- Open Access
Confero: an integrated contrast data and gene set platform for computational analysis and biological interpretation of omics data
BMC Genomics volume 14, Article number: 514 (2013)
High-throughput omics technologies such as microarrays and next-generation sequencing (NGS) have become indispensable tools in biological research. Computational analysis and biological interpretation of omics data can pose significant challenges due to a number of factors, in particular the systems integration required to fully exploit and compare data from different studies and/or technology platforms. In transcriptomics, the identification of differentially expressed genes when studying effect(s) or contrast(s) of interest constitutes the starting point for further downstream computational analysis (e.g. gene over-representation/enrichment analysis, reverse engineering) leading to mechanistic insights. Therefore, it is important to systematically store the full list of genes with their associated statistical analysis results (differential expression, t-statistics, p-value) corresponding to one or more effect(s) or contrast(s) of interest (shortly termed as ” contrast data”) in a comparable manner and extract gene sets in order to efficiently support downstream analyses and further leverage data on a long-term basis. Filling this gap would open new research perspectives for biologists to discover disease-related biomarkers and to support the understanding of molecular mechanisms underlying specific biological perturbation effects (e.g. disease, genetic, environmental, etc.).
To address these challenges, we developed Confero, a contrast data and gene set platform for downstream analysis and biological interpretation of omics data. The Confero software platform provides storage of contrast data in a simple and standard format, data transformation to enable cross-study and platform data comparison, and automatic extraction and storage of gene sets to build new a priori knowledge which is leveraged by integrated and extensible downstream computational analysis tools. Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA) and Over-Representation Analysis (ORA) are currently integrated as an analysis module as well as additional tools to support biological interpretation. Confero is a standalone system that also integrates with Galaxy, an open-source workflow management and data integration system. To illustrate Confero platform functionality we walk through major aspects of the Confero workflow and results using the Bioconductor estrogen package dataset.
Confero provides a unique and flexible platform to support downstream computational analysis facilitating biological interpretation. The system has been designed in order to provide the researcher with a simple, innovative, and extensible solution to store and exploit analyzed data in a sustainable and reproducible manner thereby accelerating knowledge-driven research. Confero source code is freely available from http://sourceforge.net/projects/confero/.
The development and application of high-throughput technologies in biological research has presented researchers with unprecedented amounts of omics data. Management, analysis and interpretation of such data still pose significant challenges. A plethora of open-source software solutions (e.g. caArray , MARS , BASE , EMMA , MIMAS [5, 6], TM4 , MADMAX , MiMiR , ExpressionPlot  to name a few) are readily available for storage and management of raw and preprocessed high-throughput datasets and metadata. These solutions provide a data management platform to facilitate the beginning of the experimental data analysis process. Depending on the complexity of experimental designs, statistical analysis of high-throughput data can involve a number of sophisticated techniques and tools. In transcriptomics, the identification of differentially expressed genes when studying effect(s)/contrast(s) of interest constitutes the starting point for further downstream computational analysis (e.g. gene over-representation/enrichment analysis, reverse engineering, network building, etc.) leading to biological interpretation and mechanistic insights. While many research sites use systems to manage raw and processed data they still do not take advantage of a central downstream infrastructure to store and further exploit analyzed data in an integrated way. In this situation, the value of knowledge gained from analyzed data is restricted to the specific study in which these data were generated, whereas this knowledge could be leveraged during analysis of other studies. Even with the arrival of bioinformatics workflow management systems (e.g. Galaxy [11–13], GenePattern , Taverna ), which facilitate reproducible analyses, these systems by themselves do not provide the functionality necessary to centrally manage and further utilize analyzed data. Currently, no open-source and free software solutions of this kind exist to store, manage and leverage analyzed data and provide an integrated platform for downstream computational analysis, knowledge acquisition and integration leading to new experimental hypothesis generation. Integration of tools and development of such platforms are important to assemble a systems biology computational workflow supporting interpretation of complex biological data .
Here we present an innovative and extensible solution to store and exploit analyzed omics data for the purpose of knowledge acquisition and biological interpretation. Confero enables research sites to store and manage analyzed contrast datasets and identifier (ID) lists of interest (e.g. gene lists extracted from research papers, diagnostic gene signatures), automatically compute and store gene sets from these contrast data and ID lists, and analyze data to support biological interpretation. Confero includes a local database for storage and management of data and metadata as well as tools for downstream computational analysis and biological interpretation, including gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) and over-representation analysis (ORA) . The Confero Functional Enrichment Analysis module includes specialized tools to facilitate and accelerate enrichment/over-representation analysis and extraction and interpretation of results.
The overall goal and spirit of Confero is illustrated in Figure 1. The left loop depicts the typical omics workflow from data generation, processing, and statistical analysis followed by downstream computational analysis and biological interpretation leading to new hypothesis generation. With Confero in place a second loop is added where statistical analysis results are automatically processed and new a priori biological knowledge (e.g. gene sets) is stored. This knowledge base grows with new experimental and external data and is leveraged by integrated tools for biological interpretation. The added loop in the analysis workflow facilitates and accelerates knowledge acquisition in biological research, for example in areas such as biomarker and gene function discovery, understanding of molecular mechanisms, and cross-study comparison. The overall process drives and enhances the experimental research lifecycle.
