Identification and characterization of microRNAs in Humulus lupulus using high-throughput sequencing and their response to Citrus bark cracking viroid (CBCVd) infection

Abstract

Background

Hop (Humulus lupulus L.) plants are grown primarily for the brewing industry and have been used as a traditional medicinal herb for a long time. Severe hop stunt disease caused by the recently discovered Citrus bark cracking viroid (CBCVd) is one of the most devastating diseases among other viroid infections in hop. MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are a class of non-coding small RNAs that play important roles in gene expression regulation. To identify miRNAs in hop and their response to CBCVd-infection, two small RNA (sRNA) libraries were prepared from healthy and CBCVd-infected hop plants and were investigated by high throughput sequencing.

Results

A total of 67 conserved and 49 novel miRNAs were identified. Among them, 36 conserved and 37 novel miRNAs were found to be differentially recovered in response to CBCVd-infection. A total of 311 potential targets was predicted for conserved and novel miRNAs based on a sequence homology search using hop transcriptome data. The majority of predicted targets significantly belonged to transcriptional factors that may regulate hop leaf, root and cone growth and development. In addition, the identified miRNAs might also play an important roles in other cellular and metabolic processes, such as signal transduction, stress response and other physiological processes, including prenylflavonoid biosynthesis pathways. Quantitative real time PCR analysis of selected targets revealed their negative correlation with their corresponding CBCVd-responsive miRNAs.

Conclusions

Based on the results, we concluded that CBCVd-responsive miRNAs modulate several hormone pathways and transcriptional factors that play important roles in the regulation of metabolism, growth and development. These results provide a framework for further analysis of regulatory roles of sRNAs in plant defense mechanism including other hop infecting viroids in particular.

Background

Endogenous small RNAs (sRNAs) consist of 18–24 nucleotides (nt) which act as an important regulatory molecules to regulate the gene expression at the transcriptional and post-transcriptional levels [1]. The content of sRNA in plant cells is intriguingly variable and complex, indicating their extensive regulatory role in different biological processes. The endogenous small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) can be classified into several classes based on their biogenesis pathways, genomic loci origin and biological function, such as trans-acting siRNAs (tasiRNAs), chromatin-associated siRNAs, repeat-associated siRNAs (rasiRNAs) and natural antisense transcript-associated siRNAs (nat-siRNAs) [2]. All these siRNAs are usually processed by the action of DICER-like enzymes from double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) precursors, derived from transgenes, endogenous repeat sequences or transposons through various mechanisms [3]. In plants, mature miRNAs are short (21–24 nt) in length and most of their coding genes (MIR genes) consist of independent transcriptional unit with their own regulatory promoters [4]. As with animals, RNA polymerase II mediates the transcription of MIR genes, yielding single strand primary miRNAs (pri-miRNA), which are stabilized by the incorporation of a 5′ 7-methylguanosine cap [5] and a 3′ polyadenylate tail [6]. In plants, pri-miRNAs mainly consist of a length of 70–400 nt that can fold into self-complementary stem-loop structures. However, unlike animal miRNAs, the processing of plant miRNAs occurs in the nucleus, via two sequential step processing by a family of four Dicer-like (DCL) RNase III endonucleases [7]. The initial step includes the formation of complex with the aid of the the dsRNA-binding protein HYPONASTIC LEAVES 1 (HYL1), C2H2 zinc-finger protein SERRATE (SE), DCL and the nuclear cap-binding protein complex that cleaves the pri-miRNA near the base of the stem to yield a double-stranded intermediate miRNA: passenger strand (miRNA*) duplex known as pre-miRNA [8]. The 3′ end of the sugars of the miRNA:miRNA* duplex is methylated by HUA ENHANCER 1 (HEN1) [8] and the passenger strand is usually degraded but may also sometimes function as a miRNA [9]. The pre-miRNAs or mature miRNAs are subsequently exported to the cytoplasm by HASTY (HST) with the assistance of additional unknown factors [8]. In the cytoplasm, the mature methylated miRNA strand (guide strand) is incorporated into the effector complex known as RISC (RNA-Induced Silencing Complex) [7]. As the core component of RISC, Argonaute proteins form a complex with the miRNA and direct the effector complex for silencing the target either via RNA degradation or translational repression [10]. In plants, miRNAs are involved in the regulation of various biological processes, such as leaf, root, stem and floral organ morphogenesis and development, biosynthesis, metabolism and homeostasis, vegetative to reproductive growth phase transition, senescence, signal transduction and response to biotic/abiotic stresses [3, 9, 11], including drought [12], salinity [13], oxidative [14], hypoxia [15], nutrient stresses [16] and micronutrient deficiency or toxicity [17].

An increasing number of miRNAs have so far been discovered and deposited in the miRBase database [18] (Release Version 21.0, June 2014, http://www.mirbase.org/). Among the available 35,828 mature miRNAs, this database contains information on 19,724 plant miRNAs and miRNAs* from a total of 153 species [18]. Phylogenetic analysis of miRNAs from different plant species has suggested that many plant miRNAs are evolutionarily conserved, which is supported by observation of some common miRNAs between ferns and flowering plants [19]. Strikingly, some miRNAs are species-specific, suggesting their recent evolution as compared to conserved miRNAs [20]. These non-conserved miRNAs are more moderately expressed than conserved miRNAs and most of them have not been detected in small-scale sequencing projects [21]. High-throughput sequencing technologies are a widely used, powerful approach for the identification and the characterization of miRNAs expression profiling among different tissues according to their relative abundance at unprecedented perspectives [21]. The approach has been successfully used to discover novel miRNAs (which are generally expressed at a lower level), due to its ability to generate millions of reads randomly and independently with a determined length, which is implausible to identify by sequencing a low number of clones (sRNA library sequencing) or in situ hybridization-based methods (sRNA Northern blot and miRNA array analyses) [22]. Over the past years, high-throughput sequencing technologies have been implemented to investigate miRNAs across different plant species such as maize [23], potato [24], peanut [25], barley [26], soybean [27], Chinese cabbage [28], mulberry [29] and tobacco [30].

