S, Lehrmann H, Polesskaya A, Harel-Bellan A. Histone acetylation and disease. Cell Mol Life Sci. 2001;58(5-6):728–36.
Liu X, Luo M, Zhang W, Zhao JH, Zhang JX, Wu KQ, Tian LN, Duan J. Histone acetyltransferases in rice (Oryza sativa L.): phylogenetic analysis, subcellular localization and expression. BMC Plant Biol. 2012;12:145.
Yamamuro C, Zhu JK, Yang ZB. Epigenetic modifications and plant hormone action. Mol Plant. 2016;9(1):57–70.
Alatzas A. Histones and plant hormones: new evidence for an interesting interplay. Bot Rev. 2013;79(3):317–41.
Ng DWK, Chandrasekharan MB, Hall TC. Ordered histone modifications are associated with transcriptional poising and activation of the phaseolin promoter. Plant Cell. 2006;18(1):119–32.
Mehdi S, Derkacheva M, Ramstrom M, Kralemann L, Bergquist J, Hennig L. The WD40 domain protein MSI1 functions in a Histone Deacetylase complex to fine-tune abscisic acid signaling. Plant Cell. 2016;28(1):42–54.
Wang Z, Cao H, Sun YZ, Li XY, Chen FY, Carles A, Li Y, Ding M, Zhang C, Deng X, et al. Arabidopsis paired Amphipathic helix proteins SNL1 and SNL2 redundantly regulate primary seed dormancy via abscisic acid-ethylene antagonism mediated by histone deacetylation. Plant Cell. 2013;25(1):149–66.
Zhou C, Zhang L, Duan J, Miki B, Wu K. HISTONE DEACETYLASE19 is involved in jasmonic acid and ethylene signaling of pathogen response in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2005;17(4):1196–204.
Li C, Xu J, Li J, Li Q, Yang H. Involvement of Arabidopsis histone acetyltransferase HAC family genes in the ethylene signaling pathway. Plant Cell Physiol. 2014;55(2):426–35.
Wang Z, Cao H, Sun Y, Li X, Chen F, Carles A, Li Y, Ding M, Zhang C, Deng X, et al. Arabidopsis paired amphipathic helix proteins SNL1 and SNL2 redundantly regulate primary seed dormancy via abscisic acid-ethylene antagonism mediated by histone deacetylation. Plant Cell. 2013;25(1):149–66.
Tian L, Fong MP, Wang JJ, Wei NE, Jiang H, Doerge RW, Chen ZJ. Reversible histone acetylation and deacetylation mediate genome-wide, promoter-dependent and locus-specific changes in gene expression during plant development. Genetics. 2005;169(1):337–45.
Zhang F, Qi B, Wang L, Zhao B, Rode S, Riggan ND, Ecker JR, Qiao H. EIN2-dependent regulation of acetylation of histone H3K14 and non-canonical histone H3K23 in ethylene signalling. Nat Commun. 2016;7:13018.
Alonso JM, Hirayama T, Roman G, Nourizadeh S, Ecker JR. EIN2, a bifunctional transducer of ethylene and stress responses in Arabidopsis. Science. 1999;284(5423):2148–52.
Qiao H, Shen Z, Huang SS, Schmitz RJ, Urich MA, Briggs SP, Ecker JR. Processing and subcellular trafficking of ER-tethered EIN2 control response to ethylene gas. Science. 2012;338(6105):390–3.
Qiao H, Chang KN, Yazaki J, Ecker JR. Interplay between ethylene, ETP1/ETP2 F-box proteins, and degradation of EIN2 triggers ethylene responses in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev. 2009;23(4):512–21.
Chao QM, Rothenberg M, Solano R, Roman G, Terzaghi W, Ecker JR. Activation of the ethylene gas response pathway in Arabidopsis by the nuclear protein ETHYLENE-INSENSITIVE3 and related proteins. Cell. 1997;89(7):1133–44.