As shown in the Figure 2, processing and analysis of omics data involves a number of steps, from data acquisition and transformation, quality control (QC) (e.g. outlier detection, batch effect correction, etc.), preprocessing and normalization, and statistical analysis. According to the experimental design and biological questions of interest, statistical analysis (e.g. pairwise comparisons, multiple linear regression models) is performed to determine the effect(s) of interest (e.g. effect of treatment over time, over dosage, interaction of both time and dose, using pairwise comparison of treated and control samples, etc.) also termed the contrast(s) of interest from a dataset.
A contrast corresponds to a quantitative estimate of the differential effect between treatment and reference conditions or more generally as defined by a contrast matrix . Linear models are generally used to estimate the coefficient(s) related to the contrast(s). The estimation of contrast data including differential expression (e.g. most often corresponding to coefficient(s) of the linear model), t-statistics and p-value can be computed for any entity (gene, protein, probe set, transcript, microRNA, etc.) using the Bioconductor limma or samr packages or other statistical analysis methods [21, 22].
The Confero platform enables one to 1) convert contrast data coming from statistical analysis into a simple and standard data format, 2) process contrast data and extract gene sets, 3) store contrast data, gene sets and metadata, 4) process and store external ID lists of interest as gene sets, 5) analyze and interpret stored data using integrated tools (e.g. GSEA, ORA) and a priori knowledge sources (e.g. Confero DB, MSigDB , GeneSigDB [23, 24]), and 6) facilitate subsequent downstream analysis with a variety of data transformation and export tools. Confero runs as a standalone system and, as shown in Figure 3, all platform modules are also integrated with the Galaxy workflow management system [11–13]. An overview of all available Confero tools with high-level description is summarized in the Additional file 1: Table S1.
Advantages and strengths of platform
The Confero platform can serve a variety of different research areas, including biomarker and drug discovery, diagnostics, clinical research, consumer products (e.g. nutrition) or any area that performs omics experiments and analyses. Incorporation of such a platform into a research site’s analysis workflow provides a number of advantages, including that Confero:
Is open-source, freely installable, customizable, and easily integrates into the Galaxy bioinformatics workflow management system
Stores, manages, and leverages analyzed omics data
Enables traceable and reproducible data analysis
Compiles new biological knowledge (extraction of gene sets from contrast data and population of Confero gene set database) that can be exported and easily shared
Leverages compiled biological knowledge to analyze (e.g. GSEA or ORA) and support biological interpretation of new contrast data
Integrates public sources of a priori biological knowledge (e.g. MSigDB, GeneSigDB)
Enables dataset comparison, i.e. systems (in-vitro vs. in-vivo), organisms (human vs. mouse), treatments (interleukin 1 (IL-1) vs. tumor necrosis factor (TNF)) in a platform-independent manner
Enables further downstream data mining and meta-analysis of compiled contrast and gene set data, e.g. biomarker discovery, iterative gene set refinement
The Confero platform currently supports two types of data input. The first type corresponds to the contrast data resulting from statistical analysis (e.g. microarray or NGS RNA-seq gene expression, microRNA expression, etc.) and the second type can be a simple list of identifiers (e.g. probe set, gene, microRNA, gene symbols, etc.) processed and imported into the Confero database as external gene sets.
idMAPS file format for contrast data
To support any type of statistical analysis approach, it was necessary to devise a comprehensive yet straightforward file format to represent statistical analysis results. In addition, as Confero requires and leverages various important metadata describing input datasets, it was also necessary that the file format support encoding and passing of such metadata from the upstream workflow in a comprehensive yet independent manner. For this purpose, the idMAPS file format was designed to represent the statistical analysis results of omics experiments including experimental and analysis metadata in fields present in the header of the idMAPS file (e.g. dataset name and description, contrast names, source ID type, etc.). A utility Confero Galaxy tool, Convert LIMMA/SAMR Object (R object imported via the Upload LIMMA/SAM R Object tool) is provided to convert a Bioconductor limma or samr R object into an idMAPS file with appropriate header information which can then be used as input for the Confero Galaxy Submit Contrast Dataset tool. During the idMAPS file import, metadata are parsed and stored in the Confero database together with contrast data and gene sets. An example of the idMAPS file format is shown in Additional file 2.
Identifier list file format for external gene sets
In addition to supporting contrast data input, Confero also accepts identifier (ID) lists. An example of an ID list is shown in Additional file 3. This simple file format is a single data column of source IDs with the same Confero metadata file header as in the idMAPS data format.
Data import, processing and storage
As shown in Figure 3, idMAPS contrast datasets and ID lists are submitted for processing and loading into the Confero database using the Confero Galaxy submission tools Submit Contrast Dataset and Submit Gene Set, respectively, or via the Confero application programming interface (API). Confero utilizes a comprehensive and robust idMAPS and ID list parser and data integrity checker which, during data processing and submission, will notify users of any problems with their input file.
Input data identifier (ID) mapping and collapsing methodology
Input idMAPS and ID list data files can use a variety of different source ID types, such as Affymetrix probe set IDs, HUGO gene symbols, and Entrez Gene IDs. To compute gene sets from such data, Confero uses the latest NCBI Entrez Gene  annotations to map data to a single gene-centric ID space. For this purpose, a novel and robust ID mapping and collapsing algorithm was developed and includes the following features:
Source ID-to-multiple Entrez Gene ID mappings are fully supported and handled robustly
Entrez Gene RefSeq status information is leveraged to determine best mapping genes
Gene symbol synonyms are supported and properly mapped
Multiple available collapsing strategies
Summary report of procedure is generated and stored in Confero database along with each dataset and viewable via the Confero web application
A detailed flowchart describing the Confero ID mapping and collapsing algorithm is shown in Additional file 4: Figure S1.