Hop (Humulus lupulus L., Cannabaceae) is a dioecious, herbaceous, climbing perennial flowering plant native to Europe, western Asia and North America. The lupulin glands of female inflorescences (also called cones or strobiles) consist of biosynthetic cells, which synthesize specific and complex metabolomes known as terpenophenolics (hop bitter acids and prenylflavonoids) and terpenoids (essential oil components), which serve as an important raw component in beer for their unique bitterness, flavour and preservative activity [31]. In addition, hop has been attributed with health benefits, including as a relaxative and sleep inducer, an anti-inflammatory agent, an estrogenic effect, antioxidant activity and cancer chemo-preventive properties [32].

Viroids are members of the smallest known pathogenic agent and cause several diseases in a wide range of host plants, including many crops [33]. They consist of single-stranded, circular, non-coding RNA with genomes ranging in size from 250 to 400 nt. Replication is solely dependent on the host transcriptional and processing machinery and cellular pathways are utilized for the transport of the resulting progeny [34]. Previous findings suggest that, similar to mature miRNAs, viroid-mediated biological actions and pathogenic activities are associated with the generation of small viroid-specific small RNAs (vsRNA), which are processed from double stranded intermediate RNA during viroid replication by the action of dicer enzymes [35]. Similar to plant endogenous small RNA, their sizes range from 21 to 24 nts in length and they have been found for Potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd) [36], Avocado sunblotch viroid (ASBVd) [37], Hop stunt viroid (HSVd) [38], Hop latent viroid (HLVd) and Citrus bark cracking viroid (CBCVd) [39]. The vsRNA regulate the host plant gene expression via target RNA degradation or translational attenuation by binding to RNA with perfect or imperfect base complementarity, thus acting as miRNA or siRNA [40]. In addition, viroid infection can cause an accumulation of host plant endogenous miRNAs, as observed in PSTVd AS1-infected tomato plants [41].

Recently identified severe hop stunt disease caused by CBCVd (a member of the Pospiviroidae family) is one of the most devastating diseases, and infection caused by CBCVd disseminates rapidly by a mechanical mode of transmission, with annual incidence progression up to 20% [39]. CBCVd-infection induces dramatic morphological and anatomical changes, which include leaf epinasty, yellowing, premature flowering and a reduction in cone size, dry root rotting, stunted growth and dieback in hop (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1

Symptoms of hop stunt disease caused by Citrus bark cracking viroid (CBCVd) in hop (cv. Celeia): An infected plant showing severe down curling and yellowing of leaves (a) compared to healthy plant leaves (b); infected cones reduced in size (c) compared to healthy cones (d) causing lower yield; dry root rot in infected plant (e) causing weaker root system, roots from healthy plants (f); characteristic bine cracking in infected plant (g)

To date, no systematic studies of miRNAs in hop plant have been performed. In this study, we analysed two deep-sequenced sRNA libraries prepared from healthy and CBCVd infected hop plants, in order to characterize the miRNAs in the hop genome and investigate their expression profile in response to CBCVd-infection. In addition, the present work will lay the foundation for further systematic analysis to elucidate the other intriguing roles of miRNAs in plant-viroid interaction.

Methods

Plant materials and RNA preparation

Healthy and CBCVd-infected specimens of the Slovenian hop cultivar ‘Celeia’ were sampled from the experimental field of the Slovenian Institute of Hop Research and Brewing (SIRHB) and naturally infected commercial fields of local farmers, which were under the surveillance of SIRHB. The presence or absence of CBCVd-infection was confirmed by visual examination and further confirmed by recently developed CBCVd-specific RT-PCR [39]. In this study, we used our previously generated Illumina sRNA raw sequence data, which has been submitted to the NCBI Sequence Read Archive (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra) under the series accession numbers SRX661829 for healthy (HP) and SRX661831, SRX661830 for CBCVd-infected (CIP) hop plants [39] for miRNA characterization and their differential expression profiling as a result of CBCVd-infection.

Small RNA sequencing analysis

Unique tags were generated following a series of processing steps, which included removal of low quality (>30% of bases with Phred score <20) reads, trimming of reads containing adapter/primer contamination and poly-A tail using the FASTX toolkit (http://hannonlab.cshl.edu/fastx_toolkit/) [42] or CLC Genomics Server. Reads that matched rRNA, tRNA, snRNA, snoRNA, repeat sequences and other ncRNAs deposited in Rfam version 12 (http://rfam.xfam.org/) and the GenBank non-coding RNA database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/) were discarded after searching with the cmsearch tool. The filtered reads obtained from CIP and HP were processed using the plant-specific parameterized probabilistic-model-based miR-PREFeR core algorithm [43] by exploring the scoring system, which includes the secondary structure, the dicer cleavage site, the minimum free energy, the presence of star miRNA evidence and other criteria mentioned earlier [44]. The remaining non-redundant cleaned reads were mapped to the hop draft genome sequence [45] using bowtie-align-reads.py script, which is a wrapper for the bowtie mapper. The main script miR_PREFeR.py was used for de-novo identification of novel miRNAs, using a bowtie aligned SAM file, a hop reference genome with the following configuration parameters (GFF File = none, Precursor Len = 600 and Reads depth cutoff = 3). The accuracy and performance of miR-PREFeR, with its characteristic plant-specific scoring system, has been documented as being superior to other NGS-based miRNA prediction tools [46].