Kieber JJ, Rothenberg M, Roman G, Feldmann KA, Ecker JR. CTR1, a negative regulator of the ethylene response pathway in Arabidopsis, encodes a member of the raf family of protein kinases. Cell. 1993;72(3):427–41.
Chang KN, Zhong S, Weirauch MT, Hon G, Pelizzola M, Li H, Huang SS, Schmitz RJ, Urich MA, Kuo D, et al. Temporal transcriptional response to ethylene gas drives growth hormone cross-regulation in Arabidopsis. elife. 2013;2:e00675.
Pedmale UV, Huang SS, Zander M, Cole BJ, Hetzel J, Ljung K, Reis PA, Sridevi P, Nito K, Nery JR, et al. Cryptochromes interact directly with PIFs to control plant growth in limiting blue light. Cell. 2016;164(1-2):233–45.
Andrews S: FastQC: a quality control tool for high throughput sequence data. Available at www.bioinformatics.babraham.ac.uk/projects/fastqc/. 2013.
Lamesch P, Berardini TZ, Li D, Swarbreck D, Wilks C, Sasidharan R, Muller R, Dreher K, Alexander DL, Garcia-Hernandez M, et al. The Arabidopsis Information Resource (TAIR): improved gene annotation and new tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012;40(Database issue):D1202–10.
Langmead B, Trapnell C, Pop M, Salzberg SL. Ultrafast and memory-efficient alignment of short DNA sequences to the human genome. Genome Biol. 2009;10(3):R25.
Langmead B. Aligning short sequencing reads with Bowtie. Curr Protoc Bioinformatics. 2010;Chapter 11:Unit 11 17.
Gjoneska E, Pfenning AR, Mathys H, Quon G, Kundaje A, Tsai LH, Kellis M. Conserved epigenomic signals in mice and humans reveal immune basis of Alzheimer's disease. Nature. 2015;518(7539):365–9.
Zhang Y, Liu T, Meyer CA, Eeckhoute J, Johnson DS, Bernstein BE, Nusbaum C, Myers RM, Brown M, Li W, et al. Model-based analysis of ChIP-Seq (MACS). Genome Biol. 2008;9(9):R137.
Shao Z, Zhang Y, Yuan GC, Orkin SH, Waxman DJ. MAnorm: a robust model for quantitative comparison of ChIP-Seq data sets. Genome Biol. 2012;13(3):R16.
Xu J, Shao Z, Glass K, Bauer DE, Pinello L, Van Handel B, Hou S, Stamatoyannopoulos JA, Mikkola HK, Yuan GC, et al. Combinatorial assembly of developmental stage-specific enhancers controls gene expression programs during human erythropoiesis. Dev Cell. 2012;23(4):796–811.
Kerenyi MA, Shao Z, Hsu YJ, Guo G, Luc S, O'Brien K, Fujiwara Y, Peng C, Nguyen M, Orkin SH. Histone demethylase Lsd1 represses hematopoietic stem and progenitor cell signatures during blood cell maturation. elife. 2013;2:e00633.
Du Z, Zhou X, Ling Y, Zhang Z, Su Z. agriGO: a GO analysis toolkit for the agricultural community. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010;38(Web Server issue):W64–70.
Ramirez F, Dundar F, Diehl S, Gruning BA, Manke T. deepTools: a flexible platform for exploring deep-sequencing data. Nucleic Acids Res. 2014;42(Web Server issue):W187–91.
Kim D, Pertea G, Trapnell C, Pimentel H, Kelley R, Salzberg SL. TopHat2: accurate alignment of transcriptomes in the presence of insertions, deletions and gene fusions. Genome Biol. 2013;14(4):R36.
Trapnell C, Roberts A, Goff L, Pertea G, Kim D, Kelley DR, Pimentel H, Salzberg SL, Rinn JL, Pachter L. Differential gene and transcript expression analysis of RNA-seq experiments with TopHat and Cufflinks. Nat Protoc. 2012;7(3):562–78.