Gene set extraction methodology
As prior biological knowledge, a gene set is information commonly utilized to assess enrichment (e.g. GSEA or ORA) of co-regulated genes representative of a specific biological process, pathway, chromosomal location, etc. In the context of contrast data, a gene set corresponds to a set of genes characteristic of an effect of interest. During the Confero submission process, once input data files have completed the ID mapping and collapsing procedure, the Entrez Gene ID-based processed data undergo a novel and robust procedure to extract and store gene sets. The Confero platform builds a gene set database from all imported data that is then leveraged by Confero tools.
Each contrast in a dataset has at least three gene sets automatically generated and named with the following suffixes: the UP (up-regulated genes), DN (down-regulated genes), and AR (all-regulated genes) gene sets. AR gene sets are a special type used to represent the global response of a system to the applied stimulus. The Confero platform provides the user complete and granular control over how each gene set is extracted. As shown in Additional files 2 and 3, special parameters can be provided in the idMAPS metadata header to override default behavior and specify to the algorithm exactly how to proceed. One can also specify to Confero not to create gene sets for a certain contrast (e.g. an intercept coefficient of a linear model) or even for an entire dataset. Different gene set extraction parameters can be specified for each contrast, such as minimum and maximum size thresholds, P (significance level, p-value, or false discovery rate (FDR)), A (average signal) and M (estimated effect of interest, e.g. log2 fold change) value thresholds, and even specific desired gene set sizes. A detailed flowchart describing the Confero gene set extraction algorithm is shown in Additional file 5: Figure S2.
Data management and export
The Confero platform provides an integrated web application to view and manage data and metadata in the Confero database. The web application operates independently of Galaxy but for convenience Confero also embeds it into the Galaxy user interface as the View and Manage Data tool. The web application also allows users to export source data, processed data, generated gene sets and data processing reports via the user interface or via the Confero API. Confero also provides an Extract Gene Set Matrix Galaxy tool to generate and export boolean gene set-to-gene membership matrices and an Extract Gene Set Overlap Matrix tool to extract gene set-to-gene set overlap matrices (i.e. number/percentage of shared genes between two gene sets).
Functional enrichment analysis module for biological interpretation
Functional enrichment analysis is commonly used to support biological interpretation of gene expression data. The Confero platform currently supports: 1) over-representation analysis (ORA) and 2) gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA), a commonly used and powerful approach for biological data interpretation . An important advantage of GSEA is that full contrast data (e.g. genome-wide expression profiles) can be analyzed in a p-value threshold independent manner unlike other approaches such as ORA.
Both approaches require as inputs a gene list (partial list for ORA and full ranked list for GSEA) and a collection of gene sets used as a priori knowledge. A targeted choice of gene sets selected for analyses can provide insight to specific biological questions. We developed a fully integrated Functional Enrichment Analysis module which can seamlessly use Confero contrast data and gene sets (Figure 3; Additional file 1: Table S1). The code and reporting for ORA was developed internally. For GSEA, Confero uses the Broad Institute’s GSEA Java implementation and results reporting . Importantly, Confero dynamically customizes the GSEA results report and provides several tools to accelerate downstream analysis of results. The Functional Enrichment Analysis module includes the following tools:
Create Ranked or DEG Lists: gene lists can be easily generated from contrast data in the Confero database using the statistic (S, moderated t-statistic) or differential expression value (e.g. M, log2 fold change) data as the rank metric for GSEA, or using the significance level (P) for ORA (further leveraged to filter the gene list while using the Analyze Data functionality described below).
Analyze Data: ranked and DEG (p-value threshold defined by the user) lists can be analyzed for gene set enrichment/over-representation against dynamically definable Confero gene set collections using annotation filters as well as the latest MSigDB and GeneSigDB gene set collections. The selection of analysis algorithm (GSEA Preranked or ORA (Hypergeometric Test)) conditions the Galaxy menu displayed to choose specific parameters for the analysis.
Extract Leading Edge Matrix: leading edge matrices of various types can be extracted from a GSEA result; the leading edge matrix is comprised of GSEA leading edge genes (in rows) from all gene sets in the result (in columns) passing a specified FDR threshold with rank metric score, rank in list, or boolean membership values as the matrix fields.
Extract Results Matrix: a comprehensive results matrix with user selected output columns can be extracted from one or more functional enrichment analysis results.
In summary, the Confero Functional Enrichment Analysis module allows biologists to compare datasets in a contextual manner (e.g. by organism, cell/tissue type, stimulus type, experimental system, etc.) and to more efficiently identify underlying molecular mechanisms based on biological interpretation of results.
Results and discussion
Case study: estrogen bioconductor dataset
To provide an example of the application of the Confero platform, we have used the estrogen expression dataset available from the Bioconductor web site . In this 2×2 factorial experiment, MCF7 breast cancer cells were treated with estrogen for 10 or 48 hours. The experimental factors were as follows: “estrogen treatment” with conditions present or absent, and “time” also with two conditions 10 or 48 hours. Following extraction, RNA was hybridized on to Affymetrix HG_U95Av2 microarrays. The purpose of this study was to identify early and late biological processes driven by estrogen putative direct target genes for early response, while for later events the response might be driven by more downstream targets in the molecular pathway.