Prediction and validation of hop miRNA target genes

The available hop transcriptome database (NCBI accession number: GAAW00000000) was downloaded and used for the prediction of potential target mRNA candidates for novel and conserved miRNAs using the psRNATarget program (http://plantgrn.noble.org/psRNATarget/) with default parameters [47]. A stringent penalty score of ≤3.0 (lower scores are better) with previously established criteria [48] was used for high specificity and low noise in miRNA target genes prediction. The predicted target transcripts of miRNAs were functionally annotated using protein databases and non-redundant nucleotide databases (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/). Conserved domains in the target transcripts were assigned by searching them against the PFAM database using the HMMscan program. Functional categories of target gene sequences were annotated against the COG database (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/COG/) using BLAST with a cut-off E value <1e⁻⁵. The Blast2GO program was used to perform gene ontology (GO) annotation of the target genes based on categories of biological processes, molecular functions and cellular components [49].

In order to locate the cleavage sites within the predicted target genes of miRNAs (hop-miR156, hop-miR164a and hop-miR171b), an RNA ligase-mediated rapid amplification of 5′ ends (RLM-5′ RACE) experiment was carried out using GeneRacer Kit (Invitrogen, USA) following the manufacturer’s instructions. Two micrograms of total RNA isolated from leaves was directly ligated to the 5′ RACE oligo adaptor without enzymatic pretreatment. The resultant ligated products were reverse transcribed and further PCR amplified with gene specific primers (Additional file 1: Table S1). The 5′ RACE-PCR amplicons were cloned into pGEM-T Easy Vector (Promega, USA) and sequenced for each target gene.

Differential expression analyses of miRNAs

The frequency of miRNA read counts in HP and CIP tissues were normalized as transcripts per million (TPM) using equation (1).

• (1) Normalization formula: (Actual miRNA count/Total count of clean reads) × 10⁶

  Based on normalized expression analysis, the miRNA logarithmic fold-change ≥ 2.0 or fold-change ≤ −2.0, P-value <0.05 was used to judge the significance of the differentially recovered miRNAs between CIP and HP.

  The fold-change and P-value were calculated according to equations (2) and (3) respectively [50].

• (2) Fold change = log₂ (normalized read counts in CIP library/normalized read counts in HP library)

• (3) P value formula:

  $$ \begin{array}{cc}\hfill \mathrm{P}\left(\mathrm{x}\left|\mathrm{y}\right.\right)={\left(\frac{{\mathrm{N}}_2}{{\mathrm{N}}_1}\right)}^{\mathrm{y}}\frac{\left(\mathrm{x}+\mathrm{y}\right)!}{\mathrm{x}!\mathrm{y}!\left(1+\frac{{\mathrm{N}}_2}{{\mathrm{N}}_1}\right){\left(1+\frac{{\mathrm{N}}_2}{{\mathrm{N}}_1}\right)}^{\left(\mathrm{x}+\mathrm{y}+1\right)}}\hfill & \hfill \begin{array}{c}\hfill \mathrm{C}\left(\mathrm{y}\le {\mathrm{y}}_{\min}\left|\mathrm{x}\right.\right)={\displaystyle \sum_{\mathrm{y}=0}^{\mathrm{y}\le {\mathrm{y}}_{\min }}\mathrm{p}\left(\mathrm{y}\left|\mathrm{x}\right.\right)}\hfill \\ {}\hfill \mathrm{D}\left(\mathrm{y}\ge {\mathrm{y}}_{\max}\left|\mathrm{x}\right.\right)={\displaystyle \sum_{\mathrm{y}\ge {\mathrm{y}}_{\max}}^{\infty}\mathrm{p}\left(\mathrm{y}\left|\mathrm{x}\right.\right)}\hfill \end{array}\hfill \end{array} $$

  N₁ and N₂ represent the total count of clean tags in CIP and HP libraries, respectively, x and y symbolize the normalized expression level of a particular miRNA in CIP and HP libraries, respectively, C and D are considered as the probability discrete distribution of the P-value inspection. The Poisson distribution model was used to examine the statistical significance of miRNA expression changes due to CBCVd-infection [50]. A positive value was considered to be up-regulation, while a negative value was considered to be down-regulation of miRNA expression levels.

Expression analysis of miRNAs and target genes using quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR)

Stem-loop qRT-PCR and end-point PCR analyses were employed to validate the predicted hop miRNAs as described previously [51]. Primer sets (miRNA-specific stem-loop RT and forward primers, and universal reverse primer) for 15 selected CBCVd-responsive novel miRNAs and eight selected CBCVd-responsive conserved miRNAs were designed (Additional file 2: Table S2) according to recommended guidelines [51]. Small RNA was isolated from leaf, root and cone tissues of HP and CIP (cv. Celeia), using a PureLink™ miRNA Isolation Kit (Invitrogen, USA). The concentration and quality of miRNAs were measured using the Qubit® miRNA Assay Kit with the Qubit® 2.0 Fluorometer and subsequently 200 ng of miRNA was reverse transcribed into cDNA using a miRNA-specific stem-loop primer and TaqMan^® microRNA RT kit (Applied Biosystems, USA) according to the manufacturer’s instruction. The reverse transcription (RT) reactions were carried out in a 20 μl reaction volume containing 2 μl of sRNA, 50 nM stem-loop RT primer, 0.25 mM each of dNTPs, 3.33 U reverse transcriptase, 1× reverse transcriptase buffer, 10 mM DTT and 0.25 U RNase inhibitor. The RT reactions were incubated at 16 °C for 30 min, followed by pulsed RT step of 60 cycles at 30 °C for 30 s, 42 °C for 30 s, 50 °C for 1 s. Reactions were incubated at 85 °C for 5 min to inactivate the reverse transcriptase. Uniformly expressed U6 sRNA was used as the internal control for stem-loop RT-PCR experiment. End-point PCR reaction mixtures in a final volume of 20 μl consisted of 1 μl of RT product, 0.6 units of Hot Start Ex Taq polymerase (TaKaRa Bio), 1× Taq buffer, 0.25 μM each miRNA-specific forward primer and universal reverse primer and 200 μM dNTPs mixture. The PCR amplifications were performed in a thermal cycler (Bio-Rad, USA) comprised of following steps: an initial denaturation of template at 94 °C for 2 min, followed by 40 cycles of 95 °C for 15 s and 60 °C for 1 min. The amplicon size was confirmed by 4% agarose gel electrophoresis. In addition, the end-point PCR products of five randomly selected novel miRNAs (hop-miR02, hop-miR09, hop-miR17, hop-miR28 and hop-miR42) were purified using a spin-column PCR purification kit (Promega, USA) and subsequently cloned into a TOPO cloning vector following the manufacturer’s instructions (Invitrogen, USA). Positive transformants were selected randomly (ten clones each for each novel miRNA library) and inserts were sequenced using an ABI377 sequencer (Applied Biosystems, USA) with T3 and T7 primers. The resulting sequences showed perfect sequence similarities with their corresponding mature miRNA sequences listed in the database (Table 3) and thus confirmed the specificity of the stem-loop RT-PCR amplification.