Bai MY, Fan M, Oh E, Wang ZY. A triple helix-loop-helix/basic helix-loop-helix cascade controls cell elongation downstream of multiple hormonal and environmental signaling pathways in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2012;24(12):4917–29.
Livak KJ, Schmittgen TD. Analysis of relative gene expression data using real-time quantitative PCR and the 2(−Delta Delta C(T)) method. Methods. 2001;25(4):402–8.
Lu L, Chen X, Sanders D, Qian S, Zhong X. High-resolution mapping of H4K16 and H3K23 acetylation reveals conserved and unique distribution patterns in Arabidopsis and rice. Epigenetics. 2015;10(11):1044–53.
Struhl K. Histone acetylation and transcriptional regulatory mechanisms. Genes Dev. 1998;12(5):599–606.
Perrella G, Lopez-Vernaza MA, Carr C, Sani E, Gossele V, Verduyn C, Kellermeier F, Hannah MA, Amtmann A. Histone deacetylase complex1 expression level titrates plant growth and abscisic acid sensitivity in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2013;25(9):3491–505.
Wu K, Zhang L, Zhou C, Yu CW, Chaikam V. HDA6 is required for jasmonate response, senescence and flowering in Arabidopsis. J Exp Bot. 2008;59(2):225–34.
Lee K, Park OS, Jung SJ, Seo PJ. Histone deacetylation-mediated cellular dedifferentiation in Arabidopsis. J Plant Physiol. 2016;191:95–100.
Wang Z, Chen F, Li X, Cao H, Ding M, Zhang C, Zuo J, Xu C, Xu J, Deng X, et al. Arabidopsis seed germination speed is controlled by SNL histone deacetylase-binding factor-mediated regulation of AUX1. Nat Commun. 2016;7:13412.
Kim JA, Hsu JY, Smith MM, Allis CD. Mutagenesis of pairwise combinations of histone amino-terminal tails reveals functional redundancy in budding yeast. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012;109(15):5779–84.
Ma XJ, Wu J, Altheim BA, Schultz MC, Grunstein M. Deposition-related sites K5/K12 in histone H4 are not required for nucleosome deposition in yeast. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1998;95(12):6693–8.
Schubeler D, Francastel C, Cimbora DM, Reik A, Martin DI, Groudine M. Nuclear localization and histone acetylation: a pathway for chromatin opening and transcriptional activation of the human beta-globin locus. Genes Dev. 2000;14(8):940–50.
Anamika K, Krebs AR, Thompson J, Poch O, Devys D, Tora L. Lessons from genome-wide studies: an integrated definition of the coactivator function of histone acetyl transferases. Epigenetics Chromatin. 2010;3(1):18.
Wang Z, Zang C, Cui K, Schones DE, Barski A, Peng W, Zhao K. Genome-wide mapping of HATs and HDACs reveals distinct functions in active and inactive genes. Cell. 2009;138(5):1019–31.
Chen X, Lu L, Mayer KS, Scalf M, Qian S, Lomax A, Smith LM, Zhong X. POWERDRESS interacts with HISTONE DEACETYLASE 9 to promote aging in Arabidopsis. elife. 2016;5:e17214.
Tamkun JW, Deuring R, Scott MP, Kissinger M, Pattatucci AM, Kaufman TC. Kennison JA: brahma: a regulator of Drosophila homeotic genes structurally related to the yeast transcriptional activator SNF2/SWI2. Cell. 1992;68(3):561–72.
Pandey R, Muller A, Napoli CA, Selinger DA, Pikaard CS, Richards EJ, Bender J, Mount DW, Jorgensen RA. Analysis of histone acetyltransferase and histone deacetylase families of Arabidopsis thaliana suggests functional diversification of chromatin modification among multicellular eukaryotes. Nucleic Acids Res. 2002;30(23):5036–55.