Raw data (CEL files) were preprocessed and normalized as described in the Confero platform overview schema (Figure 2). The Bioconductor limma package was used to compute contrasts corresponding to the effect of estrogen at 10 (early) and 48 (late) hours (estrogen treatment vs. control comparison for each time point). Additionally, the contrast corresponding to the interaction effect was computed to directly investigate the differential effect of estrogen treatment at 10 and 48 hours. The output limma R object from the eBayes R function (see Additional file 6) was imported into Galaxy using the Confero Upload LIMMA/SAM R Object tool. Data for each contrast, including log2 fold changes (M) between control and estrogen treatment conditions, probeset average signal (A), moderated-t statistic (S), and associated FDR (P), were automatically extracted from the R object and converted into idMAPS format using the Confero Convert LIMMA/SAM R Object tool (see Figure 3, Additional file 2 and Additional file 1: Table S1). The idMAPS file was then imported into the Confero database using the Submit Contrast Dataset tool (Figure 3 and Additional file 1: Table S1). To note, it is also possible to directly import an already formatted idMAPS file into the Confero platform without using the Convert LIMMA/SAM R Object tool (Figure 3 and Additional file 1: Table S1). A summary report shows how the contrast dataset was processed and imported as well as information on the gene sets (UP, DN, and AR) extracted and stored for each contrast (Figure 4). In this example, 169, 105 and 274 most significantly up-, down- and all-regulated genes (FDR<0.05) were respectively extracted as gene sets UP, DN and AR from the contrast data “Estro10” (comparison of gene expression levels of estrogen vs control samples collected at 10h). Stored in Confero database, these gene sets represent gene expression perturbation fingerprints of estrogen effect on MCF7 at 10h and could be further leveraged as a priori knowledge to analyze and compare new datasets. Contrast data and gene sets derived from the Estrogen data analysis can be accessed and visualized using the View and Manage Data tool as shown in Figures 5 and 6.
To unravel biological processes/pathways regulated by estrogen at the early and late time points, GSEA was performed on the imported contrast data from the estrogen dataset. The Confero Create Ranked or DEG Lists tool was used to generate a ranked genome-wide differential expression profile for each contrast of the dataset using the moderated-t statistic data column (S) as ranking metric. With these ranked profiles (i.e. “Estro10”, “Estro48”, and “Interaction”) as input, the Confero Analyze Data tool was used to set up options and parameters to perform GSEA or ORA (Figures 3, 7 and 8). As an example of GSEA used in the context of this study case, the MSigDB C2 gene set collection from the Broad Institute was selected as a priori knowledge. Over time, Confero DB is automatically populated by gene sets as new contrast data or manually curated gene sets are imported into the database. Therefore, having the ability to filter gene sets in a specific manner is crucial to have the possibility to address specific biological questions. A filtering functionality is currently available in the Analyze Data tool and will be enhanced in future developments (Figures 3 and 7; Additional file 1: Table S1). The generated GSEA and ORA results for each contrast are directly accessible via the Galaxy user interface (Figures 9 and 10). The investigation of GSEA results through the report on the web is generally a long and tedious process to interpret the results. Indeed, researchers typically have to manually analyze the results sifting through the report for each contrast and drilling down to each gene set to access the associated leading edge genes. Therefore, to facilitate and accelerate analyzing results and biological interpretation, the Confero Extract Results Matrix tool was used to extract all related GSEA results into a tab-delimited spreadsheet file (see Additional file 7). The user has the flexibility to select which GSEA results to be extracted. The file contains normalized enrichment scores (NES), NES-associated false discovery rate (FDR) and eventually ranks at which NES is observed in the ranked gene list for all analyzed Estrogen contrast data (i.e. “Estro10”, “Estro48”, and “Interaction”). When interpreting GSEA results, it is generally important to identify which genes contribute the most to the enrichment of significant gene sets. To determine this, the Confero Extract Leading Edge Matrix tool was used to extract all leading edge genes from gene sets having FDR values below a user-defined threshold (default value of 0.05) into a single output matrix (see Additional file 8). This customizable output matrix can contain boolean values, moderated-t statistic values (see Additional file 8), or gene rank. This file provides to the biologist more granular molecular insights for interpretation by identifying genes which contribute the most to significant enrichment of observed perturbed biological processes.
Overall, the result files generated by the Confero platform tools enable more rapid and efficient biological interpretation of data. Indeed, the GSEA results matrix can be directly leveraged to identify significant gene sets per contrast and also search for enrichment patterns across contrasts similarly to Figure 11. Grouping gene sets per biological processes and investigating the leading edge genes associated to significantly enriched gene sets enables to rapidly interpret biological events at the molecular level and raise new hypothesis that could further be experimentally verified. As shown in 11, the results highlight that processes corresponding mainly to cell cycle and metabolism were activated in MCF7 cells exposed to estrogen. The pattern of gene set enrichment over time seemed to indicate that the proportion of MCF7 cells in different phases of the cell cycle diverged at early and late time points. Indeed, enrichment of genes representative of the G1 and S-phases were more important at 10 hours, whereas enrichment of genes involved in G2 and M-phases was predominant at 48 hours. Therefore, it was possible to follow the enrichment profile over time for genes implicated in processes coupled to growth and division of cells: activation of protein synthesis machinery, lipid and sugar metabolism to provide energy to the cell, nucleotide metabolism required for DNA replication, amino acid metabolism for protein synthesis, and decrease of cell-cell and extracellular interaction as well as cytoskeleton function, which is a phenomenon characteristic of cells under proliferation. Similar observations have been reported by other studies investigating gene expression profiles of MCF7 exposed to estradiol [29, 30]. Only at the later time point (48 hours), genes involved in oxidative phosphorylation and TCA cycle were highly enriched. This observation might suggest that either cell mitosis is accompanied by mitochondria biogenesis , or that estrogen regulates the transcription of those genes. Independent studies seem to support the latter hypothesis. Indeed, estradiol has been shown to enhance the transcript levels of mitochondrial genome-encoded genes in several cell types such as MCF7 [32, 33]. In hepatocytes, this effect was accompanied by an increase of the mitochondrial respiratory chain activity .