Quantitative real time PCR (qRT-PCR) was performed using a Roche LightCycler 480 instrument (Roche, USA). The PCR reaction mixture (20 μL) consisted of 2 μL of three-fold diluted RT product, 0.5 μM miRNA-specific forward primer and stem-loop reverse primer, 1× Universal SYBR^® Green PCR Master Mix (Invitrogen, USA). The LightCycler program consisted of an initial denaturing step at 95 °C for 10 min, followed by 45 cycles of 95 °C for 15 s and 60 °C for 60 s. Melting curves were generated using the following program: PCR products were denatured at 95 °C and cooled to 65 °C at a rate of 20 °C per second to determine the specificity of each reaction. The fluorescence signal at a wavelength of 530 nm was monitored continuously from 65 to 95 °C with an increase of temperature at a rate of 0.2 °C per second. All reactions were repeated three times and included no-template control and no reverse transcriptase as negative controls for each miRNA. The transcripts level of U6 snRNA was used as internal control to normalize quantity discrepancy of RNA input. The quantification cycle (C_q) values were determined by the amplification curve (exponential phase) automatically by the instrument and the relative fold changes of each miRNA genes were calculated according to the minimum information for the publication of qRT-PCR experiments (MIQE) guidelines as described earlier [52].

Reverse transcriptions for 10 selected target genes were performed with an oligo (dT) primer and SuperScript® III Reverse Transcriptase (Invitrogen, USA), according to the manufacturer’s instructions, to compare their expression in leaf, root and cone tissues of HP and CIP. The resultant was diluted three-fold and 1 μL of cDNA was used as a template to perform qRT-PCR using a Roche LightCycler 480 instrument (Roche, USA) with each target gene primer (Additional file 1: Table S1). The reactions were incubated in a 96-well plate and the real-time PCR program conditions consisted of an initial denaturing step at 95 °C for 5 min, followed by 40 cycles of 95 °C for 5 s and 60 °C for 30 s. The specificity of the primers was verified by melting curves analysis following a thermal denaturing cycle of 60–95 °C at 1 °C increments with 5 s between each step. The hop specific Hl-GAPDH gene (GenBank Accession No. ES437736) was used as an internal control. All reactions were performed in triplicate and included no-template control and no reverse transcriptase as negative controls for each gene assay. The relative expression level of the target gene was calculated according to standard (MIQE) guidelines as described earlier [52].

Results

High-throughput sequencing and characterization of potential hop miRNAs

To survey sRNAs in hop and their role in plant response to CBCVd-infection, two small RNA libraries, prepared from tissues (leaf, root and cone) of HP and CIP plants, were subjected to Illumina deep sequencing [39]. The sequencing acquired 21,449,604 reads from the HP library and 68,611,723 reads from the CIP library. After removing adaptor sequences, filtering out low-quality tags and eliminating contamination produced by the adaptor-adaptor ligation, 7,253,175 and 15,907,779 clean reads were obtained from HP and CIP libraries, respectively (Table 1). The most abundant size of mapped sRNAs (>80%) was 20–24 nt in length, with 24 and 21 nt as the most frequent size groups (Fig. 2), indicating the typical size range for Dicer-derived products as reported in a previous study [7]. The genome-matched sRNA sequences were grouped into several RNA categories, such as rRNAs, tRNAs, snRNAs, snoRNAs, repeats, known miRNAs and unannotated sRNAs (Table 1). The matched known mature miRNAs comprised of 28.07% of all sequence reads in the HP library and 17.88% in the CIP library. However, the fraction of sRNA unique sequences obtained from known miRNAs accounted for only a meagre proportion of the total unique sequences in HP and CIP libraries (0.78 and 0.39%, respectively) (Table 1). The highest proportion of genome-matched sequences was unannotated sRNA sequences. These unique sequences might include some novel miRNA candidates and several siRNAs, as well as other type RNAs, which indicates that hop contains a large and diverse sRNA population.

Table 1 Statistics of small RNA sequences from healthy and CBCVd-infected libraries of Humulus lupulus

Fig. 2

Length distribution of small RNAs in CBCVd-infected and healthy libraries in hop. The X axis represents the length of small RNAs. The Y axis represents the relative frequency

The predicted miRNA precursor sequence length ranged from 62 to 254 nt, with an average length of 152 ± 56.14 nt (Additional file 3: Table S3) and a large percentage of them (61.20) were 100–200 nt (Additional file 4: Figure S1). The percentage composition of each nucleotide was randomly distributed in the identified hop pre-miRNAs (Additional file 3: Table S3). The U content in the identified hop pre-miRNAs, in particular, was higher than the C and G contents, which were below 20% average (Additional file 3: Table S3 and Additional file 4: Figure S1). The MFE (minimum free energy), AMFE (adjusted MFE) and MFEI (MFE index) of the identified hop pre-miRNAs (Additional file 3: Table S3 and Additional file 4: Figure S1) were consistent with previous findings [30] and indicated high-confidence prediction of miRNAs in hop.