Benhamed M, Martin-Magniette ML, Taconnat L, Bitton F, Servet C, De Clercq R, De Meyer B, Buysschaert C, Rombauts S, Villarroel R, et al. Genome-scale Arabidopsis promoter array identifies targets of the histone acetyltransferase GCN5. Plant J. 2008;56(3):493–504.
Servet C, Conde e Silva N, Zhou D-X. Histone Acetyltransferase AtGCN5/HAG1 is a versatile regulator of developmental and inducible gene expression in <em>Arabidopsis</em>. Mol Plant. 2010;3(4):670–7.
Liu X, Luo M, Zhang W, Zhao J, Zhang J, Wu K, Tian L, Duan J. Histone acetyltransferases in rice (Oryza sativa L.): phylogenetic analysis, subcellular localization and expression. BMC Plant Biol. 2012;12:145.
Platt GM, Simpson GR, Mittnacht S, Schulz TF. Latent nuclear antigen of Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus interacts with RING3, a homolog of the Drosophila female sterile homeotic (fsh) gene. J Virol. 1999;73(12):9789–95.
Duque P, Chua NH. IMB1, a bromodomain protein induced during seed imbibition, regulates ABA- and phyA-mediated responses of germination in Arabidopsis. Plant J. 2003;35(6):787–99.
Chua YL, Channeliere S, Mott E, Gray JC. The bromodomain protein GTE6 controls leaf development in Arabidopsis by histone acetylation at ASYMMETRIC LEAVES1. Genes Dev. 2005;19(18):2245–54.
Airoldi CA, Rovere FD, Falasca G, Marino G, Kooiker M, Altamura MM, Citterio S, Kater MM. The Arabidopsis BET bromodomain factor GTE4 is involved in maintenance of the mitotic cell cycle during plant development. Plant Physiol. 2010;152(3):1320–34.
Misra A: The bromodomain proteins GTE9 and GTE11 associate with BT2-based E3 Ligase complex and mediate responses to multiple signals in Arabidopsis thaliana. Doctoral dissertation, Texas A&M University Available electronically from http : / /hdl handle net /1969 1 /ETD -TAMU -2011 -12 -10219 2011.
We thank S. Sung and his lab members for comments, Natalie Ahn for plant and lab maintenance. We thank the Salk Institute Genomic Analysis Laboratory for providing seeds. We thank genomic sequencing and analysis facility of institute of cellular and molecular biology at The University of Texas at Austin for ChIP-seq.
This work was supported by grants from the National Institute of Health to H.Q (NIH- 1R01GM115879-01). The funding bodies had no role in study design, data collection, analysis and interpretation, decision to publish, or writing of the manuscript.
Availability of data and materials
Sequence data can be downloaded from NCBI SRA (GSE77396 and GSE93875).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The seed samples used in this study were publicly available and de-identified, and obtained from the following sources: The Arabidopsis Information Resource (TAIR, https://www.arabidopsis.org).
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Gene expressions in Arabidopsis. Figure S2. Combined enrichment of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac is correlated with high gene expression levels. Figure S3. Histone acetylation of H3K9Ac, H3K14Ac and H3K23Ac in response to ethylene. Figure S4. The ethylene induced shift of histone acetylation marks is EIN2 dependent. Figure S5. Histone modification in ethylene regulated genes. Figure S6. Histone modification in ethylene regulated genes in ein2-5. (PDF 1200 kb)
Primers for ChIP-qPCR and qPCR. Table S2. list of genome wide genes with differential histone markers in seedlings treated with air. Table S3. list of genome wide genes with differential histone markers in seedlings treated with ethylene. Table S4. list of ethylene regulated genes with differential histone markers in seedlings treated with air. Table S5. List of ethylene regulated genes with differential histone markers in seedlings treated with ethylene. (ZIP 1241 kb)
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, L., Zhang, F., Rode, S. et al. Ethylene induces combinatorial effects of histone H3 acetylation in gene expression in Arabidopsis . BMC Genomics 18, 538 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12864-017-3929-6
- Histone acetylation
- Combinatorial effects