Galaxy integration and workflows
The Confero platform functions as a standalone system and, as shown in Figure 3, can also be fully integrated into the Galaxy reproducible research framework which allows sites to easily incorporate Confero into their existing analysis and knowledge acquisition workflows. Galaxy offers the possibility to chain as well as parallelize, in a customized and flexible way, Confero tools via Galaxy’s workflow framework. For example, the Confero Functional Enrichment Analysis module tools can be connected in a workflow to efficiently analyze data and extract results in parallel.
Public data update and confero database reprocessing
Vendor technology platform and public Entrez Gene information and annotations update frequently and since all Confero gene sets are computed utilizing this information over time the Confero gene set database would become stale and out-of-date. In addition, if a site chose to change Confero platform configuration parameters for data processing and/or gene set extraction it would be important that this change propagate not only to new data but to all existing data stored in the Confero database. An important and powerful management feature of the Confero software platform is the ability to automatically download and update all relevant and supported vendor technology platform and public gene information and then, using this information, fully reprocess all data contained in the Confero database utilizing current desired configuration parameters. Processed datasets are tagged with processing date and annotation build versions to ensure analysis reproducibility. This functionality is provided by a management program within the Confero distribution.
The Confero distribution currently supports Affymetrix, Illumina, and any NCBI GEO-derived microarray platform as well as all HUGO gene symbols. The management program automatically downloads source annotation files and Entrez Gene information to generate new mapping files. Adding support for other technology platforms (e.g. Exiqon, Nimblegen, etc.) is also possible. For NGS platforms, currently gene level data and analysis is supported.
Management features and application programming interface (API)
Confero provides a number of useful management functionalities neatly packaged as server-side programs for administrators and software platform managers. This includes programs to perform the following tasks:
Process and submit batches of contrast datasets or ID lists
Download, process, and load the latest vendor annotations and Entrez Gene information to generate new Confero source-to-Entrez Gene ID mapping files and fully reprocessing all Confero database data
Control the Confero embedded web server and application
Export the entire Confero gene set database with annotations
The API currently provides functions to export different data from the platform.
Comparison to existing software
The Confero platform provides a unique set of functionalities and differs from existing publicly available software in a number of key aspects. Currently, there are other systems, such as Cistrome  and the Genomic HyperBrowser , which also have Galaxy integration. In contrast with Confero these systems are focused on certain types of omics data types and are not provided as a software distribution that can be installed locally to work with private as well as public data. Other systems such as TM4 [7, 36], provide some similar analysis functionalities such as GSEA. Yet these systems are only all-in-one standalone solutions, not integrated with popular workflow management systems like Galaxy, and do not process imported data to build a database of a priori biological knowledge that is then leveraged by system tools. Finally, ArrayExpress and GEO, the two major public repositories, provide tools [37–41] to mine data across a subset of curated and preprocessed studies in their databases. However, such tools are clearly limited to what is available in their systems and cannot be locally installed to work with private data. In addition, many of these systems start with raw/preprocessed data and perform automated statistical analysis, which in Confero a deliberate design choice was made to allow each site the freedom to have customized statistical analysis approaches appropriate for each experimental design and relevant biological questions.
Storage and exploitation of analyzed omics data is a crucial component of a research site’s analysis workflow as it enables acquisition of new biological knowledge which facilitates interpretation of data. However, these needs are not met by the current open-source solutions freely available to researchers. The Confero platform has been built to provide an innovative, flexible and extensible solution to store and leverage analyzed data and build new a priori biological knowledge. In addition, Confero enables cross-platform comparison of omics data in a traceable and reproducible manner.
While GSEA or ORA provide a useful global overview of the perturbed biological processes occurring during an experiment, there are a number of potential methods that can further utilize Confero data to gain a more detailed understanding of underlying mechanisms. We are currently developing additional integrated tools in the following areas:
Clustering module to group Confero data (e.g. gene sets, genes, etc.) in order to highlight patterns of co-regulation in experimental data
Visualization module to provide integrated and easy-to-use plotting functions (e.g. volcano plots) on Confero results
HomoloGene infrastructure and integration to provide cleaner species-to-species translation during gene set enrichment analysis
Incorporation of additional analysis tools to provide complementary approaches to GSEA for biological interpretation
Availability and requirements
An overview of the Confero platform software architecture is shown in Additional file 9: Figure S3. Confero is written using the Perl  programming language and requires Perl 5.12 or higher. To use the Convert LIMMA/SAMR Object tool, an R version and the Bioconductor limma and samr packages should be installed. The Confero platform requires a backend database and MySQL  is currently supported. MySQL 5.0 or higher (5.1 and 5.5) have been fully tested and are being used in production installations. Confero can be installed on any UNIX like operating system (e.g. BSD, Linux, etc.) and has been fully tested and used in production using the Linux operating system. The documentation for the Confero command line interface (CLI) is provided as Additional file 10 and is also available on SourceForge (http://sourceforge.net/projects/confero/).