Identification of conserved miRNAs and their expression profile

The sRNA datasets of HP and CIP were aligned to known miRNAs sequences in the miRBase databases, resulting in the identification of 67 conserved miRNAs in hop, belonging to 40 different families (Table 2). However, the miRNAs identified in the present study were not evenly distributed among the families. The highest representation of 6 miRNAs in the MIR399 family and 4 miRNAs in families MIR169, MIR171 and MIR482 was observed. The remaining 23 miRNA families were represented by a single member. The results indicated that different members from the same miRNA families exhibited significantly different expression levels. For example, reads of miRNAs in the MIR399 family ranged from 3 to 494 and 33 to 5136 in HP and CIP groups, respectively.

Table 2 List of conserved miRNAs and their recoveries profiling in response to CBCVd-infection in Humulus lupulus

The read numbers of the conserved miRNAs were used as an index for the estimation of miRNAs relative abundance levels in the HP and CIP libraries. The expression level of these conserved miRNAs were significantly different in the two libraries (Table 2) and a total of 36 conserved miRNAs were found to be CBCVd-responsive in the infected sample (P < 0.05, log₂fold ≥ 2), suggesting their role in basal defence and in response to CBCVd-infection. These differentially recovered miRNAs included some highly recovered miRNAs, such as hop-miR166a and hop-miR482b-3p and also some moderately abundant miRNAs, such as hop-miR6297a (Table 2).

qRT-PCR analysis of eight selected conserved miRNAs, displaying different read frequency patterns, was performed using leaf, root and cone tissues of HP and CIP. The expression levels of the eight selected conserved hop miRNAs were significantly altered in all analysed tissues as a result of CBCVd-infection (Fig. 3). Among the validated conserved miRNAs, the fold change of MIR167 was more prominent, suggesting that it is an important candidate miRNA that might play significant role in the hop stress response against CBCVd-infection. Moreover, the obtained results showed a significant correlation between qRT-PCR expression profiling and read frequencies, which suggested that the obtained sequencing profiles are both quantitatively and qualitatively reliable.

Fig. 3

Differential recovery analysis of CBCVd-responsive 8 selected conserved miRNAs: The relative miRNA abundance in CBCVd-infected and healthy plants was evaluated using the comparative C_q method after normalisation to U6 snRNA as the reference. The bar graph shows log₂ fold changes of expression level of miRNAs in CBCVd-infected samples relative to healthy samples in root, leaf and cone. miRNAs with significant change of (P < 0.05 and log₂ Ratio > 1) were considered to be differentially recovered. Values are given as mean ± SD of three experiments in each group

Identification of novel miRNAs and their expression profile

Mapping of sequencing reads to the reference hop genome resulted in the identification of 49 potential miRNA candidates with a typical stem-loop structure, which were designated as hop-miR01 to hop-miR49 (Table 3). The length of the predicted novel miRNAs ranged from 19 to 23 nt, with a major peak at 21 nt, and most of them (~45%) started with a 5′ uridine, which is considered to be one of the characteristic features of miRNA. The identified hop miRNA precursor MFE values ranged from −18.30 to −139.20 kcal mol⁻¹, with an average of −66.77 ± 32.58 kcal mol⁻¹ (Additional file 3: Table S3), which was similar to the range reported previously for miRNA precursors of other plant species, such as maize [23] and Arabidopsis [53]. Sequence analysis of pre-miRNAs revealed the presence of miRNA* sequences for 49 identified novel hop miRNAs, supporting their sequence identity in our libraries and their further classification as novel miRNAs. Among the 49 novel miRNAs, only 17 had at least 0.01 TPM in both libraries, with the highest abundance, 130.31 TPM, for hop-miR41. The low abundance of novel miRNAs compared with those of conserved miRNAs in our data observed in this study was consistent with previous reports [23–30]. Normalized expression profiles of the novel miRNAs in HP and CIP libraries were compared to identify CBCVd-responsive novel miRNAs (Table 3). Among 37 differentially recovered novel miRNAs, one miRNA was found to be significantly down-regulated and 36 miRNAs were up-regulated with a more than 2.0 fold change (P < 0.05), in the CIP library.

Table 3 List of novel miRNAs and their recoveries profiling in response to CBCVd-infection in Humulus lupulus

The 49 putative novel miRNAs were also confirmed by stem-loop end point PCR (Additional file 5: Figure S2). In addition, stem-loop RT-PCR analysis of the expression patterns of the 15 differentially recovered novel miRNAs confirmed the changes in miRNA expression in response to CBCVd-infection in hop (Fig. 4) and were consistent with read frequencies. This analysis further supported the view that the read frequencies of the novel miRNAs were reliable both quantitatively and qualitatively. In addition, the relative expression level of nine differentially recovered novel miRNAs was significantly higher in leaves followed by roots and cones, whereas two of them were relatively higher expressed in cones, demonstrating that the relative expression level of differentially recovered novel miRNAs exhibited tissue-biased expression patterns (Fig. 4).