Application programming interface
Comprehensive perl archive network
Database management system
False discovery rate
Gene expression omnibus
Gene set enrichment analysis
Differentially expressed genes
Command line interface.
Workspace cSP: The Cancer Biomedical Informatics Grid (caBIG): infrastructure and applications for a worldwide research community. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2007, 129: 330-334.
Maurer M, Molidor R, Sturn A, Hartler J, Hackl H, Stocker G, Prokesch A, Scheideler M, Trajanoski Z: MARS: microarray analysis, retrieval, and storage system. BMC Bioinforma. 2005, 6: 101-10.1186/1471-2105-6-101.
Vallon-Christersson J, Nordborg N, Svensson M, Hakkinen J: BASE–2nd generation software for microarray data management and analysis. BMC Bioinforma. 2009, 10: 330-10.1186/1471-2105-10-330.
Dondrup M, Albaum SP, Griebel T, Henckel K, Junemann S, Kahlke T, Kleindt CK, Kuster H, Linke B, Mertens D: EMMA 2–a MAGE-compliant system for the collaborative analysis and integration of microarray data. BMC Bioinforma. 2009, 10: 50-10.1186/1471-2105-10-50.
Gattiker A, Hermida L, Liechti R, Xenarios I, Collin O, Rougemont J, Primig M: MIMAS 3.0 is a Multiomics Information Management and Annotation System. BMC Bioinforma. 2009, 10: 151-10.1186/1471-2105-10-151.
Hermida L, Schaad O, Demougin P, Descombes P, Primig M: MIMAS: an innovative tool for network-based high density oligonucleotide microarray data management and annotation. BMC Bioinforma. 2006, 7: 190-10.1186/1471-2105-7-190.
Saeed AI, Bhagabati NK, Braisted JC, Liang W, Sharov V, Howe EA, Li J, Thiagarajan M, White JA, Quackenbush J: TM4 microarray software suite. Methods Enzymol. 2006, 411: 134-193.
Lin K, Kools H, de Groot PJ, Gavai AK, Basnet RK, Cheng F, Wu J, Wang X, Lommen A, Hooiveld GJ: MADMAX - Management and analysis database for multiple omics experiments. J Integr Bioinform. 2011, 8: 160-
Tomlinson C, Thimma M, Alexandrakis S, Castillo T, Dennis JL, Brooks A, Bradley T, Turnbull C, Blaveri E, Barton G: MiMiR–an integrated platform for microarray data sharing, mining and analysis. BMC Bioinforma. 2008, 9: 379-10.1186/1471-2105-9-379.
Friedman BA, Maniatis T: ExpressionPlot: a web-based framework for analysis of RNA-Seq and microarray gene expression data. Genome Biol. 2011, 12: R69-10.1186/gb-2011-12-7-r69.
Goecks J, Nekrutenko A, Taylor J, Galaxy T: Galaxy: a comprehensive approach for supporting accessible, reproducible, and transparent computational research in the life sciences. Genome Biol. 2010, 11: R86-10.1186/gb-2010-11-8-r86.
Blankenberg D, Von Kuster G, Coraor N, Ananda G, Lazarus R, Mangan M, Nekrutenko A, Taylor J: Galaxy: a web-based genome analysis tool for experimentalists. Curr Protoc Mol Biol. 2010, Chapter 19: Unit 19 10 11-21.
Giardine B, Riemer C, Hardison RC, Burhans R, Elnitski L, Shah P, Zhang Y, Blankenberg D, Albert I, Taylor J: Galaxy: a platform for interactive large-scale genome analysis. Genome Res. 2005, 15: 1451-1455. 10.1101/gr.4086505.
Reich M, Liefeld T, Gould J, Lerner J, Tamayo P, Mesirov JP: GenePattern 2.0. Nat Genet. 2006, 38: 500-501. 10.1038/ng0506-500.
Hull D, Wolstencroft K, Stevens R, Goble C, Pocock MR, Li P, Oinn T: Taverna: a tool for building and running workflows of services. Nucleic Acids Res. 2006, 34: W729-W732. 10.1093/nar/gkl320.
Ghosh S, Matsuoka Y, Asai Y, Hsin KY, Kitano H: Software for systems biology: from tools to integrated platforms. Nat Rev Genet. 2011, 12: 821-832.
Subramanian A, Tamayo P, Mootha VK, Mukherjee S, Ebert BL, Gillette MA, Paulovich A, Pomeroy SL, Golub TR, Lander ES, Mesirov JP: Gene set enrichment analysis: a knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profiles. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2005, 102: 15545-15550. 10.1073/pnas.0506580102.
Smyth GK: Linear models and empirical bayes methods for assessing differential expression in microarray experiments. Stat Appl Genet Mol Biol. 2004, 3: Article3-
Gentleman RC, Carey VJ, Bates DM, Bolstad B, Dettling M, Dudoit S, Ellis B, Gautier L, Ge Y, Gentry J: Bioconductor: open software development for computational biology and bioinformatics. Genome Biol. 2004, 5: R80-10.1186/gb-2004-5-10-r80.
Tusher VG, Tibshirani R, Chu G: Significance analysis of microarrays applied to the ionizing radiation response. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2001, 98: 5116-5121. 10.1073/pnas.091062498.
Mansourian R, Mutch DM, Antille N, Aubert J, Fogel P, Le Goff JM, Moulin J, Petrov A, Rytz A, Voegel JJ, Roberts MA: The Global Error Assessment (GEA) model for the selection of differentially expressed genes in microarray data. Bioinformatics. 2004, 20: 2726-2737. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bth319.
Kim SY, Lee JW, Sohn IS: Comparison of various statistical methods for identifying differential gene expression in replicated microarray data. Stat Methods Med Res. 2006, 15: 3-20. 10.1191/0962280206sm423oa.
Culhane AC, Schroder MS, Sultana R, Picard SC, Martinelli EN, Kelly C, Haibe-Kains B, Kapushesky M, St Pierre AA, Flahive W: GeneSigDB: a manually curated database and resource for analysis of gene expression signatures. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012, 40: D1060-D1066. 10.1093/nar/gkr901.
Culhane AC, Schwarzl T, Sultana R, Picard KC, Picard SC, Lu TH, Franklin KR, French SJ, Papenhausen G, Correll M, Quackenbush J: GeneSigDB–a curated database of gene expression signatures. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010, 38: D716-D725. 10.1093/nar/gkp1015.
Dinu I, Potter JD, Mueller T, Liu Q, Adewale AJ, Jhangri GS, Einecke G, Famulski KS, Halloran P, Yasui Y: Improving gene set analysis of microarray data by SAM-GS. BMC Bioinforma. 2007, 8: 242-10.1186/1471-2105-8-242.
Kupershmidt I, Su QJ, Grewal A, Sundaresh S, Halperin I, Flynn J, Shekar M, Wang H, Park J, Cui W: Ontology-based meta-analysis of global collections of high-throughput public data. PLoS One. 2010, 5 (9): e13066-10.1371/journal.pone.0013066.
Maglott D, Ostell J, Pruitt KD, Tatusova T: Entrez Gene: gene-centered information at NCBI. Nucleic Acids Res. 2011, 39: D52-D57. 10.1093/nar/gkq1237.
Bioconductor estrogen dataset.http://www.bioconductor.org/packages/release/data/experiment/html/estrogen.html,
Gadal F, Starzec A, Bozic C, Pillot-Brochet C, Malinge S, Ozanne V, Vicenzi J, Buffat L, Perret G, Iris F, Crepin M: Integrative analysis of gene expression patterns predicts specific modulations of defined cell functions by estrogen and tamoxifen in MCF7 breast cancer cells. J Mol Endocrinol. 2005, 34: 61-75. 10.1677/jme.1.01631.
Frasor J, Danes JM, Komm B, Chang KC, Lyttle CR, Katzenellenbogen BS: Profiling of estrogen up- and down-regulated gene expression in human breast cancer cells: insights into gene networks and pathways underlying estrogenic control of proliferation and cell phenotype. Endocrinology. 2003, 144: 4562-4574. 10.1210/en.2003-0567.
Martinez-Diez M, Santamaria G, Ortega AD, Cuezva JM: Biogenesis and dynamics of mitochondria during the cell cycle: significance of 3'UTRs. PLoS One. 2006, 1: e107-10.1371/journal.pone.0000107.
Chen JQ, Delannoy M, Cooke C, Yager JD: Mitochondrial localization of ERalpha and ERbeta in human MCF7 cells. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2004, 286: E1011-E1022. 10.1152/ajpendo.00508.2003.
Chen J, Delannoy M, Odwin S, He P, Trush MA, Yager JD: Enhanced mitochondrial gene transcript, ATP, bcl-2 protein levels, and altered glutathione distribution in ethinyl estradiol-treated cultured female rat hepatocytes. Toxicol Sci. 2003, 75: 271-278. 10.1093/toxsci/kfg183.
Liu T, Ortiz JA, Taing L, Meyer CA, Lee B, Zhang Y, Shin H, Wong SS, Ma J, Lei Y: Cistrome: an integrative platform for transcriptional regulation studies. Genome Biol. 2011, 12: R83-10.1186/gb-2011-12-8-r83.
Sandve GK, Gundersen S, Rydbeck H, Glad IK, Holden L, Holden M, Liestol K, Clancy T, Ferkingstad E, Johansen M: The Genomic HyperBrowser: inferential genomics at the sequence level. Genome Biol. 2010, 11: R121-10.1186/gb-2010-11-12-r121.
Saeed AI, Sharov V, White J, Li J, Liang W, Bhagabati N, Braisted J, Klapa M, Currier T, Thiagarajan M: TM4: a free, open-source system for microarray data management and analysis. Biotechniques. 2003, 34: 374-378.
Kapushesky M, Adamusiak T, Burdett T, Culhane A, Farne A, Filippov A, Holloway E, Klebanov A, Kryvych N, Kurbatova N: Gene Expression Atlas update–a value-added database of microarray and sequencing-based functional genomics experiments. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012, 40: D1077-D1081. 10.1093/nar/gkr913.
Kapushesky M, Emam I, Holloway E, Kurnosov P, Zorin A, Malone J, Rustici G, Williams E, Parkinson H, Brazma A: Gene expression atlas at the European bioinformatics institute. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010, 38: D690-D698. 10.1093/nar/gkp936.
Barrett T, Troup DB, Wilhite SE, Ledoux P, Rudnev D, Evangelista C, Kim IF, Soboleva A, Tomashevsky M, Edgar R: NCBI GEO: mining tens of millions of expression profiles–database and tools update. Nucleic Acids Res. 2007, 35: D760-D765. 10.1093/nar/gkl887.