Fig. 4

Differential expression analysis of CBCVd-responsive 15 selected novel miRNAs: The relative miRNA abundance in CBCVd-infected and healthy plants was evaluated using the comparative C_q method after normalisation to U6 snRNA as the reference. The bar graph shows log₂ fold changes of expression level of miRNAs in CBCVd-infected samples relative to healthy samples in root, leaf and cone. miRNAs with significant change of (P < 0.05 and log₂ Ratio > 1) were considered to be differentially recovered. Values are given as mean ± SD of three experiments in each group

Potential miRNA-target prediction and functional analysis

In order to understand the regulatory roles of the newly identified hop miRNAs, particularly the development of stunt diseases due to CBCVd-infection, target genes were scanned using the psRNATarget program [47] with default parameters against the transcript sequences of the hop genome as a reference set. About 93.89% of miRNA targets were predicted to be regulated through cleavage and 6.10% by translational repression, which is in accordance with an earlier report that mRNA cleavage is the predominant mechanism of miRNA-guided regulation [54]. Based on the extent of sequence complementarity of perfect or near-perfect pairing between miRNAs and their targets, a total of 311 unigenes were predicted as potential targets of 67 conserved miRNAs and 49 novel miRNAs, with an average of 2.68 targets per miRNA (Additional file 6: Table S4 and Additional file 7: Table S5). The MFEs for the miRNA:mRNA hybrids ranged from −2.69 to −25.53 kcal/mol. Among them, 194 unigenes were identified as potential target genes of the CBCVd-responsive miRNAs including conserved and novel miRNAs.

The potential miRNA target genes (311 different transcripts) were grouped into different gene families with a variety of biological functions, including hop growth and development, signal transduction, vegetative to reproductive phase change, homeostasis and metabolism, secondary metabolite production, protein translocation and environmental responses such as biotic/abiotic stresses. Highly-conserved miRNAs, such as miR156, miR159, miR160, miR164, miR167, miR172, miR396 and miR482, shared conserved targets of various gene families of transcription factors, such as squamosa promoter-binding-like protein (SPL), AP2-like factor, GAMYB, NAC domain containing proteins, nuclear transcription factor Y subunits (NF-Y), homeobox-leucine zipper protein, floral homeotic protein APETALA, which were phylogenetically related in hop (Additional file 8: Figure S3) with homologous miRNAs in other plants (Additional file 6: Table S4). Many of these transcription factors (such as SPL, AP2-like and GAMYB) have been shown to play an important role in vegetative to reproductive growth phase change, growth and development in Arabidopsis [54]. In addition to the important roles of NF-YA in floral organ identity and flowering, it might be involved in biotic and abiotic stress resistance in hop [55]. Moreover, some novel targets of both conserved and less-conserved known miRNA families were identified, which included several regulatory proteins (such as E3 ubiquitin protein, DNAJC2, CCR4). The other important predicted targets belonged to various kinds of enzymes, such as glycine dehydrogenase, cellulose synthase, glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, carboxylesterase, xylosyltransferase and β-galactosidase, which might play roles in various metabolic pathways. The identified miRNAs might also target transporters such as ABC, or transporters of sugar, heavy metals, ions and phosphate. Interestingly, non-conserved miRNAs (hop-miR482b-5p) targeted the valerophenone synthase gene involved in prenylflavonoid biosynthesis pathways in hop [56]. The predicted putative targets (141 transcripts) of novel miRNAs included a broad range of proteins with a wide array of predicted functions (Additional file 7: Table S5). For instance, hop-miR04/hop-miR13/hop-miR30 targets cytochrome P450, hop-miR20 targets RuBisCO large subunit-binding protein and hop-miR48 targets TIC110 (chloroplastic protein), which are all involved in photosynthesis [57]. The predicted targets included disease resistance proteins, such as RPM1 (hop-miR01/hop-miR39) and TMV resistance protein N (hop-miR33/hop-miR41) and several kinases, which are known to be associated with plant defense mechanisms through signaling-related processes [58, 59]. Novel targets also included several functional proteins, such as PPR-containing protein (required for normal plant development) [60], EMF1 protein (required for floral repression during vegetative development) [61], transporter proteins (such as ABC, inositol transporter 1, USO1) [62], SAND protein (endosomal maturation protein) [63], ARC5 protein (plastid division specifically in mesophyll cells) [64], GLABRA2 (trichome differentiation) [65], TT12 (controlling the vacuolar sequestration of flavonoids in the seed coat endothelium) [65]. Candidate targets of three novel miRNA families, including hop-miR05 and hop-miR47, failed to be annotated. Intriguingly, candidate targets (e.g. chalcone synthase, farnesyl pyrophosphate synthase and valerophenone synthase) of a few novel miRNAs were identified, which are widely known to be involved in prenylflavonoid and bitter acids production in hop [56].

Furthermore, COG functional classification of targets of conserved and novel miRNAs revealed that the highest proportion of genes was involved in the transcription process, while other target transcripts encode a wide range of proteins, such as those involved in RNA processing and modification, post-translational modification and protein turnover, signal transduction mechanisms, carbohydrate, inorganic ion and amino acid transport and secondary metabolite biosynthesis (Fig. 5). In addition, we found that 4.8 and 11.4% of the predicted targets of novel miRNAs and conserved miRNAs, respectively, were scantily characterized genes, suggesting that these miRNAs might have naive roles in hop.

Fig. 5

COG function classification of predicted target genes of novel miRNAs (a) and conserved miRNAs (b). Pie chart showing distribution of different functional classes represented in the predicted targets

Comprehensive annotation of transcripts based on ontological definitions of the GO terms categorized the predicted targets of the miRNAs into a wide range of regulatory functions, and some specific biological processes, such as metabolism, biosynthesis and gene expression/transcription (Additional file 9: Figure S4). In order to gain an insight into the role of miRNAs in the pathogenesis of CBCVd-infection, the target genes of CBCVd-responsive miRNAs were grouped into 10 categories (Fig. 6) based on GO functional annotations using their ontologies in Arabidopsis. The first category of target genes of CBCVd-responsive miRNAs was represented by an array of transcriptional factors possibly involved in the regulation of gene expression. In the second category, target genes were associated with the metabolic process, suggesting that CBCVd-infection could alter the various metabolic processes in an infected plant. Target genes involved in signaling pathways belonged to the third category, indicating the role of signaling pathways in the CBCVd-infection process. The other categories included DNA and RNA processing, hormone metabolism, stress response, development and others biological processes (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6

Percentage distribution of the predicted target genes of CBCVd-responsive conserved miRNAs (a) and novel miRNAs (b) in various categories

Expression profile and experimental validation of target transcripts

The expression profiles of 10 selected target transcripts of CBCVd-responsive differentially recovered miRNAs were investigated via qPCR. The result indicated that the expression of target genes had a negative correlation with expression of their corresponding miRNAs and thus confirmed their interaction in response to CBCVd- infection. However, the fold change values of CBCVd-responsive targeted genes were not uniform across the analysed infected tissues in hop (Fig. 7).