Barrett T, Troup DB, Wilhite SE, Ledoux P, Rudnev D, Evangelista C, Kim IF, Soboleva A, Tomashevsky M, Marshall KA: NCBI GEO: archive for high-throughput functional genomic data. Nucleic Acids Res. 2009, 37: D885-D890. 10.1093/nar/gkn764.
Barrett T, Troup DB, Wilhite SE, Ledoux P, Evangelista C, Kim IF, Tomashevsky M, Marshall KA, Phillippy KH, Sherman PM: NCBI GEO: archive for functional genomics data sets–10 years on. Nucleic Acids Res. 2011, 39: D1005-D1010. 10.1093/nar/gkq1184.
Perl Programming Language.http://www.perl.org/,
MySQL Database Management System: MySQL Database Management System. MySQL Database Management System, MySQL Database Management System: MySQL Database Management System,http://www.mysql.org/,
The authors would like to thank Dean Flanders for his assistance and support during project development at the Friedrich Miescher Institute.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests. PMI and FMI authors performed this work under a research collaboration funded by PMI.
LH, CP, MBS, AS, DG, and HRH conceived the project and developed algorithms and feature requirements. LH designed and wrote all software and database platform code except for LIMMA/SAMR-to-idMAPS converter tool code designed and written by SG. The ORA tool has been designed, written and integrated by CP, SG and SC. FM and VB made significant contributions to the mapping and collapsing algorithm. SG and SC have released Confero software on Sourceforge. LH and CP wrote the manuscript. JH and MCP contributed to the manuscript and supported the project. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Leandro Hermida, Carine Poussin contributed equally to this work.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 2: estrogen dataset. The file format includes the following characteristics: • Simple, tab-delimited file format with data column header row and file header to encode metadata and other important user-defined parameters relevant to data processing. • The first data column always contains the source IDs for each data row. Source IDs can come from any technology platform supported by Confero, i.e. any platform where ID mapping data is defined. • Data column header letters represent the important statistical analysis results: M is the estimated effect of interest (e.g. log2 fold change), A is the average signal, P is the significance level (p-value or false discovery rate (FDR)), and S is the statistic (e.g. moderated t-statistic). • Contrast data derived from the same statistical analysis (i.e. a contrast dataset) are represented by repeating groups of data columns (e.g. MAPSMAPSMAPS…) as a matrix in the same file. • Data columns may be in any order (e.g. APSM, SAPM, MASP, etc.) as long as they are in the same order for each contrast (e.g. AMSPAMSPAMSP…). • Certain data columns may be omitted if they do not exist. The minimum requirements are the data column M and that each group within a dataset must have the same data column(s). Additional arbitrary data columns not used by Confero may be included for each contrast which are stored and passed through during data processing. (TXT 2 MB)
Additional file 3:Example of ID list file format using Gene Ontology (GO) Inflammatory Response biological process. The file contains header lines that provides a description of the gene list (“gene_set_desc”), indicates the type of ID used (Entrez gene ID can also be used) (“id_type”) and the organism from which the gene list is derived from. (TXT 1 KB)
Additional file 4: Figure S1: Confero dataset ID mapping and collapsing algorithm flowchart. This figure depicts the steps enabling to go from the original idMAPS data matrix to a mapped and collapsed data matrix ready for downstream GSEA or other analysis which requires no multiple probesets per gene (Gene centric). (PDF 148 KB)
Additional file 6: limma object from Bioconductor estrogen dataset pairwise comparison statistical analysis.(RDAT 2 MB)
Additional file 7: estrogen dataset MSigDB canonical pathways GSEA results matrix from Extract Results Matrix tool. All GSEA results for the analysis of several contrasts can be extracted in a single file using the Extract Results Matrix tool.The columns respectively correspond to gene set name, normalized enrichment scores (NES), NES-associated false discovery rate (FDR) and rank (for which the maximum enrichment score is identified in the ranked gene list) for the selected analyzed contrasts. The tool provides flexibility to select the contrasts and GSEA result parameters to be exported. (XLS 87 KB)
Additional file 8: estrogen dataset 10 hour time point MSigDB canonical pathways GSEA leading edge matrix from Confero Extract Leading Edge Matrix tool. When interpreting GSEA results, it is generally important to identify which genes contribute the most to the enrichment of significant gene sets. The Confero Extract Leading Edge Matrix tool was designed to extract all leading edge genes (as rows) from gene sets (as columns) having FDR values below a user-defined threshold (default value of 0.05) into a single output matrix. This customizable output matrix can contain boolean values, moderated-t statistic values (current view), or gene rank. (XLS 151 KB)
Additional file 9:Confero software architecture schematic diagram showing the various platform components and how they integrate with each other. Users currently interact with Confero via the web browser or command line interface (CLI). Users execute Confero tools via the Galaxy user interface or CLI commands and can view and manage data in Confero via the Confero web application. Users can leverage Galaxy functionalities with Confero tools such as workflow building and execution, parallel and asynchronous job processing, and sharing and publishing of results. Confero administration is performed using management scripts which update annotations from NCBI Entrez Gene, Affymetrix, Illumina, Agilent, and GEO and then can reprocess Confero DB data using updated annotations. (PDF 2 MB)
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Hermida, L., Poussin, C., Stadler, M.B. et al. Confero: an integrated contrast data and gene set platform for computational analysis and biological interpretation of omics data. BMC Genomics 14, 514 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2164-14-514
- Gene expression
- Contrast data
- Gene set
- Gene set enrichment
- Next-generation sequencing
- Reproducible research system
- Knowledge acquisition