Fig. 7

Differential expression profile of selected miRNA target genes: The relative gene expression was evaluated using the comparative C_q method taking Hl-GAPDH (GenBank Accession No. ES437736) as the reference gene. The log₂ values represent the ratio of the expression level of target genes in CBCVd-infected samples relative to healthy samples in root, leaf and cone. The predicted target genes used in this analysis were (1) Squamosa promoter-binding protein 15 (hop-miR156 Target); (2) GAMYB Transcriptional factor (hop-miR159c Target); (3) NAC domain protein NAC1 (hop-miR164a Target); (4) Cysteine protease (hop-miR167a-5p Target); (5) mediator of RNA pol II subunit 26b (hop-miR167c-5p Target); (6) GRAS family TF (hop-miR171b Target); (7) pre-mRNA-splicing factor RNA helicase PRP1 (hop-miR395a Target); (8) Glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (hop-miR827a Target); (9) disease resistance protein RPM1-like (hop-miR02 Target); (10) cellulose synthase A catalytic subunit 4 (hop-miR41 Target). Target genes with a significant change of (P < 0.05 and log₂ Ratio > 1) were considered to be differentially expressed. Values are given as mean ± SD of three experiments in each group

The cleavage sites within the target transcripts of hop-miR156, hop-miR164a and hop-miR171b were validated by 5′ RLM-RACE analysis. Sequence analysis of the cleavage products by 5′ RACE showed hop-miR164a-mediated cleavage in the NAC domain protein transcript (GAAW01060518) at sites opposite the 10th and 12th nucleotides from the 5′ end of miRNA, and hop-miR156 and hop-miR171b mediated cleavage in Squamosa promoter-binding-like protein 15 (GAAW01048142) and GRAS family transcription factor (GAAW01082848), at sites opposite the 10th and 11th nucleotides from the 5′ end of miRNA, respectively (Fig. 8).

Fig. 8

Mapping of target mRNA cleavage sites of hop-miR164a, hop-miR171b and hop-miR41 by RNA ligase-mediated 5′RACE. The positions of cleavage sites are indicated by arrows, and numbers above the arrow represent the proportion of sequenced clones. Watson-Crick pairing (vertical dashes) and G:U wobble pairing (circles) are indicated

Discussion

Hop is an economically important crop for the brewing industry and over the last few years has gained increasing attention due to its potential applications to pharmaceutical industries [31, 32]. In spite of that, hop miRNAs and their association with various biological processes are widely unexploited, although in the past few years several conserved miRNAs and species-specific miRNAs have been identified in various plant species with the aid of high-throughput sequencing methods. In the present study, a high-throughput deep sequencing method was used to identify conserved and novel miRNAs in hop. Their response to CBCVd-infection was also investigated, delivering valuable information for gaining in-depth knowledge of the function and regulatory mechanisms of miRNAs in the CBCVd-defence response. Comparison of sequencing data of the two libraries showed that sRNAs of 21-nt and 24-nt formed two major classes, consistent with the distribution patterns of sRNAs in other plant species [29, 30]. However, their distributions were significantly different between two analysed libraries. The CPI library had a higher abundance of the 21-nt class of sRNAs, while the 24-nt class of sRNAs was skewed in the HP library. This may indicate either an induction of the 21 nt class or a repression of the 24 nt class of sRNAs in response to CBCVd infection. This observation is in accordance with some previous reports showing the over accumulation of the 21-nt class of sRNAs in response to viroid and virus infection in plants [66, 67]. The different distribution patterns of 21-nt and 24-nt classes of sRNAs provided explicit evidence to support the possibility of the involvement of multiple RNA-silencing pathways and their cross interaction [68] due to CBCVd-infection. In plants, endogenous 24-nt small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are mostly derived from transposons, intergenic and repetitive genomic regions, which, after incorporation with Argonaute 4 (AGO4), triggers DNA methylation [69]. These modifications reinforce transcriptional repression or silencing of a subset of transposons and genes that harbour or reside adjacent to transposons or repeats in Arabidopsis [69]. The reduced 24-nt sRNA levels in the CIP library suggests a lower level of DNA methylation at specific loci in response to CBCVd-infection, which could enhance the resistance or susceptibility to CBCVd or other viroid infection. However, further investigation is needed in this area to prove these assumptions.

Analysis of sRNA reads from these two hop libraries revealed the existence of 67 conserved miRNAs belonging to 40 miRNA families, and 49 novel miRNAs, further supported by the presence of their corresponding star sequences in both libraries. Furthermore, the characteristic features of pre-miRNAs (such as length distribution, MFE) and miRNAs (such as size distribution, nucleotide composition of miRNAs and prevalence of 5′-uridine) were similar to those observed in other plants [28–30]. MFEI is considered as an another valuable criterion to distinguish miRNAs from other types of coding and non-coding RNAs. The pre-miRNAs predicted had high MFEI values (1.20 ± 0.32), higher than other types of noncoding RNAs, e.g. tRNAs (0.64), rRNAs (0.59) and mRNAs (0.62–0.66) [70]. Taken together, these data indicated high-confidence prediction of miRNAs in hop.

Several previous studies have shown that group of well-conserved miRNAs (e.g. MIR156, MIR159, MIR164, MIR166, MIR167, MIR169, MIR171, MIR172, MIR319 and MIR396) often retain homologous target interactions and perform similar molecular functions across plant phyla in the course of evolution and adaptation [71]. These evolutionarily conserved miRNAs regulate targets such SPL, MYB, NAC, HD-ZIPIII, ARF, NF-Y, SCL, AP2 and TCP. These transcriptional factors are involved in metabolic processes, growth and development and might involve in the cellular adaptive responses to adverse circumstances [72]. The conserved nature of these miRNAs and their functionally conserved target transcriptional factors highlights their phylogenetic distribution and versatile functions among diverse plant lineages. The target genes of other well- and less-conserved miRNAs were predicted to be implicated in various functions, such as protein degradation, defence mechanism, basic metabolic processes, regulation of ion homeostasis, lipid and sugar translocation, signal perception and transduction, and transposable elements, suggesting the important roles of miRNAs in the regulation of a wide range of biological activities in hop. The expression levels of novel hop miRNAs were very low, which is in accordance with previous reports that lineage-specific miRNAs are usually tend to be expressed at a low level [25]. Intriguingly, some novel targets were identified that play specific roles in trichome differentiation and bitter acids and prenylflavonoids biosynthesis in hop. Further studies implementing on miRNA directed gene regulation of the prenylflavonoids biosynthesis pathway are necessary to establish their relationship and functional importance in hop.

Accumulating data suggest that plant disease resistance gene families are comprised of thousand of members, which are usually considered to be putative target genes of sRNAs [73]. The mechanism of CBCVd-associated disease could therefore be better understood by analysing sRNAs and the expression profiles of target genes in hop with and without CBCVd-infection. Comparison of the two sequence libraries data showed that almost half of the conserved miRNA families (MIR156, MIR159, MIR160, MIR164, MIR167, MIR168, MIR171, MIR172, MIR390, MIR395, MIR399, MIR403, MIR482, MIR827, MIR3441, MIR5255, MIR6297, MIR7755, MIR7815, MIR7987 and MIR8963) and 37 novel miRNAs exhibited altered expression due to CBCVd-infection. In addition, miRNAs of the same family (MIR171, MIR482) shared a high degree of sequence similarity and were differentially regulated, suggesting that gene expression programming was controlled by different regulators [74]. In the present study, hop-miR156 was significantly induced in CIP and squamosa-promoter binding-like protein (SPL) was predicted as its target gene. SPL transcription factor family proteins are known to play an important role in flower and fruit development, plant architecture and phase transition from juvenile to adult and to flowering [75]. The previous study showed that the interaction of mir156-SPL could directly regulate flowering through activating MADS box genes, resulting in the loss of apical dominance, smaller leaves development and the formation of more leaves with shorter plastochron lengths [75]. Hop-miR172e-5p was predicted to target AP2 domain-containing transcription factor, which has a pivotal role in the regulation of floral organ identity and flowering time [76]. The differential expression of miR156 and miR172 might therefore affect the growth and development process and could be responsible for hop stunt disease. In plants, a group of miRNAs modulates the fine-tuned genes associated with multiple hormonal signaling pathways [77]. Our results showed that some miRNAs that target genes involved in hormone signaling and metabolism were differentially recovered between healthy and infected hop plants. For instance, miR160/miR167, identified as dynamic components of the auxin response pathway [77] were up-regulated in the CBCVd-infected plants. Moreover, hop-miR159c, hop-miR164a and hop-miR171, associated with gibberellic acid, abscisic acid and salicylic acid pathways, respectively, by regulating different transcription factors (GAMYB, NAC and GRAS families) were found differentially recovered in healthy and CBCVd-infected hop (Fig. 7). It has been reported that the NAC protein plays a role in developmental processes such as the formation of the shoot apical meristem, floral organs and lateral shoots, the GAMYB protein in anther development, stem elongation, floral initiation and seed development and the GRAS protein in seed germination, stem and root elongation and fertility [78]. In addition, hop-miR396b-5p was predicted to target the gene coding the pentatricopeptide repeat-containing superfamily protein, which is known to be involved in the abiotic stress response by integrating salicylic acid-dependent, abscisic acid-dependent or independent signaling pathways (Additional file 6: Table S4) [79]. It is therefore more likely that CBCVd-infection could modify the hormone signaling pathway, leading to reprogramming and alteration of hop growth and development and inducing symptoms. In this study, several CBCVd-responsive miRNAs involved in defense mechanisms were identified. For example, hop-miR159c and hop-miR828-3p were predicted to target CCR4-associated factor 1 and serine/threonine-protein kinase abkC, respectively, which have been reported to be involved in signaling cascades during host pathogen interaction, the subsequent activation of plant defense mechanisms and developmental control [80]. Moreover, the present work also showed that some differentially recovered miRNAs target the genes, which regulate sugar, protein and lipid metabolism and their transportation.

In contrast to miRNAs, the length of siRNAs ranges from 21 to 25 nt and they are processed from dsRNA precursors by RNA-dependent RNA polymerases and Dicer-like (DCL) proteins and RNA polymerase IV [2]. It has been reported that 22 nt forms of miRNAs (miR173, miR319, miR828 and miR771), along with tasiR2140, are important for triggering secondary siRNA production and the target genes of these siRNAs have a wide range of functions in hormone networks, metabolism, growth and development in plants [73]. It would thus be intriguing to explore the role of hop-miR828-3p in triggering production of siRNAs, and their pathways and functions in the context to CBCVd-infection in hop.

Conclusions

In conclusion, global transcriptional profiles of sRNAs were investigated in hop with and without CBCVd-infection. The identified miRNAs from hop could assist in identifying the miRNA-based regulatory system, together with their role in the biosynthesis pathway of prenylflavonoids and bitter acids production in hop. The differential expression profiles of miRNAs and their involvement in complex regulatory networks reveal their putative roles underlying CBCVd pathogenicity and the symptoms they cause in hop plants. Since the hop genome is not completed, we speculate that our analysis did not predict all hop miRNAs.